Multiple EDD redetermination letters with different dates - which one do I appeal?

You should appeal EACH letter you disagree with, using separate DE 1000M appeal forms for each one. The redetermination doesn't automatically replace the earlier determinations - they could be for different weeks or issues. Each letter has its own appeal deadline (typically 30 days from the mail date), so don't miss those deadlines! Make copies of everything before sending and use certified mail so you have proof of when you submitted each appeal.

omg i had this same problem last month!!! sooo frustrating. i just appealed the last letter and explained in my appeal that i got multiple letters. worked for me but maybe im just lucky idk

This happened to me too! The EDD is such a mess - they can't even keep their own accusations straight. I filed separate appeals for each letter just to be safe. Spent like 3 hours filling out all those stupid forms. Good luck!!

I'd strongly recommend appealing each determination letter individually. While it seems redundant, each determination may cover different benefit weeks or different issues. In your appeal statements, you can reference that you received multiple determinations about similar issues, but be specific about addressing the particular allegation in each letter. Make sure to meet all deadlines - submit your appeals for the three earlier letters immediately. For the redetermination letter, you still have a bit more time but don't delay. If you're struggling to get clarification from EDD directly, I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to connect with an EDD representative quickly instead of calling for hours. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10?si=TSwYbu_GOwYzt9km. The agent I spoke with helped me understand why I received multiple letters and confirmed I needed separate appeals.

ALWAYS APPEAL EVERY LETTER! I didn't appeal one of my determination letters because I thought the redetermination replaced it, and they garnished my wages years later! The system doesn't automatically link these issues together. Each letter has its own case number and potentially covers different weeks or different aspects of the same issue. The EDD computer system tracks them separately even if they seem related to you. For the appeal forms, I recommend addressing the specific allegation in each letter rather than using identical text. It shows you're being thorough and responsive to each specific determination.

i had 2 letters once and just did 1 appeal for both...put both reference numbers on the form...worked out fine for me but maybe im just lucky lol

Wait I'm confused...if the redetermination letter is about the same issue but just worded differently, wouldn't that replace the earlier letters? That's what happened in my case last year - my redetermination superseded the original determination. But maybe mine was a different situation?

this is y the EDD is THE WORST! sending multiple letters with different accusations...cant even keep their own story straight. im still dealing with overpayment drama from 2023!!!

One more important tip: When you mail your appeals, send them by certified mail with return receipt requested. This gives you proof of when you submitted each appeal, which is crucial if there's ever a question about whether you met the deadlines. Keep copies of everything you send as well as your certified mail receipts. Also, after submitting your appeals, watch your mail carefully for hearing notices. Sometimes these can be scheduled with relatively short notice, and missing a hearing typically results in losing your appeal by default.

I went through this exact same nightmare situation! Got 5 different determination letters over 2 weeks with overlapping but slightly different accusations. Here's what I learned the hard way: 1. Appeal EVERY SINGLE LETTER separately - don't assume the redetermination replaces anything unless it explicitly states that in writing 2. Use certified mail for each appeal and keep tracking numbers 3. Write specific responses addressing the exact allegations in each letter (don't just copy/paste the same response) 4. Include all determination letter numbers and dates in your appeals even if they seem related The EDD's computer system is ancient and treats each determination as a separate case. I made the mistake of only appealing 3 out of 5 letters thinking some were duplicates, and those 2 became final determinations that I'm still fighting today. Also pro tip - if you can't get through to EDD by phone (and you probably can't), document EVERYTHING you tried to do to contact them. Print screenshots of busy signals, keep call logs, etc. This can help in your appeal if they claim you didn't try to resolve issues before the deadline. Don't let the multiple forms intimidate you - it's better to be over-thorough than to miss something and regret it later!