


Ask the community...
I'm dealing with a very similar situation right now - client formed an S-Corp for real estate without consulting me first, and now we're trying to clean up the mess. One thing I haven't seen mentioned yet is the impact on any existing loans or mortgages on the property. When we convert from S-Corp to LLC status, some lenders consider this a change in ownership that could trigger a "due on sale" clause, even though it's the same beneficial owner. I've had one client where the bank demanded immediate payoff of a commercial mortgage during an entity conversion, which created a huge cash flow problem. Has anyone here dealt with lender issues during S-Corp to LLC conversions? I'm wondering if there's a way to structure the conversion to minimize the risk of triggering these clauses, or if we should get written consent from lenders before proceeding with the entity change. Also, for those who've successfully completed these conversions - did you find it helpful to get a formal legal opinion letter documenting that the conversion was done properly? I'm thinking this might be useful protection if the IRS ever questions the transaction down the road.
You raise an excellent point about lender issues that often gets overlooked! I dealt with this exact situation about two years ago with a client who had a commercial property loan. The key is to be proactive with the lender communication. What worked for us was contacting the lender before starting the conversion process and explaining that this was purely a tax election change with no change in beneficial ownership. We provided documentation showing the same individual owned 100% before and after the conversion. Most commercial lenders understand these entity conversions happen for legitimate tax reasons, but they want to be informed rather than surprised. We also structured it as a simple revocation of S-Corp status rather than any kind of merger or reorganization, which helped frame it as a tax classification change rather than a transfer of ownership. The bank ultimately provided a written confirmation that they wouldn't invoke the due-on-sale clause as long as the beneficial ownership remained unchanged. Regarding the legal opinion letter - I haven't found it necessary for straightforward conversions where you're just revoking S status and electing LLC treatment. However, if you're doing anything more complex like an F reorganization, having that documentation could definitely be worthwhile insurance. The cost is usually modest compared to the potential headaches if something goes wrong. @Ava Harris Have you already reached out to your client s'lenders, or are you still in the planning phase?
This has been such a valuable thread to follow! I'm dealing with a similar situation where a client set up an S-Corp for their rental property business about a year ago, and we're now realizing it's creating more problems than benefits. One aspect I wanted to add to the discussion is the timing considerations around year-end. Since we're in April, if Anastasia's client decides to proceed with the conversion, they might want to consider timing it for the end of this tax year (December 31, 2025) to create a clean break for tax reporting purposes. This would mean filing the S-Corp return for the full 2025 year, then starting fresh as an LLC for 2026. It simplifies the bookkeeping and avoids the complexity of partial-year returns that some have mentioned. Also, I noticed several people recommended getting IRS confirmation over the phone, but has anyone had success getting written confirmation of the conversion process? I've found that having something in writing from the IRS can be incredibly valuable if questions come up during future audits, especially for transactions that involve real estate and potential depreciation recapture issues. The lender communication point that Ava raised is crucial - I've seen too many people get blindsided by due-on-sale clauses during entity conversions. Always better to have those conversations upfront rather than deal with surprised lenders after the fact.
This thread has been incredibly helpful! As someone who's been putting off organizing my tax records, I'm realizing I need to get serious about this before tax season hits. One question I haven't seen addressed yet - what about receipts from mobile payment apps like Venmo, PayPal, or Cash App? I use these for a lot of business expenses, especially when paying contractors or splitting costs with business partners. The transaction history shows the amount and date, but often doesn't have detailed descriptions of what was purchased. Should I be taking screenshots of these transactions and adding my own notes about what they were for? Or is the basic transaction record from the app sufficient as long as I can explain the business purpose? Also, for anyone who mentioned using receipt scanning apps - do you scan receipts immediately or do you have a system where you batch them weekly/monthly? I'm trying to figure out the most realistic approach that I'll actually stick to!
Great questions about mobile payment apps! For Venmo, PayPal, Cash App etc., the basic transaction record usually isn't sufficient on its own since these platforms often lack detailed descriptions. I'd definitely recommend taking screenshots and adding notes about the business purpose, or better yet, ask your contractors to send you a separate invoice or receipt that you can reference. The IRS wants to see what the payment was for, not just that money changed hands. So if you paid a contractor $500 via Venmo for "office renovation," having a text exchange or email discussing the work, plus photos of the completed work, really strengthens your documentation. As for scanning timing - I've found that immediate scanning works best for me, even though it felt tedious at first. I keep a designated spot by my front door where I empty my pockets, and I scan receipts right then using my phone before they get lost or faded. For digital receipts, I forward them to a dedicated email folder as soon as they hit my inbox. The key is making it so automatic that you don't have to think about it!
Great discussion everyone! I wanted to add something that might help with organization - I've been using a simple spreadsheet to track all my business expenses in real-time, with columns for date, vendor, amount, category, payment method, and receipt location (physical file vs digital folder). This has been a lifesaver because even if I lose a receipt, I have a record of when and where the expense occurred, which makes it much easier to request duplicate receipts from vendors if needed. Plus, during my audit preparation, I could quickly filter by category or date range to pull together related documentation. One thing I learned the hard way - if you're claiming home office deductions, take photos of your office space and keep records of when you set it up. The IRS wanted to see that my home office was used "regularly and exclusively" for business, and having photos with timestamps really helped establish that timeline. Also, for anyone worried about digital storage - I keep everything in Google Drive with a shared folder that my accountant can access. That way if something happens to me or my computer, my tax prep person can still access all the documentation. Just make sure you trust whoever you're sharing access with!
This spreadsheet approach is brilliant! I'm definitely going to start doing this. Quick question about the home office photos - did you just take regular photos with your phone or did you need something more formal? I've been using part of my bedroom as an office space and I'm worried the IRS might not consider it "exclusive" enough since it's technically a dual-purpose room. Also, when you say "shared folder with your accountant" - do you give them full access or just view-only? I'm a bit paranoid about security but I can see how that would be super convenient during tax time.
I just completed my ID.me verification yesterday and this entire thread has been a lifesaver! Reading through everyone's experiences really helps set realistic expectations for what's ahead. Like so many others here, I had multiple failed attempts with the facial recognition - it's almost like that's just part of the process at this point. Got the confirmation screen finally, so now I'm settling in for the waiting game. Based on all the timelines shared here, it sounds like I should expect anywhere from 3-9 weeks, with most people falling in that 4-6 week range. I'll definitely start checking my transcript on Friday mornings like everyone suggests - seems like that's when the real updates happen. It's reassuring to know that the 570 hold code is normal and that weeks of no movement doesn't mean something's wrong. Thanks to everyone who took the time to share their experiences and timelines - it makes this whole process feel much less overwhelming!
Welcome to the waiting club! I just went through this whole process a few weeks ago and can definitely relate to the facial recognition struggles - I think I failed that step at least 4 times before it finally worked. You're smart to set those realistic expectations based on everyone's shared experiences here. The Friday morning transcript checking really is the way to go - I learned that the hard way after obsessively checking daily for nothing. One thing that helped me during the waiting period was remembering that each Friday with no movement just meant I was one week closer to resolution. The 570 code will probably show up on your transcript in the next week or so, and then it's just a matter of patience while they work through their process. Hang in there - the hardest part (ID.me verification) is behind you now!
I completed my ID.me verification about 6 weeks ago and wanted to provide an update for everyone still waiting. After dealing with the usual photo upload issues (seriously, why is that system so problematic?), I finally got through the verification successfully. Like many of you, I started checking my transcript every Friday morning based on advice from this community. I saw the 570 hold code appear about 10 days after verification, and it stayed there for what felt like forever - about 4.5 weeks. Then last Friday morning, boom - 571 release code and 846 refund issued date all appeared at once! My refund is scheduled to hit my account this Wednesday. The waiting was absolutely brutal, especially when dealing with those medical bills that just keep coming. But I can confirm that no movement for weeks doesn't mean something's wrong - it's just the IRS working through their massive backlog. For anyone just starting this journey, that Friday morning transcript check really is the key to staying sane during the process. Hang in there everyone - your turn is coming!
Congratulations on finally getting through the process! Your timeline is really encouraging - 6 weeks total with about 4.5 weeks of the 570 code showing is right in line with what most people here have experienced. I'm currently at week 3 after my ID.me verification and seeing that dreaded 570 code just sitting there, so hearing your success story gives me hope that movement could happen any Friday now. You're absolutely right about those photo upload issues - it's like they designed that system to be as frustrating as possible! The Friday morning transcript checking has definitely become my weekly ritual too. Thanks for taking the time to share your update - it's exactly the kind of real-world timeline info that helps those of us still in the waiting phase stay patient and know we're on the right track.
Has anyone run into Zelle transfer limits when doing larger amounts? I tried to move $8k once and my bank limited me to $3500 per day.
One thing to keep in mind is that while these transfers aren't taxable, you should still keep good records of them. I learned this the hard way when the IRS questioned some large deposits in my account during an audit a few years back. Even though they were just transfers from my other bank, I had to provide documentation proving both accounts were mine and that the money wasn't new income. I'd recommend keeping screenshots of both accounts showing your name, and maybe even a simple spreadsheet tracking the transfer dates and amounts. It's probably overkill, but it'll save you headaches if anyone ever questions where that money came from. The IRS agent told me that clear documentation makes these situations resolve much faster.
This is really solid advice! I never thought about keeping records for something that seems so straightforward, but you're absolutely right. Better to have the documentation and not need it than to scramble during an audit. Did the IRS give you any guidance on how long to keep those records? I'm assuming it's the same as other tax documents (7 years), but wanted to check since these aren't technically "tax" transactions.
Edwards Hugo
Wait, no one's mentioned the tax trap with refinancing! If you took cash out and didn't use that money for rental property improvements, that portion of interest isn't deductible as a rental expense! Say you owed $150k, refinanced for $200k, and used that extra $50k for personal expenses - the interest on 75% of your loan is rental expense but 25% is personal. Easy to mess this up.
0 coins
Gianna Scott
โขIs that really true? I thought mortgage interest on rental properties was always deductible regardless of what you did with the cash out. That's different from primary residences where you have the whole mortgage interest deduction limitations.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
โขThanks for pointing this out! I actually didn't take any cash out in my refinance - just lowered the interest rate and reset the term. The loan amount was almost identical to what I owed before, just with a slightly better rate. So luckily I don't need to worry about this particular issue, but it's definitely good to know for future reference!
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
Great question about refinancing costs! I went through this exact situation last year and it's definitely confusing at first. From my research and experience, you're on the right track. The $3,100 in loan origination fees and points should be amortized over the life of your new loan - so if it's a 30-year loan, you'd deduct about $103 per year ($3,100 รท 30 years). The remaining $4,100 in closing costs (attorney fees, title search, recording fees, etc.) can typically be deducted as ordinary rental expenses in 2024. Just make sure to review your closing statement line by line since some fees might have specific rules. One tip: if you refinanced mid-year, remember that you can only deduct the portion of the amortized costs that corresponds to the months the loan was active in 2024. So if you closed in July, you'd only deduct 6/12 of that annual $103 amount for 2024. The fact that your tax software is handling the origination fees and points correctly is a good sign - it sounds like you're set up properly!
0 coins
Sofia Ramirez
โขThis is really helpful! I'm new to rental property taxes and just refinanced my duplex last month. Quick question - when you say "review your closing statement line by line," are there any specific fees that commonly get miscategorized? I'm looking at mine now and there are so many different charges, I want to make sure I don't accidentally put something in the wrong bucket.
0 coins