Will I qualify for unemployment if I quit over unpaid overtime? California EDD situation
So my employer has been shorting me on overtime pay for about eight months now. I work in a warehouse and regularly put in 50+ hours a week but they keep classifying extra hours as 'flex time' that supposedly gets paid out later — except it never does. I've brought it up three times with my supervisor and once with HR, and nothing changed. Last month I finally got fed up and walked out. Now I'm sitting here trying to figure out if California EDD will even consider this a legitimate reason to quit or if I'm just going to get denied outright. I know quitting usually disqualifies you, but this feels like a situation where staying would've meant continuing to work for free. Filed my claim two weeks ago and I already have a phone interview scheduled — the DE 4800 shows the date and time. But I'm honestly terrified the interviewer is going to hear 'I quit' and just shut it down immediately. Has anyone dealt with something like this? Did you get approved? What did you say during the phone interview?
80 comments

Douglas Foster
Unpaid overtime at a warehouse job and my claim had a similar wrinkle — employer kept miscoding my hours as 'training time' for about five months. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live EDD agent on the phone because I'd been trying to reach someone for days. The agent looked at my claim and told me the interview was already scheduled and that I should bring documentation of the wage dispute to reference when I answered the interviewer's questions. There's a video on reaching a live person at EDD by phone at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you're in the same boat. The agent also confirmed the pending weeks on my claim were waiting on the interview outcome, which I hadn't been sure about from UI Online alone.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
AuthorDid the agent say anything about whether wage theft counts as 'good cause' to quit, or was that left completely up to the interviewer?
0 coins
Douglas Foster
The agent didn't weigh in on that at all — said EDD decides after both sides give their statements. What I did next was pull together my timesheets and the emails where I'd asked my supervisor about the missing pay.
0 coins
Nina Chan
Documentation of your complaints to HR is huge. Even texts or emails asking about the pay discrepancy show you tried to fix it before quitting.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
Worth knowing what 'good cause' actually means under California EDD rules before the interview. The way I'd put it to a friend: if you quit, you have to show your reason was real and serious enough that a reasonable person in your position would have done the same thing. Ongoing wage theft — your employer literally not paying you wages you earned — is about as real as it gets. The key thing EDD looks at is whether you tried to fix it first. You said you went to your supervisor three times and HR once. That's actually a strong paper trail if you can back it up. For your interview, I'd lay out the timeline clearly: when the problem started, every time you raised it, what they said, and when you finally decided it wasn't going to change.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
AuthorDo I need to have all of this written down before the interview, or is it okay to just talk through it?
0 coins
Ruby Knight
Having notes in front of you is totally fine — the interviewer expects you to reference details. Just have dates handy if you can, even approximate ones.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
Agree on the timeline thing. When I had my interview for a different reason, the interviewer specifically asked 'what date did you last raise this with your employer' and I was glad I'd jotted stuff down beforehand.
0 coins
Logan Stewart
Okay can I ask something that's been confusing me — is the phone interview the same as an appeal? Like if the interview goes badly do you then appeal, or is the appeal a separate thing entirely?
0 coins
Ruby Knight
Completely separate processes. The phone interview is EDD gathering facts before they make any decision — it happens because you quit, so they need both sides' story. An appeal is what you do AFTER EDD sends a Notice of Determination (DE 1080CZ) saying they denied you. You'd have 30 days from the mailing date on that notice to appeal in writing.
0 coins
Logan Stewart
Oh okay that makes way more sense. So the interview isn't the decision, it's just them collecting info?
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
Exactly. The interviewer doesn't tell you yes or no on the call. EDD processes the decision after and mails it, or just starts paying if you're approved.
0 coins
Sean Matthews
Eight months of this would have broken me honestly. Question though — did you keep any of your own records, like photos of your time clock punches or anything showing the actual hours you worked versus what they paid?
0 coins
Haley Bennett
AuthorLuckily yes — I'd started taking photos of the time clock screen around month three because I had a feeling this was going to blow up eventually. Also have my bank deposits which obviously don't match what 50+ hour weeks should look like.
0 coins
Sean Matthews
Those photos are gold. And the deposit record showing consistent underpayment over months is basically a visual argument that the problem was real and ongoing, not just a one-time mistake.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
Bank records vs. paystubs comparison is exactly what an employment attorney would tell you to gather too. Even if EDD decides against you, that's a wage claim through the Labor Commissioner's office separately.
0 coins
Zadie Patel
WAIT. Does quitting automatically disqualify you in California? I always thought once you quit you just can't get unemployment, full stop. Is that actually wrong??
0 coins
Ruby Knight
That's a really common misunderstanding. EDD's own rule is that if you quit, YOU have to show you had a good reason. It doesn't auto-disqualify — it shifts what EDD is looking at. For a firing it's the employer proving misconduct. For a quit it's you showing your reason was legitimate. Wage theft is the kind of thing that can clear that bar.
0 coins
Zadie Patel
Okay wow I had no idea that was how it worked. I told my coworker she couldn't claim after she quit and now I feel bad.
0 coins
A Man D Mortal
Yeah the 'you quit so you can't get unemployment' thing is one of the most widespread myths about EDD. Good cause quits absolutely can qualify — it just requires the interview to work through it.
0 coins
Declan Ramirez
Can I ask what happens if the employer lies during the interview? Like says the overtime was always paid correctly?
0 coins
Ruby Knight
EDD interviews both sides separately. Your documentation — the time records, the emails to HR, the deposit history — is what counters whatever your employer claims. That's why the paper trail matters so much here.
0 coins
Declan Ramirez
So basically it comes down to whose evidence is stronger? That feels stressful but also kind of fair I guess.
0 coins
Emma Morales
Pretty much. And employers don't always respond to EDD in time either — if they miss the window to respond, EDD moves forward without their side.
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
The employer has 10 days from the date on the notice EDD sends them to respond. After that EDD can proceed without their input, and if they want to appeal later they're in a tougher spot.
0 coins
Lucas Parker
My former employer also tried the 'flex time' thing — they called it a 'PTO bank' that accumulated instead of overtime pay, which is not how California overtime law works at all. I ended up getting approved by EDD because I had emails from my manager acknowledging the hours and saying they'd 'catch up' on the balance later.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
AuthorThose 'we'll catch up later' messages are exactly what I have too. That's reassuring to hear they were useful in your case.
0 coins
Lucas Parker
Print them out and have them in front of you during the call. I literally read a quote from one of mine when the interviewer asked me what my employer said when I raised the issue.
0 coins
Donna Cline
This is a good thread — the 'flex time' dodge is shockingly common in certain industries and EDD interviewers have seen it before.
0 coins
Harper Collins
Wait do you still have to do the work search stuff even while your claim is pending from the interview? I always assumed you didn't have to look for jobs until the claim was approved.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
You need to be able to work, available for work, and looking for work every week you certify — that's the standard for each week you claim, regardless of where your claim is in the process. Keep track of your job search activity while you're waiting.
0 coins
Harper Collins
Ugh okay so I have to be doing all of that the whole time. Got it.
0 coins
Nina Chan
Also don't forget CalJOBS registration — most claimants have to register and post a resume there within 21 days of the date on the notice they get (the DE 8405). Check yours to see if that applies.
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
Have you certified yet while this is pending? And do your weeks show as Pending in the Claim History in UI Online?
0 coins
Haley Bennett
AuthorYes certified for two biweekly periods already and all those weeks are showing Pending in Claim History. I figured that was normal while the interview outcome is still open.
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
That's exactly right — Pending means EDD is waiting on the interview decision before releasing anything. Keep certifying through it. If you get approved, those weeks pay out.
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
Definitely keep certifying no matter what. If you stop and then win an appeal later, you can't get paid for weeks you didn't certify.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
Overtime misclassification situation, eight months of it — my claim had a wage dispute in the mix too. Got a live EDD agent through Claimyr after I couldn't get through on the main line for a whole week. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the wage-related issue had flagged my claim for the phone interview, which I already knew, but she also told me my identity verification through ID.me had cleared which I hadn't confirmed anywhere in UI Online. I went into the interview less anxious knowing that one piece was settled.
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
ID.me being confirmed but still showing pending weeks — was that confusing? Like why would identity clearing not start payments right away?
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
The agent explained that the pending weeks were specifically waiting on the interview decision, not the identity step. Two separate holds, the identity one had cleared, the eligibility one was still open. Made sense once she laid it out like that.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
AuthorThis is really helpful context — I wasn't sure if my pending status was about identity or the interview. I'll double-check my ID.me status before the interview.
0 coins
Emma Morales
What week does your interview fall on? Like how far out from your quit date did they schedule it?
0 coins
Haley Bennett
AuthorAbout three weeks from when I filed, so roughly five weeks from when I actually quit. Felt like a long time to wait honestly.
0 coins
Emma Morales
That's actually pretty standard from what I've seen — the interview scheduling can take a few weeks depending on volume.
0 coins
Gianna Scott
Mine took four weeks after I filed to get the DE 4800 in the mail. Wasn't sure if the delay was normal or if something was wrong with my claim.
0 coins
A Man D Mortal
Hopefully your CalJOBS profile is set up and your resume is posted. That's one of the things that can hold up payments separately from the interview — if you got the DE 8405 notice, you've got 21 days from that date to get it done.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
AuthorAlready did it — created my CalJOBS account and posted my resume the week after I filed. Didn't want any other reason for a delay.
0 coins
A Man D Mortal
Good move. Some people miss that step and then get surprised when payments stop even after the interview goes fine.
0 coins
Donna Cline
The DE 8405 timeline is strict from what I understand — they don't really give extensions on it, so getting it done early is the smart play.
