Back to California Unemployment

Javier Mendoza

Does turning down former employer's manager job offer count as refusing work for California EDD?

So I got laid off from my retail job about six weeks ago and filed for unemployment right away. Everything was going fine, got my DE 429Z, started certifying. Then out of nowhere my old company reached out and offered me a management position. More responsibility, different location, same general industry. I didn't want to go back — the reason I was let go in the first place was a full store closure, and honestly the whole experience left a bad taste. I said no thank you and moved on. Now I'm paranoid I just tanked my own claim. I know California EDD asks about work refusals when you certify, but I honestly wasn't sure if this counted. It was my former employer, it was a different role than what I had before, and I didn't feel like I was dodging work — I felt like I was being selective in a reasonable way. But "reasonable" and "what EDD considers a refusal" might be two totally different things. Has anyone dealt with turning down a job offer from a previous employer while collecting UI? Did EDD flag it? Did you get called in for an interview? I reported it honestly when I certified but I have no idea what happens next and I'm scared I'm going to get disqualified or hit with an overpayment notice down the line.

Former employer reaching back out with a management offer while you're on a claim — that exact situation just landed in my lap too. My old warehouse was bought by another company and they asked me to come back as a shift supervisor, which I turned down. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me through to a live EDD agent after the hold times were beating me down. I asked the agent specifically about whether declining a former employer's offer triggered a work refusal flag. The agent pulled up my claim and said there was no flag on it at the time, that the interview would look at whether the offered wage and conditions were "suitable" for my experience level, and that I should keep certifying while that determination was open. The video at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 shows how the whole thing of reaching a live person at EDD by phone actually goes. I kept certifying and the pending weeks resolved about ten days later with no disqualification.

0 coins

The part about "suitable" work is what I keep seeing come up. Did the agent say anything about what makes a job suitable or not? Like does the wage matter, or is it mostly about whether the job matches your background?

0 coins

Suitable work is one of those terms EDD uses without really explaining it on the forms. The wage, the commute, your skills, how long you've been out — those all factor in apparently, but EDD makes the actual call case by case.

0 coins

The pending weeks resolving without a disqualification is reassuring to read. I'm stuck watching two weeks sit in pending right now after I turned down a part-time offer from an old gig.

0 coins

30 days on my DE 429Z was what caught me off guard — I didn't realize the award letter had an appeal window. Anyway on the actual question: when you certified and said yes to turning down work, EDD basically opens a suitability review. It doesn't mean you're automatically cut off. They look at whether the job was genuinely suitable given your background, the wage, the location, all of it. A management job with more responsibility at a different location than your previous role isn't a slam dunk refusal finding — EDD has to weigh whether declining it was reasonable. Keep certifying every two weeks no matter what, because if a determination goes against you and you appeal, EDD can only pay back weeks you certified for.

0 coins

The appeal part is important — I didn't know you had to keep certifying during an appeal for the back weeks to count. That changes how I'm thinking about this.

0 coins

Keeping certifications going during any pending issue is probably the most important practical thing in this whole thread. So many people stop and then lose those weeks forever.

0 coins

Agreed on the certifying point. The worst outcome besides a denial is a denial where you also didn't certify and can't get paid even if you win the appeal.

0 coins

The certification question that asks about refused work trips people up constantly. What it's really asking is whether you turned down any job offer that week — it's not pre-judging you, it's just flagging it for review. You did the right thing reporting it. Someone I know didn't report a refusal and ended up with an overpayment notice months later when the employer self-reported to EDD. Much messier to deal with after the fact.

0 coins

That's honestly my biggest fear — not the initial determination but finding out months later I should have reported something differently. The honest reporting feels risky in the moment but it sounds like the alternative is way worse.

0 coins

The employer self-reporting thing is real. EDD contacts former employers as part of the process and they can volunteer information. Transparency upfront is always the cleaner path.

0 coins

An overpayment notice from a refusal you didn't disclose would be a nightmare compared to just going through the suitability review honestly. Report it and let EDD do its job.

