Back to California Paid Family Leave

Adrian Hughes

Notice of potential overpayment paid family leave check not deposited — what do I do?

Got this letter from EDD last week saying there's a notice of potential overpayment on my PFL bonding claim and I'm kind of losing my mind over it. Here's the thing though — the check they're referencing, I never deposited it. Never even cashed it. It just sat on my counter because I wasn't sure if it was for the right amount after my Notice of Computation came and the numbers looked off to me. So now EDD is saying I might owe money back for a payment I literally never touched. Is that even possible? Like how do you owe back money you didn't spend? My claim was for bonding with my daughter, filed everything through SDI Online, got the proof of relationship uploaded no problem. But this overpayment notice has me worried I messed something up with my wages or the reporting. Anyone dealt with this?

Part D not" received sat on my care claim for nine days after my'husband s doctor submitted it online with the receipt number. Used (Claimyr) claimyr.com to get through to an EDD agent about it. The agent pulled up the claim and said Part D had come in but'wasn t matched to my claim ID yet, and to watch for a status change in SDI Online within a few days. That was the step I needed.'Claimyr s video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave:https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Genuinely curious what Claimyr is — I've never heard of it before this comment.

0 coins

EDD's phone line picks up when a live agent is there, and your phone rings at that point, so you don't have to stay on hold yourself. That's essentially what it does.

0 coins

Ah, that makes sense. My situation is that my own Part D was supposedly mailed three weeks ago and the status hasn't budged, so I'd want to ask whether EDD ever received it.

0 coins

The check question is actually interesting. PFL benefits are issued once EDD processes the claim, so the check represents wages they calculated you were owed based on what you reported. Whether you deposited it or not doesn't change their records. If your wages were higher than what you reported, or if you worked days you didn't report, the system flags it.

0 coins

So the deposit part doesn't matter to them at all? They're not tracking whether the check cleared?

0 coins

Right, their ledger shows benefits issued, not benefits cashed. The overpayment is about the amount calculated versus what you were actually entitled to. The undeposited check is a separate thing.

0 coins

Wait so do I need to send the check back or just respond to the notice? I got something similar and I genuinely don't know what the right move is here.

0 coins

The notice itself should tell you the steps. Read it carefully and check whether there's an appeal option or a repayment instruction on there.

0 coins

EDD sent me a potential overpayment letter last spring and I panicked too. Mine turned out to be because I had a week of vacation pay from my job that I forgot to report. Even a small amount of unreported wages can trigger the whole process.

0 coins

Vacation pay counts? I didn't even think about that. I did get one day of sick pay during my leave.

0 coins

Yep, any wages including sick, vacation, PTO — all of it gets reported. If you got sick pay for a day and didn't report it, that could be your whole thing.

0 coins

That's what got me too. One day of sick leave and EDD flagged the whole week.

0 coins

The appeal option on those notices is what a lot of people miss. EDD gives you 30 days from the date on the letter to appeal it, using the Appeal Form DE 1000A. If your situation involved wages you did report correctly, that form is where you make your case.

0 coins

30 days from the letter date, not from when I got it in the mail?

0 coins

The date printed on the notice itself, yes. So if it sat a few days before you opened it, your window is a little shorter. Worth acting on quickly.

0 coins

I'm kind of scared that if I appeal and lose it makes things worse somehow? Like is there a penalty for appealing and not winning?

0 coins

Filing an appeal doesn't add penalties. You're just asking EDD to reconsider. The worst case is the same outcome, not a worse one.

0 coins

The undeposited check situation is actually really common and there's a path for it! You can contact EDD and let them know the check was never cashed. They track issued payments and an agent can tell you what your options are with that specific check.

0 coins

Good to know I'm not the only one. Did you have to call or was there a way to do it in SDI Online?

0 coins

I ended up calling since I wanted to explain the whole situation. SDI Online has the Request Claim Update option but for something like this I wanted to actually talk to someone!

0 coins

Potential overpayment isn't a final determination. It means they found something worth looking at. Respond to it. Don't sit on it.

0 coins

Yeah I figured I couldn't just ignore it. How do I respond though — is there a form or do I call?

0 coins

The notice tells you. Read the whole thing first.

0 coins

Seriously, the notice spells it out. Mine had two options right on page two, lol.

0 coins

My cousin went through something almost exactly like this with her bonding claim and the overpayment ended up being from a week where her employer paid out some accrued hours without telling her it would affect her PFL. She had no idea that was even happening until the letter came. EDD's math wasn't wrong, her employer just did something she didn't know about.

0 coins

That's what terrifies me — that something happened I don't even know about. How would you even find out what triggered it?

0 coins

The notice usually describes what period or week they're flagging. That's your starting point to match it against what you know.

0 coins

Mine mentions a specific week in the claim period so I need to go back and think about what happened that week.

0 coins

Fourteen weeks into waiting to hear about the payment timing on my bonding claim, I finally used Claimyr to get through to EDD. The agent looked up my claim and told me the payment for weeks three and four had been issued on a date I hadn't expected, and explained I should see it in my payment method within a few business days of that issue date. I'd been anxious about it for no reason once I knew the actual date.

0 coins

I used Claimyr for my own claim too and was glad I did. The agent told me my Notice of Computation had gone out the week before I called, which explained why my benefit amount looked different from the estimate I'd gotten from EDD's calculator. So the number wasn't wrong, the timing just threw me.

0 coins

Did the agent say whether the weekly benefit amount on the computation matched what ended up getting paid out? That gap between the estimate and the final number tripped me up on my own claim.

0 coins

The agent confirmed the amount on the computation was the amount they were paying per week. The difference from the estimate was just because the calculator pulls from different wage quarters than EDD uses for the actual claim.

0 coins

the estimate vs actual thing confused me for weeks. thought i was getting less than i should

0 coins

if you never deposited the check can you just void it and return it? i feel like that would clear it up faster than fighting the notice

0 coins

Voiding and returning the check might address the payment side but it doesn't automatically resolve the overpayment notice, which is a separate process EDD needs to close out.

0 coins

ok so do both? return the check AND respond to the notice?

0 coins

That would be the safest approach, yes. Contact EDD about the check and address the notice separately within your 30-day appeal window.

0 coins

Looking at this from the reporting side: the overpayment calculation usually comes from wages in the base period or from wages earned during the leave itself that weren't reported. The claim shows what was reported; EDD's wage records show what your employer reported. If those two don't match, that's the flag.

0 coins

So EDD has records from my employer independently? They don't just take my word for what I earned?

0 coins

Correct. Employers report wages to EDD as part of normal payroll, so EDD can cross-reference what you said against what your employer filed.

0 coins

Learned that the hard way. My employer reported a bonus the month I started leave and I didn't even know it was on there.

0 coins

I'm in a somewhat similar spot — I got a notice about my own bonding PFL claim and I don't totally understand what a potential overpayment means versus an actual overpayment. Are they the same thing?

0 coins

They're different. Potential means EDD has flagged something to review. An actual overpayment determination comes after they've completed the review and confirmed the amount. You respond to the potential one to give your side before they finalize anything.

0 coins

Oh okay so I still have a chance to explain before it becomes official? That makes me feel a little better.

0 coins

Exactly. That's why the response window matters — you're not fighting a final decision yet, you're part of the process before they make one.

0 coins

I had a situation where my employer switched payroll systems mid-leave and some wages got filed twice under two different IDs. EDD flagged it as an overpayment. Took a few weeks to sort out but it got resolved once I sent in documentation showing the duplicate.

0 coins

That's a good reminder that sometimes it's not even something the claimant did wrong.

0 coins

Exactly. EDD's data is only as good as what gets filed with them. Errors happen on the employer side too.

0 coins

Does PFL have that one-week waiting period before payments start? I want to make sure I understood what period could have an overpayment issue because I thought the first week wasn't paid anyway.

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period — payments start from your first eligible day. That's disability insurance that has the seven-day thing, not PFL. So every week of your PFL claim is potentially a paid week.

0 coins

Oh wow I completely had that backwards. I was calculating my whole claim wrong in my head.

0 coins

I mixed those two up too when I first filed. PFL and pregnancy disability run back to back for new moms so the rules blur together a bit.

0 coins

Different programs with different rules. Worth reading the EDD page on each one separately if you filed both.

0 coins

For a check that was never deposited: before you do anything else, write down the check number, the amount, and the date on it. You'll need that information when you contact EDD, and having it ready makes the call faster.

0 coins

I still have the envelope, check's inside. Good call on noting those details first.

0 coins

Also note the date on your overpayment notice. The 30-day window to appeal starts there.

0 coins

Eight weeks into my claim spread across about five months of intermittent leave, I realized I wasn't sure how many weeks I had left and whether I could file another stretch. Used Claimyr to get EDD on the line. The agent told me five of the eight weeks had been paid out and three remained within my 12-month window. That number was what I needed before I scheduled anything with my job.

0 coins

The whole Claimyr thing reads like a marketing comment to me. I'm skeptical of anything that sounds like a shortcut to EDD's phone line.

0 coins

i thought the same thing honestly. tried it anyway after three mornings of the line dropping before i got anywhere. the agent told me which of my weeks had been processed and that the next payment was scheduled for the following friday. i wouldve waited another week not knowing if i hadnt gotten through.

0 coins

alright that's actually useful. might give it a shot for my own claim.

0 coins

The specific language 'potential' on that notice is EDD giving you a chance to respond before anything is finalized. You can file the DE 1000A appeal form or you can call and ask what specifically triggered the flag. Either way, don't just wait it out.

0 coins

Is the DE 1000A the right form even if I think the notice is a mistake rather than an actual overpayment?

0 coins

Yes, the DE 1000A is for appealing any determination you disagree with, including potential overpayment notices. That's the form to use.

0 coins

The DE 1000A can also be filed online through SDI Online, not just by mail. Worth knowing if you're close to the 30-day window.

0 coins

My bonding claim had a weird situation where EDD sent the payment to an old bank account I'd updated in SDI Online. The check version they mailed after the deposit failed was the one I actually got. If your check came through that kind of route, there might be a note on your account about a reissued payment.

0 coins

Mine doesn't seem to be a reissue situation, just the original check for one specific week. But good to know that can happen.

0 coins

Worth double checking your payment method settings in SDI Online just to rule it out, lol.

0 coins

You said the numbers on the Notice of Computation looked off when the check arrived. If the amount on the check was different from what you expected based on the computation, that's worth flagging specifically when you contact EDD.

0 coins

That's exactly the part that confused me. The check amount didn't match what I thought the weekly benefit should be and that's why I didn't deposit it.

0 coins

Tell EDD that. The computation is their official number. If the check was for a different amount that's their error to fix, not an overpayment you caused.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation is the controlling document for the weekly benefit amount. If the check is a different number, one of them is wrong and EDD needs to sort that out.

0 coins

Came back to this thread because I saw someone mention the 30-day window and wanted to add: if you do appeal, write down your reasoning clearly before you fill out the DE 1000A. Having your dates, amounts, and what happened in writing first makes the form a lot easier to complete.

0 coins

Good advice. I've been jotting things down since I found this thread. The check number, the week in question, what I did and didn't report.

0 coins

That's exactly the right approach. The clearer your record is, the better your appeal.

0 coins

Just want to say for anyone reading this later: PFL benefits and your regular wages can't together be more than your normal wages. So if your employer paid out sick or vacation while EDD was also paying PFL for the same days, that combination is what causes an overpayment flag. It's not necessarily that anyone did anything wrong intentionally.

0 coins

This is the part I didn't know when I filed. I thought I could get both PFL and my paid time off at the same time.

0 coins

A lot of people think that. The combined total can't exceed your normal wages, and how your employer handles it depends on their own policy. Definitely worth checking with HR about how they set it up.

0 coins

My HR never explained any of this to me when I filed. I had to figure it out from EDD's site.

0 coins

You have the check, you have the notice, you have 30 days. Call EDD, explain the check wasn't deposited, and ask what they need from you. That's the whole task.

0 coins

Direct and to the point, I appreciate it. I've been overthinking this. Making the call tomorrow morning.

0 coins

Bring the check number and the date on the notice. That's it.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure