
California Unemployment
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
So I'm trying to figure out whether to file for SDI (State Disability Insurance) or regular UI unemployment and I'm genuinely confused about which one actually pays more. Here's my situation - I was a warehouse supervisor at a logistics company for about 6 years, making decent money, around $72,000 a year. Last month I had a pretty serious back injury that my doctor says is going to keep me out of work for at least 10-12 weeks. My employer is dragging their feet on workers comp and my HR person told me I should look into California EDD options in the meantime. Now I'm staring at two different California EDD program pages and I can't figure out which one would actually put more money in my pocket. Does disability (SDI) pay more than unemployment in California? And can you even collect both at the same time? I've tried calling California EDD but honestly I give up after being on hold for 45 minutes twice this week already.
So I got laid off from my warehouse job about 6 weeks ago at age 64 and I've been collecting Social Security retirement benefits since I turned 62. I went ahead and filed for California EDD unemployment benefits because my supervisor confirmed I was laid off through no fault of my own, but now I'm second-guessing myself. A friend told me you can't get both at the same time and I might get in trouble for even applying. I reported my Social Security income when I filed my UI claim but I honestly have no idea if that disqualifies me or reduces my weekly benefit amount. Has anyone actually dealt with this situation? I don't want to end up with an overpayment notice down the road because I collected benefits I wasn't supposed to get.
One more thing nobody mentioned - when you're doing your weekly certifications and they ask if you were able and available to work that week, ALWAYS answer yes unless you genuinely weren't (like you were sick or injured). Some older workers hesitate on that question thinking they need to qualify it somehow because of their age or retirement status. You don't. Being on SS retirement does not mean you're not able and available to work. Answer that question based on your actual physical and practical availability, not your retirement status.
just want to say this thread genuinely helped me too. i'm in a similar boat and been losing sleep over whether my SS would disqualify me or reduce my benefits. reading all these responses from people who've been through it is exactly what i needed
seriously. the official EDD website is so hard to parse. sometimes just hearing from real people who dealt with it is worth more than reading the official FAQs
agreed. and when you do need to actually talk to EDD, claimyr.com was a lifesaver for me when the phone lines were impossible. just putting it out there again for anyone who hasn't tried it yet - check out the demo video at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10
So I've been trying to wrap my head around something that's been confusing me ever since I filed my California EDD claim last month. My cousin (who studied economics in college) keeps telling me that there are actually different 'types' of unemployment and that not all of them qualify for benefits the same way. He mentioned something about 4 types of unemployment but couldn't really explain how it connects to the actual California EDD UI system. I got laid off from my warehouse supervisor position about 6 weeks ago when the company downsized their distribution center. Filed my claim right away, went through the whole ID.me verification process, and I'm currently in adjudication. My cousin now has me second-guessing whether my type of unemployment even qualifies. So my actual questions are: what are the 4 types of unemployment people talk about, and does the type of unemployment you experience affect whether California EDD will approve your claim? My status has been sitting in adjudication for almost 3 weeks now and I'm starting to wonder if this is connected somehow. Any clarity would be really appreciated because I can't find a straight answer anywhere.
this whole thread should be pinned somewhere honestly. I've been unemployed three times and each time I feel like I'm learning the system from scratch. the stuff about employer responses triggering adjudication, the alternate base period, the standby status for seasonal workers - none of that is explained clearly anywhere on the actual California EDD website. quick practical tip I'll add: take screenshots of EVERYTHING in UI Online. Every certification confirmation, every status page, every uploaded document confirmation. EDD has had system glitches where things get lost and if you don't have proof you submitted something it can be hard to prove later.
the EDD website is genuinely one of the worst designed government sites I've encountered and that's saying something. screenshots are essential because you genuinely cannot trust that things registered
Not gonna pretend I understood all the economics stuff in this thread but I do want to say for anyone who googled 'what are the 4 types of unemployment' and ended up here like I did: the short version is frictional (between jobs), structural (industry changes), cyclical (economy tanks), seasonal (time of year). For actually getting California EDD benefits none of those categories affect your eligibility in a direct way - it all comes down to your specific work history, how you left your job, and staying in compliance with weekly certification and job search requirements. hope that helps the people who just want the quick answer and not the whole EDD deep dive lol
So I just filed my first unemployment claim with California EDD last week after getting laid off from my warehouse job of 4 years. I certify for my first week and the payment just shows as 'pending' with no dollar amount. My coworker told me I won't get paid for the first week because of some waiting period thing but I honestly have no idea if that's true or not. Is there actually a waiting period for California EDD unemployment? Like do they just not pay you for the first week you're out of work? I've never filed before and the EDD website isn't super clear about it. Already stressing about rent coming up next month so any info would help.
I hate that this whole waiting week thing exists but at least this thread exists so people can find actual answers. EDD's own FAQ on the waiting week is like 2 sentences and doesn't explain anything about what to do or what to expect
Final update from me - my week 2 payment came through today, day 4 after certifying! So for anyone with a clean layoff claim and no adjudication flags, it does move pretty fast once you get past that first waiting week. Thanks everyone in this thread for explaining everything, this community is genuinely helpful for navigating the whole California EDD process.
Happy to hear it resolved quickly. Best of luck - and remember if you ever do run into an actual issue with your claim, getting through to an EDD phone agent (whether through the regular line or something like Claimyr at claimyr.com) is still the fastest way to get real answers on complicated issues.
So I recently got laid off from my manufacturing job and my company actually offered something called 'supplemental unemployment benefits' through our union contract. I had no idea this was even a thing until HR mentioned it during my exit meeting. I've been filing my weekly claims with California EDD like normal but now I'm completely confused about how these supplemental payments from my employer interact with my regular UI benefits. Do I have to report the supplemental unemployment benefits on my weekly certification? Will it reduce what California EDD pays me? I don't want to accidentally commit fraud or mess up my claim but I honestly can't find a clear answer anywhere on the EDD website. Has anyone dealt with this situation before?
I just want to say I was in a similar position three months ago and the combination of understanding supplemental unemployment benefits correctly PLUS actually being able to get through to a California EDD agent made all the difference. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through the phone system - there's a walkthrough video at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see how it works before using it. The agent I reached was able to immediately pull up my claim, see the SUB payments I had reported, confirm they were being processed correctly, and note my file with the plan documentation I described. Three weeks later my benefits were paid correctly with no overpayment issues. For a situation with this many moving parts, speaking to an actual human who can see your file is irreplaceable.
claimyr really does solve the EDD phone access problem. the information in this thread is great but at some point you need someone who can actually look at YOUR specific claim not just explain general rules
bookmarking claimyr.com for when I inevitably need it
final thought from me on this thread - if your employer's SUB plan has been paying you benefits and then suddenly stops (because you found new work, or because the plan duration expired), make sure you notify California EDD promptly. Some people forget that stopping SUB payments can actually change their weekly benefit calculation back to the full WBA amount, which is good news - but only if EDD knows the payments stopped.
Exactly. EDD recalculates each week based on what you report. Week with SUB payments = reduced EDD benefit. Week without SUB payments = full EDD benefit. This is actually an argument for staying really on top of your weekly certifications and reporting accurately each week rather than just copying what you reported last week.
Yuki Sato
totally unrelated but this thread made me realize i've been on UI for 4 months and never even looked into whether i should have filed SDI instead because i have a chronic condition. is it too late to switch???
0 coins
Yuki Sato
ugh okay yeah ill try to get through to someone. thanks
0 coins
Anastasia Popova
Use Claimyr if you can't get through - this sounds like exactly the kind of nuanced question that needs an actual agent. claimyr.com - it got me through when I had a complicated situation too.
0 coins
NebulaNomad
Final summary for anyone who finds this thread later searching does disability pay more than unemployment in California: Yes, SDI (State Disability Insurance) almost universally pays more than UI unemployment benefits for anyone with consistent full-time employment. SDI replaces 60-70% of wages with a maximum benefit significantly higher than UI's cap. However the choice isn't really yours to make - if you have a medical condition preventing work you should file SDI, if you're laid off and able to work you file UI. They serve different situations and can't generally be collected at the same time. For complex situations involving workers comp, job loss during disability, or transitioning between programs, calling California EDD directly is the best approach.
0 coins
Omar Farouk
Great summary. This question comes up constantly and it's good to have a clear answer documented somewhere.
0 coins
Sean Flanagan
pinning this mentally for the next time someone in my family asks me this question lol
0 coins