Paid family leave denied wrong start date appeal new claim — what are my options?
So EDD denied my PFL bonding claim and the reason they gave is that the start date I put was wrong. I filed for bonding after my daughter was born and I guess I entered the first day I stopped working instead of the actual first day I was home with her, and those were two different days because of a shift overlap thing with my employer. Got the denial notice with the appeal form attached. Here's where I'm stuck: do I appeal the denied claim with the corrected start date, or do I scrap it and file a brand new bonding claim? The 12-month window from her birth is still open, she's only four months old, so I haven't lost the benefit period. I just don't want to pick the wrong path and end up waiting even longer. Anyone dealt with this exact situation?
75 comments

Keisha Brown
Two payments posted, then everything stopped and I had no idea which weeks EDD had actually paid. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone on the phone and the agent pulled up my claim and went through exactly which week-ending dates had been issued and told me my next payment was tied to the Continued Claim Certification coming back. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
Every morning for nine days I tried that line before 8:05 and either got a busy signal or the system cut me off after the menu. I find it hard to believe anything gets through to a live person there. What actually happened when you tried?
0 coins
Keisha Brown
Dialed once, the service held the line, and my phone rang when an EDD agent picked up. That was it. The agent read me the two week-ending dates that had paid and said the next one was waiting on the DE 2580GF I hadn't returned yet.
0 coins
Amina Toure
I tried Claimyr on my care claim and ended up talking to someone at EDD who told me I had four of my eight weeks remaining in the 12-month period. I had used some weeks earlier in the year and completely lost track!
0 coins
Yara Khalil
ok this is actually useful because I need to know which weeks they're counting if the appeal goes through vs starting fresh
0 coins
Oliver Weber
Wait, I'm confused about something. If EDD denied it because of the start date, does appealing actually let them fix the date, or do you have to prove you were home on the date you originally wrote? I'm asking because I'm worried about my own claim and I don't totally understand how the appeal works.
0 coins
FireflyDreams
The denial notice should have come with an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A. You have 30 days from the date on that notice to file it, either online or by mail. In the appeal you can explain that the start date was entered incorrectly and provide the corrected information. That's the right path rather than abandoning the claim entirely.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
yeah I have the DE 1000A, it came attached to the denial. I was just scared appealing would take forever and a new claim might process faster but it sounds like the appeal is the move here
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
Makes sense to appeal rather than re-file. A new claim with a different start date might just trigger the same question from EDD anyway, so the appeal at least lets you explain the correction directly.
0 coins
Javier Morales
EDD denied a claim over a one-day start date difference and nobody told you to just call and ask before the denial went out? That's such a waste of everyone's time. APPEAL IT. Don't start over.
0 coins
Emma Anderson
Agreed. Starting over just resets the clock. Appeal with the corrected date and the reason it was wrong.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
that's what I'm leaning toward now. just needed to hear it from people who've been through it
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
The 30-day window on the appeal is the thing to watch here. The denial notice has a date printed on it and the clock runs from that date, not from when you received it. If you're close to that edge, file the appeal first and add documentation after if you can.
0 coins
Malik Thompson
I didn't know the 30 days ran from the notice date, not from when it arrived. I had assumed I'd have more time. That's a little scary for anyone who gets mail slowly.
0 coins
FireflyDreams
Yes, the Appeal Form itself, the DE 1000A, can be submitted online through SDI Online or mailed. Online is faster if you're cutting it close on those 30 days.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
I got the notice four days ago so I still have time but I'm going to file this week to be safe
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
My cousin went through something similar, wrong info on the original claim, and she ended up appealing and explaining everything in writing. It took a few weeks but it did get resolved. The written explanation you attach to the DE 1000A matters, so be specific about why the date was entered differently and what the correct date actually is.
