Back to California Paid Family Leave

Diez Ellis

Paid family leave denied for returning to work but still off — what do I do?

I'm pretty confused and honestly scared about what happened with my PFL claim. I took leave to bond with my daughter back in October and filed everything through SDI Online. The claim went through fine at first and I got a couple of payments. But then I went back part time for about two weeks because my manager was pressuring me and I thought I could handle it, except I couldn't, and I stopped again. Now EDD sent me a notice saying my claim was denied because I returned to work, but I'm still off and I still have weeks left in my bonding window. I don't know if I did something wrong by going back and then stopping, or if I was supposed to file something different. Did I mess up my whole claim? Is there any way to appeal this or start over? Not sure what my options are at this point.

To figure out your next step, the first question to put to EDD is exactly which days they're denying and why the notice says they stopped. A denial after you returned to work part time usually means EDD didn't get your wage reporting for those weeks, or the Continued Claim Certification form didn't come back. When you went back part time, did EDD send you a DE 2580GF to fill out?

0 coins

I did get a form in the mail around that time but I honestly didn't know what it was for. I think I might not have sent it back. Could that be the whole problem?

0 coins

That's very likely the issue. The DE 2580GF is EDD's way of tracking which days you worked and what you earned while still on claim. If it doesn't come back, benefits stop. You'll want to contact EDD and explain what happened, and ask whether you can still get those weeks sorted out.

0 coins

Okay that makes sense. I didn't realize not returning that form would cause the whole thing to fall apart like this.

0 coins

EDD does this. You go back for two weeks trying to do the right thing and they treat it like you closed your claim entirely. I went through almost the same thing with my care claim last year, partial weeks reported late because the form showed up in my mailbox half destroyed, and suddenly I had an overpayment notice staring at me. The appeal process exists but EDD makes it hard to get a live person to even explain what happened.

0 coins

Appeals are real though. 30 days from the date on the denial notice, that's your window. Use it.

0 coins

Yeah I know, I ended up filing mine by mail. Just saying they don't make it easy to even understand what you're appealing before you have to file.

0 coins

First payment after my bonding claim approval took longer than I expected, so I tried reaching EDD's line for about four days straight before I found Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got someone on the phone. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification, the DE 2500E, had been generated but the payment itself was queued for the following processing cycle, so it hadn't posted yet. That settled it for me. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

I want to try that for my own situation. My bonding claim has been pending for over two weeks and I need to know if EDD is still waiting on my proof of relationship or if something else is holding it up. What should I have ready before I call?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your SDI Online receipt number, and the date you filed. The agent can see exactly what documents EDD has received and what's still missing on the claim.

0 coins

Got it, I'll get those together. I uploaded the birth certificate but I never got confirmation it was matched to the claim, so that's the question I need answered.

0 coins

Wait so if you went back part time and then stopped again, do you need a whole new claim or can the original one just pick back up? Asking because I'm about to do the same thing, go back two days a week starting next month, and I want to make sure I don't accidentally kill my own claim anyway.

0 coins

If you're going back part time while the claim is still active, you report the days and wages to EDD and they send you that DE 2580GF to complete. The claim doesn't end, it adjusts for the days you worked.

0 coins

Okay so the form is what keeps it alive. Good to know before I mess it up like apparently a lot of people do.

0 coins

There's also a question on the original DE 2501F, it's A13, where you say whether you plan to work during your leave. If you answered no there and then went back part time, EDD may not have been set up to send the DE 2580GF automatically. Worth mentioning when you contact them.

0 coins

I'm in a similar panic right now reading this. My PFL bonding claim is for my son born in August and I haven't gone back to work at all, but EDD sent me a Notice of Computation and I don't know if that means I'm approved or if it's just showing what I might get. Does getting that notice mean the money is coming?

0 coins

The Notice of Computation shows the weekly amount EDD calculated you could receive, but it isn't an approval. The actual eligibility decision comes separately, and payments follow once that's determined.

0 coins

Oh I did not know that. I thought getting the notice meant everything was settled. So I should just keep waiting and see if a payment posts?

0 coins

That's what most of us did, yeah. The notice comes pretty early in the process and the payment confirmation, that's the DE 2500E, comes after. Keep an eye on SDI Online for updates.

0 coins

Returned to work, stopped again, form didn't go back. EDD sees a gap and closes the payment. It's not the end of the claim, it's a reporting problem. Appeal the denial and explain the timeline in your own words.

0 coins

So on the appeal form I should just lay out what happened, that I went back briefly and then stopped, and that the DE 2580GF came but I didn't know to return it?

0 coins

Yes. Facts and dates. Keep it short.

0 coins

My cousin went through something kind of like this but with a care claim, so I know how stressful that denial notice feels. For the original poster, have you looked at the actual denial letter closely? It should say the specific reason and have an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A, attached. That's your starting point.

0 coins

I looked again and there is a DE 1000A with it. The reason listed is something about not being entitled to benefits because wages were reported. I think they processed my part-time weeks as me ending the claim.

0 coins

Yeah that tracks. Appeal it and spell out the dates: when you went back part time, when you stopped, and that you thought the claim would continue. EDD needs the timeline to understand it wasn't a full return.

0 coins

And get that appeal in before 30 days from the notice date. The DE 1000A says you can file it online or by mail, so do whichever is faster for you.

0 coins

You didn't ruin anything permanently. The appeal window is 30 days from the denial date. File it, explain you went back part time for two weeks and then stopped, and that the reporting form didn't get returned because you didn't understand what it was for. EDD hears this kind of thing.

0 coins

That actually helps to hear. I was afraid that going back at all meant I forfeited the whole bonding period.

0 coins

Bonding can be taken in pieces. That's the whole point. The issue here is paperwork, not your eligibility.

0 coins

Intermittent weeks on my bonding claim got messy last month because I wasn't sure how to report the days I worked back to EDD. I ended up talking to an agent through Claimyr and they looked at my DE 2580GF and confirmed which weeks had been received and which reporting period was still open. Way less guessing after that.

0 coins

The intermittent reporting piece is exactly where I'm stuck too! I've used Claimyr for a different question before and once the agent pulled up my claim they confirmed my leave start date, which mattered because I was worried I was bumping up against the 41-day filing window. After that I went into SDI Online and checked the status myself and it finally made sense.

0 coins

how many days did it take before edd even processed your intermittent weeks after you sent the form back

0 coins

For me it took about a week before anything updated. The agent said the reporting period was open so I just kept an eye on SDI Online after that.

0 coins

ugh okay ill keep waiting then. been refreshing sdionline every day

0 coins

For the original poster, the appeal doesn't have to be complicated. Write a plain statement of what happened week by week: when you started leave, when you went back part time, when you stopped again, and that you didn't return the DE 2580GF because you didn't know you had to. Attach anything you have showing those dates, like pay stubs from the two weeks you worked.

0 coins

I do have pay stubs from those two weeks. Would I include both of them even if the amounts are small?

0 coins

Include them. They show EDD exactly which dates you worked and what you earned, which is what the appeal needs to be clear.

0 coins

I didn't know pay stubs would matter for an appeal. Filing all of this away in case I ever need it.

0 coins

the denial notice date is what starts the 30 days right, not when you received it

0 coins

The 30 days runs from the date printed on the notice itself, yes. Mail can take a few days, so don't wait if you're close to the edge.

0 coins

figured, just wanted to make sure. mine took five days to arrive so i was nervous about the math

0 coins

There's a part of this that might be worth asking EDD to clarify: did your original claim have question A13 marked as you not planning to work during leave? Because if EDD set your claim up as a straight eight-week block with no intermittent days expected, they might not have sent the DE 2580GF on the schedule you needed it. That doesn't fix the denial but it's useful context for the appeal.

0 coins

I honestly don't remember what I put for A13. I filed in SDI Online and went through it pretty fast. Is there a way to see my original answers?

0 coins

You can check your claim in SDI Online to see the status and what EDD has on file. For the actual form answers you may need to contact EDD directly. Either way, noting in your appeal that the return to work was unplanned and brief helps.

0 coins

Went back to work for three weeks during my own bonding claim two years ago. EDD did send me the DE 2580GF and I returned it, claim kept going fine for the remaining weeks. The key really is that form coming back with the work dates and earnings listed.

0 coins

So the form is what keeps you in the game when you're doing partial weeks. Good to know it actually works when you send it back.

0 coins

Yep, claim just kept rolling once they processed it. No drama, payments resumed for the non-work days.

0 coins

Can you file the appeal online or does it have to be mailed in?

0 coins

The DE 1000A can be filed online or by mail, it says so right on the form. Online is faster if you have everything ready.

0 coins

Okay, online it is. Thank you.

0 coins

My own PFL claim hit a wall when I got a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination that I didn't understand at all. The language in those notices can be confusing and I kept second-guessing whether I needed to appeal or just wait. I ended up talking to an agent through Claimyr and they walked me through exactly what the DE 2514 said and confirmed whether the determination had gone out as a denial or a pending decision.

0 coins

I've tried that EDD line too many times to count. I call in the morning, I call in the afternoon, I get the recording that says high call volume and then it ends the call. I'm not convinced any service actually gets through to a live person on that line.

0 coins

I get the skepticism because I felt the same way before I tried it. What happened on my end was that I actually spoke to someone who worked at EDD, looked at my claim on their screen, and told me which weeks the DE 2514 covered. I wasn't expecting it to work that well.

0 coins

I had a similar result when I used it for a different question. The agent told me the payment method on my claim had been set to debit card, which I hadn't set up yet, and that's why I hadn't seen a deposit. Switched it over in SDI Online right after.

0 coins

Alright, that's something specific enough that I'll give it a shot for my own notice situation.

0 coins

Worth noting that PFL doesn't have a waiting period the way some people assume disability does. If the original poster's denial is specifically about wages reported during the partial return, that's different from a waiting week issue. Just want to flag it because I've seen people mix those two things up.

0 coins

Wait, there's a waiting period for disability but not for PFL? I had no idea they were different like that.

0 coins

Exactly. Disability Insurance has an unpaid waiting period, PFL does not. They're separate programs even though they both run through EDD. Easy to mix up if you haven't dealt with both.

0 coins

Good catch. Lot of people assume they're the same rules.

0 coins

I keep seeing people say you can't take bonding leave in pieces and that is not right! You can absolutely break it up, you just have to use all eight weeks within twelve months of the birth or placement. The partial weeks just need to be reported properly, which is the whole thing the original poster ran into.

0 coins

Yeah, that's what I thought too, that I could go back and then pick up where I left off. I just didn't know about the form requirement.

0 coins

The eight weeks being breakable is definitely the rule, the reporting form is just the mechanism EDD uses to track the days. Once that's clear the whole thing makes more sense.

0 coins

did you get a de 2514 or a different notice? asking because i thought denial and determination were the same thing but maybe theyre not

0 coins

The DE 2514 is specifically the Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination, which is what EDD sends when they determine you're not eligible. The appeal form, the DE 1000A, comes with it. So yes, in this context a determination is the denial.

0 coins

ok so the de 2514 is the denial. got it

0 coins

Right. If you get one, the 30-day clock on your appeal starts at the date printed on it.

0 coins

Update from me: I filed the appeal online this morning using the DE 1000A. I explained the timeline, that I went back part time for about two weeks because of pressure from my manager, that I stopped again when I couldn't manage it, and that the DE 2580GF came in the mail during that stretch and I didn't know I had to return it. I attached both pay stubs from the weeks I worked. Now I wait I guess. Thank you all for helping me figure out this was actually an appealable situation and not just a lost cause.

0 coins

Pay stubs attached and the timeline written out clearly, that's exactly what an appeal needs. Fingers crossed for you.

0 coins

Good. You acted fast. That's the right move.

0 coins

The 30-day window is tight and a lot of people miss it not knowing the clock starts on the notice date. You filed, that's what matters.

0 coins

just want to add that my bonding claim went fine taking partial weeks and the de 2580gf is not hard to fill out once you know what it is. its just the days you worked and roughly what you made those days. wish i had known sooner though

0 coins

Same. EDD could do a lot better explaining upfront that you need to return that form if you work at all during leave.

0 coins

for real. i thought the claim just knew somehow

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure