Back to California Paid Family Leave

Morgan Washington

SDI overpayment after updating actual delivery date — what happens now?

So I'm kind of panicking and hoping someone here has been through this. I was on pregnancy disability through EDD and gave them an estimated due date when I filed. My daughter ended up arriving about two weeks earlier than expected, so I logged into SDI Online and updated my actual delivery date like you're supposed to. Now I got a notice saying I have an overpayment because the system recalculated something based on the new date. I don't fully understand how updating the real birth date created an overpayment — I thought I was doing the right thing by reporting it. Has anyone dealt with this? Do I need to pay it all back right away or is there a process? And does this mess up my PFL bonding claim that I was planning to file right after?

October 14th on my own notice was when EDD recalculated after I corrected a date too. What happened in your case is that the earlier delivery date shortened the period EDD had already paid you for, so the payments you received for days after the actual birth date became an overpayment. The pregnancy disability claim ends at delivery, and anything paid past that point has to come back. It doesn't automatically block your PFL bonding claim, but you'll want to file that within 41 days of when bonding actually started.

0 coins

Wait so the overpayment is for days AFTER my daughter was born? I thought the disability ran a certain number of weeks regardless of when she came.

0 coins

The pregnancy disability period ends at the actual birth date, not the estimated one. EDD paid through the estimated date, then you corrected it, so the gap between the real birth and the estimated due date became the overpayment.

0 coins

Okay that makes more sense now. I didn't realize reporting the right date would trigger this but I guess I see the logic.

0 coins

The overpayment notice should include an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A. You have 30 days from the date on that notice to appeal if you believe the amount is wrong. I'd read the notice carefully to confirm the dates they used for the calculation before doing anything else.

0 coins

I just looked and yes the DE 1000A is attached. The 30 days starts from the notice date, not the day I received it, right?

0 coins

The 30-day window runs from the date printed on the notice itself, so don't wait on it. If the math looks wrong to you, file the appeal.

0 coins

The appeal form being included with the overpayment notice is standard. EDD's guide says to appeal within 30 days if you disagree with any determination, overpayment included.

0 coins

Payments showing week of October 7th through October 21st were on my own notice when something similar happened to me. I had no idea which weeks EDD considered paid versus still pending, so I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get an actual person on the PFL line on the phone. The agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly which weeks had been issued and when the next payment was scheduled to go out, which cleared up so much confusion about where the overlap was coming from. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

I've used Claimyr too, and the weeks question was exactly what I needed answered on my own claim. The agent I reached confirmed how many of my eight PFL weeks were still available in my 12-month window, because I'd already used some for bonding and wasn't sure how many were left for a care claim later. After that I just made sure to file before the 12 months ran out.

0 coins

How many times did you have to try the EDD line before that? I've been dialing since Tuesday and get cut off every single time before I reach anyone.

0 coins

Every morning for about a week before I tried a different route. The line either rang forever or dropped at the same point in the menu, same thing every day.

0 coins

Good to know there's a way to actually reach someone. I may need to phone them about this overpayment amount.

0 coins

EDD's phone line for SDI and PFL is basically designed to wear you down. I've spent whole mornings hitting redial and never once got a person. The overpayment system in particular seems to generate notices without any explanation of how the number was reached, which is infuriating when you updated a date in good faith.

0 coins

Accurate. The notice rarely shows the day-by-day math.

0 coins

And then you're supposed to appeal in 30 days but can't reach anyone to understand what you're even appealing.

0 coins

That's exactly why getting the actual calculation breakdown matters before the appeal window closes. If the dates on the notice don't match what SDI Online shows for your payment history, that's your argument.

0 coins

Does the overpayment have to be paid back all at once? I'm terrified this is going to happen to me because my due date also shifted and I haven't updated anything yet. I didn't even know I was supposed to report the actual delivery date separately.

0 coins

You are supposed to report the actual date. The notice will say how EDD wants you to handle repayment but it doesn't have to be a single lump sum in every case. Read what the notice says about payment options.

0 coins

I haven't gotten a notice yet, I'm just scared I will. Should I update it now even if it means an overpayment?

