
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
My cousin just appeared on this reality competition show that films in Vancouver, Canada, though it's produced by an American media company. She ended up winning $25,000 USD while she was there! She's super excited but now we're both confused about the tax situation since she lives in Boston. Does she need to pay taxes to the IRS on prize money that was won physically in Canada? The show producers didn't really give her clear info on this. If she does have to pay US taxes, how exactly are game show winnings typically taxed? Are there different rules because it happened in Canada even though it's an American company? She's worried about getting hit with some unexpected tax bill next year if she doesn't handle this correctly now.
Just checked my refund status and discovered that over 50% of my anticipated refund was taken via TOP (Treasury Offset Program) for my federal student loans. I wasn't expecting this hit right after graduation when I'm trying to get financially established. Is there any recourse to petition for a hardship refund of the offset amount if I establish an IBR payment plan with my loan servicer? I've heard about Form 9465 for installment agreements but unsure if that applies post-offset. Anyone navigate this process successfully?
Be careful about timing here. I tried this route last year and was denied because I waited too long. I filed in February, discovered the offset in March, but didn't contact my loan servicer until May thinking I could take my time gathering documentation. Turns out most servicers have a 90-day window from the offset date, and I missed it by about 2 weeks. Now I'm on an IBR plan but that money is gone for good. The worst part? If I had set up the IBR a month earlier, the offset might never have happened in the first place.
This is such valuable information! I wish I had known about these options when my refund got hit with an offset two years ago. For anyone reading this thread, I want to emphasize what several people mentioned about timing - don't wait like I did. I assumed the money was just gone and didn't even try to fight it. Now I'm kicking myself seeing that there were actually options available. The 60-90 day window seems to be pretty standard across servicers, so if this happens to you, act immediately. Also, document EVERYTHING - take screenshots of your bank balance, save any overdue notices, and keep records of all your calls. Having worked in customer service myself, I know that detailed documentation makes a huge difference in how seriously your case gets treated.
Hey everyone - I'm looking for recommendations on tax planning/projection software that regular people can use for figuring out their annual taxes throughout the current year. Basically want to check our withholdings and spot potential issues every couple months. Here's the deal - my husband and I (we file jointly) are going to get slammed with a pretty hefty tax bill this time around. The main reason is we've been under-withholding on our wages. We each run our own businesses (both S-corps where we take what's considered 'reasonable' salaries), plus I work another W2 job on the side. We followed some terrible advice and now we're paying for it. I want to take a more proactive approach to planning and be able to model different scenarios to figure out what makes the most sense for our situation. I've searched online but can't seem to find anything specifically designed for regular homeowners/taxpayers. Most of the planning software I'm finding seems to be built for tax professionals (which I get). Any suggestions would be super appreciated!
Has anyone tried the IRS's W-4 calculator? I think it's free and supposedly helps you figure out proper withholding based on multiple jobs. Wondering if it would solve part of your problem at least for the W2 portion?
The IRS W-4 calculator is decent for multiple W2 jobs but completely falls apart when you throw S-corporation income into the mix. It doesn't account for the fact that you're paying yourself a salary from your own business or that you might take distributions. I ended up STILL owing $4500 after using it last year.
I've been dealing with a similar situation - multiple income streams including S-corp income can really mess with your withholding calculations! One tool that's worked well for me is FreeTaxUSA's TaxCaster. It's free and handles S-corp salary vs distribution scenarios better than most consumer tools I've tried. The key thing I learned is that you need to track your S-corp salary as regular W-2 income for withholding purposes, but then account for the self-employment tax savings compared to if that income was straight 1099. Most calculators miss this nuance. Also, don't sleep on making quarterly estimated payments - even if your withholding is close, having that extra buffer from estimated payments can save you from underpayment penalties. I set up automatic transfers to a separate "tax savings" account so the money is there when quarterly dates roll around. The IRS safe harbor rule is your friend too - if you pay 100% of last year's tax liability through withholding + estimated payments (110% if your AGI was over $150k), you won't owe penalties even if you end up owing more at filing time.
Title: How long does IRS Installment Agreement approval take? Form 9465 submitted 30+ days ago 1 Hello everyone, I'm getting a bit anxious about my tax payment situation. I submitted Form 9465 (Installment Agreement Request) along with my tax return about a month ago. I specified on line 12 that I wanted to make monthly payments on the 15th of each month. It's been well over 30 days now, and I still haven't received any notification about whether my installment plan was approved or not. I'm not sure what to do at this point. Should I just start making payments according to the plan I proposed, even though they haven't officially approved it yet? I'm also concerned about penalties - if I wait for their decision before making any payments, will I get hit with additional penalties for late payment? The amount I owe is about $7,800 and I really want to avoid making this situation worse. Any advice would be greatly appreciated!
14 Has anyone dealt with having an installment agreement request rejected? I'm worried mine might get rejected because I had a previous one that I defaulted on about 3 years ago. Just wondering what the process is like if they say no.
23 I had one rejected last year. They sent a letter explaining exactly why (in my case, I proposed too low of a monthly payment for my income level). They gave me 30 days to submit a new proposal with a higher payment amount.
