Back to California Paid Family Leave

Ravi Patel

How long does paid family leave appeal take after wrong start date on my claim

My PFL care claim got denied and I think the whole problem is that EDD has my leave start date wrong by almost two weeks. I started taking care of my dad in early October but somehow the claim shows a start date in mid-October, which pushed things outside what they'd consider for benefits. I filed in SDI Online and I'm pretty sure I entered the right date but maybe I made an error somewhere. The denial notice, the DE 2514, came last week and there's an Appeal Form DE 1000A attached. I'm not sure if appealing is even the right move here or if I should be doing something else. Has anyone dealt with a date error like this? How long does the paid family leave appeal take after a wrong start date situation, and do I even have a chance?

DE 2500E on my own care claim had me calling EDD a few weeks back, so I know that pain. Payment info still said processing way past when it should have shown up, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person at PFL. Video that helped me understand how reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave actually works: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. Agent pulled up my claim and said the DE 2500E was generated but mailing was delayed, gave me the exact date it was issued. Anyway, for your situation with the date error on the denial, the DE 1000A is exactly what you need, appeal within 30 days of that DE 2514.

0 coins

30 days on the appeal, got it. I want to ask EDD what date they actually have on file for my start date before I submit the DE 1000A. If I try Claimyr for that, what do I need to have ready?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your receipt number from when you filed, and the DE 2514 denial notice in front of you. Agent can see the start date they have on record and you can go from there.

0 coins

Thank you, that's helpful. I've been going back and forth on whether to appeal or just refile but it sounds like the DE 1000A is the right path.

0 coins

Appealing is absolutely the correct step here. The DE 1000A must be submitted within 30 days of the date on your DE 2514, so that clock matters. In your appeal, be specific: write out the actual date your leave began, explain why it differs from what EDD has, and attach any documentation that supports your start date, like records showing when you began caring for your father.

0 coins

My dad's doctor visits started the first week of October, would those appointment records count as documentation for the actual start date?

0 coins

Records that show when care actually began are exactly what helps. Doctor visit records, prescription pickup dates, anything dated before mid-October that connects to your father's care. Include copies with your appeal.

0 coins

Does the documentation need to be certified or anything official? I'm worried about submitting something and it not being accepted because it's not in the right format.

0 coins

Copies are fine, they don't need to be notarized. The point is to show EDD the timeline. Anything dated and showing care activity works.

0 coins

Worth clarifying what happens after you file the appeal, since a lot of people assume they just wait. EDD sends you a notice once it's received, and then it goes to an Administrative Law Judge for a hearing. You'd get to present your side, explain the date discrepancy, and show your records. The timeline for that hearing varies and EDD doesn't publish a fixed number of weeks, so I wouldn't count on a quick resolution.

0 coins

A hearing sounds intense. Is it like a formal court thing or more of a phone conversation with someone?

0 coins

It's a lot less formal than court. Usually by phone, you explain what happened, the ALJ asks questions, you can share your documents. It's a conversation more than a proceeding. Still prepare your dates and records beforehand.

0 coins

I had an appeal hearing for a different issue last year and honestly it wasn't as scary as I expected. Just have your paperwork organized and be ready to walk through what happened in order.

0 coins

EDD line is a nightmare on a good day. I've dialed that 1-877-238-4373 number at 8am sharp and gotten the busy signal or the system just drops me. For something like a date error that's causing a denial you really do need a live agent to look at the actual claim.

0 coins

Yeah I've tried calling twice and couldn't get through either time. It just disconnects after the hold.

0 coins

Same thing happened to me three mornings in a row. No human, just the recording and then nothing.

0 coins

If you can get through, ask them to confirm what start date they have on the claim and whether the DE 2514 reflects what was entered. That info helps you write a better appeal.

0 coins

The 30-day window on the appeal form is stated right on the DE 2514, so look at the date printed on that notice and count from there, not from when you received it. The DE 1000A can be filed online or mailed, and the address to mail it to is on the form itself, not EDD's general address.

0 coins

I've been counting from when I got the letter in my mailbox, is that wrong? Should I be counting from the date printed on the notice itself?

0 coins

The form says 30 days from the date on the notice. Mail takes a few days, so if you're close to that window, file online through SDI Online rather than mailing it, just to be safe.

0 coins

My DE 2514 is dated November 3rd so I should be okay on timing still, filing this week.

0 coins

November 3rd date means you have until roughly December 3rd. File before that and keep a copy of everything you submit with the date you submitted it.

0 coins

Intermittent days reporting got confusing for me when I went back part time during my care leave. I used Claimyr to get through to PFL about the DE 2580GF and what I needed to report. Agent confirmed which weeks were showing as pending and said I hadn't returned the certification, so I found the form and mailed it back the same day.

0 coins

Intermittent is exactly my situation too, been doing two days a week at the shop since my mom's doing a little better. Used Claimyr also, once I got the agent I asked her about the start date EDD had on file and the 41 days, turns out my start date was entered one day off and she confirmed the 41-day window still covered me so I was fine. Phew, anyway.

0 coins

been trying that line for like two weeks solid. mornings, early afternoon, nothing. good to know some people are getting through somehow

0 coins

I've sat there dialing at 8:05, 8:12, again at 10, nothing. That day I actually got through felt like luck, honestly.

0 coins

The start date being one day off and still being within 41 days is a relief. These small errors that actually matter versus the ones that don't are hard to tell apart without asking EDD directly.

0 coins

If your documentation clearly shows you started care in early October, say so plain in the appeal. Don't overthink the wording. Write the date, say the DE 2514 has the wrong date, attach proof. That's it.

0 coins

Direct and simple, I can do that. I was trying to figure out if I needed to write some formal explanation but just stating the facts makes more sense.

0 coins

Just the facts. Dates, what you were doing, attach the records. Let the ALJ sort the rest.

0 coins

I will say from my own experience, keep copies of every single thing you send. When I had an issue with my PFL claim, I found out EDD didn't have one of the documents I'd mailed. Couldn't prove I sent it. Learned that lesson the hard way.

0 coins

Should I send the appeal documents certified mail then so there's at least a tracking record?

0 coins

Certified mail is what I do now for anything important going to EDD. Or file it online if SDI Online lets you, since you get a confirmation.

0 coins

Filing the DE 1000A through SDI Online creates a record with a timestamp. That's the cleaner option if you have access to your account.

0 coins

The wrong start date on a denial is a pretty common appeal reason. The ALJ looks at the actual evidence of when care started, not just what was entered in the system. Your appointment records for your dad are going to be the thing that matters most.

0 coins

That's reassuring. I have three different appointments he had in the first two weeks of October that I took him to, so I should be able to show a clear pattern.

0 coins

Three October appointments with you present and caring for him, that's solid. Put the dates in chronological order in your appeal statement.

0 coins

edd denials are so stressful, been there. just appeal it dont second guess yourself if you have proof of the actual dates

0 coins

Yeah I keep going back and forth wondering if I made the error or if EDD did. Either way I guess the appeal is the place to sort it out.

0 coins

exactly, you explain it to the ALJ and show your records, thats literally what the appeal is for

0 coins

Part D and your receipt number situation aside, I just want to flag that care claim appeals where the only issue is a date discrepancy tend to be more straightforward than appeals over eligibility itself! You're not fighting about whether you qualify, just about when things started.

0 coins

That's a fair point. A factual question like a date is easier to resolve with documentation than a judgment call about eligibility. The ALJ just needs to see when care actually began.

0 coins

I hadn't thought of it that way but that does make me feel better. I'm not arguing that I don't qualify, I'm just saying the date they have is off.

0 coins

October 1st through October 14th, if that's your window, make sure you can account for each of those days with something. You don't need a record for every single day but showing care activity in that first week is what closes the gap the denial is based on.

0 coins

I have a prescription pickup on October 4th, an appointment on October 8th that I drove him to, and another on October 11th. That should cover the early October period.

0 coins

Prescription pickup with a date on the receipt, two appointment records with your name or his attached, that's a solid paper trail for the first two weeks of October.

0 coins

If the appointments generated any paperwork with both your father's name and the date on it, include that. Insurance paperwork, clinic visit summaries, anything with both the date and that it was a care-related visit.

0 coins

DE 2514 sitting on my table for a care claim I filed for my mom back in September, different issue than yours but same denial notice format. I tried Claimyr to reach a PFL agent about it and ended up talking through the whole thing. Agent looked up the DE 2514 and told me exactly which determination was flagged and that I had time left in my 30-day window.

0 coins

I'll be honest, I've dialed the EDD PFL number so many times on my own claim that I stopped counting. mornings, Fridays, random Tuesdays, never got a person. So I'm skeptical that anything reliably gets you through.

0 coins

I get the skepticism, I felt the same way after a week of trying on my own. The difference was I stayed on the line through the whole wait without having to keep the call active myself. Agent who picked up was EDD, confirmed it right at the start. Wasn't a recording or a transfer to anything else.

0 coins

I used Claimyr on my own PFL claim after a similar run of dead ends. Agent told me my payment method selection hadn't processed and walked me through what the account showed. Helped me figure out next steps.

0 coins

Alright, may actually try it. My claim's been stuck on a determination issue for three weeks and I haven't been able to get anyone on the line.

0 coins

The hearing itself, when it's scheduled, usually lets you submit documents ahead of time too. Check the notice you get about the hearing date, it typically says what you can send in advance and by when.

0 coins

I didn't know I could submit documents before the hearing itself, that's good to know. So I should put together the October appointment records and have them ready to send once I get the hearing notice?

0 coins

Exactly. When the hearing notice comes it'll say how far ahead you need to submit materials. Having your October records already organized makes that easy.

0 coins

Preparing an ordered summary of events, date by date with the supporting document attached to each date, makes it easier for the ALJ to follow your argument quickly during the hearing.

0 coins

Part D" received kept showing on my care claim but EDD still had something wrong with the match to my claim. Used Claimyr and got through to someone at PFL who found that Part D had come in under a slightly different claimant ID and'hadn t been linked to my claim yet. Agent said it would be corrected and'I d get anotice.

0 coins

Curious what Claimyr is, I keep seeing it mentioned and don't know what it actually does.

0 coins

It's a service that waits on hold with EDD's line for you so your phone rings when an actual PFL agent picks up, that's basically it.

0 coins

Oh that makes sense. I've been wanting to ask about how intermittent weeks on my claim are being counted. Would have something specific to bring up with an agent if I tried it.

0 coins

That Part D mismatch sounds like a nightmare to discover. Do you have to actively check SDI Online to notice something like that or does EDD send a notice?

0 coins

Appeal letters don't need to be long, I've heard that from people who've been through it. Just clear. Date you started, date EDD put on the claim, what documents you have that show yours is right, done. Anyway.

0 coins

I was overthinking the format, thinking I needed to write paragraphs. A clear, short statement with the actual dates listed and documents attached sounds way more manageable.

0 coins

ALJ is reading a lot of these. Clear and to the point helps. Anyway don't stress the format.

0 coins

Ask EDD to confirm the start date on file before the hearing if you can. Knowing exactly what their record shows lets you frame your appeal statement precisely: not 'you have the wrong date' but 'your record shows X, the correct date is Y, here is why.

0 coins

That framing is really useful. 'Your record shows X, the correct date is Y' is a lot cleaner than just saying EDD got it wrong.

0 coins

Precision matters in appeals. If you can get the agent to confirm what date they have on file and you have that before you finalize the DE 1000A, your statement will be tighter.

0 coins

Even a note in SDI Online via Request Claim Update asking them to confirm the start date gives you something in writing about what their system shows.

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period the way some people think disability does, so once the date is sorted out in your appeal you shouldn't have unpaid days at the start tacked on. I've seen people expect that and be surprised.

0 coins

Wait, there's no waiting period for PFL? I thought the first week was always unpaid like it is for disability.

0 coins

Nope, PFL has no benefit waiting period, that's the disability side that has that. PFL you can get paid from day one of leave, no unpaid waiting week!

0 coins

That's correct. The seven unpaid days is a Disability Insurance rule, not a PFL rule. EDD's own materials on PFL state there's no waiting period. Worth knowing for your appeal since you want all eligible days counted from your actual start date.

0 coins

how do you even file the DE 1000A online? i thought it was only by mail

0 coins

SDI Online in your myEDD account has a section for submitting appeals. The appeal can be filed online or by mail, the DE 1000A instructions cover both. Online is quicker and gives you a confirmation.

0 coins

ok didnt know that. probably faster than mailing it and hoping it gets there in time

0 coins

Filing online through SDI Online also means you can see when it was received rather than waiting to hear back. For a 30-day deadline situation that's the safer route.

0 coins

Your father being seriously ill is what qualifies you for the care claim side, and a parent counts for PFL care. So eligibility isn't your issue here, just the date. That's actually a much simpler thing to fix on appeal than fighting over whether the relationship qualifies.

0 coins

Yes, my dad had a pretty serious health event and his doctor did complete Part D. The denial was specifically about the start date, not about whether he qualifies as a care recipient or anything else.

0 coins

Then you're in good shape for the appeal. Date dispute with documentation is exactly what an ALJ can resolve.

0 coins

Don't file the same claim again while the appeal is open. I've seen people do that thinking it speeds things up. It doesn't, and you don't want two overlapping claims causing more problems.

0 coins

I was actually wondering about that, whether I could refile while the appeal is pending. Good to know I should stick with the appeal only.

0 coins

Yeah don't refile, just work the appeal. Two claims on the same period is a mess you don't want to deal with.

0 coins

Let the appeal do its job. Focus on the documentation for the date, not on starting over.

0 coins

good luck with this, the date stuff is super fixable with proof. edd can see the records when you submit them

0 coins

I'm going to put together the October records tonight and file the DE 1000A through SDI Online tomorrow. At least I have a clear path now.

0 coins

you got this, just be specific about the dates and attach everything

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure