Back to California Unemployment

Connor Murphy

Disqualification some weeks already paid do i have to repay California EDD?

So I got a Notice of Determination last week saying I'm disqualified for a stretch of weeks going back about two months. The thing is, EDD already paid me for most of those weeks - the money already hit my Money Network card and I spent it on rent and groceries. The notice doesn't say anything about repayment but I'm reading people online saying disqualification automatically means overpayment. My situation: I was laid off in March and filed right away. Everything seemed fine, I certified every two weeks, payments came in. Then my former employer apparently contested something and now I get this determination letter saying I'm out for 6 weeks. Those 6 weeks were already paid out. Do I have to give that money back? And does it matter whether EDD considers this my fault or not? I haven't appealed yet - the DE 1000M appeal form is in the envelope but I honestly don't even know if I have a case. The disqualification reason on the letter is vague and I really need someone to explain what happens next with the money I already received.

My DE 1080CZ came in mid-October showing I was disqualified for four weeks that EDD had already deposited. When I saw the amount I owed listed, I went straight to the phone and spent days getting nowhere - hold music and then nothing. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through; their video on reaching a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The EDD agent pulled up my account and confirmed the overpayment was flagged as non-fraud since I had reported everything correctly when I certified. She said I'd get a separate Notice of Overpayment in the mail explaining the amount and options, and that I should look for the Application for Overpayment Waiver form DE 1446UI if I wanted to request a waiver. The agent also told me to appeal the original determination within 30 days of the mailing date if I disagreed with the disqualification itself.

0 coins

Thank you - did the agent say anything about whether the waiver actually gets approved or what the chances are? Also how long did you wait before the separate overpayment notice showed up?

0 coins

The DE 1446UI waiver is worth asking for regardless. EDD looks at whether it was your fault and whether paying it back would cause real hardship. No one can promise you get it but it's not automatic denial either.

0 coins

Appreciate this info about the DE 4800 - wait, that's the interview notice, sorry got mixed up. The DE 1446UI is the waiver form yes. Good to know you can appeal the determination and also try for the waiver at the same time.

0 coins

Disqualification and overpayment are two separate things that happen to arrive together and confuse everyone. The determination letter (DE 1080CZ) handles the eligibility decision. If EDD already paid you for weeks they're now saying you weren't eligible for, they will send a separate overpayment notice - that's the one that actually tells you how much and what your options are. The disqualification letter alone doesn't demand repayment; wait for the overpayment notice. What matters a lot here is whether EDD calls it fraud or non-fraud. Non-fraud means no extra penalty - you'd owe the base amount back. Fraud means a 30 percent penalty on top, and that's a much bigger deal. Since you said you reported everything when you certified, fraud seems unlikely, but EDD makes that call.

0 coins

That separation between the two notices is actually really helpful - I was treating the DE 1080CZ like it was demanding money immediately. So I should appeal the DE 1080CZ within 30 days AND wait for the overpayment notice separately?

0 coins

Exactly right. Appeal the determination if you think the disqualification is wrong - use the DE 1000M that came in the envelope. And if an overpayment notice arrives, you can appeal that too within 30 days of its mailing date, or request the waiver. Two different processes running at the same time is confusing but that's how it goes.

0 coins

i thought if u appeal u dont have to pay while its pending?? like it freezes the amount owed

0 coins

Keep certifying while the appeal is going - EDD can only pay back weeks that were certified. The overpayment collection piece is separate from the certification question.

0 coins

About 11 weeks into my claim I got hit with a disqualification for three weeks that had already been paid. Couldn't get through on the phone for two weeks straight. Claimyr got me to a live agent and I asked specifically whether I needed to do anything on my end before the overpayment notice arrived. The agent said to hold tight - there's nothing to submit until EDD mails the actual overpayment notice, and then I'd have 30 days from that mailing date to either appeal the overpayment amount or send in the DE 1446UI waiver request. The disqualification itself I had already appealed using the DE 1000M. She confirmed both the appeal and the waiver request could be in process at the same time.

0 coins

Mine's been about two weeks since the DE 1080CZ arrived and no overpayment notice yet. Does the timeline vary a lot or should I be checking my UI Online claim history for any updates?

0 coins

In my case it was about three weeks between the determination and the overpayment notice arriving. UI Online showed 'Pending' on those weeks the whole time. The overpayment notice came by mail - nothing changed in UI Online to signal it was coming.

0 coins

Same rough timeline for me - determination first then overpayment notice a few weeks later. Definitely keep certifying through all of it though.

0 coins

Something to understand about the waiver: EDD's standard is basically whether the overpayment happened through no fault of yours AND whether paying it back would create serious financial hardship. Both parts matter. If your employer contested something and that changed EDD's eligibility decision, the 'no fault' question depends on what you told EDD when you certified - if you certified honestly for those weeks, that works in your favor. The hardship part means documenting your actual bills and expenses. The DE 1446UI asks for income and expense information. Fill it out as completely as you can.

0 coins

The employer contesting piece is what I'm still fuzzy on - I reported everything accurately when I certified. Would EDD typically view that as a 'no fault' situation or does the employer's challenge change that calculation?

0 coins

Accurate reporting when you certified is the key fact in your favor. The employer's challenge affects the eligibility ruling, but whether the overpayment was your fault depends on what you did - not what the employer said after the fact. EDD makes that judgment but honest certification helps your position significantly.

0 coins

just fyi you can appeal the disqualification even while asking for a waiver, they're not mutually exclusive. a lot of people think requesting a waiver means admitting they owe the money but that's not really how edd treats it

0 coins

The fraud vs. non-fraud distinction matters more than people realize. When my disqualification came through last year for five weeks of payments already made, the first thing I looked at was how EDD classified it. Non-fraud overpayment means you pay back the base amount, no extra penalty. Fraud classification adds 30 percent on top AND can bring a false statement disqualification of two to 23 additional weeks. The classification is in the overpayment notice itself. If you disagree with either the disqualification OR how they classified the overpayment, both have 30-day appeal windows from their respective mailing dates.

0 coins

Really glad you clarified the fraud classification piece - my situation sounds like it should be non-fraud but I want to know what to look for in the overpayment notice when it arrives to confirm that.

0 coins

The overpayment notice will say explicitly whether EDD determined it was fraud or non-fraud. If the word 'fraud' appears and you believe it's wrong, that's worth appealing right away. The 30-day window on those is firm.

0 coins

i got hit with a fraud classification once and it was a nightmare, they said i didn't report some part-time hours correctly. if OP was careful about certifying they should be fine but definitely read the notice word for word

0 coins

EDD collects unpaid overpayments in a few ways people don't always know about - they can take it from future UI payments, future DI benefits, state tax refunds, state lottery winnings, and other state money owed to you. They can also record a lien or pursue a court judgment. What they don't do is come after your wages through your employer in the way people imagine. But all of this is way down the road - first comes the overpayment notice, then the response period, then whatever you work out or appeal. No one starts collecting the day the notice arrives.

0 coins

The state tax refund part caught me off guard - hadn't considered that angle. Does sending in the DE 1446UI waiver pause any collection activity while EDD reviews it?

0 coins

EDD's waiver process runs alongside collection notices rather than automatically halting them, from what I understand. The safest move is to call EDD directly about that specific timing question for your claim - don't rely on forum guesses when real money is involved.

0 coins

agreed call edd on that one. its worth asking because the waiver review can take a while and you want to know if anything is moving on the collection side during that time

0 coins

Filing the DE 1000M appeal is worth doing even if you feel uncertain about your case. Here's why: if you don't appeal the disqualification and EDD's ruling stands, the overpayment is locked in as valid. If you do appeal and an administrative law judge overturns the disqualification, the overpayment goes away because the underlying eligibility ruling changed. The appeal goes to EDD first for review and then to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board if needed. A judge hears testimony under oath and you can represent yourself. You have 30 days from the mailing date on the DE 1080CZ - count carefully from that date, not from when you received it.

0 coins

The mailing date distinction is something I almost missed - I was counting from when I actually got the letter. Checked the DE 1080CZ and there's about a week difference between the mailing date and when it hit my mailbox.

0 coins

That week matters a lot. The 30 days run from the printed mailing date on the notice, full stop. Missing that window means needing to explain why the appeal is late, and EDD may or may not accept the reason. File the DE 1000M as soon as you can.

0 coins

wait so if u mail the appeal form does it need to arrive within 30 days or just be postmarked? that always confuses me

0 coins

Mail it to the address printed on the notice. Getting it postmarked before the deadline is what matters - that's how written appeals to California EDD work. Keep a copy of everything you send.

0 coins

The CalJOBS registration piece tripped me up during my own disqualification situation - I hadn't registered within 21 days of the DE 8405 notice and EDD flagged that separately. Worth checking your own DE 8405 mailing date to make sure your CalJOBS registration is complete and your resume is posted, because a gap there could add another eligibility question on top of what you're already dealing with. Used Claimyr to reach EDD and confirmed with the agent that my CalJOBS registration had come through on their end. That at least took one issue off the table while I was handling the disqualification appeal.

0 coins

Hadn't thought to check the CalJOBS side while focusing on the disqualification. My registration should be fine but I'll verify on caljobs.ca.gov just to be sure. Last thing I need is a second issue running alongside the first.

0 coins

Good point to raise. The 21-day window from the DE 8405 is real and EDD does check it. If the registration is already done and the resume is posted, you're fine - but confirming it costs nothing.

0 coins

My former employer filed a response to EDD's DE 1101CZ within their 10-day window and that's what triggered my disqualification review. What I learned is that EDD interviews both sides by phone before making a final eligibility call when there's a dispute about why someone stopped working. If the OP's employer contested and EDD made a determination based on that, there should have been or will be a phone interview scheduled. Did you get a DE 4800 notice at any point with an interview time on it?

0 coins

Actually yes - there was a DE 4800 that came before the DE 1080CZ. I had the interview at the scheduled time. Afterward I thought everything was fine until this determination showed up. So the interview happened but the ruling went against me.

0 coins

That's important context for your appeal. The administrative law judge at the hearing will look at what was said in that interview and may have different conclusions than EDD's initial determination. Your own account of what you reported when you certified is the most important part to document.

0 coins

the phone interview being completed before a determination is standard procedure. the fact that one happened means EDD did consider both sides - but the appeals process exists exactly for situations where you think they got it wrong

0 coins

Six weeks of overpayment already on my own claim got cleared entirely when my appeal was upheld. While I was waiting on that process I still had a question about whether EDD had received my DE 1000M at all - nothing in UI Online confirmed receipt. Claimyr put me through to an agent who confirmed the appeal was logged and what address it was mailed to. That peace of mind mattered while I was sitting in uncertainty for weeks.

0 coins

Knowing the appeal was actually received sounds like a key thing to confirm. I'll keep this in mind once I mail the DE 1000M.

0 coins

UI Online really doesn't update on the appeal status in any useful way, which is maddening. Calling EDD directly to confirm receipt is the right move.

0 coins

An employer response doesn't decide your claim - EDD decides. A lot of people read a disqualification and assume the employer won some kind of argument, but EDD's process is to gather information from both sides through the interview and then make the determination. The employer can appeal EDD's decision too, within 30 days of the notice mailed to them. If your appeal is successful and the disqualification is overturned, the employer can't block that result - EDD and the CUIAB have the authority here, not the employer.

0 coins

Good to hear the employer doesn't have veto power over EDD's final decision. I was worried they could keep contesting indefinitely.

0 coins

The 30-day appeal window applies to employers too. If they miss it, they lose their right to challenge. And even if they appeal, it goes through the same CUIAB process - an administrative law judge hears both sides.

0 coins

employers appeal determinations more than people realize. especially when EDD rules in the worker's favor on a quit or firing case. just something to know going in

0 coins

Keeping track of everything in writing is what saved me during my own disqualification and overpayment situation. The DE 1080CZ mailing date, the 30-day window, the date I mailed the DE 1000M, copies of everything I sent - when my hearing came I had a clear paper trail. The administrative law judge specifically asked about the timeline of my certifications and whether I'd reported my part-time hours for each week. Having those details organized made a real difference in how the hearing went.

0 coins

Paper trail advice well taken. I've been keeping emails and screenshots but should probably organize the certification history too. Can I see my past certification records in UI Online?

0 coins

Claim History in UI Online shows your certified weeks and payment statuses. It's worth screenshotting those now while you're in the middle of this, before anything shifts. Some people print everything when a determination arrives, which is smart.

0 coins

print everything relevant from ui online sooner rather than later. ive heard of people needing documents at a hearing that they expected to find online but couldnt locate easily under pressure

0 coins

The appeals hearing itself is less intimidating than it sounds. Mine was by phone, the administrative law judge introduced herself, explained the oath, and asked me straightforward questions about why I stopped working and what I reported to EDD. I represented myself and the whole thing took about 40 minutes. The written decision came by mail - there's no announcement at the end of the hearing about which way it went. If you disagree with the judge's decision, there's a second-level appeal to the CUIAB.

0 coins

The 40-minute estimate and the phone format are both helpful to know going in. I was picturing something much more formal.

0 coins

i thought you had to appear in person at some office for an appeal hearing?? nobody told me it could be by phone

0 coins

Hearings are conducted by phone. You don't go anywhere - the Notice of Hearing comes by mail at least 10 days before and gives you all the details you need to prepare.

0 coins

you can also have someone represent you at the hearing - a union rep, an attorney, or just yourself. the judge is running the process, not EDD arguing against you

0 coins

Social Security benefits don't get reported when you certify and they don't affect your weekly benefit amount - just want to flag this because I confused it with pension income when I first filed. Pensions are different; EDD decides how those affect your payment. The certification question itself will tell you what to include. Sticking to the facts of what the certification actually asked is the most important part of your argument if you go to the appeal hearing.

0 coins

Had been wondering about that pension point - mine comes from a previous employer and I did report it. Good to know that was the right call since the certification asked about it.

0 coins

Reporting exactly what the certification form asks is the clearest protection you have. If you answered the questions honestly and accurately, that's your foundation for showing the overpayment wasn't your fault.

0 coins

my situation last year had the exact disqualification-after-payment pattern and EDD eventually sent me an overpayment notice for a little over $1,100. my weekly amount was $310. i filled out the DE 1446UI waiver and it got approved, took maybe 8 weeks to hear back. i had a paper trail showing everything i'd reported, low income during that period, and the reason i got disqualified wasn't something i'd hidden. honestly the waiver process was less awful than i expected if you document the hardship part carefully.

0 coins

The 8-week timeline and the $1,100 figure are helpful context - my situation looks to be around $1,860 based on six weeks at my weekly amount. What documentation did you include with the DE 1446UI?

0 coins

i attached copies of my bank statements showing what i'd spent the money on (rent, utilities, food), a list of my monthly expenses with amounts, and a written explanation of why the overpayment wasn't intentional. more documentation is better - EDD is looking at both the fault question and the hardship question

0 coins

The specificity matters on those waiver applications. Vague explanations of hardship are easier to deny than detailed ones with numbers and dates attached.

0 coins

Worth noting that EDD can recover an overpayment from future UI payments if you file another claim later. So even if collection doesn't start immediately, an unpaid overpayment follows you forward. The waiver is the cleanest resolution if you qualify - otherwise setting up a repayment arrangement directly with EDD is better than leaving it unresolved and having it offset future benefits when you might need them most.

0 coins

Hadn't thought through the future-claim angle. Trying to resolve this before it carries forward is now higher on my priority list.

0 coins

EDD also collects through state tax refunds and other state payments. It doesn't go away if you ignore it - best to engage with the process directly now.

