


Ask the community...
I went through something very similar when I switched jobs mid-year and my new employer somehow set up my withholding incorrectly. The good news is that with 2 kids under 10, you have some solid tax credits working in your favor. The Child Tax Credit alone could give you up to $4,000 ($2,000 per child), and depending on your income level, a significant portion of that can be refundable even if you paid zero in withholding. The Earned Income Tax Credit could also apply if your income falls within certain ranges - with 2 qualifying children, this can be worth thousands more. Your health issues might also qualify you to file as Head of Household, which has better tax brackets and a higher standard deduction. I'd definitely recommend running your numbers through some tax software to get a realistic picture, but don't panic - families with dependents often come out better than they expect, even with withholding issues.
This is really reassuring to hear from someone who's been through it! I'm definitely going to look into the Head of Household filing status - I hadn't even considered that might apply to my situation. The potential refund amounts you mentioned sound way better than I was expecting. Do you remember roughly what income range qualifies for the full Earned Income Tax Credit with 2 kids? I want to get a better sense of where I might fall.
The EITC income limits for 2023 (filing in 2024) with 2 qualifying children are pretty generous - you can earn up to about $50,594 if filing single or $56,844 if married filing jointly and still get some credit. The maximum EITC with 2 kids is $6,164, which phases out as your income increases. Combined with the Child Tax Credit, you could potentially see a substantial refund even with zero withholding. Just make sure your kids meet the qualifying child requirements (age, relationship, residency tests) and that they have valid Social Security Numbers. Also, definitely fix your W-4 going forward to avoid potential underpayment penalties next year. Your situation with health issues and being the primary caregiver for 2 young kids sounds like it would qualify you for Head of Household status, which would give you even better tax treatment.
This is exactly the kind of detailed breakdown I was hoping to find! The EITC income limits you mentioned are really helpful - it sounds like there's a decent chance I could qualify for at least some of that credit based on my current income situation. I'm definitely going to look into the Head of Household status too since I am the primary caregiver. One quick question - when you mention "underpayment penalties," is that something that would apply to this tax year since I've already had no withholding for most of it, or is it more about making sure I fix things going forward? I'm trying to figure out if I should be worried about penalties on top of whatever I might owe.
Has the nonprofit actually filed these late 1099s with the IRS yet? If not, maybe you could talk to them about only filing for the most recent 3 years since that's typically how far back the IRS looks anyway. The nonprofit might be willing to work with you if they understand the financial hardship this could cause.
This is really good advice. I'm an accountant (not giving professional advice here), but most small nonprofits are reasonable if you explain the situation. They're usually just trying to fix their own compliance issues and might not realize the impact on the volunteer.
This is such a stressful situation for your volunteer, and I really feel for them. I went through something similar a few years ago when I discovered I hadn't been reporting some freelance income properly. One thing that might help is to have the volunteer gather any documentation they can find about expenses related to their volunteer work - even partial records can be helpful. Things like: - Cell phone records showing calls/texts related to volunteer activities - Calendar entries or emails that could help reconstruct mileage - Any photos they might have taken during volunteer events that are timestamped - Bank or credit card statements showing purchases that could be volunteer-related Also, depending on the volunteer's income level, they might qualify for free tax preparation help through the VITA (Volunteer Income Tax Assistance) program. These volunteers are trained to handle situations exactly like this, and since your volunteer is on a limited income, they would likely qualify for the service. The most important thing is that they don't ignore this situation. The IRS is generally more willing to work with people who are proactive about fixing tax issues rather than those who try to avoid them. With the right approach and documentation, this might not be the financial disaster it seems like at first glance.
The VITA program suggestion is excellent! I didn't know about that resource. As someone new to dealing with tax issues, it's really reassuring to know there are free services available for people in tough situations like this volunteer. I'm curious - do VITA volunteers typically handle amended returns for multiple years? That seems like it could get pretty complex. Also, would they be able to help with setting up payment plans if taxes are still owed after accounting for all possible deductions? This whole thread has been incredibly helpful for understanding how complicated these situations can get. It's scary how one organization's oversight can create such a mess for someone who was just trying to help their community.
The $600 threshold is definitely real now - I learned this the hard way when I got a 1099-K for my pet sitting side business last year. Even though you might not get the form, you're still required to report all income. One thing that really helped me was setting up a separate savings account and putting aside about 25-30% of each payment for taxes (covers both income tax and self-employment tax). That way when tax time comes, you're not scrambling to find money to pay what you owe. Also, don't stress too much about perfect record keeping for what's already happened - the IRS accepts reasonable documentation. Your Apple Cash screenshots showing dates, amounts, and who paid you should be sufficient. Just start keeping better records going forward with a simple spreadsheet tracking income and any business expenses. You're being smart by thinking about this now rather than ignoring it. Most people in your situation who run into trouble are the ones who never report anything at all, not the ones trying to do things right.
This is really helpful advice! I'm in a similar situation with my tutoring business and was wondering - when you say put aside 25-30% for taxes, is that a safe estimate for most people? I'm making about $600/month and want to make sure I'm setting aside enough. Also, did you end up needing to make quarterly estimated tax payments or were you able to just pay it all when you filed your return?
