


Ask the community...
Thank you all for this incredibly helpful discussion! As someone new to homeownership and dealing with this exact scenario for the first time, I was completely lost trying to interpret Publication 936 on my own. I bought my first home in February 2023 and then had to relocate for work, so I sold that house in August and purchased a new one in October. My tax software was giving me numbers that just didn't seem right, and now I understand why - it was treating both mortgages as if I owned them simultaneously. Based on what everyone has shared here, I need to calculate each home separately: - First home (Feb-Aug): mortgage was $425K, so all interest is deductible - Second home (Oct-Dec): mortgage is $820K, so I apply the $750K/$820K limitation The professional insights from Logan and Freya about documentation are especially valuable. I'll definitely create a worksheet showing the ownership periods and calculations, and include the Pub 936 references they mentioned. This community is amazing - you've saved me from either overpaying taxes or potentially getting into trouble with incorrect calculations. Really appreciate everyone taking the time to explain this complex situation so clearly!
Welcome to the community, CosmicCruiser! Your situation sounds very similar to what others have described here, and it's great that you're getting it sorted out before filing. The work relocation scenario is actually pretty common - I've seen several cases where people have to sell and buy within the same tax year due to job changes. One thing to double-check with your October purchase - make sure you're calculating the average balance correctly for just the October-December period when you owned that second home. So if you closed in mid-October, you'd prorate that first month. It might not make a huge difference in the final number, but it's worth being precise. Also, keep all your HUD-1 settlement statements or closing disclosures from both transactions. They'll show exactly when you took ownership and can help support your timeline if there are ever any questions. The documentation approach that Logan and Freya outlined is spot-on - I always feel more confident filing when I have that paper trail backing up my calculations. Good luck with your filing, and glad this discussion could help clear things up!
This thread has been incredibly educational! I'm facing a similar situation but with a slight twist - I had overlapping ownership for about 3 weeks while closing on both properties. From what I'm understanding here, that brief overlap period might change how I need to calculate things. During those 3 weeks in June 2023, I technically owned both homes simultaneously - my old home with a $380K mortgage and the new one with a $720K mortgage. For that specific period, would I need to use the combined average balance method that TurboTax was incorrectly applying to everyone else's sequential ownership situations? So my calculation would be: - Jan-May: Old home only, $380K mortgage (100% deductible, under limit) - June overlap period: Combined $1.1M total, so $750K/$1.1M = 68% of interest deductible for both properties - July-Dec: New home only, $750K/$720K = 100% deductible (actually under the limit) Has anyone else dealt with this overlapping ownership scenario? The professional advice from Logan and Freya has been so helpful, but I want to make sure I understand how the brief simultaneous ownership affects the calculation.
Great question, Liam! You're absolutely right that the overlapping ownership period changes things. Your calculation approach looks correct - you'll need to handle each ownership period differently. For the 3-week overlap in June where you owned both properties simultaneously, you would indeed apply the combined balance method since your total acquisition debt ($1.1M) exceeded the $750K limit. So for that period, both mortgages get the same percentage: $750K/$1.1M = 68.2% of the interest from both properties. Your breakdown makes sense: - Jan-May: 100% of old home interest (under limit) - June overlap: 68.2% of interest from both homes - July-Dec: 100% of new home interest (under limit since $720K < $750K) This is definitely more complex than the sequential ownership cases others have discussed. I'd strongly recommend creating a detailed month-by-month worksheet showing the ownership periods and calculations for each phase. The IRS guidance in Pub 936 does address simultaneous ownership scenarios, so you'll have solid backing for this approach. You might also want to consider getting this reviewed by a tax professional given the complexity, especially for the overlap period calculation. The documentation will be key if there are ever any questions about your methodology.
One additional consideration for your situation - since you mentioned this was a "rough year" with your investments, you might want to think about timing any future capital gains to optimize your tax situation over the next few years. With $9,000 in carryover losses ($1,800 short-term and $7,200 long-term after the 2024 deduction), you have some flexibility in future years. If you're planning to take profits on any investments, consider the character of those gains. Long-term gains are taxed more favorably, but you have more long-term losses to offset them. Also, don't forget that capital loss carryovers never expire - they continue indefinitely until used up. So even if you don't have gains in 2025, you can still use up to $3,000 per year against ordinary income until the full $9,000 is exhausted. At that rate, it would take about 3 more years to fully utilize your carryover losses if you don't have any offsetting gains. Keep good records of your carryover amounts each year, as the IRS doesn't track this for you. Your 2024 tax return should show the carryover calculation, and you'll need those numbers for future returns.
This is really helpful strategic advice! I hadn't thought about the timing aspect of future gains. Since I have more long-term carryover losses ($7,200) than short-term ($1,800), it makes sense to prioritize realizing long-term gains if I have profitable positions to sell in the coming years. The point about carryovers never expiring is reassuring - I was worried there might be some time limit. So even if my investments don't recover quickly, I can still benefit from that $3,000 annual deduction against ordinary income for the next few years. One question: if I do have some gains next year, does the order matter for tax purposes? Like if I have $2,000 in long-term gains and decide to take $1,000 in short-term gains, will the software automatically optimize which carryover losses to apply first, or should I be strategic about the timing of when I realize different types of gains throughout the year?
The timing within the tax year doesn't actually matter for optimization - the IRS rules automatically handle the offsetting in the most tax-efficient way regardless of when during the year you realize the gains. Here's how it works: All your capital gains and losses for the year (including carryovers) get netted together on Schedule D using the prescribed IRS methodology. Short-term gains are offset by short-term losses (including short-term carryovers), and long-term gains are offset by long-term losses (including long-term carryovers). If you end up with a net gain in one category and a net loss in the other, they offset each other. So in your example with $2,000 long-term gains and $1,000 short-term gains, plus your carryovers ($1,800 short-term losses and $7,200 long-term losses), here's what happens: - Short-term: $1,000 gains - $1,800 carryover losses = $800 net short-term loss - Long-term: $2,000 gains - $7,200 carryover losses = $5,200 net long-term loss - Total: $800 + $5,200 = $6,000 net capital loss, so you'd get another $3,000 deduction against ordinary income The key insight is that you don't need to time your sales strategically within the year - the tax code does the optimization automatically. Your main strategic decision is simply whether to realize gains or losses in a given tax year based on your overall financial situation.
This automatic optimization is exactly what I was hoping to hear! I was getting stressed about trying to time my trades perfectly throughout the year, but knowing that the IRS rules handle the netting automatically takes a lot of pressure off. Your example calculation really helps clarify how the carryovers would interact with new gains. It's actually encouraging to see that even with some decent gains next year ($3,000 total in your example), I'd still end up with a net loss and get to use the full $3,000 deduction against ordinary income again. One follow-up question: does this mean I should focus more on the bigger picture of my overall investment strategy rather than getting bogged down in the tax timing details? It sounds like as long as I'm making good investment decisions, the tax optimization happens automatically through the Schedule D calculations.
This is exactly the kind of situation where getting professional help or using specialized tools makes sense. I went through something similar with multiple years of missing 8606 forms, and the complexity of calculating basis carryforward between years can get tricky fast. One thing I'd add to the great advice already given - when you file those standalone 8606 forms, make copies of everything and keep detailed records. The IRS systems don't always link these forms perfectly to your main tax records, so having your own documentation is crucial. Also, double-check your 2021 amended return to make sure the corrected 8606 properly reflects the basis from 2019 and 2020. If you didn't include that carryforward basis, you might need to amend 2021 again once you get the earlier years sorted out. The whole chain has to be correct for your basis tracking to work properly going forward.
This is such great advice about keeping detailed records! I'm just starting to deal with a similar mess and I'm realizing how important the documentation aspect is. Quick question - when you say the IRS systems don't always link these standalone forms perfectly, does that mean I should send them certified mail or with some kind of tracking? I'm worried about forms getting lost in the system and then having to prove I actually filed them. Also, regarding the basis carryforward chain - if I discover I made an error in calculating basis for one of the middle years after I've already filed the standalone forms, is it a huge hassle to correct that? Or can I just file a corrected 8606 for that year without going through the whole amendment process again?
Absolutely send them certified mail with return receipt! I learned this the hard way when the IRS claimed they never received one of my standalone 8606 forms. Having that proof of delivery saved me from having to refile and deal with potential penalties. For correcting errors in the basis carryforward chain, you can typically just file a corrected standalone 8606 for the year with the error, but you'll also need to correct any subsequent years that were affected by the wrong basis amount. It's not as complicated as a full amendment, but the domino effect means you might need to file corrected forms for multiple years. This is why getting it right the first time (or using a tool that helps calculate everything correctly) is so important - fixing one error can cascade into needing to fix several years worth of forms.
One thing that hasn't been mentioned yet is the timing consideration for when you file these standalone 8606 forms. While you can file them at any time, I'd recommend getting them submitted sooner rather than later, especially for 2019 and 2020. The reason is that if you ever need to take distributions from your IRA or do Roth conversions, having your basis properly documented with the IRS becomes critical. I've seen cases where people waited years to file missing 8606 forms, then when they needed to prove their basis during a distribution, the IRS was more skeptical about accepting late-filed forms. Also, make sure you're using the correct version of Form 8606 for each tax year - don't use the current year's form for prior years. The IRS wants to see the form version that was actually in effect for that specific tax year. You can find prior year forms in the IRS forms archive on their website. One last tip: when you mail these forms, include a brief cover letter for each year explaining that you're filing a standalone Form 8606 to report nondeductible IRA contributions. This helps the IRS processor understand why they're receiving just this form rather than a complete return or amendment.
This is incredibly helpful advice about using the correct year's form versions! I had no idea that mattered and almost made a big mistake. Just to clarify - when you mention including a cover letter, should that reference the Rev. Proc. 2022-38 that was mentioned earlier, or is that something different? Also, regarding the timing aspect, I'm curious about your comment on IRS skepticism for late-filed forms. Is there a practical time limit where they become more questioning, or is it more about having a reasonable explanation for the delay? I'm about to file forms for 2018-2021 and wondering if I should expect more scrutiny since some of these are pretty old now.
One thing everyone forgot to mention - if you decide to depreciate rather than using Section 179, and your business has a bad year or closes before the depreciation period ends, you can't just deduct the remaining value all at once. Something to consider if your business fluctuates a lot! This happened to my friend's videography business and he lost out on thousands in potential deductions.
Great question! Yes, you can absolutely deduct equipment purchases made with loan funds. The IRS doesn't care where the money came from - what matters is that it's a legitimate business expense. A few key points for your photography LLC: 1. **Section 179 vs Depreciation**: For $12,500 in equipment, you'll likely want to use Section 179 to deduct the full amount in the first year rather than depreciating over time. Much simpler and gives you the tax benefit immediately. 2. **Documentation**: Keep clear records linking the loan to the equipment purchases. Save receipts, invoices, and loan documents showing the funds were used for business purposes. 3. **Don't forget loan interest**: While the loan principal isn't deductible, the interest you pay on that business loan is a separate deductible expense throughout the life of the loan. 4. **Mixed-use equipment**: If any equipment might be used personally (like a camera you occasionally use for family photos), you can only deduct the business percentage. Since you're an LLC, you'll handle this on Schedule C of your personal return (assuming single-member LLC). The deduction will reduce your taxable business income, which flows through to your personal taxes. Definitely worth consulting a tax pro for your specific situation, but the basic principle is solid - loan-funded business expenses are still deductible business expenses!
Keisha Robinson
This is really helpful information! I'm in a similar situation as a freelance consultant. One thing I'd add is that if you're doing a lot of business travel with tolls, consider getting a dedicated business checking account and linking your E-ZPass to that account for automatic replenishment. This creates a clear paper trail that separates business toll expenses from personal ones right from the start. I also keep a simple spreadsheet where I log each business trip with the date, destination, purpose, and estimated toll cost. At the end of the month, I reconcile this against my E-ZPass statement. It takes maybe 15 minutes a month but makes tax prep so much smoother. The IRS loves clear documentation, and having everything organized upfront saves tons of stress later!
0 coins
Steven Adams
ā¢This is such a smart system! I love the idea of linking E-ZPass to a dedicated business account - that would eliminate so much of the sorting headache I deal with every month. Quick question about your spreadsheet approach: do you log the trip details in real-time or do you batch it at the end of each day/week? I'm trying to figure out the most efficient way to track everything without it becoming a huge time sink. Also, have you ever been audited on your toll deductions, and if so, was your documentation system sufficient for the IRS?
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
One thing I'd recommend is setting up a separate business toll account if your provider allows it. I have two E-ZPass accounts - one for personal use and one strictly for business travel. This eliminates the need to sort through mixed statements at tax time. The business account automatically deducts from my business checking account, creating a clean paper trail. For those using apps like MileIQ, most of them have a notes feature where you can quickly record toll amounts for each business trip. This creates a single record with both mileage and toll data. I also take photos of any cash toll receipts with my phone immediately - they fade over time and become unreadable. Remember that parking fees at client locations are also deductible separately from the standard mileage rate, just like tolls. I keep a small envelope in my car specifically for parking receipts since those are easy to lose track of.
0 coins
Chloe Zhang
ā¢This is excellent advice about separate toll accounts! I'm definitely going to look into setting up a dedicated business E-ZPass account - that would save me so much time sorting through statements. Quick question about the parking receipts: do you need to document the business purpose for each parking expense, or is it sufficient that the parking was at a client location? I've been keeping receipts but haven't been noting the specific meeting purpose on each one. Also, for those cash toll receipts you mentioned - have you found any good apps that can automatically extract the toll amount from photos, or do you still have to manually enter the details?
0 coins