0 coins

Reporting accurately is always the right move. Not reporting can make things worse, and EDD will figure it out eventually when the PFL bonding claim comes in with a different birth date than the disability file.

0 coins

I reported mine right away thinking I was doing everything correctly. The overpayment notice still surprised me but I think it would've been messier if I'd waited.

0 coins

Curious whether the overpayment affects the PFL bonding claim directly. Like does EDD put a hold on new payments until the overpayment is resolved, or do the two things run on separate tracks?

0 coins

They are on separate tracks administratively, but practically speaking an outstanding overpayment can complicate things. Best to contact EDD directly on that question rather than assume one way or the other.

0 coins

That makes sense. I guess I was hoping someone had direct experience with both running at the same time.

0 coins

My bonding claim kept moving after a disability overpayment notice. The two didn't block each other, at least in my situation. But the amounts were different so I can't say it's universal.

0 coins

If the dates on the overpayment notice are wrong, appeal it. Don't sit on it. 30 days goes fast.

0 coins

The dates they used do match what I reported, which is what's confusing me. The overpayment seems correct, I just didn't expect it.

0 coins

Then you owe it. See if the notice says anything about a payment plan.

0 coins

my cousin updated her date and got the same notice, she just paid it back in like two weeks and the bonding stuff went fine after. not saying thats everyones situation but it didnt blow up for her

0 coins

Good to hear it worked out.

0 coins

yeah she was stressed about it for nothing honestly

0 coins

Waiting on the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification on my own bonding claim had me going in circles, so I ended up on the phone with an EDD agent through Claimyr. The agent found the DE 2500E on my file and told me the date it had been issued and where the payment was going, which I hadn't been able to figure out from SDI Online alone. That settled whether my payment method was set up right.

0 coins

I've tried calling so many mornings I've lost count. How is it possible to actually reach a person? I called four days straight last week and never got past the automated part before it disconnected me.

0 coins

Honestly I had the same problem for about two weeks before I tried Claimyr. The agent who answered worked for EDD, confirmed it was my actual claim on her screen, and answered the DE 2500E question in a couple minutes. That was it, no tricks.

0 coins

I had used Claimyr too when my claim's start date was unclear after a date correction on my file. The agent confirmed the exact start date EDD had on record and told me where I stood on the 41-day filing window, which I needed to know before filing the bonding piece.

0 coins

Okay so the agent actually had the claim open and could see the dates. That would answer my question about whether my updated delivery date even got recorded correctly.

0 coins

Worth knowing your claim ID before you call, whatever route you take. Makes it faster.

0 coins

The 41 days for the bonding claim counts from when bonding started, not from when the disability claim ended or the overpayment notice arrived. EDD's guide is clear that a birth mother files the DE 2501FP and the 41-day clock starts at the beginning of her bonding leave.

0 coins

So my bonding clock is already running from my daughter's actual birth date, not from when the disability claim officially closed?

0 coins

Yes. The bonding period starts at birth. The disability claim closure and the overpayment are separate administrative matters. If bonding started when she was born, that's day one of the 41.

0 coins

Okay I need to file the DE 2501FP immediately then. I've been waiting to hear back on the overpayment first and that was the wrong call.

0 coins

File the bonding claim right away and let the overpayment process run separately. Don't let one delay the other.

0 coins

The DE 2501FP, the new mother form, doesn't need any extra documents like a birth certificate. It's just the form itself submitted within 41 days of when you started bonding. That part at least is straightforward.

0 coins

I didn't know there was a separate form for new mothers. I was going to file the regular bonding claim.

0 coins

There is a specific one for birth mothers coming off a pregnancy disability claim. EDD mails it to you but you can also file in SDI Online. Either way, 41 days.

0 coins

EDD mailing it doesn't mean it arrives in time. File in SDI Online and don't wait for the paper form.

0 coins

you'd think updating the real delivery date would be straightforward and no big deal but EDD makes it into this whole thing lol. had something similar happen with a date correction and it took way longer than it should have to get sorted

0 coins

EDD in general operates on the assumption that you have infinite time and patience to sort out administrative errors that the system created.

0 coins

right lol. and then the 30-day appeal window is their timeline not yours

0 coins

Filing the bonding claim now while the overpayment is still pending is exactly right. The two timelines don't wait for each other and EDD won't pause the 41-day window because there's an open overpayment.

0 coins

Filing it today. I had no idea the clock was already running and I've probably burned 10 days already.

0 coins

You still have time, just don't wait any longer. And make sure SDI Online shows the bonding claim submission and save that receipt number.

0 coins

Spent most of October trying the EDD PFL line every morning before my shift. Same recording, same dead end, so I tried Claimyr. The agent looked up my DE 2580GF situation, confirmed which intermittent days I'd reported and which ones were still showing as unprocessed on my file, and told me the ones I'd called in were on the claim, just not reflected yet in that week's payment.

0 coins

What's Claimyr? I've never heard of it.

0 coins

It waits on EDD's hold line for you, so your phone rings when an agent picks up. That's about it.

0 coins

I've been wanting to ask EDD whether my overpayment affects the weeks available on my bonding claim. That's the question I'd use it for.

0 coins

been trying that line since week two of my claim. different days, different times. never once got through before it dropped.

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a seven-day waiting period. That's disability insurance, not PFL. If someone tells you to expect seven unpaid days at the start of your bonding claim, that's wrong.

0 coins

I had been telling myself there were seven unpaid days at the start of bonding. I would've just sat on it thinking that was normal.

0 coins

Bonding pays from day one of eligible leave. No waiting period.

0 coins

I made the same assumption because the disability waiting period was so prominent in everything I read when I first filed. The two programs work differently.

0 coins

SDI Online will let you check your payment history and see which dates were paid. Comparing that against the overpayment notice dates is a useful step before deciding whether to appeal.

0 coins

I pulled it up and the dates on the notice match what SDI Online shows as paid. So the overpayment amount looks accurate even if I didn't expect it.

0 coins

Then the question is just the repayment terms. The notice should spell that out.

0 coins

Eight weeks total for PFL across the whole 12-month window, not eight weeks per type of leave. Somebody told me I had a separate eight weeks for bonding on top of any care claim weeks, and that is not how it works.

0 coins

I had the same misunderstanding. So if someone uses five weeks bonding, they only have three weeks left if they need a care claim during that same 12 months?

0 coins

Exactly. One combined eight-week pool. It resets after the 12 months.

0 coins

EDD's guide is explicit on this. The cap is eight weeks total within any 12-month period, bonding, care, and military assist combined.

0 coins

yeah i thought they were separate buckets too. good to know

0 coins

Overpayment notices don't always come with enough detail to understand the math. If you can't figure out how they got the amount, file a Request Claim Update in SDI Online asking for the breakdown before the appeal window closes.

0 coins

Is Request Claim Update the right path for this or is there a different category I should pick?

0 coins

Pick whatever category fits closest and explain the specific question in the text box. The point is to get it documented before 30 days pass.

0 coins

Once you file the DE 2501FP and get your receipt number, hang onto it. You'll need it if anything comes up about the bonding claim and you have to follow up.

0 coins

Noted. Filing today and writing down that number the second I see it.

0 coins

Good. And check SDI Online a few days later to confirm the claim shows as received.

0 coins

just went through something similar. reported my actual date, got the overpayment notice three weeks later. it resolved but it took longer than i expected

0 coins

How long did yours take to fully resolve if you don't mind me asking?

0 coins

couple months. not ideal but it didnt stop other payments from coming in while it was open

0 coins

Recapping for anyone finding this thread later: update the actual delivery date when it differs from the estimate, file the DE 2501FP within 41 days of when bonding starts, and handle the overpayment notice separately by either paying it or appealing within 30 days. The two processes are parallel, not sequential.

0 coins

Well put. The biggest mistake people make is waiting on one thing before starting the other, and the 41-day window does not pause.

0 coins

This is exactly the summary I needed. Filing the bonding claim right now and then dealing with the overpayment this week.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure