
California Unemployment
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
So I just started getting unemployment benefits about a month ago after being laid off from my retail management job. My former employer has been calling me back for occasional shifts here and there - nothing permanent, just like 6-8 hours a week sometimes. I want to keep working these shifts because every little bit helps but I'm terrified of messing up my claim. I've been trying to figure out what is earnings allowance for unemployment in California so I know exactly how much I can make before it affects my weekly benefit amount. Like is there a flat dollar amount I'm allowed to earn? Or does every single dollar I make reduce my benefits? I've read three different things on three different websites and I'm more confused than when I started. Can anyone break this down in plain English? My weekly benefit amount is $420 and I just want to know if I pick up a shift and make $150, how does that actually get calculated? Do I just not report it if it's a small amount? (I'm guessing no but someone at work told me that's fine which sounds wrong to me
So I got laid off from my warehouse job about two weeks ago and I honestly have no idea if I can claim unemployment or not. My coworker said I probably qualify but another friend told me I might not because I only worked there for 8 months. I'm really confused about the whole process. Like do I just go to the California EDD website and fill something out? Do I need to have worked a certain amount of time? I was making around $19/hour and worked full time the whole time I was there. I wasn't fired for anything I did wrong, the company just said they were cutting staff. Can someone explain how this actually works and whether or not I can even file a claim?
Has anyone dealt with the situation where you start a new part-time job while collecting unemployment? Like can you still claim if you find something part time but it doesn't cover all your expenses?
Late to this thread but wanted to add - if you ever get denied for any reason, you have the right to appeal. The denial notice will tell you the deadline (usually 30 days from the mailing date). Don't just accept a denial if you think you qualify - the appeals process exists for a reason and a lot of people win their appeals. You can request a hearing and present your case to an Administrative Law Judge. Worth knowing even if you hopefully never need it.
Appeals are very underutilized. So many people just accept denials and walk away. The process is free and the bar for getting a hearing is low.
So I just got laid off from my job at a ski resort in Tahoe where I've worked every winter for the past four years. My supervisor told me this is just 'seasonal' and I might not qualify for unemployment, but that doesn't sound right to me. I've been paying into the system this whole time so why wouldn't I be eligible? What is seasonal unemployment exactly, and does California EDD treat seasonal workers differently when it comes to filing a claim? I worked full-time from November through March every year and I'm completely without income now that the season ended. Really confused about my rights here and whether I'm wasting my time filing.
For those struggling to get California EDD on the phone about seasonal claims - I spent 3 days trying to call about my standby status last winter and never got through. A friend told me about Claimyr and I was skeptical but tried it anyway. Got connected to an actual California EDD agent within a reasonable time when I'd been failing for days on my own. Really made a difference when I needed to get my standby status corrected before my next certification deadline.
The website claimyr.com and their video (https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10) explain it better than I can but basically it handles navigating the California EDD phone system for you and connects you to a real agent. Simple to use and way less stressful than hitting redial for 3 days straight.
Last thing I want to add to this thread since it helped me a lot when I was a new seasonal UI claimant - keep a detailed record of every interaction with California EDD. Screenshot your UI Online status every week, save every notice they mail you, write down dates and times of any calls plus the name of any agent you speak with. When something goes wrong (and occasionally it does), having that documentation can make the difference between resolving it quickly and fighting for months.
I've been collecting California EDD unemployment benefits for about 11 weeks now and honestly I've been doing a lot of thinking about whether staying on UI is actually hurting me more than helping. Don't get me wrong - those weekly payments have kept my rent covered while I figure things out after getting laid off from my logistics coordinator job. But I'm starting to notice some real downsides that nobody talks about when you're just focused on surviving. First off the weekly claim process itself is basically a part-time job. Every Sunday I'm logging into UI Online, certifying my job search activities, making sure my work search log is filled out correctly for the required employer contacts. Miss one week and you risk losing your benefits entirely or triggering an adjudication review. The mental load of tracking all this is exhausting. Second, I've noticed I've become kind of paralyzed about taking certain job offers. Like there was a part-time retail position that came up and I spent two hours trying to calculate whether accepting it would mess up my benefit year, whether I'd need to report the partial wages correctly, whether I'd accidentally trigger an overpayment situation down the road. That kind of anxiety over every career decision feels really unhealthy. Third - and this is the one that's really bothering me - I've been out of my industry for almost three months now and I can feel the gap starting to matter in interviews. Recruiters ask what I've been doing and 'collecting unemployment and applying to jobs' doesn't exactly wow anyone. Has anyone else gone through this weird psychological trap where the safety net starts feeling like a cage? How did you break out of it while still protecting yourself financially?
I've been lurking this thread for like an hour instead of doing my weekly certification and now I need to go do that before I forget and accidentally disqualify myself but seriously this has been one of the more honest conversations about unemployment I've seen. most places it's either 'the system is evil' or 'just get a job lol' with nothing in between
late to this thread but want to add one thing about the 'unemployment is bad for you' question from a purely financial angle california EDD maximum weekly benefit amount caps out at a level that for most mid-career professionals represents a significant pay cut from what they were earning. so you're not actually incentivized to stay on unemployment from a pure income standpoint unless you were earning well below the median the trap isn't financial incentive to stay unemployed (for most people it genuinely isn't). the trap is uncertainty and loss aversion - you have a known quantity (the weekly payment) and you're being asked to trade it for an uncertain outcome (a new job that might not work out). humans are bad at that trade-off under stress
the known-quantity vs uncertain-outcome framing is exactly right and it explains why unemployment can feel harder to exit than it 'should' even when you genuinely want to be working. the solution is reducing uncertainty on the new job side as much as possible - more research, more conversations, more clarity before committing to an application
also worth noting - if you take a job and it doesn't work out within your benefit year, you may be able to reopen your existing claim depending on circumstances. so the downside of trying and failing is often smaller than it feels in the moment. another reason to talk to an actual EDD agent about your specific situation so you understand what your real options are
So I've been dealing with this nightmare situation for the past several months and I'm finally at my breaking point. California EDD hit me with an overpayment notice of around $8,200 from claims I filed about two years ago. They're saying I wasn't properly eligible during certain weeks but honestly I reported everything correctly on my weekly certifications - my part-time hours, every dollar I earned, all of it. I disputed it and lost the appeal, so now I'm stuck with this debt hanging over me. Here's where it gets complicated. I'm already in financial trouble and I've been talking to a bankruptcy attorney about filing Chapter 7. My attorney mentioned that some government debts can be tricky and I want to know if anyone here has actually gone through this - can unemployment overpayments be placed in Chapter 7 bankruptcy and discharged? Has anyone here successfully included a California EDD overpayment in their bankruptcy filing? I need real experiences, not just guesses. My attorney is looking into it but I want to hear from people who've been through this directly.
i know this is slightly off topic but can california edd still do wage garnishment while you're waiting for your bankruptcy to be processed? like from the time you file to when discharge happens?
and does that include if they already started garnishing before you filed? does it stop mid-garnishment?
Yes, an active garnishment must stop upon filing. If wages are garnished after your filing date that's a violation of the automatic stay and your attorney can take action. Even wages garnished shortly before filing can sometimes be recovered depending on the lookback period - another thing to discuss with your attorney.
One thing I want to add that I don't think has been mentioned - if you're considering bankruptcy and you have any other California EDD matters open (like a pending appeal or an active claim), timing matters. Filing bankruptcy can potentially affect how EDD handles open matters. I'd recommend making sure there are no pending EDD issues besides the overpayment before filing, or if there are, making sure your attorney is aware of all of them.
Logan Greenburg
Thread has been super helpful. One last thing I want to confirm - am I right that the earnings allowance resets every week? Like each new benefit week I get a fresh 25% allowance calculation, it doesn't carry over or accumulate?
0 coins
Logan Greenburg
Perfect, that's what I thought but wanted to confirm. So a week where I earn nothing and a week where I earn a lot are each just calculated on their own with no interaction between them.
0 coins
Charlotte White
Exactly right. Each week is its own isolated calculation. This actually works in claimants' favor because a high-earnings week doesn't somehow penalize future low-earnings weeks - every week starts fresh.
0 coins
Anthony Young
Just want to say thank you to everyone in this thread. I went from completely confused about what is earnings allowance for unemployment to actually understanding the formula, knowing I need to report gross wages, knowing I still need to do job search activities, and understanding that I will always come out ahead financially by picking up those part-time shifts. This forum is genuinely more useful than the official EDD website for understanding how this stuff actually works in practice.
0 coins
Royal_GM_Mark
Glad it helped. For anyone else who finds this later - report everything, report gross wages, report in the week you earned it, and keep doing your job search activities. Those are the four things that keep your claim clean.
0 coins
Amelia Cartwright
And if you ever have a situation that doesn't fit neatly into the standard formula, get an actual EDD agent on the phone. Whether through Claimyr or just hitting redial a hundred times, getting a human answer for complicated situations is worth the effort.
0 coins