Overpayment notice after paid family leave claim denied — what does it mean?
So my PFL care claim got denied and now I have an overpayment notice in the mail and I genuinely don't understand what's happening. I filed to care for my dad who's been having serious health problems, took about five weeks off work, and EDD actually paid me for those weeks. Then a few weeks later I get the denial notice — which I already thought was confusing because why are they denying something they already paid — and now on top of that there's this overpayment notice saying I owe money back. Does this happen often? Are these two notices connected, or did something go completely wrong with my claim? I haven't appealed yet because I'm not even sure what I'm appealing. Can someone help me understand what's going on here?
82 comments

Malik Robinson
What you're describing is actually a sequence EDD follows in certain situations. They paid you provisionally, then reviewed the claim and determined you weren't eligible, so now they want the money back. The denial notice and the overpayment notice are connected — one caused the other. The good news is you can appeal both. The denial notice should have come with an Appeal Form (DE 1000A). You have 30 days from the date on that notice to file it, either online or by mail.
0 coins
Emma Taylor
AuthorSo the denial came first and that's what triggered the overpayment? I think I got them close together so I assumed it was some kind of error. The denial notice does have that appeal form attached. Does appealing the denial also cover the overpayment or do I appeal them separately?
0 coins
Malik Robinson
They're separate notices so technically separate appeals, but if the appeal on the denial succeeds and EDD finds you were eligible after all, the overpayment would go away. I'd appeal the denial first and explain clearly why you believe you qualified. Keep copies of everything you send.
0 coins
Isabella Silva
Went through something similar with a care claim for my mom last year. The denial came and I panicked, then the overpayment letter showed up three days later. Appealing the denial was the right move and it sorted out the balance question too.
0 coins
Ravi Choudhury
You didn't do anything wrong necessarily. EDD sometimes pays while they're still reviewing, then makes a final call later. It's their process. File the appeal before that 30-day window closes. Missing that date makes everything harder.
0 coins
Emma Taylor
AuthorThe denial notice is dated about two and a half weeks ago so I still have time. I didn't want to appeal without understanding what I was even challenging, which is why I've been sitting on it.
0 coins
Ravi Choudhury
Don't sit on it much longer. You can write a simple statement — say you cared for your dad, that his condition was serious, and that Part D was submitted by his doctor. Keep it short and factual.
0 coins
CosmosCaptain
30 days goes faster than you'd think. Send it.
0 coins
Freya Johansen
Payment method on my claim kept showing wrong in SDI Online and I couldn't figure out if it would affect the actual deposit. Tried EDD's phone line four mornings in a row and got cut off every time. Eventually used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person on EDD's Paid Family Leave line. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent confirmed my direct deposit information was correctly on file and that the payment had already been issued — the online display was just lagging. Knowing that let me stop worrying and focus on the claim itself.
0 coins
Omar Fawzi
My denial notice just arrived and I want to ask EDD directly what specifically they say is missing before I write my appeal. I might try Claimyr for that. What did you have ready when the agent picked up?
0 coins
Freya Johansen
Have your Social Security number and your receipt number pulled up before anyone answers. The agent will ask for both right away and it moves faster if you're not hunting for them mid-call.
0 coins
Chloe Wilson
Good to know about having that info ready! My claim's been sitting for ten days and I keep refreshing SDI Online hoping something changes.
0 coins
Diego Mendoza
Honestly the phone line is impossible some days. I tried seven times one morning and it just kept ending the call.
0 coins
Anastasia Romanov
If you want to understand what to put in your appeal, the denial notice itself usually states the reason. Common ones for care claims are that Part D was incomplete, that it arrived after the 41-day deadline, or that the relationship between you and the person you cared for wasn't established. Which reason did yours give?
0 coins
Emma Taylor
AuthorIt says something about the medical certification being insufficient. Part D was submitted by my dad's doctor but maybe something was missing from it.
0 coins
Anastasia Romanov
That's actually appealable. If the doctor can supply a corrected or more detailed certification, attach it to your appeal. Explain that the original was submitted in good faith and that you've now included the complete documentation.
0 coins
StellarSurfer
The form for the appeal is the DE 1000A, which should be on the back of the denial notice. EDD's site also has it. You can file it by mail or online through SDI Online.
0 coins
Sean Kelly
The overpayment notice is EDD saying pay us back while we figure out if you owed it in the first place. Classic. File the appeal, win it, and the overpayment disappears. Lose it and you owe the money. That's the whole game.
0 coins
Zara Malik
Pretty much. I've seen people get these and do nothing. Then the 30 days pass and they're stuck paying back money they might not have owed.
0 coins
Luca Greco
EDD doesn't pause the overpayment while you appeal either. Worth knowing.
0 coins
Emma Taylor
AuthorWait, I have to pay it back even while the appeal is pending? Or is there a way to pause that?
0 coins
StellarSurfer
To the question about whether you owe it while appealing — you can appeal the overpayment notice separately using the same DE 1000A form. While the appeal is in process, ask EDD directly about timing, because they're the ones who set that. What I'd put in writing right now is both the denial appeal and the overpayment appeal, noting that the overpayment stems from the denial.
0 coins
Emma Taylor
AuthorFiling both at once makes sense. I don't want to appeal one and have the other become final because I didn't act.
0 coins
Malik Robinson
Exactly right. Treat them as two separate appeals but file them at the same time. Reference your claim ID number on both.
0 coins
Diego Mendoza
My cousin went through a denied care claim last spring and was completely overwhelmed by getting two letters at once. She appealed the denial, explained the situation in plain language, and included a note from the doctor clarifying the certification. It resolved in her favor. The appeal doesn't have to be a legal brief, just clear and factual.
0 coins
Emma Taylor
AuthorThat's actually reassuring. I was imagining I needed some formal document.
0 coins
Isabella Silva
Plain and factual is exactly right. EDD reviewers read a lot of these. Clear beats elaborate every time.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
Glad to hear appeals can work. Fingers crossed for you.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
I'm in a somewhat related situation, not sure if it fits here — my PFL bonding claim was approved and then I got an overpayment notice. I didn't get a denial, just the overpayment. Does that mean they think I was overpaid on the amount, not that I was ineligible?
0 coins
Malik Robinson
An overpayment without a denial usually means EDD believes it paid you more than the calculated amount, or that you had wages during the claim period that weren't reported. Check whether you returned to work at all during those weeks, even part time, and whether those wages were reported.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
I did go back part time for two weeks near the end. I didn't know I had to report that separately. I thought the employer handled it.
0 coins
Anastasia Romanov
Reporting any wages you earned during the claim is on the claimant, not the employer. EDD sends a Continued Claim Certification form for that. If wages weren't reported, that could be the source of the overpayment. You can still appeal if you think the amount is wrong.
0 coins
Aisha Hussain
The unreported wages are probably exactly it. When you go back part time during a PFL claim, your benefit for those days is reduced proportionally. The overpayment would be the difference between what you received and what you were actually owed for those weeks.
0 coins
Zara Malik
Tried for three days to get EDD on the phone about my PFL claim receipt number — the confirmation page had one number and the SDI Online dashboard showed something different and I couldn't tell which was correct. Used Claimyr and got through to an EDD agent who pulled up the claim and confirmed the receipt number on file. Turns out the dashboard number was right and the confirmation page had an older draft reference. Good to have that cleared up before mailing anything.
0 coins
Diego Mendoza
The receipt number matching was actually what I needed to check on my own denial situation. Used Claimyr too after the phone line dropped me four times on a Tuesday morning. Once the agent confirmed my receipt number was linked correctly to the claim, I asked them about the Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination I'd gotten — they said the denial was final as of the notice date, which meant my 30-day appeal window had already started. I filed the DE 1000A that same afternoon.
0 coins
GalacticGladiator
four times in one morning and it dropped you every time. that's just brutal. i've been at it for two weeks trying to reach anyone about my claim.
0 coins
Emma Taylor
AuthorKnowing the right receipt number before mailing your appeal documents is actually something I hadn't thought about. I'll double-check mine before I send anything in.
0 coins
Omar Fawzi
Something that tripped me up — I thought PFL had a waiting period like disability does, so I assumed the first week of my care claim wasn't paid and I didn't track it. Someone told me later that PFL has no waiting period at all. Is that actually true?
0 coins
Malik Robinson
PFL genuinely has no waiting period. Every eligible day from the first day of your leave counts. You may be thinking of Disability Insurance, which does have a seven-day unpaid period at the start. PFL is different.
0 coins
Omar Fawzi
That explains so much. I assumed my first week was just lost and didn't even look at whether it was included in my payment.
0 coins
Isabella Silva
A lot of people mix those two up. DI has the waiting week, PFL doesn't. Easy to get them confused if you've dealt with both.
0 coins
Ethan Brown
if your claim got denied after they already paid you just appeal it dont let the 30 days expire while you're trying to figure out the why. the why becomes clearer once you read the denial reason anyway
0 coins
Emma Taylor
AuthorThe denial does have the reason spelled out, I just didn't understand what it meant at first. I think I do now after reading this thread.
0 coins
Ethan Brown
yeah once you get the terminology it makes more sense. good luck with the appeal
0 coins
Aisha Hussain
One figure worth writing down before you do anything: the overpayment notice should state the exact amount EDD says it wants back. Keep that number and compare it against your payment history in SDI Online. If the math doesn't match what you actually received, that's a detail to include in your appeal.
0 coins
Emma Taylor
AuthorI didn't even think to compare the overpayment amount against my actual payments. I'll log in and check the payment history tonight.
0 coins
StellarSurfer
SDI Online does show payment history by week if you go into your claim. It's useful for exactly this — verifying that what EDD says was paid matches what you actually received.
0 coins
Aisha Hussain
And if there's a discrepancy, document it with dates and amounts. An appeal with specific numbers is a lot harder to dismiss than a general disagreement.
0 coins
Yuki Yamamoto
Appealing when you have documentation backing you is straightforward. Get the corrected Part D from the doctor if the reason was insufficient certification. Attach it. State the dates you were off work. Send it before the 30 days are up.
0 coins
Emma Taylor
AuthorThe doctor's office said they could provide a more detailed version of the certification. I'll request that and include it.
0 coins
Yuki Yamamoto
Good. Make sure the physician signs it and that it covers the specific dates of your leave.
0 coins
Chloe Wilson
My PFL bonding claim just got approved last week and reading about what happens with denials is making me realize I didn't track any of this carefully. Is there anything people recommend keeping records of even after a claim is approved, just in case?
0 coins
Malik Robinson
Keep the Notice of Computation, all payment confirmation emails or notifications, and your SDI Online claim ID. If you return to work before using all eight weeks, also keep any Continued Claim Certification forms EDD sends. Things can come up months later.
0 coins
Chloe Wilson
I went back after six weeks so I still have two weeks of bonding leave left in my 12-month window. I didn't realize I needed to keep anything for those remaining weeks!
0 coins
Anastasia Romanov
Those remaining weeks are yours to use anytime before the 12 months from the birth are up. When you're ready, you'd file a new claim with the DE 2501F for the remaining time. Keep the documentation from the original claim handy.
0 coins
Luca Greco
EDD denying something they already paid out is not an error or a glitch, it's by design. They review after paying in some cases. Frustrating but it's how it works. The appeal is the only real lever you have.
0 coins
Sean Kelly
And even winning the appeal takes time. Meanwhile the overpayment notice is just sitting there. The system is what it is.
0 coins
CosmosCaptain
Appeal anyway. The only outcome worse than waiting is not filing at all.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
Notice of Computation on my PFL bonding claim showed a weekly amount that didn't match what I expected based on my wages. I wanted to know if the base period they used was right. After getting nowhere with the phone line I ended up trying Claimyr and got an EDD agent who told me which four quarters made up my base period and which quarter had the highest wages they used for the calculation. Turned out the base period was correct, I had just miscalculated which quarter was highest. Anyway, back to the original question.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
I've called that line probably nine times in three weeks and gotten through to a live person exactly zero times. Every single time it disconnects before I get anywhere. I find it hard to believe Claimyr actually reaches someone.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
I get the skepticism, I really do. Nine tries and nothing, I'd be doubtful too. What I can tell you is I was talking to an EDD agent about fifteen minutes into using it. She worked for EDD, confirmed my base period quarters, and answered my question about the Notice of Computation directly. That's all I can say.
0 coins
Isabella Silva
Used Claimyr when my care claim's Part D hadn't shown as received in SDI Online even though the doctor's office had submitted it online with my receipt number. The agent looked it up and said Part D was in the system and matched to my claim. Total relief, I'd been anxious about that for a week.
0 coins
GalacticGladiator
the line just hanging up on you over and over is so demoralizing. glad something worked for at least some people here.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
Sending good thoughts. Appeals feel daunting but you clearly understand your situation now. That matters.
0 coins
Emma Taylor
AuthorThank you. I went into this thread confused about two letters and now I actually have a plan. Appeal the denial, appeal the overpayment separately, include the corrected Part D, check the payment amounts in SDI Online first.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
That's a solid plan. Hope it goes your way.
0 coins
Sean Kelly
A denial after already getting paid is not the end of it. EDD issues a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination (DE 2514) for denials and that's what has the appeal form attached. If you got paid and then got one of those, the appeal is still open to you within 30 days of that notice's date. EDD's clock, not the date you received it.
0 coins
Emma Taylor
AuthorThe date on the notice is what starts the 30 days, not when it arrived in my mailbox? I need to look at that date again.
0 coins
Sean Kelly
Correct. Mail can take a few days. If the notice is dated the 1st and you got it on the 5th, your 30 days still runs from the 1st.
0 coins
StellarSurfer
This is an important point. If mail delay has eaten into your window significantly, note that in your appeal as context. EDD has seen late delivery before.
0 coins
Isabella Silva
Just want to flag something for anyone else reading this: bonding and care are both PFL, but the documentation is totally different. For a care claim you need Part C from the person you're caring for and Part D from their doctor. For bonding with a new baby you need proof of relationship like a birth certificate, but there's no Part C or Part D. Getting those mixed up causes denials that are totally avoidable.
0 coins
Anastasia Romanov
Worth adding that Part D should never be uploaded through SDI Online — it has to be mailed, or the doctor can submit it directly in SDI Online using the claimant's receipt number. Uploading it yourself can delay the claim.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
I did not know that. I almost uploaded it when I first filed my care claim because the upload option is right there.
0 coins
Malik Robinson
The instructions on the form itself say to mail it or have the doctor submit it online. The upload feature in SDI Online is for other supporting documents, not Part C or Part D.
0 coins
GalacticGladiator
been dealing with a pending PFL care claim for eleven days now and reading about denials and overpayment notices is not helping my nerves. is pending normal for this long?
0 coins
Malik Robinson
EDD says deciding a claim can take up to 14 days. Eleven days is within that window. If it goes past 14, you can send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online — open your claim and look for that option.
0 coins
GalacticGladiator
ok 14 days is what i needed to hear. i'll give it three more days before i do anything.
0 coins
Yuki Yamamoto
Pending at 11 days is normal. Try not to read into it.
0 coins
Anastasia Romanov
To bring it back to where this started: the original question was about getting an overpayment notice after a denial, and what that means. The short version is — the denial made you retroactively ineligible for benefits already received, so EDD issued the overpayment notice for those funds. Appealing the denial is the most direct way to address both issues at once, and 30 days from the denial notice date is the window. Everything else in this thread is details around that core situation.
0 coins
Emma Taylor
AuthorThis whole thread has been genuinely helpful. I know what I'm doing now: appeal before the window closes, get the corrected certification from the doctor, verify the overpayment amount against my SDI Online history, and file the second appeal on the overpayment notice too. I'll check back in once I've heard something.
0 coins
Malik Robinson
You've got a clear head about it now. Good luck with the appeal.
0 coins
Ravi Choudhury
Just get it in the mail. Everything else sorts itself out after that.
0 coins