


Ask the community...
Quick question - do you mail the 1040-X or can you e-file an amended federal return now? Last time I had to do this it was paper only and took forever.
You can e-file amended returns now! Started a couple years ago and it's SO much faster. I e-filed my amendment back in January and it was processed in about 8 weeks versus the 6+ months it took when I mailed one in 2022.
From my experience as a tax preparer, whether you need to amend your federal return depends entirely on the nature of the error. If it was something like a state-specific deduction or credit that doesn't appear on your federal return, you're probably fine. But if it involved income, federal deductions, or anything that flows through to both returns, you'll definitely want to file that 1040-X. One thing I always tell my clients: when in doubt, amend. The IRS won't penalize you for correcting an error voluntarily, but they will charge interest and penalties if they catch it first. Since you already received your federal refund, if the amendment shows you owe additional tax, you'll need to pay that plus interest from the original due date. But if you act quickly, the interest should be pretty minimal. Also, keep good records of both your original and amended returns. The IRS sometimes sends notices years later asking about discrepancies, and having everything documented makes those situations much easier to resolve.
This is really helpful advice, especially the part about keeping good records. I'm new to dealing with amended returns and honestly feeling a bit overwhelmed by the whole process. When you say "when in doubt, amend" - is there any downside to filing an amended return if it turns out you didn't actually need to? Like, does it flag you for extra scrutiny or anything like that?
Don't forget about timing your business equipment purchases! If your LLC legitimately needs equipment, vehicles, or other qualifying assets, Section 179 expensing can let you write off up to $1,160,000 in 2025 (subject to phase-out thresholds). That's a perfectly legal way to reduce current year taxable income.
Be careful with buying assets just for tax purposes though. I bought a bunch of "business equipment" in December last year just to get the deduction and my accountant said some of it might not qualify as ordinary and necessary for my business. Apparently the IRS looks at whether the purchase is actually needed for your specific industry.
Another strategy to consider is income splitting if you have a spouse who isn't already in a high tax bracket. You could potentially employ your spouse in the LLC for legitimate business functions (marketing, bookkeeping, administrative work) and pay them a reasonable salary. This shifts some of the LLC income to them at potentially lower tax rates. Also, look into maximizing your business expense deductions that you might be missing. Many LLC owners don't fully utilize the home office deduction, business meals (50% deductible), professional development courses, industry conferences, and business travel expenses. These legitimate deductions can significantly reduce your taxable profit. If you're in a service business, you might also benefit from establishing a reasonable compensation strategy if you convert to S-Corp election. This can help reduce self-employment taxes on the portion of profits you take as distributions rather than wages, though you'll need to pay yourself a reasonable salary first.
Great point about income splitting with a spouse! I'm actually in this exact situation - my spouse has much lower income than my LLC brings in. How do you determine what constitutes "reasonable" compensation for different types of work? I don't want to run into issues with the IRS if they think I'm paying above-market rates just for tax benefits. Also, for the S-Corp election you mentioned - is there a minimum profit threshold where this strategy starts making sense after factoring in the additional payroll costs and complexity?
Has anyone used the IRS Sales Tax Calculator online? It estimates your deductible sales tax based on your income and location, then you can add large purchases like vehicles on top of that. Helped me figure out I wasn't anywhere close to itemizing being worth it.
Just to add another perspective - don't forget about other potential itemized deductions beyond just the car taxes! Things like charitable donations, unreimbursed employee expenses (if you're self-employed), tax preparation fees, and certain investment expenses can add up. I was in a similar boat last year after buying a car, and while the vehicle taxes alone weren't enough to justify itemizing, when I added up my charitable giving ($2,400), some medical expenses that exceeded 7.5% of my income, and a few other things, I ended up about $500 ahead by itemizing. The key is to do a quick calculation of ALL your potential deductions before deciding. Even if the car purchase alone doesn't push you over the standard deduction threshold, it might be the piece that tips the scale when combined with everything else you paid during the year.
This is really good advice! I think a lot of people (myself included) get tunnel vision and only focus on the big ticket item like the car purchase. But you're absolutely right that it's the combination of ALL deductions that matters. I'm curious though - for the medical expenses, how do you calculate that 7.5% threshold? Is that 7.5% of your adjusted gross income, and then only the amount ABOVE that threshold is deductible? I had some dental work done this year that was pretty expensive, but I wasn't sure if it would even count since I thought there was some minimum you had to hit first. Also, when you say "tax preparation fees" - does that include paying for software like TurboTax or H&R Block, or just if you hire an actual accountant?
