EDD appeal hearing - are both parties on phone call simultaneously like a court hearing?

Yes, both parties are typically on the phone at the same time during an EDD appeal hearing. It's very similar to a court proceeding, just over the phone. The Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) will lead the call, swear everyone in, and each side gets to present their case and evidence. You'll also be able to question your employer (and they can question you) after testimonies. Make sure you have all your documentation ready and organized before the call - separation papers, emails, texts, performance reviews, anything that supports your side of the story.

YEP my hearing was like 3 months ago and it was EXACTLY like court!!! I was so stressed I could barely speak when it was my turn. The judge was nice tho. My supervisor was there with their HR person and they kept interrupting me (which the judge shut down pretty quick lol). Make sure you write down EVERYTHING u want to say cuz I forgot half my points when I was on the spot. Good luck!!!!

had mine in january. make sure u mute when not talking, my dog barking almost got me in trouble lol

I went through this process last year. Yes, both parties are on the call simultaneously, and it operates very much like a court hearing. Here's my advice: 1. Prepare a timeline of events related to your separation 2. Have 3-5 clear, concise points about why you should qualify for benefits 3. Practice explaining your situation aloud beforehand 4. Stay calm and professional even if your employer says things you disagree with 5. Only speak when the judge asks you to 6. Avoid interrupting anyone The hearing typically lasts 30-45 minutes. The judge will mail their decision within 1-2 weeks after the hearing.

my auntie had a hearing but it wasnt by phone they made her go in person is that different? she lost btw the system is rigged

I've been through this nightmare twice. Yes, everyone is on the same call at once. My advice - GET A CALLBACK SERVICE! I wasted TWO DAYS trying to reach someone at EDD to ask questions before my hearing. Finally used Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got through to an EDD specialist in about 25 minutes who explained exactly what to expect and how to prepare. You can see how it works here: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10?si=TSwYbu_GOwYzt9km It was honestly the best decision because the EDD rep gave me specific advice for my situation that helped me win my appeal. Trying to navigate this alone is incredibly stressful.

just make sure u dont say anything about quiting even if u kinda did lol

i had my appeal hearing about 6 weeks ago, and yes it's exactly like court but over the phone. one thing nobody told me - the judge actually called me 15 mins EARLY! so be ready well before your scheduled time just in case. i was half-dressed when they called and it threw my whole presentation off lol. my former boss was there with their attorney which felt so unfair since i couldn't afford a lawyer. still waiting for the decision...

One important thing to know: you have the right to request any evidence your employer might present during the hearing. Contact the Office of Appeals ASAP and ask if your employer has submitted any documents. You should be able to review these before your hearing. Also, if you have evidence you want considered, you need to submit it to the Appeals office AND your former employer before the hearing date. The notice you received should include instructions for this process.