0 coins

the repayment arrangement option is real and worth asking EDD about if the waiver doesn't come through. not ideal but better than the amount sitting unpaid accruing toward more collection options

0 coins

Filing the appeal doesn't mean you're admitting you owe the money, and requesting the waiver doesn't mean you're giving up on the appeal. These two processes can run in parallel. If the appeal overturns the disqualification, the overpayment goes away. If the appeal doesn't succeed, you still have the waiver request in play. Running both simultaneously protects your options better than waiting to see how one resolves before starting the other.

0 coins

This is the clearest framing I've gotten - parallel tracks, not sequential. I'd been thinking I had to choose one path.

0 coins

Parallel process is exactly right. The 30-day appeal window on the DE 1080CZ won't wait for you to figure out the waiver situation. File the DE 1000M first, then get the DE 1446UI submitted once the overpayment notice arrives.

0 coins

The live chat option from the Help button in UI Online is available weekdays 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. and can sometimes answer basic status questions about where your overpayment notice is in the process without needing a full phone call. Not useful for complex questions but I've used it to confirm EDD received documents I mailed. Phone line at 1-800-300-5616 runs Monday through Friday 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. if you need to actually talk through your specific situation.

0 coins

The live chat window is narrower than I realized. 9 to 2 Monday through Friday is a tough window when you're working.

0 coins

Yeah the phone line has a wider window - 8 to 5. Neither is easy to get through on but trying right when they open at 8 a.m. is usually the fastest.

0 coins

early morning calls on a Tuesday or Wednesday are usually better than Monday which is always jammed

0 coins

Even though the disqualification notice came through, keep certifying every two weeks for every week you're still in your benefit year and meeting the requirements - able to work, available, looking for work. If your appeal succeeds and those weeks are overturned, EDD can only pay benefits for weeks that were certified. Stopping certifications now because you're in a disqualified period would mean losing those weeks permanently if the appeal goes your way.

0 coins

Continuing to certify during the appeal is something I would have stopped doing if nobody mentioned it. Certifying now for weeks after the disqualification period too?

0 coins

Yes - certify every two weeks through the entire benefit year as long as you're eligible for the week. The disqualified weeks are a specific window; weeks outside that window are unaffected by the disqualification ruling.

0 coins

wait so even if edd says youre disqualified for some weeks you still certify through it and hope the appeal fixes it? thats counterintuitive but ok

0 coins

Exactly. EDD can only issue payment for weeks that were certified. An appeal can restore eligibility for disqualified weeks - but only weeks that have certifications on file. Missing certifications during the dispute period creates a gap that can't be filled back in.

0 coins

something that confused me when this happened to me - i thought 'disqualification' meant i was permanently out of unemployment and could never collect again. not true at all. disqualification is for specific weeks only. weeks outside the disqualified period are unaffected, and if the appeal succeeds the disqualified weeks get cleared too. just took me way too long to understand that distinction

0 coins

That's exactly the confusion I had. Reading 'disqualified' on official EDD mail makes it sound permanent and total.

0 coins

right?? the language is scary. the notice should spell out the specific week dates covered. if yours doesn't make that clear, that's part of what an EDD agent can explain when you call.

0 coins

The DE 1080CZ does list the specific weeks the disqualification covers. Worth reading it again closely with that in mind - look for the date range and the reason code.

0 coins

My weekly benefit amount was $340 during my disqualification situation - six weeks of that added up fast and the idea of repaying it on reduced income was genuinely scary. What helped me think about it clearly was separating the question of whether I owed the money (which the appeal would resolve) from the question of how I'd pay it if I did (which the waiver or a repayment arrangement would handle). Keeping those two tracks distinct made the whole thing feel less overwhelming.

0 coins

The two-track framing helps. I've been collapsing the appeal question and the repayment question into one giant anxiety spiral instead of thinking about them as separate problems with separate deadlines.

0 coins

Separate deadlines is the key phrase. The 30-day window on the DE 1080CZ is the most urgent one right now. The overpayment notice comes later and has its own 30-day window. Take them in order.

0 coins

OP please update us after you file the appeal. this thread has a lot of good info and knowing how yours turned out would help the next person who lands here with the same situation

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure