Back to California Paid Family Leave

Samantha Howard

PFL appeal denied because employer paying full salary — what now?

So I filed a PFL bonding claim after my daughter was born in September and honestly thought everything was straightforward. My employer is super generous and kept paying me my full salary during the leave, which I was grateful for. But then EDD denied my claim and said I wasn't eligible because I had no wage loss. I figured I could just appeal it since I did take the leave, but I just got the appeal decision back and they upheld the denial. The denial letter mentioned something about how PFL requires you to be losing wages and since my company was covering 100% of my pay, there's nothing for EDD to pay on top of that. I'm kind of floored because I didn't know this was a thing. Has anyone dealt with this? Is there any way to get the benefits if your employer keeps your full paycheck going while you're out? Or is the appeal denial basically the end of the road here?

DE 2500E on my own bonding claim never showed up in SDI Online, about two weeks after I'd filed, so I wanted to reach a live person to find out what was going on. I tried the PFL line probably a dozen mornings over ten days and never got past the automated message. Eventually I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through, and I actually ended up talking to an EDD agent. She pulled up my claim and told me the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification just hadn't generated yet because the proof of relationship document was still being matched to the file. She said once it matched, the DE 2500E would issue. That was the piece I was missing. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. For the original question here, the wage loss issue is real. PFL pays because you're out of work and losing income. If your salary keeps coming in at 100%, EDD has nothing to replace.

0 coins

I've been going back and forth about whether to call EDD directly about my own care claim. My mother's Part D was submitted by her doctor online two weeks ago and SDI Online still doesn't reflect it. I'd want to ask whether EDD has received and matched it to my receipt number. I'll try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready before I call?

0 coins

Have your receipt number, your Social Security number, and the date the doctor submitted Part D. The agent can look up whether the form came in and whether it's been linked to your claim file. Having the doctor's name and the submission date speeds things up.

0 coins

Wait so the wage loss thing, does that mean if my employer pays even a partial top-up it would affect my PFL amount? Like if they pay 50% of my salary and EDD pays the rest, does EDD still pay the full weekly benefit or does it get reduced somehow?

0 coins

Partial top-up works differently. If your wages plus PFL don't exceed your normal weekly pay, EDD pays its share. The employer topping up to 100% is what zeroes out the benefit. Ask your HR what their policy says before you file.

0 coins

Employer paying full salary during leave. Yeah, that's the wall. EDD isn't supplementing income you still have.

0 coins

That's what the denial letter basically said too, just in a lot more words. I guess I assumed bonding leave and PFL were the same thing in terms of what I was entitled to.

0 coins

Bonding leave is the time off. PFL is the wage replacement. Two different things.

0 coins

That distinction actually makes a lot of sense when you put it that way. I wish someone had explained it to me before I filed.

0 coins

EDD's whole system is built for people who actually need the money. If you're getting paid anyway, their math says you're not losing anything. Frustrating when you find out that late but that's how they see it.

0 coins

Does that mean if I ask my employer to stop the salary top-up during my leave I could get PFL instead? Not sure if that's even allowed or if my employer would go for it.

0 coins

Whether your employer will agree to that is between you and HR. EDD pays when there's actual wage loss, so if the salary stops, there's something to replace. But check your employment agreement first because some employers have their own paid leave policies baked in.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about looking at it from that angle. I'll ask HR what the actual policy says.

0 coins

The rule as I understand it from going through a care claim last year is that the weekly benefit covers lost wages, so if wages haven't stopped, there's no benefit to pay. It's written in a way that makes sense once you see it, but it catches people off guard constantly.

0 coins

Does the same rule apply to care claims or just bonding? I'm caring for my dad and my job is letting me use a mix of PTO and unpaid leave days. Some weeks I might have full pay from PTO, some weeks nothing.

0 coins

My understanding is that any week where your combined wages and PFL would exceed your normal weekly pay, the PFL adjusts down. The weeks where you have no wages or partial wages are where PFL pays its share. You'd want to track carefully which days are paid versus unpaid.

0 coins

That's helpful, so it's really week by week depending on what I'm using.

0 coins

aw man that stings. your company paying you full was actually the reason you got denied. wish edd sent like a heads up before you filed so you knew

0 coins

Right? Even a note during the online filing that said 'if your employer is paying your full salary you may not be eligible' would have saved me months of back and forth.

0 coins

yeah that would take 5 seconds to add to the form. classic edd

0 coins

There's another layer here worth knowing. Even if PFL doesn't pay anything because wages keep coming in, the leave itself can still be covered by CFRA for job protection. Those are two separate questions. PFL is about the money, CFRA is about whether your job is protected. For CFRA specifics your HR or an employment attorney is the right call, not EDD.

0 coins

I actually do want to look into the job protection piece separately. My HR said I was covered but I didn't dig into what that meant legally.

0 coins

Definitely worth a conversation with HR to get it in writing. For the PFL money side, it sounds like the appeal ran its course.

0 coins

Didn't know CFRA and PFL were separate. Good to know.

0 coins

Intermittent schedule on my care claim got complicated fast. I went back two days a week in October and wasn't sure how to report those days properly. I'd been trying to reach EDD about the DE 2580GF for a while. Used Claimyr and got an EDD agent on the line who confirmed the weeks I'd reported were received and told me which weeks were still showing as pending because I hadn't yet returned the Continued Claim Certification for them. I sent those forms the next day.

0 coins

Intermittent is exactly what I'm dealing with on my own bonding claim. I went back three days a week two months ago and I want to make sure my start date and the 41-day window were handled right. I've used Claimyr on a different step and once I had an EDD agent she confirmed my claim start date and told me I was within the 41 days when I filed, which settled that question. Sending those certifications in as soon as they come now.

0 coins

How long were you trying that line before you gave up and went another route? I've been at it every morning for two weeks and it just cuts off.

0 coins

Tried for about three weeks myself before I did anything different. It's not like there's a secret trick, the line is just slammed.

0 coins

Two weeks, same result every morning. Might have to try something else.

0 coins

So once an appeal is denied is there literally no other step? No second appeal or anything? Asking because I'm watching a similar situation play out for a family member and want to know if there's anything left to try anyway.

0 coins

From what I know, the appeal decision from the ALJ is the determination. Beyond that, further review would involve the courts, which is a whole different level. For most people in this situation, the administrative process ends at the appeal. An employment attorney could tell you if there's anything further worth pursuing.

0 coins

Ok yeah courts sounds like overkill for this. Good to know where the line is though.

0 coins

That tracks with what I'm seeing. The letter I got pretty much read like a final word.

0 coins

Does taking the appeal all the way and losing hurt you in any way for future PFL claims? Like does EDD flag your account or anything?

0 coins

Filing an appeal is a standard part of the process and EDD's own notices include the Appeal Form with every denial for a reason. It doesn't mark you negatively for future claims. Each new claim stands on its own.

0 coins

Good. Didn't want to find out the hard way that appealing makes EDD suspicious of you later.

0 coins

For what it's worth, now you know for next time and can plan differently if you have another child or a care situation! Some people work with HR to structure the leave so they take PFL weeks first and then the employer top-up after, or they take PFL during unpaid weeks only.

0 coins

That's genuinely the most useful thing I've heard through all of this. Plan ahead, talk to HR before filing, don't assume.

0 coins

Exactly! The structure matters a lot and HR can sometimes work with you if they understand what you're trying to do.

0 coins

I didn't know you could plan it that way. I'm going out in February and I'll definitely ask HR how they handle the PFL overlap before I assume anything.

0 coins

my employer does a partial top-up and nobody warned me either. i only found out when i got the Notice of Computation and saw the weekly amount was lower than i expected. turns out my wages plus the PFL together can't go over my normal weekly pay, so it got adjusted. not a denial but still a surprise lol

0 coins

At least yours paid something. I ended up with nothing because the salary was at 100%. The math makes sense in hindsight but it really should be clearer up front.

0 coins

yeah 100% with no gap leaves edd nothing to fill. that's rough, especially after going through the whole appeal.

0 coins

same situation as you last year. partial top-up here too and i had to ask HR three times to understand what they were actually paying me vs what EDD was paying.

0 coins

Eight weeks of bonding still showing in SDI Online even after going back full time three months ago. Couldn't get through on the phone, tried calling maybe seven or eight times over two mornings and kept getting the recorded message. Want to know if those weeks are gone or if there's a way to use them before the 12-month window closes.

0 coins

Unused weeks being eaten up by going back full time was my fear too. I used Claimyr on a different step of my own claim and ended up talking to an EDD agent. When she pulled up my file and I asked about the weeks, she told me how many of the eight weeks were still available in my 12-month period and when that window would close for my claim. Knowing the actual date helped me decide whether filing again was worth it. If you went back full time and there are weeks left, you'd file a new DE 2501F to use them, but the agent can tell you exactly what's left.

0 coins

That's the part I keep going in circles on. I've sent a Request Claim Update through SDI Online but no response in 11 days. The 12-month window is the thing I'm most worried about losing track of.

0 coins

The Request Claim Update is worth following up on if you have a login. What you'd ask is how many of the eight weeks remain in your 12-month period, since EDD tracks that on your claim. If you go through Claimyr you get a live person who can read that number right off your file.

0 coins

Eleven days and nothing back on the update request did make me reconsider just trying to get someone on the phone. I'll give it a shot.

0 coins

the 12 month clock is real and it doesn't pause. been in a similar spot wondering what was left and the only way i got an actual number was talking to someone.

0 coins

If the appeal is fully denied and EDD sticks with no wages lost, is there any scenario where someone could get even partial PFL for that bonding period after the fact? Or is the door closed once the employer salary situation is confirmed?

0 coins

The claim period is in the past at that point. PFL isn't retroactive in the sense that EDD would reopen a decided claim and pay for weeks where the record shows no wage loss. The appeal decision closes the administrative review. If a future leave period comes up, the analysis starts fresh.

0 coins

So the closed weeks stay closed. Got it. That's what I figured but wanted to make sure.

0 coins

Brutal lesson but you learned it. Next kid or next leave you'll know to talk to HR before filing.

0 coins

Yep. Already planning to do exactly that. HR conversation first, then I'll understand what I'm actually losing before I decide whether to file.

0 coins

That's the move. Know your numbers before you file.

0 coins

Something most people don't think to ask HR is whether the company's paid leave policy runs at the same time as PFL or after it. Some companies structure it so their own paid leave runs first and PFL is for unpaid time. That answer changes everything about whether you have a wage loss to claim.

0 coins

This is the right question to ask and HR doesn't always volunteer it. 'Does your policy run concurrent with PFL or does it supplement after?' That one sentence gets you the answer you need.

0 coins

I would not have known to ask it that way. Writing that down for my conversation next month.

0 coins

Wished I had asked exactly that before September. Would have saved the whole denial and appeal.

0 coins

does this mean if your job doesnt offer any paid leave at all youre actually in a better spot for pfl than someone whose job is super generous lol

0 coins

Yes. PFL replaces lost wages. No paid leave from your job means more of your wages are actually lost.

0 coins

wild that being at a worse job helps you here

0 coins

kinda ironic but yeah that's exactly how wage replacement works.

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period right? A coworker told me there's a 7-day unpaid period but that sounded wrong to me.

0 coins

Your instinct is correct. PFL has no waiting period. The seven unpaid days is the rule for Disability Insurance, which is a different program. PFL starts paying from the first eligible day once the claim is approved.

0 coins

Thought so. Thanks for clearing that up.

0 coins

I had the same question and was worried about that. Good to know PFL is different from disability on that point.

0 coins

EDD really ought to have a wage replacement calculator built into the filing form that just tells you upfront 'based on what you're earning from your employer during leave, your PFL benefit is zero.' Would save everyone a pile of paperwork.

0 coins

Honestly that would be such a simple fix and would spare so many people from going through the whole denial and appeal process just to find out what the math already shows!

0 coins

Instead you file, wait, get denied, appeal, wait more, lose the appeal. Months of that just to end up where a one-line calculator could have put you on day one.

0 coins

This thread right here is basically the calculator I wish had existed in September.

0 coins

For anyone reading this and trying to figure out the interaction between employer salary and PFL, the core thing to know is that you can combine sick leave, vacation or other paid leave with PFL, but your wages plus PFL can't go over your normal weekly pay. So if you're earning anything from your employer during the leave week, that affects the PFL payment for that week. The EDD benefits calculator on edd.ca.gov can give you an estimate to run before you file.

0 coins

The calculator is genuinely useful. I ran it before my care claim and the weekly benefit amount it gave was close to what showed on my actual Notice of Computation.

0 coins

Good habit to run the calculator first and then compare with your Notice of Computation when it arrives. If the numbers are very different, that's worth asking EDD about.

0 coins

Exactly, the Notice of Computation is the official number, the calculator is just for planning before you file.

0 coins

OP did your employer know you were also filing for PFL at the same time you were getting full salary from them? Just wondering if that changes anything or if EDD asks about that in the appeal anyway.

0 coins

My employer knew I filed, yes. And EDD did ask about wages during the leave as part of the appeal process. That's how the wage loss question came into it. The company's HR confirmed to EDD that I was paid in full throughout the leave.

0 coins

So it was EDD's own review that surfaced the salary, not something you had to disclose separately. Interesting.

0 coins

Yeah, they verified it through the process. I'd already reported wages honestly on the claim form so it wasn't a surprise to them or me.

0 coins

late to this but just want to say the interaction between employer paid leave and PFL is probably the least explained thing in all of EDD's materials. most people find out the hard way exactly like you did.

0 coins

Exactly why I posted. If this thread saves one person from going through two months of denial and appeal paperwork, that's worth it.

0 coins

It really does help to see a real case spelled out. The abstract rule makes sense but seeing how it played out is what sticks.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure