Back to California Paid Family Leave

Ravi Malhotra

How to repay PFL overpayment after receiving full sick pay from my employer

So my employer paid out my full sick leave during the same weeks I was getting PFL bonding payments. Didn't realize until HR flagged it last month that you can't double-dip like that. Got an overpayment notice in the mail and I'm honestly not sure where to start. The notice has an amount on it but doesn't explain super clearly what my options are. Can I appeal this or do I just have to pay it back? Is there a form or somewhere online to handle it? Sorry if this is obvious but I've never dealt with this before and I'm kind of panicking a little about the amount. Anyway.

The notice itself should tell you the repayment steps, but the short answer is yes, there are two separate paths. You can pay it back, or you can appeal within 30 days of the notice date using the Appeal Form DE 1000A. The form comes with the notice, or you can appeal online through SDI Online. If you think the amount is wrong or there's something EDD misunderstood about your wages and sick pay, an appeal is worth filing.

0 coins

Is the 30 days from when they mailed it or when I received it, because there's about a week gap there and I want to make sure I haven't already missed the window.

0 coins

The notice date printed on the letter is what EDD goes by, so count from that date, not the postmark or the day it arrived.

0 coins

Got it. The date on mine is from three weeks ago so I need to move fast. Filing the appeal online today.

0 coins

DE 1000A is the right form. It's included with the overpayment notice, and EDD's site confirms you file it within 30 days. The appeal goes to EDD, not to your employer, even though your employer's sick pay is what caused the overlap.

0 coins

Does appealing it mean I'm saying I don't owe it at all, or can I appeal and still offer to pay part of it? I'm not sure how flexible this is.

0 coins

The appeal is a formal dispute of the determination. If you agree you owe some but not all of it, you can say that in your appeal statement with the specific weeks and amounts you're contesting.

0 coins

I think I read somewhere you can also ask for a waiver? Not sure if that's a real option here or only for disability claims.

0 coins

Waivers exist for overpayments but EDD decides whether to grant one. Nobody can promise that outcome. The appeal and the repayment are the two things you can actually control.

0 coins

DE 2514 came to me around this same situation, except mine was a care claim. Couldn't get anyone at EDD on the phone for days. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through, and when I finally had an agent she pulled up the determination and read me exactly which weeks triggered it and what figure they had on file for each one. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

What claim info did you have ready when the agent picked up? I want to ask about my own determination notice, going to try Claimyr for it.

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, the notice date, and the specific weeks on the determination. The agent can pull each week individually so the more precise you are the faster it goes.

0 coins

Genuinely didn't know you could get that level of detail over the phone. Every time I've tried calling I get a recording and then it hangs up on me.

0 coins

That was my experience too, every morning for about four days straight before I tried something different.

0 coins

The overlap rule trips a lot of people up. Wages plus PFL can't be more than your normal weekly wages, so if your employer paid you 100 percent of your salary through sick leave that same week, PFL for those days becomes an overpayment. It's not a penalty, it's just the math.

0 coins

Does that mean if my employer only paid me 60 percent sick pay those weeks, PFL could cover the rest up to my normal wage? Or is it all or nothing?

0 coins

That's how it's supposed to work, PFL can fill in the gap up to your normal wages. How your employer structures it is their policy, so check with HR, but EDD's side of the math is based on what you actually received.

0 coins

This is basically my situation except HR paid me 100 percent without asking. I didn't know to tell them not to.

0 coins

My HR did the exact same thing to me after my second kid. Paid me full sick leave the whole time and I had no idea PFL was running at the same time until a notice showed up four months later. I ended up filing the appeal because I genuinely didn't know and explained that in my statement.

0 coins

Did EDD adjust the amount or was the appeal mostly about buying time to figure out the payment?

0 coins

Both honestly. The agent I eventually reached clarified which weeks were actually overlapping versus the weeks I took after sick leave ran out, so the amount came down from what the original notice said.

0 coins

This is kind of reassuring actually because I thought an overpayment notice was always final.

0 coins

Appeal it. Even if you think you owe it, filing the appeal gives you a hearing where someone actually looks at your specific weeks and your employer's pay records. The raw notice number is often not the final number.

0 coins

Has anyone had the appeal actually reduce the amount owed versus just delaying the repayment?

0 coins

Yes. If EDD included weeks where your employer didn't pay you full wages, those weeks shouldn't be in the overpayment. The appeal is where you show that.

0 coins

Makes sense. I just always assumed once EDD sent a number it was set.

0 coins

Proof of relationship was what held my bonding claim up, so this overpayment thing is a different headache. When proof question came up on mine I used Claimyr to get an agent and she confirmed they had received the birth certificate but it hadn't been matched to the claim yet. She put a note on it and the claim moved within a couple days.

0 coins

The unmatched document part matches what happened with my care claim. Used Claimyr too, different step though. What receipt number format did the agent ask for on yours?

0 coins

She just needed the SDI Online claim ID, the one on the confirmation page when you file. Have that and the document name ready.

0 coins

How long were you trying the line before you tried something different? I've been at it three mornings already.

0 coins

Four days for me. The line was either busy or dropped after the automated part. Stopped fighting it after day four.

0 coins

November 3rd is when my overpayment notice arrived and the amount on it covered six weeks. What I did first was write out each week, what PFL paid me and what my employer paid, to see where the actual overlap was. Two of the six weeks my sick leave had already run out so those weeks shouldn't have been in the notice at all.

0 coins

Did you bring that breakdown to the appeal or did you need any documentation from your employer to support it?

0 coins

I brought both. A simple week-by-week table I made myself and a pay statement from HR showing the sick leave exhaustion date. The hearing officer asked for the HR document specifically.

0 coins

That's exactly the right approach. Organizing it by week makes it easier for EDD to see which weeks are actually disputed.

0 coins

edd is so confusing with this, my job paid me pto and i had no idea that counted the same as sick pay for the overlap rule. nobody told me when i filed

0 coins

Vacation and PTO fall under the same wages rule so yeah same situation. If combined you were over your normal weekly wages, those days are an overpayment.

0 coins

ugh so i probably have one coming too. do i wait for the notice or is there a way to flag it myself before they catch it

0 coins

You can report wages through SDI Online. Getting ahead of it is better than waiting because if they catch it first you have less room to explain the circumstances.

0 coins

Not sure if this matters but I think I saw somewhere that PFL doesn't have a waiting period like disability does. Does that affect how they calculate the overpayment weeks?

0 coins

Correct that PFL has no waiting period, the first day is covered. The overpayment calculation is about overlapping wages, not about waiting days, so the two things don't interact.

0 coins

Okay that makes more sense. I was confusing myself thinking the first week might be treated differently.

0 coins

My situation was basically the same and the amount on the notice scared me honestly. Called the appeals number and the person told me exactly what week triggered it. Filed the DE 1000A the next day. The hearing is set for January, we'll see.

0 coins

January feels far but that's actually pretty normal timing for a PFL appeal hearing from what I've seen.

0 coins

Yeah I'm not panicking about the timeline, just want the right number on record before anything gets sent to collections or whatever happens next.

0 coins

An active appeal pauses the collection process generally speaking, so filing it was the right call.

0 coins

Payment date on my care claim was sitting as unknown for two weeks and I couldn't get a human on the phone no matter what I tried. Ended up getting through via Claimyr and the agent confirmed the first payment had actually been issued three days earlier, it just hadn't posted to SDI Online yet. Would've waited another week for nothing without that call.

0 coins

Spent almost two weeks trying that line myself, mornings mostly, and either got a busy signal or the automated system ended the call. How did you actually end up talking to someone?

0 coins

Claimyr handles the hold time for you and your phone rings when an EDD agent is on the line. That's really the whole thing. I'd been trying for ten days on my own.

0 coins

Agent confirmed payment issued but not yet showing in SDI Online, that tracks. Processing and display timing are two different things.

0 coins

If the payment was already issued that's actually a relief. I'll try it for my own claim, the Notice of Computation showed a weekly amount but I still haven't seen the first payment come through.

0 coins

Notice of Computation isn't an approval. First payment usually comes within two weeks once EDD has a completed claim, so if it's past that, worth checking your payment method in SDI Online too.

0 coins

The DE 1000A appeal form is straightforward once you have your weeks organized! Don't just write 'I disagree,' include the specific dates and what your employer actually paid you those weeks.

0 coins

Is there a word limit or length restriction on the appeal statement?

0 coins

No specific limit from what I know. Mine was about a page and a half and covered every disputed week with dates. More detail is better than less.

0 coins

The assumption that your employer and EDD are coordinating in real time is a myth. They don't talk to each other. Your employer paid full sick leave because that's their system, EDD paid PFL because you filed a valid claim. Neither knew what the other was doing until EDD cross-referenced at audit time.

0 coins

That's wild. So the claimant is basically responsible for flagging the overlap themselves?

0 coins

Yes. Reporting wages to EDD when you're also receiving employer pay is on the claimant. Most people don't know that until they get the notice.

0 coins

That would have been useful to know when I filed. There was nothing in the SDI Online process that asked me to confirm my employer's sick leave policy.

0 coins

There are questions in the filing process about whether you'll receive wages, but they're easy to miss or misread. EDD could be clearer about it.

0 coins

just got a notice too. similar thing with pto. doing the week by week thing now like someone above said

0 coins

December 1st was when I finished my own week-by-week table and it took maybe an hour. Way less stressful than I expected once I had my pay stubs out.

0 coins

yeah i have the stubs just havent sat down with them. probably tonight

0 coins

The overlap rule isn't about punishing anyone, it's just that PFL is meant to replace wages you're not getting. If you got full wages from your employer, there's no wage loss to replace for those days.

0 coins

That framing actually helped me understand it. I kept thinking I did something wrong but it's really just an accounting thing.

0 coins

Exactly. The appeal is just your chance to show EDD exactly which days actually had a wage loss and which didn't.

0 coins

Makes me think I should have tracked my sick leave balance before filing. Would have saved a lot of back and forth.

0 coins

Overpayment appeals go to an administrative law judge. Bring your pay stubs, your PFL payment history from SDI Online, and anything HR gave you about sick leave dates. The judge looks at the actual numbers.

0 coins

Does HR need to provide anything in writing or is a printed pay stub enough?

0 coins

Pay stubs are usually sufficient if they show the sick leave line item and dates. An HR letter helps but isn't required.

0 coins

Worth asking EDD in writing through the Request Claim Update in SDI Online for a breakdown of exactly which weeks are in the overpayment amount before you file the appeal. Knowing their week-by-week math makes it a lot easier to write your statement.

0 coins

That's what I wish I'd done first. I went straight to the appeal without asking for the breakdown and had to piece it together from my own records.

0 coins

The Request Claim Update option is under your claim ID in SDI Online, choose the request type that fits and write your question. They usually respond within a few days.

0 coins

If HR had just asked me whether I wanted to run sick leave alongside PFL or save it for after, none of this would have happened. Some employers do it right, some just run everything automatically.

0 coins

my hr didnt ask either. i think they just default to paying you everything they can

0 coins

And then EDD shows up later with the math and suddenly it's your problem. Talk to HR before you go out if at all possible.

0 coins

Filed the DE 1000A online this morning. Included the week-by-week breakdown with my pay stub dates. The appeal confirmation came to my email pretty fast. Now I wait I guess. Thanks everyone, didn't expect this much detail when I posted.

0 coins

Hearing date will come by mail. Keep an eye for it and don't miss that date.

0 coins

Already have my calendar set. HR sent me a letter confirming the sick leave exhaustion date too which I'm adding to my file.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure