PFL for fathers — do I file separately from my wife and what documents does EDD need?
My daughter was born three weeks ago and my wife has been on her pregnancy disability claim since before the birth. I want to take my own bonding leave starting next month, but I genuinely have no idea how PFL for fathers works when there's already an open claim in the household. Do I file my own completely separate claim? Do I need to wait until her pregnancy disability closes out? And what documents does EDD actually need from me since I obviously have no pregnancy claim leading into this? I've been going back and forth on SDI Online trying to figure out where to even start and I keep second-guessing myself. Any dads out there who've done this recently?
73 comments

Vanessa Figueroa
Filed mine last spring when our son was born, wife was still on her disability claim at the time. Your claim and hers are completely separate — EDD doesn't link them or make you wait for one to close. You file yours through SDI Online, same as any bonding claim, and because you're a dad with no pregnancy disability behind it you'll need to upload a proof of relationship document. For us that was the birth certificate once we had the certified copy. Got the receipt number right away on the confirmation screen, saved that thing immediately.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
AuthorSo I don't need to wait for her disability claim to end before I start mine? That's the part I kept tripping over. Good to know I can just go ahead and file.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Yep same thing happened when my twins were born. Filed while my wife was still on her disability and EDD treated it like it had nothing to do with her claim at all. The two claims just run independently.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
The 41-day window is the part that caught me off guard. You have to file no later than 41 days after your bonding leave actually starts — not 41 days from the birth. So if you're planning to start leave next month, the clock on that deadline begins the first day you're off work for bonding, not the day your daughter arrived. I nearly filed too late because I thought the birth date was the trigger.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
AuthorWait so the 41 days runs from when I stop working, not from her birthday? That changes my math completely. I was counting from the birth date.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
Exactly right. The leave start date is what starts that 41-day count. The birth just sets the outer 12-month window inside which the eight weeks have to be used.
0 coins
Laila Prince
Missed this myself and panicked when I reread the instructions. The form is pretty clear about it once you slow down and read the actual question but it's easy to assume birth date is the trigger.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
Intermittent schedule tripped me up with my PFL bonding claim last year — I was working two days a week from home while taking the other days as leave and had no idea I had to report those work days or that EDD would send a form for it. The DE 2580GF showed up and I didn't even recognize it at first. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone on the phone at EDD because I couldn't find answers anywhere about which days to put on the form. The agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly which weeks were still showing as pending and confirmed they had the form on their end. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. Ended up getting that sorted and payments resumed the following cycle.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
AuthorThe intermittent piece is actually relevant for me too — I'm thinking of going back to work part time for a few weeks before taking the last stretch of leave. Good to know about the DE 2580GF.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
Any wages you earn during the leave period, even if not paid yet, have to be reported to EDD. Missing that is what causes overpayments and those are a nightmare to fix after the fact.
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
Had the same DE 2580GF panic. Phoned the EDD Paid Family Leave line a couple weeks after it arrived because I wasn't sure if the days I listed matched what was pending. It's worth calling rather than guessing.
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
One thing dads often assume is that PFL eight weeks is per claim — like the mom gets eight weeks for bonding and the dad gets a separate eight weeks on top of that. Each parent does file their own claim, but the eight weeks comes from one pool per person per 12-month period. So if you used some weeks for another reason in the last year, that comes out of your eight. Fresh situation for most new dads though so usually the full eight is there.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
AuthorThat makes sense — my eight weeks is my own pool tied to my own SDI earnings history, not shared with hers.
0 coins
TommyKapitz
Worth adding: bonding weeks and care claim weeks all draw from the same eight-week pool for a given person in a 12-month stretch. So if you bond with the baby for eight weeks now and a parent gets seriously ill six months later, you'd have used up your PFL for that period already. Something to keep in mind if other family situations might come up.
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
Exactly. It's one limit across bonding, care, and military assist combined for the same 12 months. Not eight per category.
0 coins
Angel Campbell
PFL pays but it doesn't protect your job on its own. The benefit payments are from EDD but whether your job is held comes from CFRA or FMLA and that depends on your employer's size and your own situation. Definitely worth asking your HR department about CFRA coverage before you start leave — EDD handles the money side, your employer and those laws handle the job side.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
AuthorHR already confirmed I'm covered for job protection so that piece is sorted. Was mainly confused about the EDD filing side.
0 coins
Payton Black
A lot of dads don't realize EDD's claim and job protection are two completely separate things. Good call flagging it in this thread.
0 coins
Harold Oh
Proof of relationship for a dad bonding claim — the certified birth certificate is what most people use but there are other options if that isn't ready. A Declaration of Paternity (the CS-909) works, and for adoptive or foster placements there are placement-specific documents. Certified birth certificate is usually easiest for a biological parent though and hospitals often give you a head start on requesting it before you leave.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
AuthorGot the certified copy from the hospital's records office last week so I should be good to upload it once I file.
0 coins
Amun-Ra Azra
Upload it in SDI Online after you file — you'll see the option once the claim is in the system under that claim's ID. Don't wait for them to ask for it, just get it in there with your receipt number attached.
0 coins
Summer Green
Hospital gave us a commemorative certificate first which EDD won't accept — make sure the one you have is the official certified copy issued by the county, not the decorative one with the footprints.
0 coins
Gael Robinson
The Notice of Computation is not an approval, just want to flag that because I completely misread mine. It shows your potential weekly benefit amount based on your wages in the base period. EDD still decides eligibility after that. The actual approval shows up differently — first payment notification is the DE 2500E if everything goes through. I called EDD celebrating after I got my Notice of Computation thinking I was approved and the agent had to explain the difference to me.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
AuthorGenuinely would have made the same mistake. So the Notice of Computation is more like 'here's what you'd get if approved' and the actual yes-or-no comes later?
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
Right. Notice of Computation tells you the weekly amount from your wages. The claim being approved is a separate step that happens after.
0 coins
Edward McBride
EDD says deciding a claim can take up to 14 days. Mine came through around day 11 and I was checking SDI Online every single morning after day 7.
0 coins
Darcy Moore
PFL has no waiting period — no unpaid waiting week before benefits start. I had a coworker insist I had a seven-day unpaid period like disability and I almost didn't file on time because I thought I was wasting my own leave days at the start. That's the DI rule, not PFL. Bonding and care claims under PFL, your first eligible day is paid.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
AuthorMy wife mentioned the waiting week thing and now I'm second-guessing whether she actually had one or was confused about which program it was.
0 coins
Darcy Moore
The seven-day unpaid period applies to Disability Insurance, which is what your wife's pregnancy claim ran through. PFL is different — no waiting period. So she likely did have unpaid days at the start of her DI claim, but yours as a PFL bonding claim won't have that.
0 coins
Dana Doyle
Yep this exact confusion came up when my husband filed his bonding claim after I finished my disability period. He was budgeting for seven unpaid days and was pleasantly surprised when that wasn't the case for his PFL.
0 coins
Liam Duke
Are the payments every week or every two weeks? I'm about to file and trying to figure out how to budget around the gaps.
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
If you're taking the leave all at once, EDD pays every two weeks for the duration. If you go intermittent — some days on, some days off — it works out per eligible day, each day paying one seventh of the weekly benefit. You still get paid through SDI Online either way, just the timing depends on how you're taking the leave.
0 coins
Liam Duke
Every two weeks makes sense, I can work with that. Was worried it was monthly or something.
0 coins
Manny Lark
Denial notice came out of nowhere on my bonding claim — I had the DE 2514 in my inbox on myEDD and completely froze. Ended up phoning EDD using Claimyr because I needed to understand what had triggered it before the 30-day appeal window closed. The agent looked at the claim and confirmed EDD had not received the proof of relationship document, which I had thought I'd uploaded. Went back to SDI Online, saw it hadn't attached correctly, resubmitted it, and filed the appeal with the DE 1000A the same afternoon. Appeal resolved in my favor.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
AuthorThe 30-day window to appeal is tight — good instinct to move fast on that. Glad it worked out.
0 coins
TommyKapitz
DE 1000A is the appeal form for PFL denials and overpayment notices. It's worth keeping in mind any time EDD sends a determination you disagree with — you have 30 days from the date on the notice to get it in.
0 coins
Rita Jacobs
Proof of relationship not attaching correctly is more common than it should be. Worth always going back into SDI Online after uploading to confirm the document actually shows as received, not just uploaded.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
Wages question — if you're going to have any income at all during your leave, like paid out sick days your employer is making you use, or any hours you pick up, that has to be reported to EDD. PFL can stack with sick or vacation pay your employer provides but the combined total can't go over your normal wages. How your employer handles that combination is up to their policy, so worth asking HR what they do.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
AuthorMy company doesn't require me to use sick time during PFL so I shouldn't have wages to report, but good to know the rule either way.
0 coins
Angel Campbell
Even if you think you have nothing to report, any wages even not yet received have to go to EDD when you earn them, not when the check clears. Better to report and have nothing adjustment happen than to find out later you had an overpayment.
0 coins
Khalid Howes
EDD's benefit calculator on their site gives you a reasonable estimate of your weekly amount before the Notice of Computation arrives. It's not a guarantee since the real calculation is on the notice, but it helps with budgeting. Your base period covers wages from roughly 5 to 18 months before your claim start date, highest quarter is what matters most.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
AuthorWent and ran the calculator just now. The estimate is lower than I was hoping for but at least I know what to plan around while I wait for the actual notice.
0 coins
Amun-Ra Azra
Base period for PFL trips people up because it's not your most recent wages — it's a window that ends a few months before you file. So if you got a raise recently it might not be fully in the base period yet.
0 coins
Ben Cooper
How does payment actually land — debit card or direct deposit? The SDI Online claim gives you a choice right?
0 coins
Harold Oh
For claims filed in SDI Online you can choose direct deposit or a debit card. Paper claims only get the debit card option. EDD's card is through Money Network, not a bank card. Direct deposit is usually faster to access once a payment is issued.
0 coins
Ben Cooper
Went with direct deposit when I filed last week. Hoping it speeds things up a bit.
0 coins
Dana Doyle
Proof of relationship document got held up on our bonding claim — my partner filed for PFL and we had a foster placement, so the birth certificate wasn't the right document. The foster care agency letter was what EDD needed but the agency was slow getting it to us. After a week of the claim sitting with no movement, my partner phoned EDD using Claimyr to find out what exactly was missing. The agent confirmed the proof of relationship had not yet been received and told us which document EDD was expecting for a foster placement. Got the letter from the agency the next day and mailed it in directly.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
AuthorThe foster placement situation adds a layer I hadn't thought about. Good to know the agency letter is the right document for that case.
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
For anyone in a foster or adoptive situation — the Adoptive Placement Agreement (AD-907) works for adoptions. The agency letter is for foster care placements. Neither is the same as a birth certificate so it's worth confirming with EDD exactly what they need for your type of placement.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
EDD's SDI Online confirmation page actually lists what document is expected for the type of bonding claim you filed. Worth rereading that confirmation once you have your receipt number.
0 coins
Edward McBride
Fourteen days felt like forever when I was waiting on my PFL claim decision. Around day 10 I sent a Request Claim Update through SDI Online — you open your claim, pick the claim ID, and there's an option to send a message directly about that claim. EDD responded within a couple days just saying it was still under review, but at least it felt like doing something.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
AuthorGood to know that option exists. I'll probably do the same if I hit day 10 with no movement.
0 coins
Payton Black
Request Claim Update in SDI Online is way less frustrating than trying to call during peak hours. Not instant but it creates a record too.
0 coins
Naila Gordon
Can both parents take PFL bonding at the same time or does one have to finish before the other starts?
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
Each parent's claim is independent so there's no rule that one has to end before the other begins. Both parents can take their bonding leave overlapping if they want. The limits are each person's own eight weeks within 12 months — your eight weeks and your partner's eight weeks are each separate.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
No coordination requirement between households either. EDD handles each claim on its own merits.
0 coins
Summer Green
Payment date showed up wrong in SDI Online on my bonding claim — I thought a payment had been issued for two weeks ago but the amount hadn't hit my direct deposit. Phoned EDD using Claimyr and the agent looked at the claim and told me the payment had been issued on a specific date and the amount in question. Turned out direct deposit for that payment had a one-business-day lag that week. Arrived the next morning.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
AuthorDirect deposit lag is annoying but good to know it can just be a timing thing and not a problem with the claim itself.
0 coins
Khalid Howes
SDI Online payment history shows the issued date, not the date it hits your account. Those two dates are not always the same day, especially around state holidays.
0 coins
Cynthia Love
California doesn't tax PFL payments. EDD sends a 1099-G in January showing what was paid in the prior year. Whether any of it is taxable at the federal level is a question for a tax professional or EDD's own tax information — nobody here should be giving that advice and I've seen some really confident wrong answers on other threads.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
Good flag. California state taxes not applying to PFL is confirmed. Federal side, ask a tax professional or check EDD's tax information page, don't take forum guesses on that one.
0 coins
Gael Robinson
Got burned by overconfident advice on a tax forum the year before last. Pointing to the 1099-G and EDD's own guidance is the right move.
0 coins
Darren Brooks
My situation is a little different — adoption finalized last month, the baby has been with us since placement but the finalization just happened. Does my 12-month bonding window run from placement or from finalization?
0 coins
Harold Oh
For adopted children, the 12-month window runs from the date of placement, not finalization. The Adoptive Placement Agreement (AD-907) is the document EDD needs for that claim. Worth confirming with EDD directly given your specific timeline since placement to finalization can vary a lot and you want to be sure the proof of relationship document matches what they're expecting.
0 coins
Darren Brooks
Placement was about two months ago so I still have time to file. Going to get the AD-907 together and file this week. Thank you.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
File as soon as you can — you don't want that 41-day window to become a problem if you count from placement. The earlier you file once your leave starts, the better.
0 coins
Rita Jacobs
If you're a dad whose employer offers any kind of supplemental pay on top of PFL, make sure you understand how it interacts. Some employers top up your pay to your full salary but the EDD rules say combined wages plus PFL can't exceed your normal wages. Your HR should be able to explain their specific policy since EDD handles its side and the employer handles its own calculation.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
AuthorHR told me my company doesn't offer a top-up so this doesn't apply to me, but useful for anyone whose employer does have a supplemental pay policy.
0 coins
Angel Campbell
The employer's policy on combining its own paid leave with PFL varies a lot from company to company. EDD sets the ceiling — you can't come out ahead financially — but the employer decides whether to offer anything extra up to that ceiling.
0 coins
Laila Prince
Came through the other side of my bonding claim last month, so: the whole thing was less complicated than I feared once I actually sat down with SDI Online. Filed on a Tuesday afternoon, receipt number in hand that night, certified birth certificate uploaded two days later when I had the certified copy, Notice of Computation arrived about a week in, first payment came through the week after that. It moves if you don't stall on the documents.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
AuthorThis timeline is really helpful. I'm going to file this weekend since the certified copy is already in hand. No reason to keep waiting.
0 coins
Edward McBride
Having the proof of relationship ready before you file is the move. Claims that sit waiting for a document stall the whole process.
0 coins
Cynthia Love
Start to first payment in under three weeks is a reasonable expectation if everything is in order. The horror stories usually involve a missing document or a proof of relationship that took forever to arrive.
0 coins