25-30% is a pretty good rule of thumb for most people, but it can vary depending on your total income and tax bracket. If you're a student or have lower overall income, you might get away with closer to 20-25%. If you have other income that puts you in a higher bracket, you might need 30-35%. For quarterly payments, technically you're supposed to make them if you expect to owe more than $1,000 when you file. With $600/month ($7,200 annually), you'd probably owe around $1,100-1,400 in self-employment tax alone, so quarterly payments would be the safe route to avoid underpayment penalties. That said, if this is your first year with significant self-employment income and you had taxes withheld from other jobs, you might be okay paying it all at once when you file. The IRS has a "safe harbor" rule - if you pay at least what you owed last year, you typically avoid penalties even if you don't make quarterly payments. I'd suggest talking to a tax professional if you can afford it, or at minimum use tax software that can help estimate your quarterly payments based on your specific situation.
The key thing to remember is that you're already ahead of most people by thinking about this proactively! I run a small freelance writing business and went through this same panic when I first started making money through payment apps. A few practical tips from my experience: 1. Yes, you need to report this income on Schedule C regardless of whether you get a 1099-K form. The $600 threshold just determines if payment processors send you and the IRS a form, but your obligation to report income hasn't changed. 2. For documentation, your Apple Cash screenshots are actually fine - just make sure they show the date, amount, and ideally what the payment was for. Create a simple spreadsheet now with columns for date, amount, client/description, and keep it updated going forward. 3. Don't forget about business deductions! Things like repair supplies, any software you use for tutoring, a portion of your phone bill, even some textbooks if you reference them for tutoring could potentially be deductible. 4. Consider opening a separate checking account for your business income. Makes tracking so much easier and looks more professional if you ever do get audited. You don't necessarily need a business license for this scale, but check your college's policies too - some schools have rules about students running businesses on campus or in dorms. The IRS isn't going to come knocking down your door over $4,800, especially if you report it properly. Just get organized now and you'll be fine!
This is really solid advice! I'm just starting my own tutoring side hustle and was worried about the documentation aspect. One question - when you mention deducting textbooks you reference for tutoring, does that apply even if I already owned the books from my own classes? Or do you need to buy them specifically for the business to claim them as an expense? Also, for the separate checking account - did you go with a business account or just a regular personal account that you only use for business? I've heard business accounts sometimes have fees that might not be worth it for small operations like ours.
Are you and your fiancΓ©e filing taxes together? Because if so, I think there might be a different issue - you can't claim someone as a dependent if you're filing a joint return with them.
That's correct - you can't be claimed as a dependent if you're filing a joint return (with very limited exceptions). The original poster mentioned their fiancΓ©e claims them as a dependent, so they would need to file separately.
We're not married yet so we aren't filing jointly. My fiancΓ©e claims me as a qualifying relative since I've lived with her the whole year, had almost no income until recently, and she provides over half my support. We're planning to get married next year, so I guess that'll change our tax situation again!
Just to add another perspective - I work as a tax preparer and see this confusion all the time! You're absolutely right that it's the net profit from Schedule C that counts toward the qualifying relative income test, not gross receipts. One thing to also keep in mind is that if you had any estimated tax payments or self-employment tax throughout the year, those don't reduce your "gross income" for dependency purposes - it's still the $2,700 net profit that counts. The self-employment tax is calculated separately and doesn't affect whether you meet the income test. Also, since you mentioned you're getting married next year, just be aware that once you're married, you'll need to decide whether to file jointly (which would be more beneficial in most cases) or separately if one of you wants to continue being claimed as a dependent by someone else. But that's a problem for next year's taxes!
Jenna Sloan
Has anyone mentioned the business income limitation for Section 179? You can't deduct more than your business income for the year. So if you only have $4k in business income, that's your maximum Section 179 deduction regardless of the vehicle cost.
0 coins
Christian Burns
β’That's correct but there's a workaround - any disallowed amount due to the business income limitation can be carried forward to future years. So if your business grows in year 2, you can take the remainder of the deduction then.
0 coins
Oliver Schmidt
This is exactly the kind of question I love seeing here! As someone who's helped several small business owners navigate vehicle deductions, I want to add a few practical considerations to the excellent advice already given. First, @Kingston Bellamy nailed the technical aspects, but let me add this: with only $3,500-4,500 in expected revenue, you might want to seriously consider the standard mileage rate that @Raul Neal mentioned. Here's why - even if you qualify for the full Section 179 deduction, you're limited by your business income. So you'd only be able to deduct $4,500 maximum in year one, with the rest carried forward. However, if you're confident your woodworking business will grow significantly in years 2-3, then taking the Section 179 approach makes sense because you can use those carryforwards. One thing I always tell clients: make sure you have a separate business bank account and keep immaculate records from day one. The IRS scrutinizes vehicle deductions heavily, especially for newer businesses. Document every business trip with date, destination, business purpose, and odometer readings. Also, since you mentioned this is currently a hobby, make sure you're operating with profit motive and treating it as a real business. The IRS has specific rules about hobby vs. business classification that could affect all your deductions. The F-150 Lightning is an awesome choice - just make sure the business case supports the tax strategy!
0 coins
Harper Collins
β’This is such helpful perspective, @Oliver Schmidt! I'm definitely leaning toward starting with the standard mileage rate now, especially given the flexibility to switch later if my business takes off. Quick question about the hobby vs. business classification you mentioned - I know I need to show profit motive, but does having a formal business plan or specific revenue targets help establish that? I'm worried the IRS might look at my first-year numbers and assume it's still just a hobby. Also, for the separate business bank account - should I be running ALL vehicle expenses through that account, or just the business-related ones? I'm assuming if I use the truck for personal stuff too, I'd pay for personal gas from my personal account? Thanks for the practical advice - this is exactly the kind of real-world guidance I was hoping for!
0 coins