


Ask the community...
Has anyone else noticed that this seems to be happening more often lately? I returned something to HomeGoods last week and they tried to keep the tax too. When I questioned it, they suddenly "found a way" to refund the full amount. I think some retailers are trying this as a sneaky profit tactic hoping people don't notice or complain.
I work in retail (not naming the store) and can confirm some places are starting to do this intentionally. Our system was recently updated to default to "tax retained" on returns unless the manager overrides it. Most customers don't notice the small difference, especially on cheaper items. Probably doesn't help my job security to admit this but it feels dishonest.
This is really concerning if retailers are systematically doing this. I work in tax compliance and can tell you that what BigTech Store told you is absolutely incorrect. Sales tax refunds on returned merchandise are governed by state law, not store policy. When you return an item, the original transaction is essentially being reversed. The store collected that tax as an agent of the state - they don't get to keep it when the underlying sale is canceled. Most states have specific provisions requiring retailers to refund sales tax on returned items, and failure to do so can result in penalties for the retailer. I'd recommend going back with your receipt and asking to speak with a manager. If they refuse, you can file a complaint with your state's department of revenue. They take sales tax compliance seriously and will investigate retailers who aren't following proper refund procedures. The fact that some commenters are seeing this happen more frequently suggests this might be a deliberate policy at some chains, which is even more problematic from a regulatory standpoint.
Thanks for the detailed explanation from a compliance perspective! This is exactly the kind of professional insight I was hoping to find. The fact that you mention this could be a deliberate policy at some chains is really alarming. I'm definitely going back to BigTech Store with this information. Do you happen to know if there's a specific timeframe I need to file a complaint with the state department of revenue if they continue to refuse? And would it help to document the conversation or get something in writing from them about their "policy" of keeping sales tax on returns? I'm also wondering if this affects their sales tax remittance to the state - like are they essentially double-dipping by keeping customer refunds AND potentially not adjusting their tax payments to the state?
I switched from TaxAct to TurboTax for our S Corp last year and it was definitely worth it! Like you, I was getting frustrated with TaxAct's outdated interface. TurboTax handles the S Corp passthrough income much more smoothly - especially the flow from the business return to personal. The interview process walks you through everything step by step, which helped me catch some deductions I'd been missing (like properly calculating the home office percentage for business use). One specific advantage: TurboTax does a better job explaining the reasonable salary requirements for S Corp owners taking distributions. This is crucial since the IRS scrutinizes this area heavily with 1099 income flowing through S Corps. The price difference is noticeable, but given that you're already doing the accounting work yourself, the time savings and reduced stress during tax season made it worthwhile for us. Plus their customer support is significantly better if you run into issues. If you're comfortable with tax concepts already, you might also want to double-check your past returns to make sure you haven't missed anything over the years with TaxAct's less intuitive interface.
This is really helpful! I'm curious - when you mention checking past returns for missed items, did you find any significant issues when you switched? I'm wondering if it's worth having someone review my last few years of TaxAct returns before I make the switch to see if there are any patterns of missed deductions or errors.
I made the exact same switch two years ago and haven't looked back! As a freelance graphic designer with an S Corp handling multiple 1099s, I was getting so frustrated with TaxAct's clunky interface. TurboTax's biggest advantage for S Corps is how it handles the flow-through calculations automatically. When you complete the S Corp return (1120S), it seamlessly transfers the K-1 information to your personal return without you having to manually enter everything twice. With TaxAct, I always felt like I was double-checking myself constantly. One thing that really impressed me: TurboTax caught that I wasn't properly handling my quarterly estimated payments allocation between the business and personal sides. It walked me through the correct way to report them, which actually got me a slightly larger refund. The interface is definitely more modern and intuitive. The step-by-step interview process for S Corp specific issues (like reasonable salary vs distributions) gives you confidence you're doing it right. Worth the extra cost in my opinion, especially since you're already doing the heavy lifting on the accounting side. Pro tip: wait for their early bird pricing in December if you're not in a rush - you can often get the business version for about 30% off.
This is exactly the kind of detailed comparison I was looking for! The automatic flow-through from 1120S to personal return sounds like a huge time-saver. I've definitely been doing a lot of manual double-entry with TaxAct and always worry I'm missing something. The quarterly estimated payments issue you mentioned is particularly relevant - I feel like I never quite get that allocation right between business and personal. Did TurboTax's guidance help you understand the logic behind how to split them properly, or does it just do the calculations automatically? And thanks for the December pricing tip! Since we're still early in tax season, I might wait and see if they offer any deals.
This whole system is such a scam. The government knows exactly how much we owe, but they make us figure it out ourselves and then penalize us if we get it wrong. Meanwhile, rich people pay nothing with their fancy accountants finding loopholes. Last year I owed $600 after getting refunds for years and nearly had a heart attack.
It does seem unnecessarily complicated, but there are some free resources that can help. I've been using the free filing options through the IRS website for years and haven't had any issues. They partner with several tax software companies that offer free filing if your income is below a certain threshold.
I went through something very similar when I switched jobs mid-year! The key thing to understand is that your withholding is calculated based on what your employer thinks your annual income will be, but if you started a higher-paying job partway through the year, the calculations can get thrown off. When you were making $32k, you were likely in the 12% tax bracket, but jumping to $68k puts you into the 22% bracket for a portion of your income. The $5.3k withheld might have been appropriate if you had earned $68k for the full year, but since you probably earned less than that (due to starting the job partway through), the withholding percentage was based on incomplete information. The fact that you only owe $15 means your withholding was actually pretty accurate overall! Many people in your situation end up owing much more. For next year, I'd recommend using the IRS withholding calculator in January to make sure your W-4 is set up correctly for a full year at your new salary level.
Does anyone know if I can file a 1065 partnership return myself using regular tax software, or do I need to hire an accountant? I'm also a small manufacturer with a 50/50 partnership, but the quotes I've received from CPAs are outrageous!
I used TaxAct Business last year for our partnership return and it worked pretty well. There's definitely a learning curve but it walks you through all the forms including 1125-A. Saved us about $1,200 compared to what our accountant wanted to charge.
I went through this exact same situation last year when my wife and I converted our craft business to an LLC! The Form 1125-A confusion is totally normal - I must have read the instructions 50 times before it clicked. Since you're manufacturing products from raw materials, you definitely need Form 1125-A. Here's what helped me understand it: think of it as tracking the "journey" of your materials from purchase to finished product. Your beginning inventory is zero (first year), then you add all material costs throughout the year, subtract what you actually used in products you sold, and what's left is your ending inventory. The key insight that saved me was realizing that materials sitting in my workshop on December 31st - even if it's just $50 worth of fabric or wood - counts as ending inventory and affects your taxes. I initially tried to say my ending inventory was zero because we "use everything quickly," but my accountant caught that mistake. One thing that really helped was doing a physical count on December 31st and taking photos of all unused materials with rough cost estimates. Made the whole process much clearer for the following year too.
This is incredibly helpful! The "journey" concept makes so much sense - I was overthinking it by trying to figure out complex inventory systems when really it's just tracking what materials I bought, used, and have left over. Your point about the December 31st physical count is genius. I never thought about taking photos for documentation, but that would make next year's beginning inventory so much easier to verify. Did you have any issues with the IRS accepting rough cost estimates for small amounts of leftover materials, or do they expect exact receipts for everything? Also, when you say materials you "used in products you sold" - does that mean only materials for products that were actually sold to customers, or all materials used to make finished products even if some are still sitting in inventory waiting to be sold?
AstroAce
When I had both W2 and 1099 income, I learned that if you physically go to an IRS Taxpayer Assistance Center, they sometimes offer free tax prep services if your income is below certain limits. You need to call to make an appointment though. Also check if your local library or community center offers VITA (Volunteer Income Tax Assistance) services. They'll do your taxes for free including Schedule C if your income is under about $60k.
0 coins
Zoe Kyriakidou
ā¢I used VITA last year and it was great! Just make sure to book early because appointments fill up FAST as it gets closer to tax day.
0 coins
Chloe Green
Just to add another perspective - I had a very similar situation with W2 income from two states plus freelance 1099 income. After trying multiple free options, I ended up going with H&R Block's online service. They have a mid-tier option that handles both W2 and Schedule C filing for around $50, which was way cheaper than their in-person service. What really helped me was their interview-style questions that walked me through the multi-state income reporting step by step. They automatically calculated how much state tax I owed to each state based on where I earned the income, which was exactly what I needed for my Colorado/Nevada situation. The key thing I learned is that while you definitely can't split your filing like you originally asked, there are affordable options beyond the expensive TurboTax upgrades. Don't feel like you're stuck paying premium prices just because you have mixed income sources!
0 coins
Anastasia Sokolov
ā¢This is really helpful! I'm in a similar boat with mixed income sources and was feeling overwhelmed by all the different filing options. The H&R Block mid-tier option sounds like a good middle ground between free services that don't handle everything and the really expensive premium options. Did you find their multi-state calculations were accurate? I'm always nervous about state tax allocations getting messed up.
0 coins