Pay nothing until a live IRS agent is on the phone with you.
Can't reach IRS? Claimyr calls for you, so you don't have to wait on hold.
$0 upfront. We only hold your card.
No live agent, no charge.
$9.99 is charged only once a live IRS agent is on the phone with you.
Using Claimyr will:
- Connect you to a human agent at the IRS
- Skip the long phone menu
- Call the correct department
- Redial until on hold
- Forward a call to your phone with reduced hold time
- Give you free callbacks if the IRS drops your call
Ask the community...
- DO post questions about your issues.
- DO answer questions and support each other.
- DO post tips & tricks to help folks.
- DO NOT post call problems here - there is a support tab at the top for that :)
Join the conversation
Join the conversation
Just adding another data point - I'm from Montreal and I used the US Consulate route last summer. Made an appointment online, brought my passport + W-7 + tax return, and they certified the copy right there. Took about 25 minutes total. Mailed everything to the IRS and had my ITIN in about 7 weeks. One tip they gave me at the consulate: make sure you call ahead to confirm they offer the passport certification service specifically for ITIN purposes. Some smaller consulates apparently don't offer it or have limited hours for this service.
Great thread with lots of helpful info! I went through this process as a Canadian in 2023 and wanted to add a few practical tips: 1. **Timing is everything** - If you're applying during tax season (January-April), expect longer processing times. I applied in May and got my ITIN in 6 weeks, but friends who applied in February waited 10+ weeks. 2. **Double-check your W-7 form** - The most common mistake I see other Canadians make is in Section 6a where you select your reason for needing an ITIN. Make sure you're checking the right exception box based on your specific situation. 3. **Keep copies of EVERYTHING** - The IRS will return your certified passport copy, but sometimes things get lost in the mail. I made photocopies of all documents before sending them. 4. **US Consulate appointment booking** - Book your consulate appointment ASAP. In Toronto especially, they can be booked weeks out. You can find the online booking system on the US Consulate website. The certified copy route is definitely the way to go - never send your original passport! I was traveling internationally while my application was processing and had zero issues.
For your situation as an independent contractor working remotely for a US company, you'll want to select exception 1(d) "Nonresident alien filing a U.S. tax return." Exception 1(a) is specifically for claiming tax treaty benefits, which doesn't sound like your primary reason for needing the ITIN. As a Canadian contractor receiving US income, you're required to file a US tax return to report that income, which is exactly what exception 1(d) covers. You'll likely be filing Form 1040NR (Nonresident Alien Income Tax Return) along with your W-7 application. Just make sure you have your 1099-NEC or other income documentation from your US client ready to include with your application - the IRS needs to see the tax return that requires the ITIN. Good catch on double-checking this detail - it's exactly the kind of mistake that causes rejections and delays!
For your situation as an independent contractor working remotely for a US company, you'd want to select exception 1(d) "Nonresident alien filing a U.S. tax return." Exception 1(a) is specifically for claiming treaty benefits, which typically applies when you're trying to reduce withholding taxes under the US-Canada tax treaty. As an independent contractor receiving US-source income, you'll be filing Form 1040NR to report that income, which makes 1(d) the correct choice. The key distinction is that you're filing a return to report income rather than claiming a specific treaty benefit to reduce taxes. I'd also recommend including a letter from your US company client explaining the nature of your work relationship and that you're receiving US-source income as an independent contractor. This helps support your application and can prevent any questions from the IRS about why you need an ITIN.
Join the conversation
I think everyone is missing a key point on the insolvency worksheet 4681. The liabilities need to be ones that would have been discharged in bankruptcy! At least that's what my accountant told me. So if your back taxes wouldn't be dischargeable in bankruptcy (which most aren't), then they might not count on Line 10.
That's not quite right. The insolvency worksheet instructions don't say anything about debts needing to be dischargeable in bankruptcy. Line 10 specifically asks for "taxes owed" with no qualification about whether they'd be dischargeable in bankruptcy. I just went through this process last month.
You're right, I double-checked and I had it confused with something else. Line 10 is just asking for the total amount of taxes you owed at the time the debt was canceled, regardless of whether they'd be dischargeable in bankruptcy. My mistake! All federal, state and local taxes that were owed at the time should be included on Line 10.
Don't forget that the worksheet also asks for "other assets" on Line 5. Do you have any retirement accounts, cash value life insurance, household goods, etc? You need to include the fair market value of all those things too, which might affect your insolvency calculation.
Thanks for bringing that up! I do have an old 401k with about $8,200 in it that I forgot to mention. I also have some collectibles worth maybe $2,000. I guess I need to add those to my asset total which would bring it to around $18,500 instead of just $8,300. Does this mean I'm not insolvent anymore? My liabilities are around $21,800 ($14,500 credit card + $7,300 taxes), so I'd only be insolvent by about $3,300 now. Would I still get any tax benefit from that?
Yes, you'd still get a tax benefit! Even if you're only insolvent by $3,300, that means $3,300 of your $14,500 forgiven debt can be excluded from taxable income. You'd only have to report $11,200 as income instead of the full $14,500. That's still a significant tax savings. Make sure to get accurate valuations for all your assets though - the IRS can question your numbers if they seem unreasonable. For the 401k, use the account balance as of the date the debt was forgiven. For collectibles, you might want to get them appraised or at least research comparable sales to support your $2,000 valuation.
Join the conversation
The biggest thing to watch out for switching from in-person to online is making sure you accurately transfer last year's info. Enter the EXACT SAME personal info (names, SSNs, DOB) as your previous returns to avoid delays.
So true. My brother-in-law had his refund delayed 3 months because he abbreviated his middle name differently than previous years. Such a dumb thing but the IRS systems flagged it.
I made this exact switch two years ago and haven't looked back! Was paying around $300 at H&R Block and getting similar refunds to what you described. With TurboTax Deluxe, I now pay about $60 and get the same refund amounts. The key thing that gave me confidence was realizing that with W-2 income and kids, most of your refund comes from automatic credits (child tax credit, earned income credit if applicable) that any software will catch. The "professionals get you more money" thing is mostly true for people with complex situations like rental properties or businesses. One tip: Before you file, you can actually run through the entire process in TurboTax without submitting to see your estimated refund. If it's significantly different from what you normally get, then you know something might be off. But for straightforward situations like ours, the software is just as good as a human preparer who's probably using similar software anyway.
Join the conversation
I used to struggle with this exact question until i took an economics class. Something that helped me understand was the concept of "marginal dollars" and what economists call "diminishing marginal utility." Basically, each additional dollar means less to you as you get richer. The difference between having $1000 and $2000 is HUGE when you're poor (rent vs homeless). But the difference between having $1 million and $1,001,000 barely impacts your life at all. A progressive tax tries to take this into account. Taking 30% from someone making $25k hurts their ability to meet basic needs, while taking 15% from them and 35% from someone making millions still leaves the wealthy person with all needs met and plenty of luxury. Flat taxes SOUND fair because the percentage is the same, but when you think about the real-world impact on livelihood, they affect people very differently.
This makes sense in theory but where do you draw the line? Who decides at what point someone has "enough" and should pay more? Seems arbitrary and ripe for political manipulation.
You're absolutely right to question this! I think what's missing from the flat tax discussion is that true "fairness" might not just be about equal percentages, but about equal sacrifice or equal impact on quality of life. Consider this: if someone making $25k pays $3,750 in taxes, they might have to skip meals, delay medical care, or live in unsafe housing. But someone making $1.3M paying $195k still has over $1M left - they can still afford luxury cars, multiple homes, private healthcare, and generational wealth building. The progressive system tries to ensure that everyone contributes meaningfully without creating genuine hardship. It's less about "penalizing success" and more about recognizing that money has different survival value at different income levels. That said, I do see the appeal of flat taxes for their simplicity and the psychological fairness of "same rules for everyone." Both systems have merit - it really comes down to whether you prioritize mathematical equality or practical impact equality.
Ana Rusula
Has anyone dealt with the healthcare premium tax credit in this situation? My boyfriend and I are having a baby next month and we get our insurance through the marketplace with a subsidy. We're trying to figure out if claiming the baby will affect our subsidy amount.
0 coins
Mary Bates
•Yes, this is an important consideration! The Premium Tax Credit is based on household size and income, so adding a dependent will likely increase your subsidy amount since your household size increases while income stays the same. However, only one tax household can claim the child, so if you and your boyfriend file separately, only the person claiming the child would get the increased subsidy. This could be another factor in deciding who should claim your baby.
0 coins
Dylan Mitchell
Congratulations on your new baby! As someone who went through this exact situation a few years ago, I can share what we learned. The key thing to understand is that since you're unmarried, you both technically qualify to claim your daughter, but only ONE of you can actually do it each tax year. Given that your incomes are similar ($58k vs $62k), the decision should come down to who gets the bigger tax benefit. Here are the main things that will be affected by who claims her: 1. **Child Tax Credit** - Up to $2,000 per child 2. **Child and Dependent Care Credit** - If you're paying for childcare 3. **Earned Income Tax Credit** - This phases out at higher incomes, so might benefit the lower earner more 4. **Head of Household filing status** - Better tax brackets and higher standard deduction than filing single Since you pay for health insurance, that shows you're providing support, but it doesn't automatically mean you should be the one to claim her. The person who gets to file as Head of Household will likely see the biggest benefit. My advice: Use tax software to run both scenarios before you file. See what your combined tax liability looks like with each of you claiming her, then go with whichever saves your household the most money overall. You can also alternate years if that works better long-term. Just make sure you communicate clearly about who's claiming her each year - the IRS will flag duplicate claims and that creates a headache for everyone!
0 coins