EDD taking tax refunds for overpayment - who actually got their refund?
So I'm stressing out BIG TIME about my tax refund this year. I owe EDD around $5,400 from an overpayment situation back in 2023 (long story - basically they decided I wasn't eligible for benefits AFTER paying me for 4 months). They've been sending collection notices but I've been on a payment plan paying like $75/month because that's all I can afford right now. My question is - has anyone who owes EDD money actually received their tax refund this year, or did the state/feds intercept it? I'm expecting about $2,800 back and REALLY need that money for car repairs. My fear is that they'll take the whole thing even though I'm making payments on time. The collection letters mention something about "Treasury Offset" but don't explain if that applies if you're on a payment plan. Has anyone gone through this? Did they take your entire refund or just part of it? Anyone actually get their refund despite owing EDD?
18 comments
Liam McGuire
they took my entire refund last year. didnt matter that i was on payment plan. the moment u owe EDD money they can grab ur refunds sorry
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
•Damn, that's what I was afraid of. Did they at least notify you before taking it or did you just find out when your refund didn't show up?
0 coins
Amara Eze
The situation depends on your specific overpayment classification. If EDD determined your overpayment was due to fraud, they will definitely intercept your tax refund through the Treasury Offset Program (TOP) regardless of your payment plan status. However, if your overpayment was classified as non-fraud, AND you've been maintaining your payment plan consistently for at least 6 months, there's a possibility they won't intercept. Best course of action is to contact EDD directly to verify your status. You should also check if you received a "Notice of Intent to Offset" letter, which they're required to send before taking your refund.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
•Thank you for this detailed info. My overpayment wasn't labeled as fraud - they just said I didn't qualify for the extension period after reviewing my case. I've been on the payment plan for about 8 months now. I never got any "Notice of Intent to Offset" letter, but maybe I missed it? I'll try calling EDD tomorrow.
0 coins
Giovanni Greco
THEY TOOK MY ENTIRE REFUND LAST YEAR!!! It was almost $3,000 and I was counting on it for my daughter's braces. The worst part? I was on a payment plan too and never missed a payment! The EDD system is BROKEN and they don't care about people actually trying to make good on their debts. They just take whatever they can get their hands on. I filed my taxes early last year and waited and waited for my refund... finally had to call the FTB and they told me it was intercepted. NO WARNING, NO NOTICE, NOTHING!!!
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
•Ugh I'm so sorry that happened to you. That's absolutely terrible especially since you were making payments. I'm filing my taxes this weekend so I guess I should just assume I won't see that money. So frustrating.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Farsi
I actually got my federal refund last year despite owing EDD about $3,200. However, they did take my state refund. From what I understand, your federal refund might be safe if your debt is only with the state of California, but the state will definitely take their portion. This year though, I received a letter specifically warning me that my federal refund would also be subject to offset. If you need to reach EDD to discuss your options, you might want to try Claimyr (claimyr.com). They helped me get through to an actual human at EDD when I kept hitting dead ends trying to call myself. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10?si=TSwYbu_GOwYzt9km. Once I got through, I was able to negotiate a temporary hold on collections while I sorted out my finances.
0 coins
Liam McGuire
•wait u actually got ur fed refund? thats weird cuz they took both of mine state and federal
0 coins
Dylan Wright
Have you checked your account on the FTB website? You can sometimes see if there's a hold or offset on your refund before it processes. Also, if you filed jointly with a spouse, you might be able to file an "Injured Spouse Allocation" form to protect their portion of the refund. My husband and I did this last year when they tried to take our joint refund for my EDD overpayment. We got about 60% of our refund that way.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
•That's a good idea about checking the FTB site. I'm not married so unfortunately the injured spouse form won't help in my case. I'll definitely check online though to see if there's any information there.
0 coins
Sofia Torres
my cousin had same problem last year and he just did his taxes different so he wouldnt get a refund. he adjusted his withholdings so he broke even instead. that way EDD couldnt take anything cuz there was nothing to take lol
0 coins
Amara Eze
•While this approach might work in the short term, it's not a long-term solution and could potentially create other issues. The debt to EDD will continue to accrue interest and penalties, and they have other collection methods beyond tax intercepts. Additionally, adjusting withholdings to deliberately avoid a refund could potentially raise flags with tax authorities if it appears you're trying to evade a legitimate collection action.
0 coins
GalacticGuardian
I know this isn't exactly what you asked, but have you considered requesting a waiver for your overpayment? If it wasn't your fault (like if EDD made the mistake or if paying it back would cause significant financial hardship), you can file for an overpayment waiver. I did this last year and got about half of my $6200 overpayment waived. It took about 3 months to process but was worth it. You can find the DE 1446W form on the EDD website.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
•I actually didn't know about this option! Thank you so much for mentioning it. I'm definitely going to look into this because it really wasn't my fault - I answered all their questions honestly when applying and they approved me, then changed their mind later. Did you need to provide a lot of documentation for the waiver?
0 coins
GalacticGuardian
•Yes, I had to provide bank statements, bills, pay stubs, and a detailed letter explaining my financial situation. Be really thorough with your hardship explanation. I also included a timeline showing that I applied in good faith. Good luck!
0 coins
Amara Eze
Just to clarify some misinformation I'm seeing in this thread: The Treasury Offset Program (TOP) works independently from your payment plan with EDD. Even if you're making regular payments, your tax refund can still be intercepted if your debt has been certified for offset. The good news is that any amount intercepted will reduce your overall debt balance. If your refund is intercepted, you should receive a notice from the Department of Treasury explaining the offset and providing contact information. Any disputes about the offset need to be directed to EDD, not the IRS or FTB. Also worth noting that federal refunds may be applied to state debts under certain circumstances through reciprocal agreements between California and the federal government.
0 coins
Giovanni Greco
•So basically they can just take whatever they want whenever they want even if you're trying to pay it back? That's highway robbery! The system is BROKEN!!
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
•Thank you for the clear explanation. I think at this point I'll prepare for the worst and assume my refund will be intercepted. I'm going to look into that waiver option mentioned above too. Really appreciate everyone's input on this.
0 coins