
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
I'm having a weird situation with my sister-in-law's taxes. She left her position at a marketing firm back in September, and now that tax season is approaching, she tried logging into her ADP account to see if her W-2 was ready. The strange thing is that her entire employment history with that company seems to have completely disappeared from her ADP portal. There's literally no trace that she ever worked there. When she tried to go through the account recovery process, ADP only shows her previous job at a restaurant she worked at until 2022. It's like her most recent employer has wiped her from their system entirely. I told her she should email HR about getting her W-2, and if she doesn't receive anything by mid-February, she should contact the IRS. But what I'm really confused about is whether a company can legally remove a former employee's access to their payroll information after they quit? Is this normal practice or something shady? Anyone dealt with this before?
I recently converted my traditional IRA to a Roth IRA and now I'm staring at this 1099-R form wondering if something's wrong. The distribution code in box 7 shows code 2, but I'm confused if that's correct for my situation. Here's the thing - I never got to deduct my traditional IRA contributions because my income was over the limits. So these were after-tax dollars going in. Now that I've rolled it over to a Roth, am I seriously going to have to pay taxes AGAIN on money that was already taxed? I've been looking at the distribution codes and I'm thinking it should maybe be code H instead of code 2? Code H seems to indicate a direct rollover of a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA, which is exactly what I did. Anyone dealt with this before? I don't want to end up double-taxed or have issues with the IRS later.
Is this also true for partial conversions? I'm thinking about converting just 50k of my traditional IRA to Roth this year to spread out the tax hit. Will I see this same code 2, and will the Form 8606 still handle the partial non-deductible portion correctly?
Yes, this applies to partial conversions too. When you convert only a portion of your traditional IRA to a Roth, you'll still get a 1099-R with likely a code 2. The key difference is how Form 8606 calculates the taxable amount. For partial conversions, the IRS doesn't let you just convert the non-deductible (already taxed) portion. Instead, each conversion is treated as containing a pro-rata portion of your taxable and non-taxable funds. Form 8606 will calculate this "pro-rata rule" based on the percentage of your non-deductible contributions compared to your total IRA balance.
I went through this exact same confusion with my traditional IRA to Roth conversion! Code 2 on the 1099-R is actually pretty standard for these conversions, even though it seems counterintuitive since you're not really taking an "early distribution." The most important thing is making sure you have proper documentation of your non-deductible contributions. If you've been making after-tax contributions to your traditional IRA because you were over the income limits, you should have been filing Form 8606 each year to track your basis. This is absolutely critical to avoid double taxation. One thing I learned the hard way - keep excellent records of all your IRA contributions and Forms 8606. The financial institutions don't track your basis for you, so if you ever get audited or need to reference your contribution history, having those forms and records will save you major headaches. The pro-rata rule mentioned earlier can get complex if you have multiple IRAs, so definitely consider getting professional help if your situation is complicated.
I've been struggling with something every year during tax season. When I fill out Form 8889 for my HSA, I notice that some calculation happens with my remaining HSA balance (the cash that's just sitting there), and a percentage of it seems to get pushed to Form 1040 and added to my total income. This makes it look like the government is taxing the money I'm keeping in my HSA account. But I thought HSAs were completely tax-free? That's what everyone tells me about HSAs - tax-free contributions, tax-free growth, tax-free withdrawals for medical expenses. Can someone please explain this percentage calculation that's happening? Why is my HSA balance seemingly being added to my taxable income? I'm starting to wonder if I've been misunderstanding how HSAs work all this time or if I'm completing Form 8889 incorrectly.
Question for anyone who knows - when filling out Form 8889, do employer contributions count toward the annual limit? My company puts in $500 per quarter ($2,000/year) and I contribute about $3,000 through payroll. The form seems to add these together but I'm not sure if that's right or if I'm supposed to be tracking them separately?
Yes, employer contributions absolutely count toward your annual HSA contribution limit. For 2023, the total limit from ALL sources (your contributions + employer contributions) is $3,850 for self-only coverage or $7,750 for family coverage. For 2024, it's $4,150 for self-only and $8,300 for family. So in your case with $2,000 from your employer and $3,000 from you, that's $5,000 total. If you have family coverage, you're good. If you have self-only coverage, you've exceeded the limit by either $1,150 (for 2023) or $850 (for 2024).
I had a similar confusion with Form 8889 last year! What helped me understand it was realizing that the form is just tracking contributions and distributions - not taxing your balance. The key thing to check is Part III of Form 8889. If you see amounts in lines 14a (total distributions) that are greater than line 15 (qualified medical expenses), then the difference goes to line 16 and becomes taxable income. This would happen if you withdrew HSA money for non-medical purposes. Your actual HSA balance (the money just sitting there growing) is never taxed. That's the whole point of an HSA - it's a tax shelter for medical expenses. Make sure you're not accidentally including employer HSA contributions as taxable income either - those should be excluded from your W-2 wages if they went through a cafeteria plan. Double-check your 1099-SA and 5498-SA forms from your HSA provider to make sure the numbers match what you entered on Form 8889. That's usually where the disconnect happens.
Title: Organizing a charity car show - do I need to register as a 501c3 nonprofit? 1 I'm the president of a local car enthusiast group and we're planning a big charity car show for next summer. We'll be charging an entry fee for participants, but 100% of the profits will be donated to a community youth center after covering basic event expenses (venue rental, insurance, porta-potties, etc). We expect around 90-95% of all money collected will go directly to the charity after necessary expenses. I'm getting a bit worried about the tax implications though. Since we're not an official nonprofit, I'm unsure if there are special requirements or if we need to formally register as a 501c3 organization. We'll have complete transparency with all funds - easy to track registration fees coming in, event expenses paid, and the final donation amount. None of our club members will pocket a dime. Should I be concerned about anything tax-wise with this arrangement? Do we need special paperwork or nonprofit status to run this kind of fundraiser? Or can we just operate as our informal car club since we're passing the money through to an established charity?
7 Tax accountant here. A few additional points to consider for your car show: 1) Make sure you're clear with participants about what portion of their fee is tax-deductible (typically only the amount exceeding the fair market value of what they receive). 2) Consider using something like "Friends of [Charity Name]" in your event materials to make it clear you're raising funds for an established charity. 3) For transparency, provide a financial summary to both the charity and participants after the event showing income, expenses, and the donation amount. 4) Check your state's requirements - some states require registration even for temporary fundraising activities.
1 That's really helpful information! For the financial summary, do you have any suggestions on what format we should use or what specific details we should include to make it most transparent?
7 For the financial summary, keep it simple but comprehensive. Create a one or two-page document with: 1) Total income (broken down by registration fees, sponsorships, additional donations, etc.) 2) Itemized expenses with brief descriptions (venue, insurance, advertising, supplies, etc.) 3) Net proceeds and donation amount Include dates for major transactions and the final donation. Some organizers also include copies of the actual donation receipt from the charity. This level of transparency helps build trust with your participants and sponsors, making them more likely to support future events.
18 I did something similar last year with a motorcycle charity ride. Instead of creating our own 501c3, we became an official "third-party fundraiser" for the charity. The charity provided us with a letter authorizing us to collect funds on their behalf, which solved a lot of the tax concerns. We still handled the registration and event logistics, but having that official relationship with the charity gave everyone peace of mind. The charity also helped us with some marketing since they had a vested interest in our success!
22 Did the charity take a percentage of what you raised? I've heard some do that to cover their administrative costs.
No, they didn't take any percentage! The youth center we worked with was just happy to have the donation. They provided the authorization letter for free and even helped promote the ride through their social media channels. I think it depends on the charity though - larger organizations might have different policies. It's definitely worth asking upfront when you approach them about partnering.
My wife and I are trying to max out our HSA contributions for 2025 and I'm confused about the limits. I know the 2025 HSA contribution limits are $4,850 for self-only coverage and $9,750 for family coverage. I also understand there's a $1,000 catch-up contribution allowed for those over 55. Here's my question - both my wife and I are over 55 years old. So is our maximum family contribution $9,750, or can we add both of our catch-up contributions to make it $11,750 total? I'm not sure if the catch-up is per person or if only one catch-up is allowed per family plan. Any help would be appreciated because I don't want to over-contribute and deal with excess contribution penalties, but also want to take full advantage of the tax benefits if we're eligible for both catch-ups.
A little warning from someone who messed this up before - make absolutely sure your total family contributions don't exceed the correct limit! I incorrectly thought my wife and I could each contribute the family maximum to our separate HSAs, and ended up with an excess contribution. The IRS charged me a 6% excise tax on the excess amount for each year it remained in the account. Had to file Form 5329 and everything. What a nightmare! To recap what others have said: - Family limit for 2025: $9,750 - Catch-up contribution if 55+: $1,000 per eligible person - Each catch-up must go to separate HSA owned by that person - Total max for married couple both 55+: $11,750
That 6% excess contribution penalty is no joke! Thanks for the warning. Did you have to withdraw the excess amount too or just pay the penalty?
Yes, I had to both withdraw the excess contribution AND pay the 6% penalty tax. You can avoid the penalty if you withdraw the excess contributions (and associated earnings) before your tax filing deadline including extensions. If you don't withdraw the excess, you'll pay the 6% penalty every year the excess remains in your account. I didn't catch my mistake right away so I ended up paying the penalty for two years before finally fixing it. Definitely learn from my mistake!
Great question! I went through this exact same confusion last year. Yes, you can absolutely add both catch-up contributions for a total of $11,750 since you're both over 55. However, there's one critical detail that trips up a lot of people (including me initially): your wife will need her own separate HSA account for her $1,000 catch-up contribution. Here's how it breaks down: - Base family contribution: $9,750 (can go into either HSA or split between them) - Your catch-up: $1,000 (must go into your HSA) - Wife's catch-up: $1,000 (must go into an HSA in her name) The catch-up contributions are tied to the individual, not the family plan. So even though you have family coverage, each person's catch-up must go into their own HSA account. If your current HSA is only in your name, you'll need to open a second HSA for your wife to receive her catch-up contribution. This is actually a pretty common misconception, so don't feel bad about being confused! The important thing is getting it right before you make the contributions to avoid any excess contribution penalties.
QuantumQuest
just fyi if ur sis works for a big company they might use a totally different system for w2s vs regular paystubs. my company uses adp for paychecks but w2s come from some weird third party system i never heard of before. u might wanna ask if there's a separate login for tax docs!!
0 coins
Connor Murphy
This is true! My company uses ADP for payroll but Workday for W-2s. It's super confusing. I panicked the first time I couldn't find my tax forms in ADP.
0 coins
Natasha Orlova
This is actually a really common issue that catches people off guard! Companies absolutely can and often do disable ex-employees' access to their ADP portals after termination - it's not shady, just standard practice for data security reasons. The employment records still exist in their system, but your personal access gets cut off. Your sister-in-law should definitely reach out to HR first. Most companies have a process for providing W-2s to former employees, and they're legally required to get it to her by January 31st. If she can't reach anyone or doesn't get the W-2 by mid-February, calling the IRS is the right next step. One thing that might help in the meantime - if she kept her final pay stub from December, that should have all her year-to-date totals for wages and tax withholdings. That information can be really useful as a backup if she needs to file Form 4852 (substitute W-2) while waiting for the official document.
0 coins