


Ask the community...
Based on my experience as a fee basis official for a federal agency, I want to emphasize the importance of getting your classification sorted out ASAP. The distinction between employee and independent contractor has huge implications beyond just withholding. If you're truly a fee basis official who's an employee, you should have access to workers' compensation, unemployment benefits, and potentially other employment protections. Independent contractors don't get these benefits. One thing that helped me was looking at the actual IRS factors for worker classification: Do they control HOW you do your work or just WHAT work you do? Do you use their equipment/office space? Are you integrated into their regular operations? These factors matter more than just the payment structure. Also, don't forget about potential deductions if you are classified as an independent contractor - home office, professional development, equipment, etc. Keep detailed records of all work-related expenses from day one, regardless of your classification, because you might need them later. The quarterly estimated tax payments are crucial if you're 1099 - missing them can result in penalties even if you pay everything at year-end. Set aside money immediately from each payment you receive.
This is incredibly helpful advice! I'm a newcomer to this whole fee basis situation and had no idea about the workers' compensation and unemployment benefits implications. That's a huge difference I hadn't considered. The IRS factors you mentioned are really useful - I think my agency does control HOW I do the work since they have specific procedures I have to follow and I use their systems and office space. That sounds more like employee status to me. Quick question about the quarterly payments - if I do end up being classified as independent contractor, when exactly are those due? I just started this position last month so I want to make sure I don't miss any deadlines. And do you have any recommendations for what percentage to set aside? I've seen everything from 25-35% mentioned in different places. Thanks for sharing your federal agency experience - it's reassuring to hear from someone who's actually navigated this successfully!
Great questions! For quarterly payments, the deadlines are typically January 15, April 15, June 15, and September 15 each year. Since you just started last month, you'll want to track when your first payment period began to determine which quarter you fall into. As for percentages, I personally set aside 30% to be safe - this covers federal income tax, state tax (if applicable), and the full 15.3% self-employment tax. Better to have a little extra set aside than to come up short! The exact amount depends on your total income and tax bracket, but 30% is a good starting point for most people. Your situation with using their systems, office space, and following specific procedures definitely sounds more like employee status to me. Those are strong indicators of an employer-employee relationship under IRS guidelines. I'd really encourage you to get written clarification from your agency about your classification - it could save you a lot of headaches down the road. You might also want to document those control factors you mentioned (procedures, systems, office space) in case you need to reference them later if there's any dispute about your classification.
As someone who recently went through a similar classification challenge with my municipal position, I'd strongly recommend getting everything in writing from your HR department about your status. Don't just accept verbal explanations - ask for documentation that clearly states whether you're classified as an employee or independent contractor. One thing that really helped me was requesting to see the actual job description and any internal memos about how positions like yours are supposed to be handled. Sometimes there's a disconnect between what HR tells you verbally and what their official policies actually say. Also, keep detailed records of everything - your work schedule, supervision level, equipment provided, training requirements, etc. This documentation could be crucial if you ever need to challenge your classification with the IRS or Department of Labor. From a practical standpoint, if you're not having taxes withheld, I'd recommend opening a separate savings account immediately and transferring 25-30% of each payment into it for taxes. Even if you later find out you're misclassified as a contractor, you'll have the money set aside and won't be scrambling at tax time. The uncertainty is stressful, but getting proper documentation and keeping good records will protect you either way the classification goes.
4 Has anyone dealt with the failure-to-file penalty for Form 1065 specifically? I'm in a similar situation but with a multi-member LLC, and we're getting hit with $2,100 per partner per month for late filing! It's absolutely crushing us.
16 Yes! Form 1065 penalties are brutal - $220 per partner per month for up to 12 months (as of 2025 tax year). I was able to get them completely abated by demonstrating reasonable cause. Document any issues with previous tax preparers, health problems, or natural disasters that contributed to late filing. The key is being extremely specific about why each year was late.
I've been through this exact nightmare with my LLC! Here's what I learned that might help: First, don't panic - you have options. The IRS penalty system is harsh but there are legitimate ways to get relief. Since you're a single-member LLC filing Schedule C, you're likely dealing with failure-to-file and failure-to-pay penalties on your personal return. Your current accountant sounds unreliable if they've consistently filed late despite claiming to file extensions. Extensions only give you time to file, not to pay - so if you owed taxes, you'd still get hit with penalties even with valid extensions. Here's my action plan that worked: 1) Get your IRS transcripts immediately to see what was actually filed and when 2) Fire your current accountant - they're clearly not handling your situation properly 3) Look into First Time Penalty Abatement for at least one tax year 4) Document everything about your previous accountant retiring and the chaos that caused 5) Consider "reasonable cause" arguments for the other years The key is being proactive. I waited too long hoping my accountant would fix things, and it just got worse. You might be surprised how much penalty relief is available if you approach it systematically. Don't let the intimidating notices paralyze you - there's definitely a path forward here.
This is really helpful advice! I'm curious about the "reasonable cause" arguments you mentioned - what kind of documentation did you need to provide to the IRS? I have emails from my first accountant's office saying they were closing, but I'm not sure if that's enough proof. Also, how long did the whole penalty abatement process take once you submitted everything?
I completely understand your concern about this situation, Jamal. Your instincts are absolutely right - what your neighbor is suggesting is tax evasion, plain and simple. Here's the bottom line: You're required to report ALL income, regardless of how you're paid. At $300 per job doing 2-3 jobs monthly, you're looking at roughly $1,800-$2,700 per year. This definitely needs to be reported on your tax return. Your neighbor also has obligations - if he's paying you as an independent contractor and it totals $600+ per year, he should issue you a 1099-NEC. If not, you still need to report it as "other income" on your return. My advice: Start tracking all payments from now on, set aside about 25-30% for taxes (income tax plus self-employment tax), and consider making quarterly estimated payments to avoid a big bill next April. You might also be able to deduct work-related expenses like tools or mileage. Don't let your neighbor's casual attitude toward taxes put you at risk. The "everyone does it" mentality doesn't protect you from penalties, interest, or potential criminal charges. Better to handle this properly from the start than deal with IRS problems later.
This is really helpful advice, Alexis! I'm actually in a similar situation with some freelance work I've been doing. When you mention setting aside 25-30% for taxes, is that a general rule of thumb or does it depend on your regular income bracket? I'm worried I might be setting aside too little since I have a day job too and this pushes me into a higher tax bracket.
Great question, Cole! The 25-30% is a general starting point, but you're absolutely right that your total income matters. Since you have a day job, that freelance income gets taxed at your marginal rate (your highest bracket), not your average rate. If your day job already puts you in the 22% bracket, for example, that freelance income would face 22% federal income tax PLUS 15.3% self-employment tax, putting you closer to 37% total. You might want to calculate based on your actual marginal rate plus the 15.3% SE tax. I'd recommend using the IRS Form 1040ES worksheet or one of the online estimated tax calculators to get a more precise number for your situation. Better to overpay slightly and get a refund than underpay and face penalties!
Just want to echo what others have said - your gut feeling is absolutely correct. This is tax evasion, not a "tax headache avoidance strategy." I work in tax preparation and see people in similar situations all the time. The "everyone does it" line is classic - it's what people tell themselves to justify risky behavior. But the reality is that unreported income catches up with you eventually, often when you least expect it. A few practical points for your situation: - Keep detailed records of all payments (dates, amounts, work performed) - You'll likely need to file Schedule C for this self-employment income - Don't forget about self-employment tax (15.3%) in addition to regular income tax - Consider quarterly estimated payments if this continues The peace of mind from doing things correctly is worth way more than the temporary "savings" from hiding income. Plus, as a legitimate business expense, your neighbor can actually deduct what he pays you - so there's really no good reason for him to want to hide these payments other than avoiding his own tax obligations. Better to have an honest conversation with him about proper documentation, or find a different side gig if he's unwilling to do things legally.
This is excellent advice, Rajan. I'm actually new to understanding tax obligations and this thread has been incredibly eye-opening. One thing I'm curious about - when you mention having an "honest conversation" with the neighbor about proper documentation, what exactly should someone in Jamal's position say? I imagine it could be awkward to basically tell your employer they're asking you to commit tax fraud, especially if they seem to think it's totally normal. Any suggestions for how to approach that conversation diplomatically while still protecting yourself legally?
Something nobody's mentioned yet - if your husband's getting this stipend without any tax docs, his employer might be misclassifying this payment to avoid payroll taxes. That could cause bigger problems down the road. If he's truly an employee (W-2), ALL compensation should be reported on his W-2, including stipends. The only exception would be properly documented reimbursements under an accountable plan.
That's actually a really good point I hadn't considered. The stipend comes separately from his regular paycheck, as a check with no taxes taken out. His manager just told him it was "non-taxable" for travel expenses but we've never received any official documentation about it. Should we ask his employer to clarify this in writing?
Definitely ask for clarification in writing. Request a formal policy document explaining how their travel reimbursement program works. If it's truly meant to be an accountable plan (non-taxable reimbursement), they should have policies requiring documentation of expenses, business purpose, and returning excess amounts. If they can't provide this documentation, that's a red flag that they may be improperly handling these payments. In that case, your husband should keep meticulous records of all his business travel - dates, destinations, mileage, purpose of trips - and all stipend payments received. This documentation will be crucial if there's ever an audit.
I handle payroll for a small company and we've had this exact issue. If the stipend is a true reimbursement under an accountable plan it should NOT be on his W-2. But there are strict rules - he must submit expense reports/mileage logs to his employer, have a business purpose for each expense, and return any excess money not used for business expenses. If those requirements aren't met, it's just taxable income that should be included on his W-2.
