Back to California Paid Family Leave

Yara Abboud

What happens if employer overpays during paid family leave — does EDD come after you?

So I started my PFL bonding claim about three weeks ago and my employer accidentally kept paying me my full salary on top of whatever EDD was sending. I didn't catch it until my bookkeeper friend noticed the deposits didn't add up. The thing is, the total coming in each week was more than my normal take-home. I know that's not supposed to happen, but I'm not sure exactly what the rules are or who's going to want money back. Does EDD flag this automatically? Does my employer just claw back their extra payments? Has anyone dealt with this situation?

December 3rd the DE 2514 showed up in my mailbox, right when I thought my care claim for my dad was settled. EDD had flagged an overpayment tied to the weeks my employer had also been paying out sick leave on top of my PFL. I tried the phone line five mornings in a row, got the recording every time. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person on EDD's Paid Family Leave line. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the DE 2514 had been issued because my combined wages plus PFL exceeded my normal weekly pay, and that I had 30 days from that notice date to appeal with the DE 1000A if I disagreed with their calculation.

0 coins

Sounds like a service that just wants your info and collects fees. How does something like that actually work if EDD's line is that impossible to get through?

0 coins

Felt that way to me too at first, honestly. Then I tried it because my receipt number wasn't showing any claim attached to it after two weeks. The agent found that the confirmation hadn't linked properly and walked me through what to do next. The person who answered was definitely an EDD employee, not someone from the service.

0 coins

Okay that changes things a little. Might look into it because I've been sitting with questions about my own notice for days now.

0 coins

The rule that tripped me up when I was on PFL caring for my mother last year was this: your combined PFL benefit plus whatever wages your employer pays you in the same week cannot exceed your normal weekly earnings, not counting overtime. My employer was topping off my PFL, which they're allowed to do, but the HR department miscalculated one week and went over. EDD eventually issued a determination notice for that week. The safe thing is to flag it to your employer's payroll right away and let them correct it before EDD notices on their own.

0 coins

Does that mean my employer has to repay EDD, or is EDD going to come after me for it?

0 coins

EDD's overpayment notice goes to the claimant, not the employer. You'd owe EDD the excess. Then it's between you and your employer to sort out how they recoup what they overpaid you on their end.

0 coins

Wait so I could owe EDD money even if it was my employer who made the mistake and I didn't even know the checks were too high? That feels really unfair, is there an appeal for that?

0 coins

You can appeal within 30 days of the notice date using the DE 1000A. The appeal form comes with the determination notice. Keep the envelope with the postmark.

0 coins

EDD does not flag this in real time, in my experience. They reconcile it later, sometimes weeks later, and then you get a notice out of nowhere. Happened to a coworker last spring on her bonding claim. Full surprise.

0 coins

How far back did they go on that? Like how many weeks?

0 coins

Three weeks got flagged on hers. All at once in one notice.

0 coins

Three weeks of overpayment showing up in one envelope is brutal.

0 coins

The part people miss: PFL regulations say wages plus PFL can't exceed your normal earnings for the week, excluding overtime. Overtime doesn't count toward your normal wage baseline. So if your employer was paying your regular salary in full while EDD was also paying out, every week where the two combined went over your usual non-overtime weekly pay is a potential overpayment week. The number to check is on your Notice of Computation, which shows the weekly benefit amount EDD is paying.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came pretty quickly after I filed, but I didn't realize I was supposed to be tracking the employer payments against it at the same time.

0 coins

Most people don't. The notice explains the weekly amount but doesn't spell out the interaction with employer top-offs. It becomes clearer when you read the wage-reporting requirement: any wages earned during a PFL week have to be reported to EDD, even if they haven't been paid yet.

0 coins

The wage reporting part is where things get messy fast. I learned that one the hard way on my bonding leave.

