


Ask the community...
This is such a complex area of tax law that I think it's worth highlighting one more important consideration: the timing of when you converted the space to residential use matters a lot for the IRS. Since you mentioned renovating 40% as living quarters in August 2017 and living there until March 2021, you clearly meet the 2-out-of-5-years requirement. But if any portion of your residential space was ever used for business purposes during that time (even occasionally), it could complicate the exclusion calculation. Also, make sure you have documentation showing exactly when the residential conversion was completed. The IRS may want to see permits, receipts for residential improvements (like kitchen/bathroom installations), or other proof that establishes when the space became truly habitable as a home versus just a commercial building with some sleeping arrangements. The good news is that legitimate mixed-use properties do qualify for partial exclusions all the time - you just need to be thorough with your documentation and calculations. Given the significant tax implications, I'd strongly recommend getting a tax professional who specializes in real estate transactions to review your specific situation before filing.
This is excellent advice about the timing documentation! I'm actually dealing with a similar situation right now and hadn't considered how important it would be to prove exactly when my residential conversion was complete. Do you know if the IRS has any specific guidelines about what constitutes "completion" of a residential conversion? I'm wondering if they'd accept something like a certificate of occupancy for the residential portion, or if they typically want to see utility hookups, final inspections, etc. My concern is that I did the renovation in phases over several months, so pinpointing an exact "move-in ready" date might be tricky. Also, you mentioned not using residential space for business purposes - does this mean even having a home office in the residential portion could complicate things?
Great questions about the timing and completion criteria! From my experience helping clients with similar situations, the IRS doesn't have one rigid definition of "completion" - they look at when the space became functionally habitable as a residence. Certificate of occupancy is gold standard documentation if you have it, but many mixed-use conversions don't require separate residential CO's. The IRS typically accepts a combination of evidence: utility connections for residential use (separate meters if applicable), completion of essential living amenities (full kitchen, bathroom, proper heating/cooling), and evidence you actually began living there full-time (mail delivery, voter registration, etc.). For phased renovations, document each major milestone with photos and receipts. The "move-in" date doesn't have to be when everything was perfect - just when it became your actual primary residence where you slept, cooked, and lived daily. Regarding home office in residential space: this is nuanced. A legitimate home office used exclusively for business would need to be allocated as business use, potentially reducing your residential percentage. However, if it's just a desk where you occasionally handled personal finances or paid bills, that's typically considered personal use. The key is "exclusive business use" - if the space served dual purposes, it generally stays in the residential category. The safest approach is to clearly delineate: business activities stayed in the designated commercial area, personal life happened in the residential area, with minimal crossover.
I've been following this discussion with great interest since I'm in a similar situation with a mixed-use property I'm preparing to sell. One thing I haven't seen mentioned yet is the importance of keeping detailed records of your actual living expenses versus business expenses during the time you occupied the property. The IRS may look at patterns like whether you deducted utilities, insurance, and maintenance costs as business expenses for the entire property, or if you properly allocated them between personal and business use. If you claimed 100% business deductions on utilities while living there, it could undermine your argument that 40% was truly residential. Also, for anyone dealing with this situation: make sure you understand the "non-qualifying use" rules. If you ever rented out the residential portion or used it for business purposes after May 6, 2008, those periods of non-qualifying use could reduce your available exclusion even if you otherwise meet the ownership and use tests. The tax implications can be substantial, so definitely worth getting professional guidance, but it's encouraging to see that others have successfully navigated similar situations with proper documentation and planning.
This is such an important point about the expense allocation! I hadn't thought about how claiming business deductions on utilities could contradict a residential use claim. I'm curious - if someone did mistakenly claim full business deductions on utilities while living there, is there a way to correct this retroactively? Would you need to file amended returns for those years, or could you just adjust the calculations when determining the capital gains exclusion percentages? Also, the non-qualifying use rules you mentioned are really concerning. If I had a friend stay in my residential area for a few weeks and they paid me some rent money, would that count as non-qualifying use? I'm starting to realize there might be more complexity here than I initially thought.
Here's a systematic approach to determine if you need to amend: 1. Check if you received Premium Tax Credits (Form 8962) 2. If yes, verify if the 1095-C shows you were eligible for employer coverage 3. If you were eligible for employer coverage AND received tax credits, you need to amend 4. If you didn't claim tax credits, no amendment needed 5. Keep the 1095-C with your tax records for at least 3 years Alternatively, you could file Form 8275 (Disclosure Statement) with your next year's return explaining the situation, though this is usually unnecessary for 1095-C issues.
I went through this exact scenario two years ago and can share what I learned. The key thing to understand is that the 1095-C serves as documentation for the IRS to verify that you had minimum essential coverage, but it's not something you typically need to include with your return unless you're claiming Premium Tax Credits. What I'd recommend doing is comparing the information on your 1095-C with how you answered the health insurance questions on your tax return. If you indicated you had employer coverage for the months shown on the form, and you didn't claim any Premium Tax Credits, then you're likely fine. The IRS already receives this information directly from your employer anyway. However, if there's a discrepancy - like the form shows you were offered coverage during months you claimed you didn't have access to employer insurance - then you might need to consider an amendment. But based on what you've described, it sounds like you're probably in the clear. Just keep the form with your tax records in case the IRS ever has questions later.
Just went through something similar with my heat pump installation last year. H&R Block seems to have issues with energy credits - they missed mine too! Here's what worked for me: I filed Form 1040-X electronically (much faster than paper) and made sure to attach a corrected Form 5695 with both sections properly completed. Since you have the manufacturer's certificate showing CEE highest tier qualification, you're in great shape documentation-wise. One tip - when you file the amendment, consider calling the IRS practitioner hotline if you have any questions about the form. Regular taxpayer lines are swamped, but the practitioner line (if you can access it through a tax pro) moves much faster. Also, double-check that your furnace purchase date falls within 2023 and that you haven't already claimed any other energy credits that might affect the total allowable amount. The good news is there's no penalty for amending to claim a credit you were entitled to - you might even get interest on the refund!
I'm dealing with a similar situation where my tax preparer missed energy credits on my 2023 return. Reading through everyone's experiences here has been really helpful - it sounds like amending for missed energy credits is pretty straightforward and there shouldn't be penalties for claiming something you were entitled to. A few questions for those who've been through this process: When you filed your Form 1040-X, did you need to include copies of your original return or just the corrected forms? Also, has anyone had issues with the IRS questioning the manufacturer certifications during processing, or do they typically just accept them if the documentation is clear? I'm planning to file electronically like some of you mentioned, but I want to make sure I include everything needed to avoid delays. Thanks for sharing your experiences - it's given me confidence to move forward with the amendment!
Great questions! When I filed my 1040-X electronically, I didn't need to include copies of my original return - the IRS already has that on file. You just need to submit the corrected Form 5695 along with your 1040-X showing the changes. Regarding manufacturer certifications, I haven't had any issues with the IRS questioning them during processing. As long as your documentation clearly shows the equipment meets the required efficiency standards and includes the model number, they typically accept it without additional scrutiny. The key is having that official manufacturer certificate stating it meets CEE highest tier requirements like @Lincoln Ramiro mentioned having. Electronic filing is definitely the way to go - it s'much faster than paper and you get confirmation that it was received. Just make sure all your math is correct on the amended forms before submitting. Good luck with your amendment!
Here's what's likely happening with your return based on the current processing patterns: 1. Returns first go through automated acceptance 2. Then they enter the main processing queue 3. Some returns are randomly selected for additional verification 4. Returns without tax topics are often in this verification queue 5. These verifications typically take 2-4 weeks to complete 6. Once verification is complete, most returns are approved within 48 hours 7. Direct deposits typically arrive 3-5 business days after approval The lack of a tax topic usually means your return is in a standard verification queue, not that there's a problem requiring your attention.
I'm in a very similar situation - filed on February 29th and have been stuck on "still processing" with no tax topic for 16 days now. It's reassuring to see I'm not alone in this experience. I've been checking WMR obsessively and starting to worry something was wrong with my return. Based on what everyone is sharing here, it sounds like this is unfortunately just the new normal for processing times this year. I'm going to try accessing my transcript online to see if there's any additional information there that WMR isn't showing. Thanks for posting this - sometimes just knowing others are going through the same thing helps reduce the anxiety of waiting!
Ben Cooper
Anyone know how the amortization works for the amounts above $5,000? My startup costs were about $8,200 and organizational were about $2,800. I understand I can deduct $5k of startup costs immediately, but how do I handle amortizing the remaining $3,200?
0 coins
Harold Oh
โขFor your situation, you'd deduct the full $5,000 of your startup costs immediately on your Schedule C. The remaining $3,200 would be amortized over 180 months (15 years), which means you can deduct about $213 per year for the next 15 years ($3,200 รท 180 ร 12 months for a full year). For your organizational costs, since the total is under $5,000 (at $2,800), you can deduct the entire amount in the first year. Make sure you attach an election statement to your return stating you're electing to amortize startup costs under Section 195 and deduct organizational costs under Section 709 (assuming you're filing as a partnership) or Section 248 (if filing as a corporation).
0 coins
Connor O'Reilly
This is such a helpful thread! I'm in a similar situation with my new single-member LLC and had been stressing about these deductions. One thing I want to add - make sure you keep really detailed records of what you spent and when. I created a spreadsheet categorizing each expense as either startup or organizational from day one, which made tax prep so much easier. Also, for anyone wondering about timing - the IRS considers your business to have "begun" when you start offering goods/services to customers, not when you filed your LLC paperwork. So expenses before that date are typically startup/organizational, while expenses after are regular business deductions. This distinction was crucial for me since I had some overlap expenses right around my launch date. The election statement requirement that @Manny mentioned is super important - I almost forgot to include it and caught it at the last minute. Better to be safe than sorry with the IRS!
0 coins
Benjamin Carter
โขGreat point about the timing distinction! I'm just getting started with my LLC formation and hadn't thought about when exactly the "business began" for tax purposes. When you say "offering goods/services to customers" - does that mean the first sale, or just when you're ready to accept customers? I've set up my website and marketing but haven't made my first sale yet. Want to make sure I'm categorizing my recent expenses correctly between startup costs and regular business expenses.
0 coins