What's the deadline for having an accountable plan in place? If her husband's company hasn't been treating it as an accountable plan but they start now, does that fix the issue for this tax year or are they stuck?
Unfortunately, an accountable plan needs to be established prospectively - you can't retroactively create one to fix past tax years. The IRS requires that the accountable plan policies be in place before the reimbursements are made. For this current tax year, if the company hasn't been following accountable plan rules (requiring expense reports, business purpose documentation, etc.), then those stipend payments should be treated as taxable compensation and included on the W-2. However, the company could establish proper accountable plan procedures going forward for next year. They'd need to create written policies requiring employees to submit detailed expense reports with receipts, document the business purpose of each trip, and return any unused funds within a reasonable time period (typically 120 days). @Danielle Mays - for this year s'taxes, you ll'likely need to report the stipend as income and unfortunately won t'be able to deduct the mileage as an employee under current tax law.
Amara Chukwu
Great question! Yes, you can absolutely convert the entire $14,500 from your Traditional IRA to Roth IRA in 2025. There are no annual limits on conversion amounts - only on contributions. Since you mentioned your Traditional IRA contributions are non-deductible (after-tax), you'll have minimal tax consequences. You'll only owe taxes on any earnings that accumulate between contribution and conversion. Given that you're doing this as part of a backdoor Roth strategy with minimal growth, your tax hit should be very small. A few tips from my experience: - Convert soon after contributing to minimize taxable earnings - Keep detailed records and file Form 8606 for each year you make non-deductible contributions - Consider doing the 2025 contribution and conversion early in January to maximize your Roth growth time This is a perfectly legitimate strategy that many people use to get around the Roth IRA income limits. Just make sure you don't have any other Traditional IRA balances (like old 401k rollovers) that could trigger the pro-rata rule and complicate your taxes.
0 coins
Mateo Gonzalez
ā¢This is really helpful! I'm new to the backdoor Roth strategy and had no idea about the pro-rata rule you mentioned. Could you explain what happens if someone does have old 401k rollovers in their Traditional IRA? Does that completely mess up the backdoor Roth conversion, or is there a way to work around it? Also, when you say "convert soon after contributing," are we talking days, weeks, or months? I want to make sure I'm timing this right to minimize any tax complications.
0 coins
Chloe Martin
ā¢Great question about the pro-rata rule! If you have old 401k rollovers sitting in a Traditional IRA, it can definitely complicate the backdoor Roth strategy. The IRS looks at ALL your Traditional IRA balances when calculating taxes on conversions, not just the account you're converting from. Here's how it works: Let's say you have $90,000 from an old 401k rollover (pre-tax money) and you add $6,000 in non-deductible contributions. When you convert that $6,000, the IRS sees it as converting 6.25% of your total IRA balance ($6k out of $96k total). So 93.75% of your conversion would be taxable - meaning you'd owe taxes on about $5,625 of that $6,000 conversion! The workaround is to roll that old 401k money INTO your current employer's 401k plan (if they allow it) before doing the conversion. This clears out your Traditional IRA and lets the backdoor Roth work cleanly. As for timing - I typically convert within a few days to a week after contributing. Some people do it the same day. The key is minimizing any market gains that would create taxable earnings. Even a few weeks is usually fine since there's rarely significant growth in that short time. @Mateo Gonzalez Hope this helps clarify things!
0 coins
Javier Torres
You're absolutely right that there's no limit on conversion amounts! I did exactly what you're describing last year - converted about $13,000 from my Traditional IRA to Roth in one go after making contributions for both 2023 and 2024. One thing I learned the hard way: make sure you understand how your brokerage handles the conversion process. Some require you to call them, others let you do it online. I assumed I could just transfer money between accounts, but it needs to be processed as an official "conversion" for tax reporting purposes. Also, keep really good records of your contribution dates and amounts. When tax time comes, you'll need to report the non-deductible contributions on Form 8606, and having clear documentation makes everything much smoother. I created a simple spreadsheet tracking contribution dates, amounts, and conversion dates - saved me a lot of headaches come April! The backdoor Roth is such a great strategy for high earners who can't contribute directly to Roth IRAs. You're on the right track!
0 coins
Nia Harris
ā¢Thanks for sharing your experience! That's a great point about the conversion process - I hadn't thought about the mechanics of actually doing it through my brokerage. Do you remember if there were any fees associated with the conversion, or was it just a matter of filling out the right forms? Your spreadsheet idea is brilliant. I've been pretty casual about my record-keeping so far, but with tax reporting being so important for this strategy, I should definitely get more organized. Did you track anything else besides the dates and amounts, like account values at conversion or any small earnings that accumulated? I'm excited to finally take advantage of this backdoor strategy since my income puts me over the direct Roth contribution limits. It feels like I'm leaving money on the table by not maximizing my Roth savings opportunities!
0 coins