I went through this exact same situation about 6 months ago! Submitted my Form 9465 and waited what felt like forever. Here's what I learned: First, definitely start making payments now according to your proposed schedule. The IRS continues charging penalties and interest while they process your request, so you're just costing yourself more money by waiting. Any payments you make will be credited to your account regardless. Second, the processing times are really unpredictable right now. Mine took about 7 weeks to get approved, but I've heard of people waiting 2-3 months. The $7,800 you owe should qualify for streamlined processing since it's under $50,000, but that doesn't seem to be speeding things up much lately. One thing that helped me was calling the Practitioner Priority Service line (if you have a tax professional) or trying to get through to the regular customer service line very early in the morning. They were able to at least confirm my request was in the system and being processed. Don't stress too much - the vast majority of installment agreement requests get approved as long as you proposed a reasonable payment amount based on your financial situation. Just keep making those payments!
I've been contributing to my Roth IRA for several years now and I'm trying to understand the 5-year rule regarding withdrawals. I know you need to be over 59ยฝ years old AND the account needs to be open for 5 years before you can take money out without penalties. Here's my situation: I opened my Roth IRA in 2019 and I've been consistently funding it: 2019 - contributed $6k 2020 - contributed $6k 2021 - contributed $6k 2022 - contributed $6k 2023 - contributed $6k So my understanding is that starting in 2024, I'll have satisfied the 5-year rule since my account would have been open for 5 years. But here's where I'm confused: Can I withdraw ALL of my contributions plus earnings (about $30k plus whatever gains) without penalty? Or am I only allowed to withdraw the first year's contribution plus its earnings without penalty (just the $6k from 2019 plus whatever that specific money earned)? Does each contribution have its own 5-year clock or is it just the account itself that needs to be 5 years old? I'm over 60 if that matters for this situation.
Something everyone seems to be overlooking in this thread - the contribution limits you listed don't seem right. The Roth IRA contribution limit for 2019-2022 was only $6,000 per year if you were under 50, or $7,000 if you were 50+. You mentioned contributing $8k each year which would exceed the limits unless you're counting both yours and a spouse's contributions together? If you over-contributed, you might need to address that before worrying about the withdrawal rules. Excess contributions are subject to a 6% tax penalty for each year they remain in the account.
You're absolutely right about the contribution limits - that was a typo in my post. I meant to write $6k per year, not $8k. I'm definitely aware of the contribution limits and have been careful not to exceed them. I'm still just trying to understand whether the 5-year rule applies to the account as a whole or to each individual contribution. From what the others have said, it sounds like once my first Roth IRA hits the 5-year mark AND I'm over 59ยฝ (which I am), then all contributions and earnings can be withdrawn tax and penalty free. That's a relief!
Just to add a small clarification that might help - there's also a separate ordering rule for Roth IRA withdrawals that determines what comes out first: 1) Regular contributions come out first (always tax and penalty free) 2) Conversion contributions come out next (might be subject to penalties if within 5 years of conversion and under 59ยฝ) 3) Earnings come out last (subject to tax and possibly penalties if you don't meet requirements) Since you're over 59ยฝ and if your first Roth contribution was indeed in 2019, then starting in 2024, everything comes out tax and penalty free including earnings. This assumes 2019 was truly your first-ever Roth IRA.
This ordering rule is super important! I messed up by not knowing this and incorrectly reported my distribution on my taxes. Can you clarify something? If I take out $15k from my Roth that has $30k in contributions and $20k in earnings, I don't need to specify which "portion" I'm withdrawing right? The IRS automatically considers it coming from contributions first?
Exactly right! You don't need to specify which portion you're withdrawing - the IRS automatically applies the ordering rules. So your $15k withdrawal would be treated as coming entirely from your $30k in contributions, making it completely tax and penalty free regardless of your age or how long the account has been open. The IRS tracks this automatically through Form 8606 if you have any conversion contributions, but for regular contributions like in your example, it's straightforward. You should receive a 1099-R showing the distribution, but the taxable amount would be zero since you're only withdrawing contributions. Just make sure to keep good records of your contribution amounts each year in case the IRS ever questions it. The brokerage should also have this information, but it's always good to have your own documentation.
Finley Garrett
When I won on a Canadian game show (different one, smaller prize), they actually withheld Canadian taxes first, then I had to report it in the US. But I got a foreign tax credit for the Canadian taxes paid, so I didn't end up paying double. Make sure your cousin keeps ALL documentation they gave her. Also, if this aired on TV, keep a copy of the episode if possible as proof if ever questioned.
0 coins
Madison Tipne
Did you have to file a Canadian tax return too, or just the US one?
0 coins
Issac Nightingale
Your cousin should also be prepared for this to potentially affect her state taxes in Massachusetts. Game show winnings are typically subject to state income tax as well, so she'll need to report the $25,000 on her Massachusetts return too. One more thing - if the show hasn't aired yet, she might want to consider making quarterly estimated tax payments now rather than waiting until next year's filing deadline. Owing $25k worth of additional taxable income could result in a significant tax bill, and the IRS charges underpayment penalties if you don't pay enough throughout the year. She can calculate roughly what she'll owe using her current tax bracket and make payments using Form 1040ES. The safe harbor rule is to pay at least 90% of this year's tax liability or 100% of last year's (110% if her previous year's AGI was over $150k). Since this is unexpected income, making an estimated payment could save her from penalties later.
0 coins