0 coins
Nina Chan
What industry is the warehouse in? Not to get too specific but some industries have really consistent patterns of this overtime misclassification stuff and EDD interviewers know the red flags.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
AuthorIt's a third-party logistics company, so we handle shipments for multiple retail clients. It's very common in that space from what I've seen talking to people at other companies.
0 coins
Nina Chan
3PL companies are notorious for this. The 'flex time bank' thing is almost a standard workaround they try across the industry. EDD has probably seen this exact structure before.
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
Did you file a wage claim with the Labor Commissioner at the same time? Or do you have to wait to see what EDD does first?
0 coins
Ali Anderson
Those are completely separate — EDD decides your unemployment eligibility, and the Labor Commissioner handles the unpaid wage recovery. You can pursue both at the same time, they don't interfere with each other.
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
Oh good because I was worried filing a wage claim would somehow make it look like you're still connected to the job and mess up the unemployment claim.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
It doesn't affect your UI eligibility status. The Labor Commissioner claim is about getting the money owed to you from past work, which you're entitled to regardless.
0 coins
Sydney Torres
Overtime documentation situation on a claim I dealt with — my employer also disputed the hours and my claim went to a phone interview. Used Claimyr to reach EDD beforehand and the agent confirmed the specific weeks that were pending and which week the interview was tied to. Knowing exactly which weeks were being held let me make sure I hadn't missed certifying any of them.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
AuthorHow did you know to ask about which specific weeks were affected? I hadn't thought to ask anything that precise.
0 coins
Sydney Torres
The agent can just look at your claim and read it off. Worth asking directly — which weeks are pending and is there anything other than the interview holding them up.
0 coins
Logan Stewart
Is there any way to see which weeks are affected in UI Online without calling, or do you have to reach someone to find out?
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
After the interview decision comes, however it goes, you'll get a Notice of Determination in the mail. If they deny you, the 30-day clock on your appeal starts from the mailing date on that notice. Don't miss it — a late appeal needs you to explain why it was late, and that's an extra hurdle you don't want.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
AuthorIf I do have to appeal, is that a whole separate hearing process or just more paperwork?
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
It's a real hearing before an administrative law judge — you testify under oath, your employer can participate too. The notice of hearing comes by mail at least 10 days before it's scheduled. You can represent yourself or have someone represent you.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
Keep certifying through the whole appeal process too. The only weeks that can be paid out if you win are ones you actually certified for.
0 coins
Donna Cline
The flip side of this that I want to flag: if your employer claims during the interview that you weren't actually working those extra hours — that this is your word against theirs — the documentation is what breaks the tie. Photos of a time clock don't lie. Emails asking about pay don't lie.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
AuthorThat's exactly the scenario I'm most worried about. They're going to say the hours weren't real and I'm going to need my own records to counter it.
0 coins
Donna Cline
And if they provided any written schedule or assignment records showing the shifts, those work in your favor too. The more third-party records the better.
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
Just to think about the worst case — if EDD denies you even with all this documentation, you'd still have the wage claim route and potentially a retaliation claim if they can connect any negative actions to your complaints. The EDD appeal is not the only path.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
AuthorHadn't really thought of the retaliation angle. They did cut my hours for about two weeks after I first complained to HR before I finally quit.
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
That detail matters and might be worth mentioning in the interview too — that the conditions got worse after you raised the issue. That supports that you had exhausted your options.
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
An employment attorney consult might be worth it even just to understand what you have. A lot of them do free consultations for wage cases.
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
My claim was pending for almost a month before my interview date and I nearly had a breakdown. How are you holding up with no income coming in during the wait?
0 coins
Haley Bennett
AuthorHonestly not great but I've been doing some gig work to cover basics while I wait. Making sure to report those earnings accurately when I certify.
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
Smart to report everything. EDD's earnings formula means you can still get a partial payment on weeks you earn something part-time — the first $25 or 25% of what you earned, whichever is more, doesn't count against your benefit.
0 coins
Gianna Scott
CalFresh is also worth looking into if money is tight — unemployment benefits count as income when you apply, and eligibility is based on your income level, so it might be an option in the meantime.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
Something I'd add for the interview itself: answer what they ask and don't oversell or add extra detail they didn't ask for. When they ask why you quit, you say the overtime wasn't being paid and you'd raised it multiple times. Let them ask follow-ups rather than dumping everything at once — it comes across more credible.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
AuthorThat's actually really useful advice. I've been worrying about cramming everything in and that's making me more nervous.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
The interviewer has a list of questions they go through. Trust the process — they'll ask about documentation, they'll ask about what your employer said, they'll cover the important stuff if you don't panic and try to cover it all in your first answer.
0 coins
Zadie Patel
Does the interviewer tell you at the end of the call whether you're approved or just leave you hanging?
0 coins
Diego Castillo
They leave you with nothing — just 'we'll process the information and you'll receive a notice.' It's annoying but that's how it works.
0 coins