


Ask the community...
My brother went through this exact situation last year. He was working part-time making about $28k AND took $35k from his IRA. He got super worried when his January SS payment was lower and thought it was because of the IRA withdrawal. After calling SSA (which took forever btw), they explained it was ONLY the part-time job income that triggered the reduction. His accountant also helped him fill out Form SSA-131 (Employer Report of Special Wage Payments) to exclude a one-time payment that shouldn't have counted as regular earnings. Just something to keep in mind if you have any special payment situations - there are ways to exclude certain types of compensation!
This is such valuable information! I'm in a similar boat at 64 and was completely stressing about my planned IRA withdrawals affecting my Social Security benefits. Reading through all these responses has been incredibly helpful. I've been working reduced hours specifically to stay under the earnings limit, but now I realize I could have been taking more from my IRA this whole time without any impact on my SS benefits. It's frustrating how confusing the SSA materials can be - they really should make this distinction clearer between "earned" and "unearned" income. For anyone else in this situation, I'd definitely recommend getting confirmation directly from SSA about your specific circumstances. Every situation is a bit different, and it's worth the peace of mind to know exactly where you stand before making major financial decisions.
I completely agree about how confusing the SSA materials can be! I'm new to this community but facing a similar situation at 65. It's really reassuring to see so many people sharing their actual experiences with this issue. The distinction between earned and unearned income seems like such a fundamental concept, but it's buried in all the technical language on their website. I've been putting off some necessary IRA withdrawals because I was worried about the impact on my benefits, but this thread has given me the confidence to move forward. Thank you to everyone who shared their stories and resources - it's exactly the kind of real-world guidance that's so hard to find elsewhere!
Wait, I'm seeing some conflicting information here! @CosmicVoyager just pointed out that Publication 3112 says permanent residents CAN apply for an EFIN. @LunarEclipse - are you sure you checked the most current requirements? Maybe there was some confusion about the citizenship requirement? If permanent residents are actually eligible, that would completely solve your problem without needing to involve your sister or work under someone else's business structure. I'd definitely double-check the official IRS documentation before exploring these more complicated arrangements. Has anyone else successfully gotten an EFIN as a permanent resident recently? Would love to hear real experiences since the official publication seems to contradict what the OP was told.
This is a great catch! I just went through the EFIN application process myself last year as a permanent resident and can confirm that green card holders ARE eligible. I think there might be some confusion because the online application system initially rejected my application, but it turned out to be a technical glitch with how I entered my immigration status. The key is making sure you select "Legal Resident Alien" in the dropdown and provide your green card number in the correct format. I also had to upload a copy of both sides of my green card as supporting documentation. The whole process took about 6-8 weeks from submission to approval. @LunarEclipse, I'd definitely recommend trying the application yourself first before going through all these workarounds with your sister. Save yourself the complications!
This is exactly why I love this community - you all just saved @LunarEclipse a ton of unnecessary complications! @DeShawn Washington and @CosmicVoyager are absolutely right about permanent residents being eligible for EFINs. I went through this same process two years ago as a green card holder. The application can be tricky because the system sometimes flags non-citizen applications for additional review, but that doesn't mean you're ineligible. Make sure you have: 1. A clear copy of both sides of your green card 2. Your alien registration number (A-number) ready 3. Select "Legal Resident Alien" not "Non-resident Alien" in the dropdown The IRS customer service reps sometimes give incorrect information about this requirement - I was told twice by phone that I needed citizenship, but the written regulations clearly state otherwise. Go straight to the source with Publication 3112 and save yourself from having to navigate family business arrangements or contractor relationships. Good luck with your tax prep business!
Wow, this thread has been incredibly eye-opening! As someone who's completely new to the tax preparation world, I had no idea there were so many nuances to the EFIN application process. It's really helpful to see experienced preparers sharing their actual experiences rather than just repeating what they "heard somewhere." @Oliver Schmidt - your checklist is super practical! I m'bookmarking this entire discussion because even though I m'not dealing with immigration status issues myself, the level of detail everyone s'providing about EFIN requirements and business structures is invaluable for anyone starting out in this field. It s'amazing how a simple question about one specific situation turned into such a comprehensive resource about EFINs, business partnerships, and even backup plans for reaching the IRS when things go wrong. This community is awesome!
Is there a simple calculator online where I can just plug in my numbers and see what my QBI deduction would be with different scenarios? My business is projected to make about $450k this year with just me and one employee, and I'm trying to figure out if I should buy that new $120k piece of equipment before year-end or not.
This is such a common confusion point! Let me try to explain it with your actual numbers to make it clearer. With $1,350,000 in net profit and only $100,000 in W2 wages, you're likely hitting the W2 wage limitation hard. Here's the math: At your income level, your QBI deduction is limited to the greater of: - 50% of W2 wages = $50,000 (50% of $100k) - 25% of W2 wages + 2.5% of qualified property So even though your business profit could theoretically give you a $270,000 QBI deduction (20% of $1,350,000), you're actually limited to maybe $50,000 or so. But if you increase your W2 to $270,000: - 50% of W2 wages = $135,000 - Your remaining QBI would be about $1,080,000 ($1,350k - $270k wages) - 20% of $1,080,000 = $216,000 potential deduction Now your wage limitation ($135,000) is much higher, so you might be able to take a larger portion of that $216,000 deduction. The exact amount depends on other factors, but you can see how paying more W2 wages can actually unlock more QBI deduction benefits. The key insight: sometimes the tax savings from a larger QBI deduction outweigh the additional payroll taxes on higher W2 wages.
This breakdown is incredibly helpful! I've been spinning my wheels trying to understand this for weeks. One follow-up question - when you say "the exact amount depends on other factors," what are those other factors? I want to make sure I'm not missing anything important when I run these numbers for my own business situation.
I'm going through the exact same thing right now - my refund was mailed 3/16 and still nothing in the mailbox. It's so nerve-wracking when you're depending on that money! I signed up for USPS Informed Delivery after reading these comments and that's been helpful to at least see what's coming each day. What I've learned from calling around is that IRS checks can take anywhere from 2-6 weeks depending on postal processing delays. I know it's frustrating (especially when caring for family like you are), but from everything I've read here and elsewhere, most people do eventually get their checks - they just take longer than we'd hope. If nothing shows up by next Friday (which would be about 3 weeks), I'd definitely start the process of calling the IRS. Hang in there!
Thanks for sharing your experience - it's oddly comforting to know I'm not the only one going through this! I actually just signed up for Informed Delivery too after seeing it recommended multiple times in this thread. The 2-6 week range is pretty wide, but at least it gives me a better sense of what to expect. I'm at about 2.5 weeks now since my 3/15 mail date, so I guess I'm still in the "normal" range even though it feels eternal when you're watching the mailbox every day. Really appreciate the tip about calling after 3 weeks - I'll mark next Friday on my calendar as my "panic and call the IRS" day if nothing shows up by then. Hope yours arrives soon too!
I feel for you - the uncertainty is the worst part when you're caring for family and need that money. I went through something similar last year where my check took almost a month to arrive. A few things that helped me stay sane: First, I called my local post office and they confirmed that Treasury checks sometimes get extra security screening which can add 5-7 days. Second, I started checking my mailbox at different times since sometimes the mail carrier delivers later in the day. Third, I made sure to check with all my immediate neighbors in case of misdelivery. The good news is that based on everyone's experiences here, checks mailed mid-March are still well within the normal delivery window. I know waiting is brutal when you're worried about your mom, but try to give it until early next week before calling the IRS. Most people in your situation do get their checks - they just arrive later than expected.
This is really reassuring to hear from someone who went through the same thing! The extra security screening explanation makes a lot of sense - I hadn't thought about that being a factor. I've been checking my mailbox obsessively (sometimes multiple times a day which is probably overkill), but your suggestion about checking at different times is smart since our mail carrier's schedule does seem to vary. I'll definitely talk to my neighbors this weekend too - with all the package deliveries in our area, mail does occasionally end up in the wrong box. It's helpful to know that mid-March checks are still in the normal window. The waiting is definitely the hardest part when you're worried about family finances, but I'll try to be patient until early next week before making that dreaded call to the IRS. Thanks for the perspective!
Aaron Boston
For what it's worth, I've been emailing 1099s to my contractors for 3 years now. I just send a simple email in December asking if they prefer email or mail, save their responses, and then send PDFs to those who chose email. Never had an issue with the IRS or any contractors. Just be careful with security - I password-protect the PDFs and send the password in a separate email or text message. Better safe than sorry with sensitive tax info!
0 coins
Sophia Carter
ā¢Is there a specific way you password protect the PDFs? I've never done that before but sounds like a good idea given all the SSNs and financial info.
0 coins
Aaron Boston
ā¢I use Adobe Acrobat to add password protection - it's pretty straightforward. Open the PDF, go to "Protect" then "Encrypt" then "Encrypt with Password." You can set it to require a password to open the document. If you don't have Adobe, there are free online tools that can add password protection too, though I'd be careful about uploading sensitive documents to random websites. Some tax software also has built-in options to password protect tax documents when you save them.
0 coins
Chloe Zhang
Just a heads up - if you're filing more than 10 1099s, you're required to e-file them with the IRS now! The old rule used to be 250 forms, but they've been lowering the threshold. So even if you mail or email copies to your contractors, you'll still need to submit them electronically to the IRS.
0 coins
Brandon Parker
ā¢Is that true for small businesses too? I thought there was an exception if your business is below a certain size. I've been paper filing my 15-20 1099s for years!
0 coins
Justin Trejo
ā¢Yes, the 10-form threshold applies to all businesses regardless of size! The IRS lowered it from 250 to 10 forms starting with the 2024 tax year (forms filed in 2025). There aren't any small business exceptions for this rule unfortunately. You'll need to use the IRS FIRE system (Filing Information Returns Electronically) to submit them. It's free to use, though the interface takes some getting used to. Alternatively, many tax software programs and payroll services can handle the e-filing for you if you don't want to deal with the IRS system directly. Since you mentioned filing 15-20 forms, you'll definitely need to switch to electronic filing this year. Better to get ahead of it now rather than scramble at the deadline!
0 coins