0 coins

EDD's suitability standard isn't just one thing — from what I understand it looks at whether the work is in your usual occupation or a related one, whether the pay is comparable to what you were earning, and how far into your claim you are. Earlier in a claim EDD tends to give more weight to whether the job matches your previous work. Later on, the expectations shift and you might be expected to take something with lower pay or in a different field. A management role paying more but at an inconvenient location six weeks in is a genuinely gray area.

0 coins

The timing piece is new to me. So the longer I'm on UI the less picky I'm allowed to be, basically? That tracks but it's a little stressful to hear.

0 coins

The original question was specifically about a former employer reaching back out, which adds another layer. EDD might look at the fact that you already have a relationship with that employer differently than a cold offer from a new company.

0 coins

The location change matters too. A different store in a different city is not the same job you left. That seems relevant to whether declining it was reasonable.

0 coins

Turning down a manager job from your old employer is not automatically a disqualifying refusal — EDD has to decide if the offer was "suitable," and suitability involves more than just "there was a job and you said no." The fact that it was a different location, a different role with added responsibilities, and a company whose closure you just came through — all of that goes into the picture. Report it on your cert, keep certifying, and wait for any notice. If you get a DE 4800 scheduling a phone interview, the questions on it will tell you exactly what aspect of the refusal EDD is looking at.

0 coins

The DE 4800 is the interview notice right? Should I be gathering any documentation before that — like the offer itself or any communication from the employer?

0 coins

Emails or texts from the employer showing what the offer actually was (location, pay rate, hours, role title) would be useful. The more specific you can be in describing why you declined, the better the interview goes.

0 coins

Writing down your recollection of the conversation or offer details while it's fresh is smart even before any notice arrives. Memories get fuzzy and EDD interviewers ask very specific questions.

0 coins

The difference between a voluntary quit and a work refusal is something people mix up constantly in these threads. A refusal is turning down a new offer — it's not the same as quitting, and the analysis EDD runs is different. For a refusal, the core question is suitability. EDD isn't just rubber-stamping every offer as work you have to accept.

0 coins

I was confusing those two things honestly. I kept reading about quit cases thinking they applied to me but my situation is a refusal, not a quit. The standard being different is good to know.

0 coins

Layoff paperwork that then has a job offer attached to it on the same day is a whole other confusing situation. My previous company did a site shutdown, then emailed the same week about a role at a regional hub two hours away. When I turned that down I ended up getting a suitability interview scheduled. Used Claimyr to get through to EDD beforehand — the agent told me my DE 4800 had already been generated and mailed, and I should watch for it and have documentation of the commute distance ready. That was genuinely useful to know before walking into the interview.

0 coins

Two-hour commute is a real suitability argument. Distance from home to job is explicitly part of how EDD evaluates whether a refusal was reasonable.

0 coins

Can I ask a dumb question — when you certify and say yes to refusing work, does that automatically pause your payments or does it just get reviewed in the background? I turned down something last week and I'm watching my payment status like a hawk.

0 coins

Payments can go to Pending in UI Online while EDD reviews the refusal, or they might just process normally and EDD handles the review separately. It varies. Pending doesn't mean denied, it means EDD is looking at something before releasing the payment.

0 coins

Pending status is what I'm seeing for last week's cert. I was hoping that just meant normal processing but maybe it is the refusal review. I'll give it a few more days before panicking.

0 coins

Pending after a refusal flag is common. It usually means a determination is being worked up, not that you're already denied. Keep certifying the following period on schedule.

0 coins

My sister kept telling me any job refusal automatically disqualified you from unemployment and I spent two weeks convinced I'd ruined my claim. That is NOT how it works. EDD reviews whether the refusal was of suitable work. If the job wasn't suitable, there's no disqualification. The suitability standard exists specifically so claimants aren't forced to take any job no matter how poor a fit.

0 coins

That misconception is so common and so stressful. I had the same fear. It helps to hear it laid out that way — the review exists to protect claimants too, not just to catch people dodging work.

0 coins

The "any refusal = disqualified" myth probably keeps a lot of people from reporting honestly, which then creates actual overpayment problems later. Report everything and let the suitability determination run its course.

0 coins

Former employer offers are tricky because EDD might also factor in your history with that employer. If you were laid off in a closure, you're not "quitting" a stable job by saying no to a new offer from them — you're exercising judgment about a new opportunity. That's a different situation from someone who quit and then turned down an offer from the same employer who wanted them back in the exact same role.

0 coins

The circumstances of the original separation matter for context. A full store closure vs. a layoff for performance vs. a voluntary quit all frame the refusal differently when EDD looks at it.

0 coins

Mine was a full closure — the whole store shut down, it wasn't a performance thing at all. So the new offer was really from a company that reorganized, not from the job I had. That feels relevant.

0 coins

That detail could matter. Document that the offer was at a different location than the closed store if you end up in an interview. It goes to whether the job was truly comparable to your prior work.

0 coins

My pending weeks finally resolved and I want to come back and say what happened since I mentioned them above. EDD mailed me a Notice of Determination that said my refusal was of work that wasn't suitable given the wage and location difference. No disqualification, payments released for both pending weeks. The process took about three weeks from the cert where I reported the refusal.

0 coins

This is exactly what I needed to see. Three weeks of waiting sounds rough but getting both pending weeks released is a good outcome. Did you do anything specific to prepare or did EDD just decide on its own?

0 coins

No phone interview in my case — EDD just made a determination from the information it had. I think the wage difference was big enough that it wasn't a close call. But I had the offer details documented just in case.

0 coins

Not every refusal review results in an interview. EDD can make a determination from the cert and claim information alone if the facts are clear enough.

0 coins

Turned down an assistant manager offer from a former employer and EDD scheduled a phone interview via DE 4800. The notice showed up in my mailbox about a week after my cert processed. I was nervous about the call and wanted to understand what the interviewer was likely to ask about the wage and location differences before the scheduled time. Got through to a live EDD agent using Claimyr and walked through the specifics of the offer — the agent confirmed the wage offered was actually above what I'd been earning before, which I knew could hurt my argument, and said to focus on the location and commute during the interview. That was a heads-up I really needed going in.

0 coins

The wage being above your prior earnings complicates things — I hadn't thought about that angle. Mine was also a pay raise in the offer. That might be the detail that makes my situation harder.

0 coins

For my claim, the commute distance ended up being what carried the suitability argument. The wage alone going up didn't automatically make it suitable — EDD weighed it alongside the full picture.

0 coins

Wage above prior earnings doesn't automatically kill a suitability claim. EDD looks at the whole picture — commute, hours, role match, how the job changed from what you left.

0 coins

The CalJOBS registration piece is worth mentioning in this thread too. If your DE 8405 required you to register within 21 days of the notice date, make sure that's done. A refusal review while also having a CalJOBS registration gap can complicate things. Those are two separate issues EDD could raise at once.

0 coins

I did register in CalJOBS and posted my resume within the first week. That part I'm not worried about. Good reminder though for anyone reading who hasn't done it yet.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration and the work refusal review are totally separate determinations. Getting one wrong doesn't affect the other but having both issues open at the same time would be stressful to manage.

0 coins

30 calendar days from the mailing date on any Notice of Determination you receive — that's the appeal window, and it goes fast. If EDD decides against you on the refusal and you think it got the suitability call wrong, you use the DE 1000M appeal form or write a letter and send it to the address on the notice. Don't miss that window waiting to see if EDD changes its mind on its own.

0 coins

I haven't gotten a Notice of Determination yet — still in pending. But I'm writing that 30-day window on my calendar now so I don't miss it if the determination goes the wrong way.

0 coins

The appeal deadline sneaking up on people is a real thing. By the time the notice arrives, gets opened, and you figure out what it says, you've already burned a week.

0 coins

CUIAB hearings after an appeal are conducted by an administrative law judge and you can represent yourself. The notice of hearing comes at least 10 days before the hearing date. It's a real process but it's not court — people go through it on their own all the time.

0 coins

Something that tripped up a friend in a similar situation: they thought the management offer meant their former employer was trying to convert their claim into a voluntary quit situation. It doesn't work that way. The employer offering you a new job after a layoff doesn't erase the layoff. The original separation stays what it was, and the new offer is evaluated as a potential work refusal, completely separately.

0 coins

That reframing helps a lot. I was low-key worried they were doing this to claw back my claim somehow. The layoff is still the layoff — the offer is its own thing EDD looks at independently.

0 coins

Employers can't "undo" a layoff by making an offer after the fact. The claim is based on the separation that happened. The refusal question is added on top of that, it doesn't replace it.

0 coins

For what it's worth, the EDD Benefit Calculator on edd.ca.gov can help you see roughly how a week with partial earnings would look if you end up taking part-time work at some point. Not directly related to the refusal question but useful context if you're thinking through whether future offers make financial sense to accept or not.

0 coins

I actually used that calculator when I first filed to understand my weekly amount. It's more useful than I expected. Good reminder that it's there for modeling future scenarios too.

0 coins

The calculator gives an estimate — the actual weekly benefit amount is on the DE 429Z, which is the number that really matters for planning.

0 coins

EDD takes longer on these determinations when both the claimant and the former employer have submitted information. If your former employer responds to EDD's notice about the offer and their version of events differs from yours, that can extend the timeline. Keep certifying through all of it.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about the employer weighing in. They might have a whole different characterization of the offer — especially if they think it was generous. That's a little unsettling.

0 coins

Both sides can submit their version and EDD weighs it. That's also why having documentation of exactly what the offer said — wage, location, hours — matters more than just your recollection.

0 coins

If EDD schedules a phone interview after reviewing both sides, the DE 4800 will reflect the specific questions being asked. That notice tells you a lot about which direction the determination is leaning.

0 coins

Misconception I see in a lot of these threads: people think turning down a job offer automatically counts against their work search activities. The refusal review and the work search requirement are two different things. You still need to be actively looking for work every week regardless of whether you declined an offer that week. One offer declined doesn't substitute for work search contacts.

0 coins

That's actually a distinction I didn't realize. I figured turning one job down at least showed I was engaged with the job market. Turns out those are tracked completely separately.

0 coins

Keeping your own log of where you applied each week is a good habit regardless. EDD can ask about work search activities and having records ready makes that easier.

0 coins

Active job searching means you're genuinely available and looking — that's the standard you're certifying to every two weeks. A refusal review doesn't change that underlying requirement.

0 coins

Had a suitability interview last year for a different kind of refusal situation and want to share one practical thing: the interviewer asked specifically what I had communicated to the employer when I turned down the offer. What you say in the moment to the employer matters because it can either help or hurt the "good cause" argument. Saying you declined because of family reasons is different from saying it didn't pay enough vs. saying the commute was unreasonable. Keep the stated reasons consistent with what you tell EDD.

0 coins

I told them the location was too far and I didn't want to be in management at this stage of my job search. I'll make sure I say exactly that to EDD if the interview happens. Consistency is the key word here.

0 coins

Consistency between what you told the employer and what you tell EDD is genuinely important. If the employer tells EDD you said one thing and you tell EDD something different, that inconsistency creates a problem.

0 coins

Final thing worth flagging — UI Online's Claim History showing Pending doesn't mean you're in trouble, it means EDD is working on something. A lot of first-time claimants mistake Pending for Denied and either stop certifying or start calling in a panic. They are not the same thing. Keep going through your normal certification schedule and watch your mail for any DE notices.

0 coins

I definitely had that moment of thinking Pending was bad news. Reading this thread helped me understand it's just part of the process. I'll keep certifying and watching the mail.

0 coins

My Pending weeks sat there for almost three weeks before the determination was mailed. The waiting is the hardest part but stopping certifications would have been much worse.

0 coins

Watching the mail daily while Pending weeks are open is not an overreaction — the DE notices have deadlines and you don't want to miss the mailing date because the envelope sat unopened.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure