Stuck verifying identity when filing new claim with open unemployment claim
So here's my situation and I honestly don't know what I'm doing wrong. I got laid off from my logistics job back in October and filed a California EDD claim that's currently still open with a remaining balance. Last week my hours got cut to zero at a part-time gig I'd picked up to supplement, so I'm now completely without income again. When I tried to file a new claim through myEDD (https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/), it's asking me to verify my identity through ID.me all over again even though I already did this when I set up the original claim. I've uploaded my documents twice now and ID.me keeps telling me there's an issue with the photo verification step. Meanwhile my existing claim just sits there and I'm not sure if I should even be filing a new claim at all or if I should be doing something else with the original one. Does anyone know if you're supposed to reopen your existing claim when a second job ends while you're still in the same benefit year? I'm getting confused between filing new vs reopening and now the identity verification stuff is on top of that. Any help appreciated.
80 comments

Rami Samuels
DE 4581 is what gets mailed when you need to certify by paper, but before you go that route — if your original benefit year is still open, you don't file a new claim at all. You reopen the existing one through UI Online. Look for the option to reopen your claim on the homepage once you log in. Filing a new claim when one's already open and in its benefit year can cause all kinds of delays.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorThat makes sense about reopening vs filing new. I think I might have accidentally started a new application instead of reopening. Would that cause the ID.me verification to trigger again, or does it do that every time regardless?
0 coins
Rami Samuels
Starting a fresh application when you already have an active claim can definitely kick off the full verification process again. If you catch it early, abandon that application and go back to the homepage and use the reopen option instead. The identity verification shouldn't loop on you if you're just reopening.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
Happened to me exactly this way last spring. I filed new when I should have reopened and spent two weeks in ID.me purgatory before someone here pointed out the reopen option.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
ID.me photo issues are usually about lighting or the angle of the ID card in the shot. Try a plain dark background, hold the card flat, and make sure there's no glare from overhead light. The front camera on a phone usually works better than a webcam for this. If it still rejects the image after a couple of tries, ID.me has a video call option where a real person walks you through it in real time.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorTried the dark background thing last night and it rejected it again. Didn't know about the video call option — going to try that next. Is the video call with ID.me or with EDD?
0 coins
Douglas Foster
The video call is ID.me's own process, not EDD's. When you're at the step where it fails, there should be a link to verify with a live agent instead. ID.me's agents can confirm your documents manually. After that, your verified status carries over to EDD automatically.
0 coins
Nina Chan
The ID.me video option saved me months ago. Wait times vary but I got through in about 25 minutes on a Tuesday afternoon.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
Open claim sitting at the wrong status because of an identity hold — that was my situation last month. Termination from a warehouse job mid-November, certified for two weeks, then everything froze on me with a pending identity flag in Claim History. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with an EDD agent and I asked her directly whether the ID.me hold was blocking my pending weeks or just my ability to certify going forward. She pulled up my claim and told me the specific weeks that were frozen and said once ID.me sent EDD the confirmation, those weeks would process automatically without me having to do anything else. There's a video Claimyr put out about reaching a live EDD agent that shows what the process looks like: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorReally useful to know the agent can actually see which weeks are frozen. My Claim History just says Pending on the last two weeks and I have no idea if it's the identity thing or something else.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
Same kind of ambiguous Pending status drove me crazy. Calling EDD and having them read off exactly what the hold is on your account is so much clearer than staring at that screen.
0 coins
Logan Stewart
Knowing the agent can pinpoint the exact weeks is what I needed to hear. Makes it less of a guessing game.
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
Worth double-checking whether you even need to file anything new. The standard setup is: your claim runs for 52 weeks from the date you first filed. If your part-time job ending happens inside that window, you're just reopening. Only if that 52-week benefit year has already ended would you need a brand new claim — and in that case you'd also potentially be starting with a new base period for calculating your weekly benefit amount.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorFiled the original claim in October so I'm definitely still inside the 52 weeks. Good to know reopening is the right move here.
0 coins
Sean Matthews
People mix this up all the time. The 52-week benefit year is the frame and reopening is almost always what someone in this situation needs, not a fresh application.
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
Exactly. And reopening doesn't reset your weekly benefit amount or use up your waiting week again — your remaining balance just picks back up where it left off.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
The ID.me loop when you already have a verified account sometimes happens because EDD's system doesn't automatically carry over your verified status if something triggers a re-review. What worked for someone I know was logging into ID.me separately at ID.me's own site, confirming the EDD connection was still active under the sharing settings, and then going back to myEDD and logging in fresh. Sometimes the link between the two accounts just needs a nudge.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorChecked the ID.me sharing settings just now and EDD wasn't listed as an active connection anymore somehow. Re-authorized it and now myEDD is loading differently. Fingers crossed this is what fixed it.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
That disconnected sharing is exactly what causes the loop. Once you re-authorize, give it a few minutes before trying to proceed in UI Online — sometimes there's a short sync delay.
0 coins
Zadie Patel
Bookmarking this tip for my nephew — he's going through the exact same ID.me disconnect issue right now.
0 coins
A Man D Mortal
While you're sorting out the verification, keep certifying on your existing claim if EDD is still letting you. If the certification page is locked because of the pending identity issue, note those weeks down because once the hold clears you'll want to certify for any weeks you missed during the freeze. Uncertified weeks don't get paid retroactively unless you eventually certify them.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorUI Online isn't showing me the certify option right now, just the Pending status and no way to proceed. So I'm going to have to certify those weeks after the ID hold clears?
0 coins
A Man D Mortal
Likely yes — once the identity verification goes through, the certification option should reappear and you'd certify for the blocked weeks at that point. Keep track of them.
0 coins
Declan Ramirez
Had a three-week freeze like that and was able to certify all three weeks back-to-back once my account unlocked. The system let me do them all at once.
0 coins
Emma Morales
Your new application may have also created a duplicate claim flag on your account, which EDD sometimes needs to manually clear. If the reopen path was what you should have done, you might want to contact EDD through the message option in UI Online to let them know you accidentally started a new application and want it cancelled in favor of reopening the existing one. Doing it in writing through Ask EDD gives you a record of the request.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorDidn't even think about the duplicate flag. I'll send a message through my UI Online account today explaining what happened. Is there a specific form I should reference or just explain it in plain language?
0 coins
Emma Morales
Plain language in the message is fine. Just include your claim start date, explain you filed a new application by mistake, and ask them to deactivate it and restore the reopen path on your original claim. No special form needed for that kind of correction.
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
The written message route is smart because if something does get tangled up between the two claims you have documentation showing you flagged the error proactively.
0 coins
Lucas Parker
ID.me rejecting the same documents multiple times usually means one of two things: either the resolution on the photo is too low or the name and address on your supporting document don't exactly match what's in EDD's system. If you moved since your original claim, your ID might show an old address that conflicts with what EDD has. That mismatch can cause ID.me to flag the verification as incomplete even if the photos themselves look fine.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorActually did move about six weeks ago and haven't updated my address with EDD yet. That could absolutely be the conflict. How do I update the address in UI Online before retrying ID.me?
0 coins
Lucas Parker
Address updates go through the contact information section in your myEDD profile settings. Update it there first, then try the ID.me verification again. Give it a day or two for EDD's system to reflect the change before you retry.
0 coins
Nina Chan
Address mismatch was exactly what killed my ID.me verification last year. Updating it on the EDD side first made everything go through on the first try after that.
0 coins
Donna Cline
Two weeks of pending weeks that wouldn't move even after my ID.me verification completed — that was the wall I hit after getting laid off from a restaurant in September. Used Claimyr to get through to an EDD agent and asked why the weeks were still frozen after ID.me confirmed my identity. The agent found that EDD hadn't received the ID.me confirmation yet on their end and manually triggered the update, and my payment posted the next morning.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorSo the ID.me confirmation doesn't always automatically reach EDD? That's a step I didn't know could fail. Good to know an agent can push it through manually.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
The sync between ID.me and EDD failing silently is more common than it should be. Calling to confirm EDD received the verification is worth doing if your pending status doesn't change within a day or two of completing ID.me.
0 coins
Sean Matthews
One thing that tripped me up in a similar situation: EDD's Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (DE 8405) — if you got one when you first filed, check whether the CalJOBS registration deadline has passed. EDD requires most claimants to register in CalJOBS and post a resume within 21 days of that notice's date. If your claim got frozen during that window and you missed it, it can hold up payments separately from the identity issue.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorGot the DE 8405 when I first filed in October and did register in CalJOBS back then. Should I need to do that again now that I'm reopening, or does the original registration still count?
0 coins
Sean Matthews
The original registration should still be active in CalJOBS — you don't typically need to redo it just because you're reopening. Log into caljobs.ca.gov and confirm your resume is still posted and your profile is showing as active, just to be safe.
