


Ask the community...
Quick question about this - does this same rule apply for state taxes too? My husband and I file separately for federal but jointly for state because our state has better credits for joint filers.
It depends entirely on your state. Some states require you to use the same filing status as your federal return, while others allow you to choose differently. And yes, in states that allow separate choices, the itemization rules can vary too. For example, in some states, if you file jointly at the state level but separately at federal, and one spouse itemizes federally, both must still follow the same itemization approach on the state return. It gets complicated quickly, which is why it's worth checking your specific state's rules or consulting with a tax professional.
I've been following this thread and wanted to share my experience as someone who went through almost exactly the same situation. My spouse and I had been filing separately for about 6 years, with me itemizing (due to high medical expenses and charitable donations) while my spouse took the standard deduction. Like you, we never received any notices from the IRS, so I assumed we were doing everything correctly. It wasn't until I mentioned our situation to a CPA friend that I learned about the "both must itemize if one itemizes" rule for married filing separately. What really opened my eyes was when we finally did a comprehensive comparison of filing jointly vs. separately (with both of us itemizing correctly). We discovered we had been overpaying by about $1,800 annually! The joint filing gave us access to credits we couldn't claim when filing separately, and even though our combined income pushed us into a higher bracket, the overall tax was still significantly lower. The lesson I learned is that tax situations change over time - income levels, deduction amounts, tax law changes - and what made sense years ago might not be optimal anymore. I'd strongly recommend doing that side-by-side comparison before this year's filing deadline. You might be surprised by the results!
Make sure you also check your state tax rules for gambling income! Federal and state rules can be different. Here in NJ, we can deduct losses against winnings without itemizing on our state return, but have to follow the federal rules for our federal return. Really makes a difference if you had losses too.
Does anyone know how California handles this? Their tax system seems way more complicated than federal sometimes.
California is pretty strict with gambling income and losses. They follow the federal approach where you need to report all winnings as income, but you can only deduct losses as an itemized deduction on Schedule CA (540). And just like federal, losses can only offset winnings, not other income. The tricky part with California is they have a higher standard deduction threshold for many taxpayers, so you might not benefit from itemizing unless you have substantial other deductions. Definitely worth calculating both ways to see which gives you the better outcome.
Pro tip from someone who bet regularly - start keeping a "gambling diary" NOW for 2025. Write down dates, locations, specific games/bets, amounts wagered, and amounts won/lost. The IRS specifically mentions a gambling diary as appropriate documentation if you're ever questioned.
Would bank statements showing deposits/withdrawals to gambling sites work instead? Seems easier than tracking every single bet...
Bank statements are definitely helpful and better than nothing, but a detailed gambling diary is much stronger documentation if the IRS ever audits you. The diary shows your intent to properly track your activity and provides specific details about each session. That said, if keeping a detailed diary feels overwhelming, at minimum try to download and save your account statements from each gambling platform at the end of each month. Most sites like DraftKings, FanDuel, etc. let you export transaction histories that show individual bets, winnings, deposits, and withdrawals. This gives you more detail than just bank statements and is easier than writing everything down manually.
I'm going through the EXACT same thing right now but with DraftKings. Is anyone using TurboTax to handle this? I can't figure out where to enter my gambling wins and losses, and it doesn't seem to have a specific spot to reconcile the 1099-K amounts that aren't income. I'm so confused!!
In TurboTax, you need to go to "Income" then "Less Common Income" then "Gambling Winnings." You'll enter your total winnings there, and then your losses go under "Deductions & Credits" then "Deductions" then "Gambling Losses." For the 1099-K reconciliation, you'll need to use the "Other Tax Situations" section. It's definitely not intuitive!
Thank you so much! I was looking in completely the wrong section. Appreciate the step-by-step guidance! I'll try this tonight when I get back to my tax return.
I went through this exact situation last year with my Hard Rock account and PayPal 1099-K. The key thing that helped me was creating a detailed spreadsheet that matched up my PayPal transactions with my Hard Rock win/loss statement by date. What I found was that the 1099-K included not just my deposits, but also some withdrawals that got processed back to PayPal, which made the total even more confusing. The actual taxable amount was way less than what the 1099-K showed. One thing to watch out for - make sure your Hard Rock win/loss statement covers the exact same tax year as your 1099-K. Sometimes there's a day or two difference in how they calculate the reporting period, and those end-of-year transactions can throw everything off. I ended up using the gambling reconciliation worksheet that comes with the tax software to show the IRS exactly why my reported income was different from the 1099-K amount. Keep all your documentation - the win/loss statement, the 1099-K, and any records of your actual deposits/withdrawals. The IRS is seeing a lot of these cases this year so they're pretty familiar with the situation.
Anyone know if the free version of TurboTax lets you import forms? Or do you need to pay for the deluxe or whatever to get that feature?
I tried TurboTax's import feature last year and it was kinda hit or miss. Got my main W2 from my full-time job but completely failed to import anything from my side gig. My bank's 1099-INT imported fine but Robinhood's forms didn't. Just don't go in expecting it to import everything automatically. You'll probably still need to enter some stuff manually. And ALWAYS double-check the imported values against your paper forms. I caught a few errors last year where the imported numbers didn't match my actual documents.
Is there any way to know in advance which institutions are supported for the import?
TurboTax has a list on their website of supported financial institutions for direct import, but it's not always up to date. You can also check during the filing process - when you get to the import section, it'll show you which of your institutions are available before you try to connect. Generally the big players like Chase, Bank of America, Fidelity, Schwab are supported, but smaller credit unions or newer fintech companies might not be. For employers, most major payroll systems like ADP, Paychex, and Workday work, but smaller regional payroll companies often don't participate.
Lily Young
Has anyone tried just calling PayPal to get them to issue a corrected 1099-K? This seems like a massive problem they've created for tons of people who use their service for gambling transactions.
0 coins
Kennedy Morrison
ā¢I tried that route last year. PayPal basically said "too bad, we're required to report all transactions over $600" (was previously $20k). They won't issue a corrected form because technically they're reporting correctly - they processed that amount of money through your account. It's up to us to explain to the IRS that it's not all income. Super annoying.
0 coins
Paige Cantoni
This is such a frustrating situation that many of us are dealing with thanks to the new $600 1099-K reporting threshold. I went through this exact same headache last year with about $12K showing on my PayPal 1099-K when my actual sports betting profit was only around $2,800. What worked for me was keeping meticulous records from each betting platform showing my complete transaction history. Most sites like DraftKings and FanDuel will provide you with annual summary statements if you contact their customer service - these are gold for documentation purposes. I reported my actual gambling winnings as "Other Income" on Schedule 1 and attached a brief statement explaining the discrepancy with the 1099-K. The key is being transparent about the situation rather than trying to hide it. The IRS knows this is a common issue with payment processors now. One tip: make sure you track not just your deposits and withdrawals, but also any bonuses or promotional credits you received. Those can sometimes count as taxable income even if you didn't actually win that money through betting. Keep everything organized in a spreadsheet with dates and amounts - it'll save you tons of stress if you ever get questioned about it.
0 coins