0 coins
CosmicVoyager
Specific is exactly right. Vague appeals drag on. Dates, what day you were actually home with the baby, why the shift overlap caused the entry error.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
I'm going to write out the whole shift situation, I have text messages from my supervisor about the overlap that might help as documentation
0 coins
Ravi Kapoor
just appeal it man dont start over, new claim means new 41 day window and more waiting, not worth it
0 coins
Freya Nielsen
the 41-day thing isn't quite right here though. bonding claims just need to be filed within 12 months of the birth, which the person already said is still open. the 41-day deadline is more about filing within 41 days of when the leave starts to avoid losing benefits from before you filed.
0 coins
Ravi Kapoor
ok fair i mixed that up, still think appealing beats starting fresh tho
0 coins
Yara Khalil
yeah the 12-month window is what matters for me, she was born in july so I have until july
0 coins
Omar Mahmoud
For your documentation: pull together anything that shows your actual first day of bonding leave. Pay stubs showing the last day you were paid for work, a note or message from your employer about the overlap, your daughter's birth record if the dates help tell the story. EDD needs the corrected date supported by something, not just your word.
0 coins
Chloe Harris
Payroll records are the clearest. If HR can give you a letter confirming your last day worked and your first day of leave that removes any ambiguity.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
HR actually gave me a leave confirmation letter when I started, so I have that. I think that plus the supervisor texts should cover it
0 coins
CosmicVoyager
That HR letter is probably exactly what they need. Hang onto a copy for yourself too.
0 coins
FireflyDreams
After getting my care claim moving again, I had a question about the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification, the DE 2500E, because I never received one and wasn't sure if my direct deposit was set up. I tried phoning EDD myself for a few mornings and couldn't get past the automated menu. Eventually I tried Claimyr and got an EDD agent on the line who confirmed the DE 2500E had been issued to my address on file and that my direct deposit information had not come through, so I needed to update it in SDI Online.
0 coins
Javier Morales
What is Claimyr exactly, I keep seeing it mentioned here?
0 coins
FireflyDreams
You give it your number and it handles staying on hold with EDD, then your phone rings when an actual EDD agent is on the line. That's the whole thing.
0 coins
Javier Morales
Huh. I've got a question about my own claim status that I've been trying to get answered for two weeks. Might actually use that for the determination notice I got that I don't understand.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
Appeal. Wrong start date is correctable. EDD has seen this before.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
short and to the point, thank you
0 coins
Emma Anderson
Yep. This is not an unusual situation for them.
0 coins
Oliver Weber
Does PFL have a waiting week the way some other benefits do? I heard somewhere there's like a week you don't get paid at the start and I want to know if that affects the appeal or a new claim.
0 coins
NeonNinja
PFL doesn't have a waiting period. No unpaid first week. That's a disability insurance thing, different program. Your first eligible day of bonding pays.
0 coins
Oliver Weber
I had it completely backwards, I thought PFL worked the same way. Good to know before I file my own claim.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
A lot of people mix those two up. DI has the seven-day wait, PFL doesn't. EDD's own site says it flat out.
0 coins
Malik Thompson
I'm really nervous reading this because I'm about to file my own bonding claim and I'm scared I'll enter the wrong date too. Is there a way to double-check the start date before you submit in SDI Online? Or is it basically a one-shot thing?
0 coins
Omar Mahmoud
SDI Online does show you a review screen before final submission. Read every field carefully on that screen, especially the leave start date. Have your employer-provided leave documentation in front of you when you fill it out.
0 coins
Malik Thompson
ok I did not know there was a review screen, that helps a lot. I'll have my leave letter open when I do it
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
And write down your receipt number the second you submit. That number is how EDD links everything to your claim.
0 coins
Anastasia Popov
Went back to work two days a week while still on bonding leave and the second payment just never came. I tried that EDD phone line six mornings in a row, got a recording every single time. Ended up reaching an agent through Claimyr and they told me the DE 2580GF, the Continued Claim Certification, had been mailed to me and that EDD was waiting on it before releasing any more payments. Agent said I needed to report my work days and wages on that form and return it.
0 coins
Freya Nielsen
I ended up talking to EDD through Claimyr on my own claim and the agent confirmed my actual leave start date had been recorded right, which mattered because I had filed close to the 41-day cutoff and wanted to be sure EDD had the correct date. Payments were already in motion so it was really just peace of mind.
0 coins
Sean Murphy
How did the agent figure out the date so fast? Like did they just look it up in the system?
0 coins
Freya Nielsen
They just read back what was on the claim, the date EDD had on file matched what I'd submitted. Took maybe two minutes of the call.
0 coins
Zara Khan
been trying that phone line for three weeks on my own care claim. glad to hear someone actually got through
0 coins
Chloe Harris
Something worth knowing: when you write the appeal explanation, don't just say the date was wrong. Explain the specific reason, the shift overlap, and what the correct date was and why. Appeals with a clear factual correction tend to be more straightforward than ones that are vague about what changed and why.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
I've been drafting it this way. I'm going to lay out the last shift date, the overlap day, and the actual first full day I was home. Then attach the HR letter and the supervisor message.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
That's a solid approach. Keep it factual and short. The person reviewing it doesn't need the whole story, just the correction and why it happened.
0 coins
Sean Murphy
my bonding claim went pending for 11 days before anything moved, so just heads up the appeal might sit a while before EDD responds too. not trying to stress you out just so youre not refreshing SDI Online every hour lol
0 coins
Yara Khalil
honestly I probably will be refreshing it every hour but good to know
0 coins
CosmicVoyager
11 days pending was my experience too. The waiting is the hardest part.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
Just to make sure I understand the timeline here: you're within the 12-month bonding window, you have the HR letter, you have the DE 1000A, and you're going to file the appeal this week. That sounds like a reasonable path. The appeal explanation just needs to be clear that the entry error was on the start date and here's what it should have been.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
that's exactly the plan. I'll attach the HR letter and the supervisor texts and explain the shift overlap in writing
0 coins
Amina Toure
You've got this! Having documentation ready makes such a difference.
0 coins
NeonNinja
PFL bonding benefits have to be used within 12 months of the birth. Your appeal, if approved with the corrected start date, still needs to land within that 12-month window. Four months in, you have time, but keep the birthday in mind as you wait for the appeal decision.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
right, July is the deadline. that gives me several months even if the appeal takes a while
0 coins
FireflyDreams
If the appeal resolves in your favor, EDD would go back to the corrected start date for calculating eligible days, so make sure the date you put in the appeal explanation is the actual first day you were home with her.
0 coins
Emma Anderson
Don't forget to keep the denial notice itself. You'll want the case or claim number off that document when you submit the DE 1000A.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
still have it, didn't throw anything out
0 coins
Keisha Brown
Good. Keep everything EDD sends until the whole claim is resolved and paid out.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
Does the 30-day appeal window restart at all if you get additional mail from EDD, or is it locked to that first denial notice date no matter what?
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
It runs from the denial notice. Additional correspondence doesn't reset it. The 30-day deadline is on that specific determination.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
Got it. So the first envelope is the one that matters for the clock.
0 coins
Zara Khan
filed a bonding claim myself three weeks ago, still pending, now reading about denials and i'm spiraling a little
0 coins
CosmicVoyager
Three weeks is longer than average but not unheard of. If it's past 14 days you can send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online, under your claim ID.
0 coins
Zara Khan
didnt know about the request claim update option, doing that today
0 coins
Omar Mahmoud
One thing to track after you file the appeal: EDD will send you a response by mail. If the appeal is approved you should see the claim move to eligible in SDI Online and eventually receive the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification. If it's denied again, there's a further appeals process, but cross that bridge only if you have to.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
I'll keep watching SDI Online. And yeah hoping I don't need a second round.
0 coins
Oliver Weber
Is there a way to check appeal status in SDI Online or is it only by mail?
0 coins
Omar Mahmoud
EDD communicates appeal outcomes by mail. SDI Online shows the claim status but appeal decisions come as a written notice.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
You have your documentation, you have time, you have the form. File it this week and stop second-guessing the choice between appeal and new claim. Appeal is right.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
filing Thursday. thanks everyone, this thread helped me think through it clearly.
0 coins
Ravi Kapoor
good luck hope it goes through fast
0 coins