0 coins
Zadie Patel
CalJOBS profiles can go inactive if you haven't logged in for a while. Worth logging in and refreshing your activity there whenever you reopen a claim.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
Phone line for EDD is 1-800-300-5616, weekdays 8 to 5. Early mornings on Tuesdays or Wednesdays tend to have shorter waits in my experience. If your situation is at the point where the UI Online message hasn't gotten a response and ID.me isn't resolving it, calling is probably the fastest path to getting someone to look at the actual account.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorHow long does EDD typically take to respond to a UI Online message? I sent one this morning about the duplicate application.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
Response times through messages vary a lot — sometimes a few days, sometimes longer. If you need a faster answer, calling is more reliable for something that needs immediate action on the account.
0 coins
Declan Ramirez
My last UI Online message took eight days to get a reply. For anything time-sensitive I go straight to the phone.
0 coins
Logan Stewart
Pending weeks during an identity hold don't pay interest or anything but they do stay eligible for payment once the hold clears, as long as you certify for them. The key thing is making sure you actually certify for every week — EDD can only pay weeks that have been certified, so if any slipped through during the freeze, get them certified as soon as the account unlocks.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorNoted — I'm keeping a running list of the weeks I need to certify once this clears. Two weeks so far where I couldn't get into the certification screen.
0 coins
Logan Stewart
Two weeks is manageable. Some people come back after a longer freeze and have to certify five or six at once. The system handles it, it's just a lot of questions in a row.
0 coins
Harper Collins
Retail job ended in mid-October and my benefit year from an earlier claim was still open when that happened. Claimyr put me on the phone with an EDD agent and I asked whether reopening the old claim or filing new made more sense given my earnings at the retail job. The agent walked through my claim balance and told me I had enough remaining on the existing claim that reopening was the right call, and that filing new would start a fresh base period calculation that might actually come out lower given my recent earnings pattern.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorThat's a really good point I hadn't thought about — a new claim might actually calculate a lower weekly amount depending on what's in the base period. The agent can compare those scenarios?
0 coins
Harper Collins
She walked me through it without giving me a hard number for the new claim scenario, but she confirmed the existing balance and said the reopen path made sense for my situation. The EDD Unemployment Benefit Calculator on EDD's site can give you a rough estimate if you want to run the comparison yourself before deciding.
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
DE 1326C is the form EDD mails when they can't verify your identity automatically — if you applied by phone or mail originally, or if the ID.me connection breaks, that's what starts the paper verification path. If you haven't gotten one of those in the mail yet and ID.me is still failing, it may be on the way. Sometimes the paper path is actually faster than fighting the ID.me photo verification.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorHaven't gotten a DE 1326C yet but it's only been a few days. I'll watch the mail this week. If it comes is that the route I should take instead of trying ID.me again?
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
You can pursue both in parallel — keep trying ID.me but don't ignore the DE 1326C if it arrives, since responding to it quickly keeps the paper path moving. Whichever resolves first is what updates your account.
0 coins
Nina Chan
Got a DE 1326C once and responding to it quickly made a big difference. EDD processed the identity confirmation faster than I expected through that route.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
Something worth flagging: when you reopen a claim, EDD may still schedule a phone interview if there's a question about your separation from the most recent job — in this case the part-time position where hours went to zero. Even a layoff-style situation where hours were cut can sometimes trigger an interview if the last employer's response to EDD raises a question. Keep an eye on your UI Online homepage and your mail for a DE 4800 notice showing the interview date and time.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorGood to know. If a DE 4800 comes, is there anything I should prepare in advance, or is it straightforward for a situation where hours just got cut to zero?
0 coins
Diego Castillo
The DE 4800 itself lists the questions likely to come up in the interview. Read it carefully before the scheduled time. Have your dates and any documentation about the hours reduction ready. The interviewer phones at the time listed on the notice, so keep your phone nearby.
0 coins
Rami Samuels
Hour reductions to zero are generally treated as a layoff situation but EDD still wants to hear both sides. The interview is usually brief in those cases.
0 coins
Declan Ramirez
My claim history showed Pending for almost three weeks after I completed ID.me and I was convinced something else was wrong. Turned out the system just needed time to fully sync. Logged in one morning and all three pending weeks had flipped to paid overnight with no action on my part. So sometimes the wait is just the system catching up, not a new problem.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorThat's actually reassuring. I keep checking every few hours expecting something to change and nothing does. How often does UI Online update?
0 coins
Declan Ramirez
Payment info in UI Online updates daily. There's no point checking more than once a day — the status you see at noon will be the same as at 10 p.m.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
Tele-Cert at 1-866-333-4606 also gives you payment status updates 24 hours a day if you want to check outside UI Online.
0 coins
Zadie Patel
The address mismatch and ID.me disconnect you described earlier in the thread actually cover almost every case I've seen where someone's stuck in that verification loop. Fixing both — updating the address in myEDD and re-authorizing the ID.me sharing — before retrying the verification usually breaks the cycle. Did updating the sharing setting earlier actually let you get further in the process?
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorAfter re-authorizing the ID.me connection and updating my address in myEDD, I tried again this morning and it accepted my documents for the first time. Still waiting to see if it fully processes but it at least didn't reject the photos immediately.
0 coins
Zadie Patel
Getting past the photo rejection is the biggest hurdle. Once it accepts the documents it usually processes within a few hours and updates your EDD claim status by the next morning.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
Address corrected plus ID.me re-linked — that's the exact fix. Glad it's moving for you.
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
Benefit year end date had passed without me realizing and I filed what I thought was a reopen but it triggered a full new application with an ID.me verification requirement. Claimyr landed me on the line with an EDD agent who clarified that my original benefit year had closed three days prior and the new application was actually correct in that case — but the ID.me step was still required. She told me my new weekly amount would be based on a recalculated base period and gave me the weeks I needed to certify once verification cleared.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorGood to know there's a scenario where a new application is actually the right call — if the benefit year has ended. Confirms I need to reopen since I'm still inside mine.
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
Exactly. For anyone still inside their 52-week window, reopening is what you want. The new application path with recalculation only makes sense once the benefit year closes.
0 coins
Emma Morales
If the pending status does clear and your payment processes, your weekly benefit amount from the original claim carries forward when you reopen — you don't get recalculated mid-benefit-year. That amount was set by the DE 429Z when you first filed and it stays the same through the end of your 52 weeks regardless of what you earned at the part-time job in between.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorThat's good news. I was worried that the part-time earnings might somehow change my weekly benefit amount on the existing claim.
0 coins
Emma Morales
Part-time earnings during the claim affect how much you're paid in the weeks you work, through the earnings formula, but they don't change the underlying weekly benefit amount on the award. That number is fixed from the original DE 429Z.
0 coins
Sean Matthews
The earnings formula for weeks you work is the first $25 or 25 percent of gross wages, whichever is larger, doesn't count — the rest comes off your weekly benefit amount. So partial weeks can still pay something, they're just reduced.
0 coins
A Man D Mortal
Somewhere in this thread the topic of the waiting week came up and I want to make sure it's clear: the waiting week was served on your original claim's first eligible week. When you reopen, you don't serve it again. That's one of the advantages of reopening over filing a new claim — a new claim would have another unpaid waiting week before any benefits could pay.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorDidn't realize a new claim would mean another waiting week. That's another reason the reopen route is better for my situation.
0 coins
A Man D Mortal
Right — the waiting week on a new claim would be the first eligible week all over again, unpaid. On a reopened claim you go straight to certifying eligible weeks.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
Two weeks of no pay at the start of a new claim is brutal when you're already dealing with an income gap. Reopening whenever it's available is almost always worth it just to skip that.
0 coins
Nina Chan
Follow-up for anyone who lands here through search: the specific combination of an open claim plus an identity hold plus accidentally filing new is surprisingly common and all three parts have solutions. Reopen instead of file new, fix the ID.me connection and address before retrying verification, and message EDD through UI Online to flag any duplicate application so they can clear it on their end. None of this is hopeless even if the account looks stuck right now.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorComing back to say the ID.me verification did go through this morning, the sharing re-authorization and address update were the fix. Now I can see the reopen option on my UI Online homepage and the pending weeks are showing as processing. The message I sent EDD about the duplicate application also got a response saying they'd flag the new application for removal. Things seem to be moving.
0 coins
Nina Chan
Address fix plus ID.me re-link plus the EDD message about the duplicate — you hit all three and it cleared. That's exactly how this kind of situation resolves when you work through it systematically.
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
Glad the pending weeks are processing. Certify as soon as the certification option appears for those frozen weeks — the sooner you certify them the sooner they'll pay.
0 coins