0 coins

edd doesnt know what your employer paid you unless you tell them or your employer reports it, so if you just leave it you might be fine for a while but then it comes back as an overpayment notice later and that is way worse to deal with

0 coins

Reporting wages is actually required, not optional. Any wages earned during PFL weeks get reported to EDD. Not reporting them is exactly what leads to the overpayment that's harder to deal with later.

0 coins

yeah ok fair i thought it was more of a you-figure-it-out situation but i get it

0 coins

Proof of relationship sat unmatched on my bonding claim for nine days after I uploaded the birth certificate. Status just said pending. Used Claimyr to reach someone at EDD and the agent found the document had been received but not yet matched to my claim ID. She confirmed the receipt date and said to give it a few more business days. That was it. Straightforward call, no runaround.

0 coins

Did you have to do anything else after the call, or did it just resolve on its own?

0 coins

Just waited. Payment came through five days after that call. Nothing I had to submit again.

0 coins

been trying that line for two weeks and can't get past the initial recording. glad to know it's at least possible to reach someone.

0 coins

This happened to us with my wife's bonding leave, employer just kept the salary going for two weeks, we thought it was fine, it was not fine, anyway ended up sorting it out but it took a few calls to EDD and her HR both.

0 coins

How did you sort out the EDD side of it, did they let you pay it back over time or was it immediate?

0 coins

They issued a notice and we had the option to appeal or just repay. We repaid. The appeal option was there but we didn't want to drag it out.

0 coins

Was there any penalty on top of what you owed, or just the base amount?

0 coins

Report the overpayment to your employer now, in writing. Get their confirmation. Then report the wages through SDI Online so EDD has the accurate numbers from you, not discovered later.

0 coins

Can I report wages through SDI Online directly, or does that only work through the paper form?

0 coins

You can report through SDI Online. Log in through myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and find your claim. If EDD has already sent a Continued Claim Certification form, return that with the corrected wage information.

0 coins

The continued claim form is the one to watch for, it trips people up if they're not expecting it lol.

0 coins

Talked to a guy on my crew last month who tried to just ignore it. Got a DE 2514 three months later for the full amount plus a note about appeal rights. Don't ignore it. Report it and let HR fix their end.

0 coins

DE 2514 is the denial notice right? Or is that the overpayment one?

0 coins

That's the determination. When EDD decides you owe them money, that's the form. It comes with the appeal form attached, the DE 1000A.

0 coins

Correct. The DE 2514 is EDD's official determination notice. If you disagree with it, you have 30 days from the date on that notice to file the DE 1000A appeal.

0 coins

Payment date questions dragged on my own care claim after a corrected wages report went in. Tried Claimyr to reach EDD and ask about the adjusted payment timing. The agent confirmed the corrected report had been received, gave me the specific date the adjusted payment was issued, and explained that the corrected amount reflected the overlap weeks. Having that exact date helped me track when it would actually land.

0 coins

My bonding claim has a week sitting unpaid and I want to know if it's because of a wage mismatch or just processing lag. Going to try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when I call?

0 coins

Have your receipt number, the week in question, and your employer's pay records for those weeks nearby. The agent can look up the claim status and payment details if you can tell them the specific week.

0 coins

Tried that line eleven straight mornings last month. Nine times it cut off before I even got to hold.

0 coins

Sorry if this is a dumb question but I'm on PFL right now caring for my husband and I had no idea wages even had to be reported. I'm not working at all during my leave so I don't have wages, does that mean I'm fine or do I still have to do something?

0 coins

If you're not working and not receiving any wages during your leave weeks, you don't have wages to report for those weeks. The reporting requirement applies when you do earn wages during a PFL week. Sounds like you're in the clear for the weeks you're describing.

0 coins

Okay that's a relief. I was nervous reading everyone else's situation. My employer did ask me to do one thing remotely last week though, should I count that as wages?

0 coins

Anything you earn, even from one remote task, counts. Report those earnings for that week through SDI Online or on your Continued Claim Certification if EDD has sent you one.

0 coins

Thank you, I'll do that for that week. Good to know before it becomes a problem.

0 coins

My salon gave me a week of paid vacation that overlapped with my PFL bonding leave and I genuinely didn't know that was an issue until my hairstylist friend who had been through it texted me. Vacation pay counts as wages, combined with PFL it went over my normal pay. EDD flagged it in a determination notice maybe six weeks later.

0 coins

Does vacation pay count the same as regular wages in EDD's calculation?

0 coins

My determination notice treated it the same as regular wages. Vacation, sick leave, all of it combined against the PFL amount.

0 coins

Same thing happened with my sick leave payout during bonding. Employer paid it out without asking and EDD caught it.

0 coins

The good news is EDD does give you a chance to explain and appeal before anything is enforced! The DE 1000A appeal process is real and people do use it successfully.

0 coins

Whether they win those appeals is a different question.

0 coins

True, no guarantees, but the option is there and the 30-day window is worth taking seriously if you think their calculation was off.

0 coins

EDD sends the DE 2514 to the claimant. You cannot wait for your employer to handle it. They may owe you a repayment from their end, but EDD's claim against you is separate. Treat the two as two separate problems and work on both at the same time.

0 coins

That's exactly the right way to frame it. We learned this by not doing it that way first.

0 coins

Makes sense. So I need to be in contact with both HR and EDD simultaneously, not wait for one to fix it before I deal with the other.

0 coins

Not sure if this is the same thing but I thought PFL had a waiting period before the first payment, like a week where you get nothing, and that the employer was supposed to cover that week. Is that what causes the overlap?

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period. No unpaid first week. That's Disability Insurance that has the seven-day waiting period, not PFL. So the employer covering a gap week isn't the source of an overlap in bonding or care claims.

0 coins

Oh wow I completely had that backwards. I was mixing up PFL and disability this whole time.

0 coins

Lots of people mix those two up, especially birth moms who go from a DI pregnancy claim right into PFL bonding. The rules are different for each one.

0 coins

Reported my wages late once and EDD sent the determination about two months after the leave ended. The overpayment notice covered every week where the total exceeded my normal pay. It was a lot to sort out at once.

0 coins

Two months later sounds rough. Did you appeal or just repay?

0 coins

Repaid. Didn't feel confident appealing since I genuinely hadn't reported on time.

0 coins

if your employer is the one who messed up can you make them pay edd directly instead of you having to pay

0 coins

EDD's overpayment claim is against the claimant. Doesn't matter who caused the error. You pay EDD, then separately pursue your employer to reimburse you for what they miscalculated.

0 coins

that seems backwards but okay good to know before i just assume my payroll department would handle it

0 coins

Flagging it proactively with EDD before they send you a notice is always going to be less stressful than waiting for the DE 2514 to arrive. Use the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online to let them know you're reviewing weeks where wages overlapped with your PFL payments.

0 coins

Can you use the Request Claim Update to submit corrected wage info, or is that only for status questions?

0 coins

You can write in what you need to report in the message. For anything where you want a confirmed record, the SDI Online message thread and a note to your employer both help.

0 coins

The Continued Claim Certification form, the DE 2580GF, is also the right place to report wages per period if EDD sends it. Don't skip returning that one.

0 coins

been dealing with this exact situation for my bonding leave. employer didnt tell me they were keeping my salary going. three weeks in before i noticed. filed a Request Claim Update in SDI Online last thursday, waiting to see what they say.

0 coins

That's almost exactly my situation. Let me know what comes back from the update request, I'm curious if EDD responds with a determination right away or asks for more info.

0 coins

will do. it feels better having done something rather than waiting and hoping it sorts itself out.

0 coins

Proactive is the right move. If they need more from you they'll say so in the response.

0 coins

Bottom line: tell your employer to stop overpaying, report the wages to EDD now, and keep copies of everything. That's it.

0 coins

The copies part saved me on a different claim. Keep everything with dates on it.

0 coins

Noted on all of this. I already emailed HR today asking them to fix it going forward. EDD is my next step.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure