


Ask the community...
Weirdly, my tax software (TurboTax) asked me if I knew the basis amount even though box 2a was blank on my 1099-R. Anyone else have this happen? Not sure if I should override what's on the form.
Yes! Same thing happened to me. I ended up calling my brokerage (Fidelity) and they gave me my "basis information" which is basically the total amount of contributions I've made. Since my withdrawal was less than my total contributions, I entered that info into TurboTax and it properly showed the distribution as non-taxable.
I went through this exact same situation last year! The blank box 2a on your 1099-R for a Roth IRA withdrawal is actually pretty common and usually means your financial institution doesn't have enough information to determine what portion is taxable. Here's what I learned: You'll need to calculate this yourself using Form 8606. The key is figuring out your "basis" - basically all the contributions you've made to your Roth IRA over the years (not including any earnings/growth). If your $2,700 withdrawal is less than your total lifetime contributions, then it's likely completely non-taxable and you'd enter $0 for the taxable amount. But if you've withdrawn more than you've contributed, then part of it could be taxable earnings subject to penalties. I'd strongly recommend contacting your IRA custodian to get a statement of your contribution history before filing. They should be able to tell you exactly how much you've contributed versus earnings. Don't guess on this - the IRS can be pretty strict about retirement account distributions!
I almost signed up with Optima last year but decided to check reviews first. Thank god I did! Instead, I went directly to the IRS and set up a payment plan myself. It took one phone call (admittedly after being on hold for 2 hours) and I was approved for a monthly payment I could afford. These companies make it sound like you need some special expertise or insider connections to deal with the IRS, but for most basic tax problems, you absolutely don't. They're just inserting themselves as expensive middlemen.
Did you have to provide all your financial details to get the payment plan? I'm worried about the IRS wanting to see all my bank statements and stuff before they'll approve a payment plan.
This is exactly why I always tell people to be extremely cautious with these tax relief companies. The pattern you described - big promises upfront, poor communication after payment, and then trying to silence customers with NDAs - is unfortunately very common in this industry. The fact that they're demanding you sign an agreement to remove negative reviews in exchange for a partial refund is a huge red flag. Legitimate businesses don't operate this way. They're essentially admitting their service was inadequate while trying to manipulate their online reputation. For anyone reading this who's dealing with tax problems: before paying anyone thousands of dollars, try these free or low-cost options first: 1. Call the IRS directly to discuss payment plan options 2. Use the IRS Online Payment Agreement tool 3. Contact your local Low Income Taxpayer Clinic (LITC) if you qualify 4. Consult with a local CPA or Enrolled Agent for a transparent fee quote Don't let these companies prey on your stress about tax issues. Most tax problems can be resolved without paying these inflated fees to middlemen who often provide little actual value.
This is such valuable advice, thank you for laying out these options so clearly. I'm actually dealing with a similar situation right now where I owe about $8,000 to the IRS and have been getting calls from multiple tax relief companies promising they can "settle my debt for a fraction of what I owe." After reading this thread, I'm definitely going to try calling the IRS directly first before paying anyone thousands of dollars. It's honestly a relief to hear that most people can handle this themselves - these companies make it sound like you need a team of lawyers and specialists just to talk to the IRS. The Low Income Taxpayer Clinic option is something I'd never heard of before. Do you know if there's an income threshold to qualify for their services?
Small tip: After you get this issue resolved, I HIGHLY recommend setting up direct deposit info in your IRS account at https://www.irs.gov/payments/your-online-account rather than leaving it to tax preparers each year. This keeps your bank info consistent regardless of who prepares your taxes. It also lets you check transcripts online to see exactly what's happening with your refund - including rejected direct deposits - without waiting for customer service.
Thank you all so much for the advice! I checked my old savings account and there's no deposit there, so it definitely went to a completely wrong account. I'm going to try both taxr.ai and Claimyr to get this sorted out. Also definitely setting up that IRS account for next year - I had no idea that was an option!
I went through this exact same nightmare last year! My preparer switched two digits in my account number and my $2,400 refund went into the void. Here's what I learned: First, don't wait - contact your preparer immediately and demand they fix this. Most professional preparers carry errors and omissions insurance specifically for mistakes like this. Mine initially tried to brush me off saying "it happens," but when I mentioned their insurance should cover the costs of their mistake, they suddenly became very helpful. Second, file Form 8379 if you're married filing jointly and only one spouse has the banking error - this can help separate your portion of the refund for reprocessing. The good news is that if the account doesn't exist or belongs to someone else, banks are required to return erroneous deposits within a reasonable timeframe. The bad news is "reasonable" can mean anywhere from 3 days to 3 weeks depending on the bank. Document everything - keep records of all calls, emails with your preparer, and IRS correspondence. If this drags on, you may need this for a complaint with your state's board of accountancy if your preparer is licensed. Most importantly, this WILL get resolved. It's frustrating and scary, but the IRS deals with these situations regularly and has processes in place. You're not going to lose your refund permanently.
This is really reassuring to hear from someone who's been through the same thing! I'm definitely going to bring up the insurance issue with my preparer - they've been pretty dismissive so far saying these things just happen sometimes. Can you tell me more about Form 8379? I am married filing jointly, so this might apply to my situation. Also, how long did it ultimately take for you to get your refund back?
Just download it and take screenshots of the codes section. That way you can reference it easier when people try to help explain things to you
I totally get your confusion! CP74 notices can be really overwhelming when you're not familiar with them. Based on what you described, it sounds like you previously had your Child Tax Credit denied (probably flagged for potential fraud or errors), and you successfully completed Form 8862 to recertify for those credits. The good news is that the notice is saying you're all set - your credits have been restored and you should get your refund within 6 weeks! The best part is you won't have to deal with Form 8862 again for these credits in the future. Just keep an eye on your bank account and maybe check your transcript in a few weeks to see if there's a refund date posted. You're basically in the home stretch now! š
Owen Devar
Could you possibly take public transit instead? Many employers offer pre-tax transit benefits that are easier to access than parking benefits. I switched from driving to taking the bus and now get a pre-tax transit pass that saves me about $40/month in taxes.
0 coins
Daniel Rivera
ā¢Public transit is great if it's available, but not everyone has that option. I work at a suburban hospital with literally no bus service within 2 miles.
0 coins
Oliver Zimmermann
I feel your pain on this! $109/month is brutal on a $15/hour wage. While the direct tax deduction isn't available anymore as others mentioned, definitely push your HR department hard on the pre-tax parking benefit. Many hospitals have this but don't advertise it well to employees. Also, if your hospital is part of a larger health system, they might have employee assistance programs that offer parking subsidies for lower-wage workers. I've seen some hospitals offer sliding scale parking fees based on income level. It's worth asking specifically about hardship parking assistance programs - the worst they can say is no, but you might be surprised what's available that they don't publicize widely. Another angle: if you're in a union or there's talk of unionizing, parking costs are often a major bargaining issue that gets addressed in contracts.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
ā¢This is really helpful advice! I hadn't thought about asking specifically about hardship programs. Do you know what kind of documentation they typically require for income-based parking assistance? I'm definitely going to ask HR about this - it's worth a shot since $109/month is eating up almost 5% of my gross pay before taxes. The union angle is interesting too, though I don't think there's any unionization talk at my hospital right now. But you're absolutely right that parking costs would be a huge issue if that ever came up.
0 coins