This thread has been incredibly informative! I'm in a similar situation - Australian citizen planning to move to the US permanently in about 2 years. One aspect I haven't seen discussed is the impact of currency fluctuations on the tax treatment. Since my super is denominated in AUD but I'll be filing US tax returns in USD, I'm wondering how currency exchange rates affect the calculation of taxable income and basis. For example, if the AUD strengthens significantly between when I become a US resident and when I eventually withdraw from my super, could that create additional taxable "gain" from a US perspective even if the underlying investments haven't actually grown? Also, does anyone know if there are any special rules for reporting currency gains/losses on foreign retirement accounts under the treaty? I'm trying to understand if I need to track exchange rates at specific dates for future tax calculations. The complexity of this whole situation is mind-boggling, but reading everyone's experiences has been really helpful in understanding what I need to prepare for. Thanks to everyone who's shared their knowledge!

I've been dealing with a very similar situation and wanted to add a few practical points that might help. I moved from Australia to the US two years ago and have been navigating the superannuation tax implications ever since. One thing I learned the hard way is that you need to be very careful about how you report your super fund on Form 8938 (FATCA) and Form 3520/3520-A if the IRS treats it as a foreign trust. The reporting thresholds and requirements are different for each form, and the penalties for getting it wrong or filing late are severe. Also, I'd recommend getting a letter from your super fund administrator confirming the tax treatment of your contributions in Australia. When I was preparing my US tax returns, my accountant needed documentation showing which portions of my super were from pre-tax employer contributions, post-tax salary sacrifice, and any after-tax voluntary contributions I'd made. Without this breakdown, the IRS might default to treating everything as pre-tax, which could result in double taxation. One more tip: if you're planning to make any additional voluntary contributions to your super before moving, be very careful about the timing and tax treatment. Contributions made after you become a US tax resident might be treated differently than those made while you were still an Australian resident. The whole process is definitely complex, but with proper planning and documentation, you can navigate it successfully. Good luck with your move!

As someone who's been through this exact situation with my daughter's UTMA account, I can share some practical insights. The tax implications really aren't as scary as they initially seem once you understand the mechanics. One key point that often gets overlooked - you should keep detailed records of all withdrawals and what they were used for. While there's no additional tax penalty for using UTMA funds for education, having documentation helps if there are ever questions about whether the custodian used the funds appropriately for the minor's benefit. Also, timing can matter for tax planning. If your nephew has other income (like a part-time job), you might want to coordinate UTMA withdrawals with his overall tax situation to stay within favorable tax brackets. Since he's 16, he likely has minimal other income, so the standard deduction and lower tax rates could work in your favor. The financial aid impact mentioned by others is real - UTMA assets hit the Expected Family Contribution calculation hard. If you're planning to apply for need-based aid, consider using UTMA funds for expenses in the years before filing FAFSA rather than letting them sit in the account where they'll reduce aid eligibility.

This is such a helpful thread! I'm in a similar situation with my son's UTMA account. One thing I learned from our financial advisor that might help - you can actually time your UTMA withdrawals strategically around the FAFSA timeline to minimize the financial aid impact. The FAFSA looks at your financial snapshot as of the day you file, so if you use UTMA funds to pay for qualified education expenses (like a semester's tuition) right before filing, those funds won't count as student assets on the application. This can potentially increase your aid eligibility significantly since student assets are assessed at 20% vs parent assets at around 5.6%. Also, keep in mind that starting with the 2024-25 academic year, the FAFSA uses tax information from two years prior (called "prior-prior year"). So for a student starting college in fall 2025, you'd use 2023 tax information. This gives you even more planning opportunities since you can see exactly what income levels will be reported before making withdrawal decisions. The key is coordination between the timing of withdrawals, when expenses are actually paid, and when you file the FAFSA. It's definitely worth running some scenarios to see how different approaches affect your overall financial aid picture.

Has anyone had success filing Form 8919 without having an official determination from the IRS or DOL? My employer is clearly treating me as an employee (sets my hours, provides equipment, etc.) but refuses to classify me properly, and I can't wait months for an official determination before filing.

Just to clarify something important - Form 8919 doesn't eliminate your tax liability. You still owe the income tax on all those earnings. What Form 8919 does is ensure you're only paying the employee portion of Social Security and Medicare taxes (7.65%) rather than the full self-employment tax rate (15.3%). For someone in your tax bracket, you should probably be setting aside around 15% for federal income tax PLUS the 7.65% for Social Security/Medicare. So that 20% your mom suggested might actually be a bit low depending on your total annual income. I'd recommend using the IRS Tax Withholding Estimator tool to get a more precise figure based on your specific situation.

One more thing to consider - if you make over a certain amount from your contractor work (I think it's around $1,000), you'll need to file Schedule C along with your tax return. This is where you report business income and expenses. You'll also fill out Schedule SE for self-employment tax. Start keeping track of ALL business-related expenses now if you haven't already! Mileage for business travel (not commuting), home office if applicable, portion of internet/phone, software subscriptions, office supplies, professional development, etc. These can significantly reduce your taxable income.

This thread has been incredibly helpful! As someone who just started contracting this year too, I want to add one thing that caught me off guard - make sure you're tracking your business expenses from DAY ONE, not just when tax season approaches. I learned this the hard way when I realized I had forgotten to save receipts for legitimate business expenses like software subscriptions, equipment purchases, and even parking fees for client meetings. The IRS requires documentation for deductions, so having a system in place early (even something as simple as a dedicated folder or app) can save you hundreds or thousands in missed deductions. Also, don't forget about the home office deduction if you work from home regularly and exclusively use a space for business. You can either use the simplified method ($5 per square foot up to 300 sq ft) or calculate actual expenses. Even if it's just a corner of your bedroom that you use only for work, it might qualify! One last tip: consider making estimated payments for 2025 even if you're not required to. It helps with cash flow management and prevents that massive tax bill shock next April. You can always adjust the amounts throughout the year if your income changes.

I think a lot depends on what kind of disability pension you have from France. I went through this with my Spanish disability pension. There are two main types: contributory (based on what you paid into their system) and non-contributory (more like social benefits). They're treated differently under most tax treaties. If it's a government pension (paid because you worked for the French government), that's another category with different rules. Article 18 vs. Article 19 of the treaty applies differently. Also check if it's considered "not taxable in France" - some disability pensions aren't taxed in the country of origin, which affects how the US treats them.

The key thing to understand is that US citizens are subject to worldwide income taxation, so yes, you do need to report your French disability pension on your US return. However, you're absolutely right that this creates a double taxation issue - and that's exactly what tax treaties are designed to prevent. Since your pension is contributory (you paid into the French system) and partially taxed in France, you should be able to claim a Foreign Tax Credit on Form 1116 for the French taxes already paid. This will reduce your US tax liability dollar-for-dollar. Make sure your accountant is familiar with the US-France tax treaty, particularly Article 18 which covers pensions. Some disability pensions may qualify for reduced taxation or exemptions under the treaty provisions. You might also need to file Form 8833 if you're claiming specific treaty benefits. The IRS Publication 514 (Foreign Tax Credit for Individuals) has detailed guidance on how to calculate and claim the credit. Don't let the complexity discourage you - proper application of the treaty and foreign tax credit should prevent true double taxation.