Quick tip from a tax preparer: If you receive a 1099-K that includes personal transfers, make sure you keep a "contemporaneous log" of your business income. Basically, track tips as you receive them in a notebook or app - date, amount, and maybe client first name (for privacy). This real-time tracking is MUCH stronger evidence than trying to sort it out later. If you're ever audited, having records you created at the time of the transactions will be viewed much more favorably than a spreadsheet you made right before filing taxes.
For tracking tips and business transactions, I'd recommend something simple like a basic spreadsheet app (Google Sheets or Excel mobile) or even a dedicated expense tracking app like Mint or YNAB. The key is consistency - pick something you'll actually use every time you receive a payment. Some massage therapists I know just use their phone's built-in notes app but create a new note each month with a consistent format like "Date - Amount - Client Initials - Notes." Whatever you choose, just make sure you're recording it right when the transaction happens, not trying to remember later!
As someone who went through this exact situation last year, I can't stress enough how important it is to start organizing your records NOW rather than waiting until tax time. The 1099-K will show the gross amount, and you'll need to be able to justify which portions aren't taxable income. One thing I learned the hard way: Venmo's transaction descriptions can be super helpful for sorting business vs personal. Look for patterns - your massage clients probably use words like "tip," "service," or "massage" in their payment notes, while personal transactions might say things like "dinner," "rent," or just be emoji. Also, don't panic about hiring an accountant immediately. Try going through your transactions yourself first using the export feature, and if you get overwhelmed or your situation is more complex than expected, then consider professional help. Many tax preparers are familiar with this 1099-K mess now since it's affecting so many people. The key is documentation - keep everything showing how you determined what was business income versus personal transfers. Screenshots, spreadsheets, notes about regular clients, anything that shows your reasoning was legitimate and not just trying to avoid taxes.
This is such helpful advice! I'm actually in a really similar boat - just started getting tips through Venmo this year and had no idea about the $5K threshold change. The transaction description tip is genius - I never thought to use those payment notes as evidence for categorizing. Quick question though: when you say "keep everything showing how you determined what was business income" - does that mean I should literally screenshot every single transaction? That seems like it would be hundreds of screenshots. Or is a detailed spreadsheet with the reasoning enough for documentation purposes? Also, did you end up having to pay taxes on any personal transfers by mistake, or were you able to successfully separate everything?
Ellie Lopez
Has anyone used SprintTax or OLT for reporting foreign income like this? TurboTax is completely confusing me with how to enter the T4A-NR information.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
β’I used SprintTax last year for a similar situation with Australian income. They handle foreign income much better than TurboTax in my experience. There's a specific section for foreign employment income where you can enter the T4A-NR details, and it automatically completes the Form 1116 for you. The interface walks you through the currency conversion and documentation needs.
0 coins
Ellie Lopez
β’Thanks for the recommendation! I'll check out SprintTax. TurboTax keeps trying to treat my wife's Canadian income as US self-employment income which would make us pay extra SE tax, and I can't figure out how to override it properly.
0 coins
StarSailor}
I'm dealing with a very similar situation - my husband worked in Canada for about 3 weeks and we received a T4A-NR form. What really helped me was understanding that the T4A-NR withholding rate depends on whether you're covered by the US-Canada tax treaty. If your spouse is a US resident, the treaty rate should be 15% for employment income rather than the standard 25% non-resident rate. You might want to check if the correct rate was applied to your withholding. If they withheld at 25% when the treaty rate should have been 15%, you can file for a refund of the excess. Also, make sure to convert the Canadian dollar amounts to US dollars using the average exchange rate for the year (the IRS publishes these rates). This is important for both reporting the income correctly on your US return and calculating the proper Foreign Tax Credit amount. The good news is that even though this seems complicated, it's actually a pretty straightforward situation once you know the steps. The key is just making sure you report it correctly on both sides to avoid double taxation.
0 coins
Natalie Adams
β’This is really helpful information about the treaty rates! I had no idea there was a difference between the standard 25% and the treaty rate of 15%. Looking at our T4A-NR, it looks like they did withhold at 25%, so we might be able to get some of that back. Do you know what form or process is used to claim a refund of the excess withholding? And when you mention the IRS exchange rates, where exactly do they publish those? I want to make sure I'm converting the amounts correctly for our US return. Also, just to confirm my understanding - we would still report the full Canadian income on our US return and claim the Foreign Tax Credit for whatever Canadian tax ends up being final (either the full 25% or the reduced amount after any refund), correct?
0 coins