


Ask the community...
Anyone know if this "undetermined term" stuff affects your overall tax liability? Like, if I can't find my original cost basis for some old Bitcoin I bought years ago, am I just screwed and have to report the full sale as gain?
Technically, if you can't document your cost basis, the IRS could consider it $0, meaning the entire proceeds would be taxable. However, they generally expect you to make a "reasonable effort" to determine your actual cost basis. If you truly can't find records of your original purchase, you might be able to use the price of Bitcoin on the approximate date you acquired it as your basis. Just document your methodology clearly in case of audit. But definitely try to find those original records first - old emails from exchanges, bank statements showing transfers, etc.
I went through this exact same situation last year with Robinhood! What worked for me was downloading my complete transaction history from Robinhood (you can get this from their web platform under Documents & Reports). Then I created a simple spreadsheet tracking all my crypto purchases chronologically. For those 3 undetermined transactions, I used FIFO method to match them with my earliest purchases. So if you sold 0.1 Bitcoin on a specific date, you'd match it with your first 0.1 Bitcoin purchase (or combine multiple small purchases until you hit 0.1). The key is being consistent with your method. Once you calculate the cost basis, report these on Form 8949 with Box C checked (short-term) or Box F (long-term), enter the sale proceeds from your 1099-B, then manually add your calculated cost basis and gain/loss. It's tedious but totally doable! I spent about 3 hours reconstructing everything but it was worth it to get it right. Make sure to keep documentation of your methodology in case the IRS ever asks.
This is super helpful, thanks Diego! Just to clarify - when you say "combine multiple small purchases until you hit 0.1", do you mean if I had like 3 separate Bitcoin purchases of 0.03, 0.04, and 0.05 BTC, I'd use all three to match against a 0.1 BTC sale? And then calculate a weighted average cost basis across those three purchases? I want to make sure I'm doing the FIFO calculations correctly.
Exactly right! With FIFO, you'd use those three purchases in chronological order. So if you bought 0.03 BTC at $30k, then 0.04 BTC at $32k, then 0.05 BTC at $35k, your total cost basis for the 0.1 BTC sale would be: (0.03 Ć $30k) + (0.04 Ć $32k) + (0.03 Ć $35k) = $900 + $1,280 + $1,050 = $3,230. You'd still have 0.02 BTC remaining from that third purchase at $35k for future sales. The key is keeping detailed records of which lots you've "used up" so you don't double-count anything on subsequent transactions.
Tax preparer here. This is really common! Most likely the software is making different assumptions about your filing status or eligibility for certain credits based on your children. Did you answer the same "interview" questions on all platforms? Sometimes one platform will ask "Did you provide more than half the support for your child?" while another assumes this based on other answers. Or one platform might qualify your kids for the Child Tax Credit while another is qualifying them for the Credit for Other Dependents instead.
This happened to me two years ago and it was incredibly frustrating! The key thing is that even though you uploaded the same W2s, the platforms are making different assumptions about how to apply various tax laws based on your family situation. Since you mentioned you have kids, here's what's likely happening: each platform is automatically calculating child-related credits (Child Tax Credit, Additional Child Tax Credit, etc.) differently based on their initial questionnaires. They might also be handling your state taxes completely differently - some states have complex interactions with federal calculations that each software interprets slightly. My advice: pick the two platforms that seem most reasonable (I'd probably eliminate the one showing the most extreme result) and complete your entire return on both. Don't just stop at W2 entry. Enter all your deductions, any 1099s, childcare expenses, education credits - everything. Then compare the final results line by line. Most platforms will show you a detailed tax summary or Form 1040 preview before you file. Look specifically at: - How they calculated your Child Tax Credit - State income tax deduction vs. state taxes owed - Any automatic deductions they applied The differences will probably become much clearer once you have the complete picture rather than just the W2 portion.
This is really helpful advice! I'm new to dealing with multiple tax platforms and this whole situation has been so confusing. Your point about completing the entire return makes a lot of sense - I was probably jumping to conclusions too early by only looking at the W2 results. Quick question: when you say "eliminate the one showing the most extreme result," in my case that would be HR Block (showing we get a state refund but owe $2,100 federal). Does that seem like the right one to eliminate, or should I be more concerned about FreeTaxUSA showing we owe $2,300 to the state? Also, is there a particular order you'd recommend for entering information? Like should I do all the basic stuff first across both platforms, then move to deductions, or complete one platform entirely before starting the other?
Just wanted to share my experience since I was in a similar situation last year with a small LLC partnership. You're absolutely right that the IRS website can be confusing! The key thing that helped me was realizing that Form 1065 is basically a "package deal" - all those schedules (B-1, B-2, and the K-1s) are considered part of the main return and go to the same address. Think of it like sending a book with multiple chapters rather than separate documents. One tip that saved me stress: if you're getting close to the deadline, definitely consider e-filing instead of mailing. The confirmation is instant, and you don't have to worry about postal delays or whether the IRS actually received your package. Most basic tax software can handle a simple 50/50 partnership return like yours. Also, make sure you keep copies of everything for your records, especially those K-1s since you'll both need them for your personal tax returns. Good luck with the filing!
This is really helpful advice! I'm actually in a very similar situation with a small LLC I started with my business partner last year. We've been putting off the filing because we were also confused about all the different forms and where they go. Your "book with chapters" analogy really clicked for me - that makes so much more sense than thinking of them as separate filings. And I definitely agree about e-filing being less stressful, especially this close to deadline season. Quick question - did you find any particular tax software worked better for partnership returns, or are they all pretty much the same for simple 50/50 splits like ours?
For a simple 50/50 partnership like yours, most tax software options will work fine. I used FreeTaxUSA Business for my LLC partnership return and it handled everything smoothly - Form 1065, all the schedules, and generated the K-1s automatically based on our 50/50 split. The main things to look for in any software: make sure it includes Form 1065 (some personal tax software doesn't cover business returns), that it can e-file partnership returns (not all can), and that it automatically generates the K-1s for each partner. TaxAct, as someone mentioned earlier, is also a good budget option. TurboTax Business works well too but costs more. For the amount of income you're dealing with ($1,000 total), I'd probably go with one of the cheaper options since your return will be pretty straightforward. The software will walk you through each section and automatically populate the schedules based on your income and expense entries. Much less stressful than trying to fill out all those forms manually!
This is exactly the kind of breakdown I was looking for! I've been going back and forth between different software options and getting overwhelmed by all the features I probably don't need. FreeTaxUSA Business sounds like it might be perfect for our situation - we literally just have the one income source from our summer camp program and minimal expenses. The fact that it automatically handles the 50/50 K-1 generation is huge since that was one of the parts I was most worried about messing up. Quick follow-up question - when you e-filed through FreeTaxUSA, did you get immediate confirmation that everything was accepted by the IRS? I'm still a bit nervous about whether I'll know for sure that everything went through properly, especially since this is our first year filing as a partnership.
Yes, FreeTaxUSA gives you immediate confirmation when the IRS accepts your e-filed return! You'll get an email confirmation within 24-48 hours (usually much faster) letting you know the return was successfully received and accepted. The acceptance confirmation includes your return's acknowledgment number, which you should definitely save for your records. If there are any issues with the return, you'll get an error message explaining exactly what needs to be fixed, rather than finding out months later like what can happen with paper filing. One thing that really put my mind at ease was that the software does validation checks before you even submit - it catches common errors like missing EINs, math mistakes, or incomplete forms before sending anything to the IRS. So by the time you're ready to e-file, you can be pretty confident everything is correct. For your first partnership return, the peace of mind of immediate confirmation is definitely worth choosing e-filing over mailing. Plus you'll have everything done and confirmed well before the deadline rather than stressing about whether your mailed package made it in time!
I've been through this exact same situation with my husband's return where I was listed as the third party designee. The frustration is real! After weeks of trying, I finally got through using a combination of the strategies mentioned here. What ultimately worked for me was calling the main IRS line (800-829-1040) on a Tuesday morning right at 7am when they opened, selecting option 1 for "questions about a form you filed," then option 3 for "1040 individual return questions." When prompted for specific issues, I said "third party designee inquiry" which seemed to route me to someone who actually understood the designation. The key phrase that helped was exactly what Daniel mentioned - I started with "I am the third party designee listed on this taxpayer's Form 1040" and had his PIN ready. The agent was able to tell me his return was held up because they needed verification of his business expenses, something we never would have known from the generic "still processing" message. One thing I learned: the 9+ week delay you're experiencing often indicates they're waiting for third-party income verification (like W-2s or 1099s that don't match what employers reported). As the designee, you can authorize them to proceed with processing based on the information submitted if the discrepancies are minor. Don't give up - the designation really does give you power to help resolve issues once you finally reach someone!
This is incredibly helpful! I'm going to try your exact approach - calling at 7am Tuesday and using that specific menu path. I hadn't thought about saying "third party designee inquiry" when they ask for the specific issue, but that makes perfect sense for getting routed to the right person. The possibility that it could be third-party income verification is interesting. My sister did have a few different part-time jobs last year, so there could definitely be some W-2 or 1099 discrepancies that are causing the hold-up. If that's the case, at least as her designee I might be able to help move things along rather than just waiting indefinitely. Really appreciate you sharing the exact script and timing that worked for you. After 9+ weeks of this limbo, I'm willing to try anything that has a proven track record. Going to set my alarm for 6:55am Tuesday morning and give this a shot!
I'm dealing with this same frustration as a third party designee for my mom's return! Reading through all these experiences really validates what I've been going through. The inconsistency between IRS reps is maddening - some immediately recognize the designation while others act like it doesn't exist. What's really helped me is keeping detailed notes from each call attempt, including the rep's ID number when they give it. If someone incorrectly tells you that you need Form 8821 or other additional authorization (which you don't for basic return discussion), having those details helps when you call back or ask for a supervisor. One thing I've noticed is that the third party designee works best for straightforward processing questions, but if there are compliance issues or audits involved, they sometimes want more formal authorization. For basic refund delays and status questions though, the 1040 designation should absolutely be sufficient. The timing advice here is gold - I've had much better luck with mid-week morning calls. Also, if you're using any of the callback services mentioned (like Claimyr), make sure you clearly explain your third party designee status when you first speak with them so they can prep you for what information the IRS agent will need to verify your authorization. Hang in there! The designation really is valuable once you can actually use it properly.
This thread has been so helpful for understanding the third party designee process! I'm actually new to being a designee - my brother just asked me to be his for next year's return after hearing about all these IRS delays. One question I have after reading everyone's experiences: when you're initially setting up the designee on the 1040, is there a recommended PIN strategy? Should it be something memorable for both the taxpayer and designee, or does the IRS have specific requirements? I want to make sure we set it up properly from the start so I don't run into verification issues when calling. Also, it sounds like keeping a copy of the actual return is crucial for when you finally get through. Should I be asking my brother for a complete copy, or just specific pages that have the designee information and key details the IRS might ask about? Thanks to everyone sharing their experiences - this is exactly the kind of practical advice you can't find in the official IRS publications!
Eloise Kendrick
Has anyone here actually run the numbers on this? I did a cost segregation on my rental last year and while the depreciation deduction was nice, the cost of the study itself was around $4,500. Plus I had to pay my CPA extra to handle the more complex tax situation. Just wondering if it actually pencils out for smaller properties or if there's a certain property value where this makes more sense.
0 coins
Debra Bai
ā¢Great question about the cost-benefit analysis. Generally, cost segregation studies make financial sense for properties valued at $500k+ (excluding land value). The higher the building value, the better the return on the cost of the study. For example, on a $750k property (assuming $600k building value), a cost seg study might move 25-30% of the value to 5-15 year property classes instead of 27.5 years. This acceleration can create $60k-$80k in additional deductions in year one, which at a 32% tax bracket would save $19k-$25k in taxes - definitely worth the $4,500 study cost. For smaller properties under $350k total value, the math often doesn't work as well, especially considering the additional accounting complexity and fees.
0 coins
Keisha Williams
One thing to keep in mind that I learned the hard way - even if you qualify for the short-term rental loophole and can deduct losses against your RMDs, you need to be prepared for the administrative burden. I'm in year 2 of this strategy and the record-keeping requirements are intense. You'll need to track every hour spent on the property (I use a detailed spreadsheet), maintain receipts for all expenses, document all guest communications, and keep detailed records of maintenance activities. The IRS scrutinizes short-term rental businesses heavily, especially when significant losses are claimed against retirement income. Also, don't forget about state tax implications. Some states have different rules for rental income and depreciation, which could affect your overall tax savings. I had to file returns in two states last year because my rental property was in a different state than my residence. The strategy can definitely work, but make sure you're prepared for the extra complexity it adds to your tax situation. It's not just a set-it-and-forget-it investment when you're trying to qualify for active participation.
0 coins
Zadie Patel
ā¢This is exactly the kind of real-world insight I was hoping for! The administrative burden aspect is something I hadn't fully considered. Can you share more about your spreadsheet system for tracking hours? I'm wondering if there are any apps or software that make this easier, or if a simple Excel sheet is the way to go. Also, how detailed do the guest communications need to be documented - is it just saving emails/messages, or do you need to log every interaction separately?
0 coins