Determination interview rep said good but letter says 15 penalty weeks - what do I do?
Okay so I'm completely lost and kind of panicking right now. Had my phone interview with EDD about three weeks ago regarding why I left my last job. The interviewer asked me a bunch of questions and at the end of the call she said something like 'it sounds like things are in order' and I honestly walked away thinking I was fine. Then yesterday a Notice of Determination showed up in my mailbox saying I have a 15-week false statement penalty on my claim. FIFTEEN WEEKS. I haven't been paid anything yet and now I'm looking at this letter saying I'm disqualified for over three months because of a 'false statement' and I genuinely don't know what I told them that was false. I reported my wages when I certified, I answered the interview questions honestly. Has anyone ever gotten one of these after what seemed like a positive interview? The letter came with an Appeal Form (DE 1000M) and says I have 30 days from the mailing date to appeal. I don't even know where to start - do I appeal? Do I try to call EDD first to understand what the actual statement was that they flagged? I've never dealt with anything like this before.
81 comments

Rami Samuels
DE 1080CZ with a 15-week penalty attached to it is a fraud finding, not just a regular disqualification. EDD's false statement penalty runs between 2 and 23 weeks, so 15 is in the upper half - that's serious and you need to treat the 30-day appeal deadline as your hardest deadline right now. File the DE 1000M or write a letter and mail it to the address on the notice before that date. Even if you get more information by calling, do not wait to appeal while you try to sort out what happened.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorThe letter is dated 11 days ago so I still have time but not a ton. Is it okay to send the appeal before I even fully understand what they're saying I lied about?
0 coins
Rami Samuels
Absolutely appeal first. You can explain everything at the hearing. Missing the 30 days and trying to file late is much harder than appealing without all the answers yet - a late appeal needs a reason for missing the deadline and EDD doesn't always accept those.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
Appeal ASAP and keep certifying every two weeks too. You need those weeks certified or EDD can't pay them back even if you win.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
Something I want to flag here: what the interviewer says on the call does not decide anything. The actual decision comes from whoever reviews the case after the interview, and that person may be looking at something different than what the interviewer asked you about. I learned this the hard way when my own interview seemed totally fine and then the determination went the other way. The interviewer's tone is not a preview of the outcome.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorThat's what I'm struggling with - she seemed so relaxed about it and I genuinely thought we were on the same page. Now I feel like I misread the whole conversation.
0 coins
Nina Chan
Had the exact same experience. My interviewer was friendly and I left feeling fine. The determination letter that came two weeks later had nothing to do with what we talked about - EDD had flagged something from my employer's response that I hadn't even been asked about.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
yeah interviewers aren't supposed to tell you the outcome anyway, 'sounds fine' or 'looks good' doesn't mean much unfortunately
0 coins
Diego Castillo
Fourteen weeks into my own false statement penalty situation, something a lot of people don't tell you: you can get the specifics of what EDD flagged before your hearing date, but you need to actually talk to someone. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with a live EDD agent - there's a video showing how reaching a live person at EDD works at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent I spoke with told me exactly which week's certification EDD was treating as the false statement and which wages they said I hadn't reported. That detail let me pull my pay stubs for those exact weeks and build a real appeal instead of guessing. The hearing went a lot better because I knew what I was actually defending.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorWhich question did they say you got wrong on certification? Was it the work search part or the wages you reported?
0 coins
Diego Castillo
Wages for a week I did part-time consulting. EDD said I underreported by not including a check that was paid in a different week than it was earned. That's the part I didn't realize - you have to report wages in the week the work was done, not when the payment hits your account.
0 coins
Logan Stewart
Knowing exactly what week they flagged would change everything about how you prepare. Really practical to find that out before filing anything.
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
The 30-percent fraud penalty is on top of the false statement disqualification weeks - so a 15-week penalty means you're also looking at a 30-percent hit on any overpayment amount EDD says you owe. That's the part that really stings. If you appeal and win, both the disqualification weeks and the penalty go away. If you don't appeal and they stand, you're paying back benefits plus 30 percent on whatever they calculated as overpaid.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorWait, so there could be an overpayment amount on top of the 15 weeks? The letter mentions a dollar figure but I honestly couldn't process it when I first read it.
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
Read the notice carefully for a dollar amount - it usually shows what EDD calculated as the overpayment. The penalty is 30 percent of that number. All of it is appealable within the same 30-day window.
0 coins
Sean Matthews
yes and they can collect from future UI benefits, state tax refunds, lottery winnings, basically anything the state has a hand in - so appealing and winning actually matters a lot
0 coins
Ali Anderson
Filing the appeal is not admitting you did something wrong. I think people hesitate because it feels confrontational, but the Appeal Form (DE 1000M) just says you disagree with the determination and want a hearing. You write your side of things, you gather your documentation, and an administrative law judge hears both sides. You can represent yourself - you don't need an attorney, though you can bring one.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorDo I need to lay out my entire defense in the appeal form itself or can I just say I disagree and explain everything at the actual hearing?
0 coins
Ali Anderson
You don't have to write a whole argument on the form. Many people just write that they disagree and ask for a hearing. You present your documentation and explanation when you're in front of the judge.
0 coins
Zadie Patel
I'd at least write a sentence or two about why you think the determination is wrong, just so the record has something from you, but yeah the real presentation is at the hearing itself
0 coins
A Man D Mortal
My cousin thought the same thing after her interview went smoothly - actually wait, I had this happen to ME, not her, sorry. My determination interview in March went fine and then the DE 1080CZ arrived saying wages from a contract gig I did were misreported. I was so confused because I had entered something in the Report Wages section of UI Online. Turns out EDD was looking at a different week than the one I thought I was reporting for. The week wages are reported has to match the week the work was actually performed.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorThat's exactly the kind of thing I'm worried I may have messed up without realizing it. How did your appeal go?
0 coins
A Man D Mortal
Still pending - filed it about six weeks ago. Waiting for the Notice of Hearing to come in the mail. They said to keep certifying in the meantime.
0 coins
Declan Ramirez
the earning week vs pay date thing trips up so many people. it's really not obvious at all and yet EDD treats it like you deliberately hid something
0 coins
Emma Morales
False statement findings often come from the employer's side of things, not from what you said in the interview. When EDD mails the last employer a notice about your claim, the employer has 10 days to respond, and if they submit information that doesn't match what you certified, EDD can flag it as a discrepancy. I used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent about my own penalty weeks situation and found out the flag on my claim was entirely from my former employer's response - something their HR said about my final paycheck timing. Having that information let me get the right records together.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorI hadn't even thought about what my former employer might have said. They weren't exactly happy when I left so I could see them submitting something that makes me look bad.
0 coins
Emma Morales
Employer responses that contradict your certification are taken seriously by EDD, especially around wages, severance, and final pay timing. Getting the exact discrepancy from an agent before the hearing is really valuable.
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
this is a good point - i assumed my penalty was about something i did wrong in my certification and it turned out to be a date my employer gave for my last day that was one week off from what i had
0 coins
Lucas Parker
Keep certifying every two weeks through the appeal process. A lot of people stop because they assume there's no point while they're under a penalty, but if the appeal succeeds, EDD can only pay back the weeks that were actually certified. Weeks you skip are gone even if you win.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorEven with the 15-week disqualification sitting there, I should still certify?
0 coins
Lucas Parker
Yes - certify every two weeks, answer everything honestly about your work search and any wages, and keep records of it. The certification preserves your ability to collect if the penalty is lifted.
0 coins
Donna Cline
appeals can take a while and you dont want to look back and realize you lost weeks of backpay just because you stopped certifying while waiting
0 coins
Harper Collins
DE 4800 gives you the interview date and time and the questions EDD plans to ask - did you have a chance to review that before your interview? I'm asking because sometimes the questions in the determination notice reference things the DE 4800 listed as topics, and comparing the two can help you figure out where the disconnect is between what you said and what ended up in the finding.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorI did get the DE 4800 and I looked at it before the call. The topics it listed were about why I left and my wages. Neither of those felt complicated to me at the time.
0 coins
Harper Collins
Then pull out whatever records you have for your last 18 months of wages and your final pay from that employer. If the DE 1080CZ has a specific week or dollar amount attached to the finding, match it against your pay stubs. That's usually where the inconsistency lives.
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
Something worth knowing about the hearing itself: testimony is under oath, the administrative law judge runs it, and you can bring any documentation you want - pay stubs, bank statements, emails from your employer about your last day or final pay, anything that supports your version of events. Union reps can also represent you at the hearing if that applies to your situation.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorCan I bring someone with me who isn't a lawyer or union rep? Like a family member just for support?
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
Anyone can represent you at the hearing - it's not limited to attorneys or union officials. A family member can be there. They should know not to speak unless the judge allows it, but you're not going in alone if you don't want to.
0 coins
Zadie Patel
bring every piece of paper you have. judges see a lot of these cases and documentation makes a real difference versus just saying you didn't do anything wrong
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
Overpayment amounts connected to a false statement penalty can be collected in ways that feel pretty aggressive - tax refunds, state lottery winnings, future unemployment or disability or PFL benefits. Last year I had a penalty situation on my own claim and ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr about whether I could dispute the overpayment amount separately from the disqualification weeks. The agent walked me through the fact that the same DE 1000M appeal covers both and that I didn't need to file two separate appeals. That saved me from a lot of confusion about what I was actually fighting.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorSo the appeal covers the disqualification weeks AND the overpayment dollar amount in one filing?
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
That's what the agent told me - one appeal on the DE 1000M or a letter sent to the address on the notice, and it covers everything in that determination. You explain both parts of your disagreement when you write it or when you get to the hearing.
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
i didn't know that either. i thought i had to file two different things. good to know it's all one form
0 coins
Ruby Knight
For your work search, keep doing it and keep notes. Even under a penalty and an appeal, EDD expects you to be able to show you were actively looking for work during the weeks you certified. I know the question feels buried under everything else right now but it matters.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorI've been applying to jobs but I haven't been super organized about tracking them. Should I be keeping a log?
0 coins
Ruby Knight
EDD's pages don't name a required number of contacts or a specific log format, but having your own record of where you applied and when is a solid habit. If EDD ever asks, you have something to show.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
dates and job titles at minimum. even a note in your phone is better than trying to remember everything later
0 coins
Nina Chan
Adjudication and a false statement penalty are two different things, just for clarity. Adjudication is when EDD is deciding whether you're eligible - like after you quit or were fired. A false statement penalty is a fraud finding that comes after EDD believes you intentionally gave wrong information. The 15 weeks you're describing is the second one, not just an eligibility question still being resolved.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorI've been using those terms like they're the same thing, so that's actually helpful. This is a fraud finding not just an eligibility decision.
0 coins
Nina Chan
Right. And the difference matters for the appeal because what you're trying to show is that whatever discrepancy EDD flagged wasn't intentional, not just that you were eligible for benefits in the first place.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
This distinction is important and a lot of people miss it. The hearing lets you show there was no intent to deceive - that's the crux of fighting a false statement finding.
0 coins
Sean Matthews
CalJOBS registration - did you do that within 21 days of the date on your DE 8405? That's separate from everything else going on and if you haven't done it, it can freeze your payments independently of the appeal. Just making sure that piece isn't adding another layer to what you're dealing with.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorI did register in CalJOBS and posted my resume there. At least that part I handled early on.
0 coins
Sean Matthews
Good. That's one fewer thing to worry about. The resume needs to be posted too, not just the account created, so as long as both are done you should be clear on that front.
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
Appeals go to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board (CUIAB) after EDD does its own review. The Notice of Hearing comes by mail at least 10 days before the hearing date. The hearing is in front of an administrative law judge - not an EDD employee, an actual judge - and after the hearing they mail you a written decision. If you lose at that level there's a second-level appeal to the full CUIAB board.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorHow long does it typically take between filing the appeal and getting the Notice of Hearing?
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
Honestly that varies and nobody on a forum can give you a reliable number. Keep certifying, keep your contact info current in myEDD, and watch for mail from the CUIAB. Missing the Notice of Hearing is bad.
0 coins
Declan Ramirez
CUIAB is completely separate from EDD - a lot of people don't realize the hearing is handled by a different agency
0 coins
Logan Stewart
Mailing the appeal is the safer move over faxing or dropping it off. Send it with some kind of tracking or certificate of mailing so you have proof of the date it was sent. The 30-day deadline is from the mailing date on the determination, not from when you received it.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorThe postmark date counts, not the date it arrives at EDD?
0 coins
Logan Stewart
What you want is proof that you sent it within 30 days of the mailing date on the notice. Certified mail or certificate of mailing from the post office gives you that. Keep your receipt.
0 coins
Rami Samuels
certified mail is worth the few dollars just for that receipt. if EDD ever says they didn't get it you have a postmark and a tracking number to point to
0 coins
Declan Ramirez
My false statement disqualification was 8 weeks and I still found the appeals process completely overwhelming at first. 15 weeks is a lot to be staring at. The main thing that helped me was writing out exactly what I remembered saying during the interview and what I remembered certifying for each week in question, before I forgot any details. Memory fades fast and your own notes become evidence at the hearing.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorI've been meaning to write everything down but I keep putting it off because it feels overwhelming. I'll do that today.
0 coins
Declan Ramirez
Do it now. Seriously. What the interviewer asked, what you answered, what you remember about each certification where there might be a wage question. Write the date of the interview too. That document is for you, not for EDD, but it's how you prepare.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
your own contemporaneous notes carry real weight at a hearing. judges take them seriously even if you wrote them the same week the determination arrived
0 coins
Zadie Patel
EDD's live chat through the Help button in UI Online runs Monday to Friday, 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. if you want to try asking a question in writing before you decide whether to call. Sometimes they can tell you which week or which item triggered the finding. It's worth trying alongside the phone.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorI haven't tried the chat yet - I've been going in circles on UI Online looking at Claim History and not finding any detail beyond the pending weeks.
0 coins
Zadie Patel
The chat agent can sometimes pull more detail than what shows in Claim History. 9 a.m. is the best time to get in because the queue fills up fast.
0 coins
Donna Cline
chat has worked for me once out of maybe four attempts. the phone or the actual appeal is more reliable for something this serious
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
You mentioned the interviewer's attitude at the end of the call, but those phone interviewers genuinely aren't authorized to tell you the outcome. What she said isn't part of the determination. It's frustrating because it creates this false sense of security, but it's also not something you can cite in the appeal as evidence of anything.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorThat's hard to hear but I figured as much. I was just holding onto it because I had nothing else to go on.
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
Makes total sense. But your strongest material for the appeal is your documentation - pay stubs, the actual weeks and amounts, your employer's final pay records. That's what actually moves the needle.
0 coins
Donna Cline
DE 1000M doesn't require a lot of space to write your case. If you need more room than the form gives you, attach a separate page and reference it on the form itself. Judges see attached pages all the time and it won't count against you.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorGood to know. The box on the form looked way too small to explain everything that happened.
0 coins
Donna Cline
Attach as many pages as you need. Label them clearly with your name and Social Security number so they don't get separated from the form at the appeals office.
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
staple everything together and keep a full copy for yourself before mailing anything. you want an exact record of what you sent
0 coins
Haley Bennett
30 days goes faster than you think when you're trying to gather records and understand what happened. Even if you mail the appeal this week with minimal explanation, you can build your full case between now and the hearing date. The goal right now is to get the appeal on record before the deadline.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
AuthorI'm going to mail it tomorrow with the basic information and get the certified mail receipt. Then I'll spend the next few weeks pulling all my pay documentation together.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
That's exactly the right move. Appeal now, build the case after. Good luck at the hearing - document everything.
0 coins
Harper Collins
Pay stubs for every week in the base period are worth having regardless. If this comes down to a wages question, having the full picture ready is better than scrambling later.
0 coins