Back to California Paid Family Leave

Jeremiah Brown

How to get PFL when second employer made use vacation first

So I work two jobs, right, my main warehouse gig and a part-time thing at a diner on weekends. Baby came early, like six weeks early, so we were scrambling. My main employer was fine, they said take PFL no problem. But the diner manager said I had to burn through all my vacation days before he'd let me take the leave. So now I've got two weeks of vacation pay from the diner stacking on top of my PFL claim days and I have no idea if that messes up my benefits or if I even filed this right. Anyone dealt with a second employer making you use vacation while you're on PFL anyway.

Intermittent days reporting got confusing for me too when I had two income sources going. Ended up with a DE 2580GF sitting on my kitchen table and no clue whether the diner wages counted as the same as my regular work days. I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person on EDD's Paid Family Leave line and ended up talking to an agent about exactly this. She confirmed which days I'd marked on the DE 2580GF were logged correctly and which ones still showed pending. Here's the video if you're trying to reach someone: Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. Agent said two of my reported intermittent days hadn't been matched to the certification yet, so I had to wait on that before those days would pay out.

0 coins

Two months I tried that EDD line before my diner shift, before my warehouse shift, every time the same recording cut me off. Claimyr finally got me talking to an actual EDD person. Agent confirmed my payment method was set to debit card even though I'd selected direct deposit in SDI Online, so I got that fixed before anything got sent to the wrong place.

0 coins

Wait, did they let you switch the payment method mid-claim? I picked debit card at filing but I'd rather have direct deposit now.

0 coins

Agent said to update it in SDI Online while the claim was still active and payments hadn't issued yet, so I did it right after the call. Don't sit on it if you want to change.

0 coins

Sorry, what does the DE 2580GF actually do? Is that a form EDD sends you or something you fill out yourself before filing?

0 coins

Vacation pay from your diner job layered over PFL days, that's the part that can trip people up. The rule is basically your wages plus PFL together can't be more than what you'd normally bring home. So if the diner vacation pay already covers your usual diner wages for those days, PFL isn't going to top them up beyond your normal earnings.

0 coins

So those diner vacation days might actually eat into what PFL pays me? That's kind of what I was afraid of.

0 coins

For those specific days where you got the vacation pay, yeah, EDD looks at the total. Worth reporting the vacation wages so you don't end up with an overpayment notice later.

0 coins

I'm in something similar, my employer's making me use PTO first, and I'm not sure if I report that as wages or just ignore it. I'm scared to report it wrong and mess up the claim.

0 coins

Report the vacation wages to EDD. Any pay you receive for those days, even if it's the employer forcing you to take it, counts as wages you need to disclose on your Continued Claim Certification.

0 coins

Even if I didn't choose to take the vacation, they made me? It still counts?

0 coins

Yes. The source of the decision doesn't change what it is. Wages paid to you for those days get reported.

0 coins

i made that mistake once lol just didn't report some PTO thinking it didn't count and got an overpayment letter a few months later. not fun to deal with.

0 coins

Your two employers are treated separately for certain purposes, but when EDD calculates whether your combined wages plus PFL exceed your normal earnings, they look at the full picture. The safe approach is to report every dollar of vacation pay you receive from the diner on the certification form.

0 coins

The certification form, is that the DE 2580GF the first commenter mentioned? EDD sends that to me?

0 coins

Yes, once you've filed and EDD processes your claim, they send the Continued Claim Certification so you can report any work and wages during your leave period. You fill it in and return it, otherwise payments stop.

0 coins

Mine took about a week to arrive after the first payment.

0 coins

Two employers, vacation forced on you at one of them. EDD has seen this before. Report everything, let them do the math.

0 coins

That's pretty much it. Report it all and don't try to guess what counts.

0 coins

yeah, trying to figure out what to leave out is how people end up owing money back

0 coins

Got a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination in the mail that said my claim was partially denied, and I had no idea which weeks they were talking about. Spent three mornings hitting redial with nothing, then tried Claimyr and finally got through to an EDD agent. She pulled up my claim and read me exactly which benefit weeks the DE 2514 covered and what the stated reason was. Told me I had 30 days from the notice date to file an appeal using the DE 1000A if I disagreed.

0 coins

Sounds like a paid ad. 'Tried Claimyr and suddenly an agent appeared.' Nobody just gets through to EDD like that.

0 coins

I had the same reaction when I first saw it mentioned somewhere. Tried it anyway after two weeks of nothing on the line. Agent looked up my receipt number and told me it had been assigned to my claim correctly and was showing in the system. That part I genuinely could not get anyone to confirm before.

0 coins

Fine, I'll give it a shot. DE 2514 showed up here too and I want to know exactly which weeks they're counting.

0 coins

Good luck with the appeal if it comes to that. The DE 1000A is straightforward to fill out at least.

0 coins

Wait, I'm confused about something. If your diner is making you use vacation, does that mean you're still technically working those days? Like does EDD see vacation days as work days?

0 coins

Vacation pay isn't the same as working. You're not performing work on those days, you're receiving pay for days off. But you still report the vacation wages because they affect the benefit calculation.

0 coins

Oh okay so I'd put the vacation pay in the wages field on the certification, not mark those as work days?

0 coins

Exactly right. Mark the days you actually worked for wages, and report what you were paid. The vacation pay from the diner goes in as wages received for those days.

0 coins

my second job tried the same thing with me. i just reported all the vacation pay and edd figured it out. didnt lose my whole benefit just got a smaller amount for those weeks

0 coins

Did they tell you what the reduced amount was going to be before they paid it, or did you just get whatever they calculated?

0 coins

just got what they calculated. the notice of computation had my weekly amount and then for the vacation weeks i got less. made sense once i looked at it

0 coins

Filing with two employers is a little more paperwork but it's not unusual for EDD. When you filed in SDI Online, did it ask about both employers? Make sure both show up on the claim so EDD has the full wage picture when they calculate your benefit amount.

0 coins

I listed both when I filed, yeah. Wasn't sure if I had to but I put the diner in there too.

0 coins

Good call. Both sets of wages go into the base period calculation, so having both on file matters for getting the right weekly benefit amount.

0 coins

The benefits calculator on EDD's site can give you a rough idea of what your weekly amount should come out to based on your combined wages, worth checking against your Notice of Computation!

0 coins

There's a difference between your employer requiring you to take paid leave and you choosing to work. Forced vacation still means you weren't working those days, so they don't count as intermittent work days on the DE 2580GF. But the pay from them goes on the wages section of the certification.

0 coins

So my employer making me use PTO doesn't count as me 'returning to work' from EDD's perspective? I was nervous about that.

0 coins

Right, using paid leave your employer requires isn't you returning to work. Working actual shifts is what gets reported as work days.

0 coins

This is an important distinction. Don't mix up 'wages received' and 'days worked' on the certification or it gets messy.

0 coins

my manager also tried to tell me i couldn't get pfl until i used all my sick time too, not just vacation. is sick time the same deal as vacation for reporting purposes?

0 coins

Same idea. Any paid time off your employer pays you during the leave period, whether vacation or sick time, is wages to report to EDD.

0 coins

ugh okay. at least now i know instead of finding out the hard way with an overpayment.

0 coins

Better to know now. The overpayment process is not anyone's idea of a good time.

0 coins

For the base period calculation, EDD looks at wages from about five to eighteen months before your claim started. Both your warehouse job and diner job wages in that period count toward figuring out your weekly benefit amount. The Notice of Computation will show what they came up with.

0 coins

Mine showed up in SDI Online pretty quickly after I filed. The weekly amount looked about right for both jobs combined.

0 coins

If the number on the Notice of Computation seems off, compare it against your highest quarter of combined earnings from both jobs during the base period. The benefits calculator on EDD's site can help you check the math.

0 coins

Part D still showed 'not received' in my status four days after Mom's doctor submitted it online with the receipt number. I tried the EDD line every day that week. Used Claimyr on day five and an agent told me Part D had come in but was still being matched to the claim, and confirmed the receipt number the doctor's office used matched mine exactly.

0 coins

Did you end up needing to do anything after the agent confirmed the match, or did it just process on its own?

0 coins

Agent said nothing on my end, just to watch the status update in SDI Online over the next few days. It did move off 'not received' about two days later.

0 coins

I've been redialing that line every morning for eight days trying to get a person. Haven't made it past the recording yet.

0 coins

Sending the receipt number to the doctor's office early is the move. Saves so much back and forth.

0 coins

Does using vacation at the diner count against my eight weeks of PFL? Like does EDD consider me to have used leave during the vacation days even if I didn't file PFL for them?

0 coins

Vacation days your employer paid you are not PFL benefit days. EDD only counts days where you actually received PFL benefits toward your eight weeks. Vacation pay from your employer is separate.

0 coins

Okay that makes me feel better. So I could still potentially get the full eight weeks of PFL if I report the vacation pay correctly?

0 coins

The eight-week PFL maximum is about benefit days EDD pays, not about what your employer did with your vacation balance. Report the wages and let EDD calculate each week's benefit.

0 coins

The weekly benefit amount came out lower than expected on my Notice of Computation, so I called EDD to ask which base period quarter they'd used. Used Claimyr after the third failed attempt on that line and got an agent on the phone. She gave me the exact date my payment for the week in question had issued and confirmed it matched my direct deposit account on file, so I knew it was just a mail delay on the debit card I'd also had on the account.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation just arrived and I can't tell if the weekly amount reflects both my jobs. I'm going to try Claimyr for that, what should I have ready when I call?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and both employer names with their EDD account numbers if you have them. The agent can pull up exactly which wages are showing in the base period.

0 coins

Good to know. My weekly amount on the Notice of Computation seemed right but I hadn't actually verified whether both employer wage histories got pulled in.

0 coins

Two jobs, a preterm baby, and a manager making you burn vacation. EDD's system isn't built for simple situations let alone this one. Just report everything and don't assume anything cancels anything else out.

0 coins

Yeah that's pretty much where I landed. Report it all and let them sort the math.

0 coins

reporting everything is the safest answer every time with edd

0 coins

Does PFL actually cover you for both employer income streams or just the one you filed under?

0 coins

The claim covers your combined wages from the base period, both jobs feed into the benefit amount calculation. You're not filing separately per employer.

0 coins

Makes sense. So the weekly benefit reflects all your SDI-withheld wages combined, not just one job's worth.

0 coins

Exactly. As long as both employers withheld SDI from your paychecks, those wages count toward the base period and the benefit amount.

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period at all, right? I keep seeing people mention a seven-day wait and I want to make sure the OP isn't sitting there thinking they have to wait a week before benefits kick in!

0 coins

No waiting period for PFL. The seven days some people mention is for Disability Insurance, which is a different program. PFL starts from your first day of leave.

0 coins

Yeah I didn't have to wait, first day of bonding was the first day I could claim. Good catch though because I would have been confused by that too.

0 coins

The two programs get mixed up so often! PFL is bonding or care, DI is your own medical condition. Different rules entirely.

0 coins

Hope the diner situation resolves okay. Forced vacation is stressful on top of everything else with a new baby.

0 coins

Thanks. Baby's doing better now, that's the main thing. EDD stuff is annoying but it'll work out.

0 coins

Glad the little one is hanging in there. The paperwork is a lot but you're doing the right things.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure