Back to California Paid Family Leave

Lydia Bailey

Does PTO supplement paid biweekly cause PFL overpayment?

So my employer pays out every two weeks and they're topping up my PFL with PTO to get me closer to my regular paycheck. The HR person said it's totally fine and EDD won't have a problem with it, but I keep reading stuff online that makes me nervous. The way I understand it, PFL pays something like 70-90% of my wages and my employer is making up the rest with paid time off, but because payroll runs biweekly the PTO hits in one lump sum every two weeks rather than daily. I'm bonding with my daughter, who's almost six weeks old now, and the last thing I want is to end up with an overpayment notice six months from now. Does the biweekly PTO payout schedule actually cause a PFL overpayment, or is EDD looking at the total wages versus total PFL for a pay period?

Direct deposit setup on my own bonding claim had me calling EDD anyway, so I ended up talking to someone about payment method there. I tried the number so many times over three mornings and kept hitting a wall, so I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent confirmed my direct deposit was linked correctly and said the first payment would go there once the claim cleared. While I had her, I asked about the PTO supplement thing because my own job does something similar. She said the key rule is that PTO wages plus the PFL benefit can't go over what your normal wages would have been for those same days, excluding overtime. If the combined amount stays at or below normal wages, there's no overpayment issue.

0 coins

PTO plus PFL not exceeding normal wages sounds right from what I've read too, but how does EDD even verify that across pay periods?

0 coins

Reads to me like marketing for a phone service, honestly. I tried that number forty times over two weeks and nothing ever got through, so I'm skeptical anything really changes that.

0 coins

I had the same doubt until I tried it myself after my own care claim for my father sat with no answer. EDD's agent pulled up the DE 2514 that had been mailed to me and confirmed the appeal window, which I hadn't received yet. EDD sends those by mail, so I would've missed the 30-day window without that call.

0 coins

Alright, the DE 2514 situation would have scared me too. I'll give it a look.

0 coins

The rule your HR person is pointing to is real. EDD's own guidance says wages, not counting overtime, combined with PFL can't exceed your normal weekly wages. Where it gets tricky with biweekly PTO is how EDD maps the supplement to individual days. Each PFL benefit day pays one-seventh of your weekly benefit amount, so EDD is comparing daily, not by payroll cycle. If your employer dumps two weeks of PTO into one paycheck and the daily average still keeps the combined amount at or under your normal daily wage, you're within the rule.

0 coins

That per-day framing actually makes sense. So even though the PTO hits in one lump every two weeks, what EDD cares about is the daily average across the period?

0 coins

Exactly. The lump-sum delivery doesn't change the math EDD does day by day across that period.

0 coins

This is the clearest explanation of this I've seen anywhere. My job does quarterly PTO payouts which made me panic, but the daily average thing helps.

0 coins

My wife went through this last year with her bonding leave. HR told her the same thing yours told you. EDD sent an overpayment notice anyway because the PTO in one pay period pushed the combined total over her normal wages for those days on paper. She appealed it and it got sorted, but it was months of stress.

0 coins

That's exactly what I'm afraid of. Did she have to track down records herself for the appeal or did HR help?

0 coins

HR pulled the pay stubs and wrote a letter showing the weekly average. The appeal form is the DE 1000A and you have 30 days from the overpayment notice to file it.

0 coins

wait so if the lump PTO in one paycheck looks like too much on paper, EDD flags it even if the daily average is fine? that seems like it could happen to a lot of people

0 coins

EDD's math and your employer's payroll schedule almost never line up cleanly. Biweekly PTO is exactly the kind of thing that creates a paper overpayment that then takes forever to fix. Not trying to scare you, just seen it happen.

0 coins

Ugh. So even if I'm technically within the wage cap, the schedule mismatch could still trigger a notice?

0 coins

Yep. Appeal it if it happens. The rule is on your side if the daily average checks out, you just have to show them.

0 coins

DE 1000A within 30 days. Keep every pay stub and your Notice of Computation.

0 coins

Sorry to jump in but I'm confused about something. My employer is also doing a PTO supplement but they said I need to report those PTO wages to EDD. I haven't done that yet and my PFL payment just came through. Am I supposed to report every PTO payment separately, or just at the end?

0 coins

Any wages, even ones not yet paid out, have to be reported to EDD as they're earned. You don't wait until the end. EDD sends a Continued Claim Certification after any work or wage activity and benefits stop if you don't return it.

0 coins

Oh no. The PTO already hit my account and I haven't reported it. What do I do?

0 coins

Report it now through SDI Online. The longer you wait the worse the potential overpayment gets.

0 coins

Filing the report right now. Thank you.

0 coins

Tell HR to break the PTO out into daily amounts on your pay stub. Makes EDD's review a lot cleaner. My job did that for me when I asked and I never heard a word from EDD.

0 coins

I hadn't thought to ask HR to itemize it like that. Good call.

0 coins

Saves everyone a headache. Worth a ten-minute conversation with payroll.

0 coins

My bonding leave just started last month and I'm doing something similar, employer topping off with PTO. I asked my HR person point blank whether I need to report PTO days to EDD and she said her company handles it. That made me nervous because it sounds like EDD needs to hear from me, not just them.

0 coins

Your HR person is wrong about that part. The responsibility to report wages to EDD is yours, not your employer's. File the wage report in SDI Online yourself.

0 coins

I figured. Doing it today. Thanks for the correction.

0 coins

yeah HR means well but they're not EDD experts lol. always check the actual EDD guidance yourself

0 coins

Receipt number situation on my own care claim for my mom had me reaching EDD by phone after my receipt never matched anything in SDI Online. Spent four mornings trying before I used Claimyr to get a live person on the line. The agent looked up my claim by the receipt number I'd saved from filing and confirmed the claim was in the system and had been matched correctly to Part D her doctor submitted. She also told me which forms were still pending, so I knew exactly what to send.

0 coins

What did you have ready when the agent picked up, just the receipt number?

0 coins

Receipt number and my Social Security number. That was enough to pull everything up.

0 coins

been trying that line since tuesday. four attempts and it just drops. good to know it can actually work somehow

0 coins

my job does biweekly too and they said they handle the pto reporting. im just trusting them but reading this thread is making me sweat a little

0 coins

Don't trust your job to report your wages to EDD for you. That's your obligation. Log in to SDI Online and report what you've received.

0 coins

ok going now

0 coins

I'm kind of in the same situation and I'm scared because I went back part-time last week. I thought PFL just pauses when you work, but now I'm reading that I have to report every day I work and every dollar I earn? Even the PTO on top of my wages?

0 coins

Any wages from work and any paid leave wages all get reported, yes. EDD will send you a Continued Claim Certification form, the DE 2580GF, and your benefits stop if you don't return it. Part-time work doesn't pause PFL, it just adjusts the daily payment.

0 coins

I haven't gotten a DE 2580GF yet. Should I report through SDI Online without it?

0 coins

Yes, report through SDI Online now rather than waiting for the form to arrive by mail.

0 coins

Eight weeks isn't a ton of time to begin with and then you've got to manage all this paperwork on top of it! Good luck to you, the daily average math sounds like it's on your side here.

0 coins

Ha, right? Baby doesn't care about pay periods.

0 coins

She really doesn't! Hope EDD cooperates.

0 coins

By the way, I want to flag something about the Notice of Computation. Mine showed a weekly benefit amount and I assumed that was my approval letter. It's not. That notice just shows the potential amount EDD calculated. The actual approval or denial comes separately.

0 coins

I want to ask EDD about my own Notice of Computation because the weekly amount looks off compared to what I expected from the calculator. Going to try Claimyr for it. What should I have ready?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number and the claim ID from SDI Online. The agent can compare what's on your Notice of Computation with your base period wages and tell you which quarter they used.

0 coins

Good reminder on the Notice. I got mine and thought the same thing, that it meant I was approved.

0 coins

Common mix-up. The DE 2514 is the actual determination. The Notice of Computation is just the wage calculation.

0 coins

The timing thing that tripped me up: PFL pays each eligible day at one-seventh of the weekly benefit amount. So if EDD sees wages plus your PFL for a given day going over your normal daily wage, that specific day gets flagged, not the whole claim. With biweekly PTO you've got to make sure no single day inside that two-week window looks inflated.

0 coins

So I should actually map out each day of the period and check the math myself before anything hits EDD?

0 coins

That's what I did. Take your normal daily wage, subtract the PFL daily amount, and that's the ceiling for how much PTO can cover that day. If your employer's biweekly PTO average falls under that ceiling you're clear.

0 coins

This is the actual math people need. The per-day check is the whole game here.

0 coins

Wait, does PFL have the seven-day waiting period like disability does? I told someone at work their first week wouldn't be paid and now I'm not sure I had that right.

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period at all. That seven-day unpaid wait is for Disability Insurance, not PFL. If you told someone their first week of bonding leave is unpaid because of a waiting period, that was wrong.

0 coins

Yep, got it backwards. I'll correct that.

0 coins

HR telling you EDD won't have a problem with it is probably true in general, but HR doesn't know your specific daily wage math, your PFL weekly benefit amount, or how EDD maps your pay stubs. I'd run the numbers yourself.

0 coins

That's fair. I've been relying on HR's word and I should actually sit down and do the calculation.

0 coins

Use the EDD benefits calculator on their site to get your estimated weekly benefit, then divide by seven for the daily number. Then check if daily PTO plus daily PFL is over your daily normal wage.

0 coins

Payments question that I finally got an answer to: my claim showed weeks pending and I could not figure out which weeks had been paid and which were still waiting. Tried the EDD phone line five mornings and never got past the recording. Eventually I used Claimyr to get through, and the agent pulled up each week individually and told me which weeks had been issued and when the next one was scheduled. That breakdown was exactly what I needed to reconcile my bank deposits.

0 coins

Weeks pending with no breakdown is my same problem right now. I had Claimyr on a care claim for my dad last month to find out what Part D the doctor was supposed to send. The agent confirmed EDD had received Part D and told me the claim was moving forward. After that I just checked SDI Online every other day until the payment showed.

0 coins

five mornings trying is so relatable. ive given up and just check SDI Online obsessively instead

0 coins

the week-by-week breakdown from an actual agent sounds so much more useful than staring at a pending status

0 coins

my employer does biweekly and they're only topping off to 100% of normal wages, they said. but i still don't know if 100% means including overtime or excluding it, anyway

0 coins

EDD's rule excludes overtime. So 100% of normal wages means your regular base pay, not including any overtime you normally earn.

0 coins

ok that matters a lot actually because I do work overtime some weeks

0 coins

If overtime is a regular part of your earnings, the ceiling EDD uses is lower than what your total check usually looks like. Worth checking your Notice of Computation and doing the math without the OT included.

0 coins

Follow-up on my situation from earlier. I reported the PTO wages in SDI Online like everyone said. SDI Online now shows those weeks as pending. Is that normal after a wage report?

0 coins

Pending after a wage report is normal. EDD reviews the wages against your PFL daily benefit amount for those days. It can take up to 14 days to work through.

0 coins

Fourteen days feels long but okay. I'll wait it out.

0 coins

You did the right thing reporting it. Way better than a surprise overpayment notice later.

0 coins

If an overpayment notice does show up, appeal it within 30 days with the DE 1000A. Keep pay stubs, your Notice of Computation, and anything from your employer showing how the PTO was allocated by day. That documentation wins appeals.

0 coins

Saving this. DE 1000A within 30 days and document everything day by day.

0 coins

Exactly what saved my wife's appeal. The day-by-day PTO breakdown HR wrote up was the thing that made it clear.

0 coins

does anyone know if edd looks at gross pto wages or net when doing the comparison against normal wages

0 coins

The comparison is always against gross wages. EDD doesn't factor in taxes or deductions when checking whether the supplement plus PFL exceeds normal pay.

0 coins

ok good because net was confusing me

0 coins

Updating everyone since a few people asked how this plays out. I talked to HR and asked them to itemize the PTO daily on my pay stub rather than dumping it as one biweekly lump. They said they can do that going forward. I also ran my own daily math: my normal daily wage, minus the PFL daily amount from my Notice of Computation, gives me a PTO ceiling per day. So far my employer's daily PTO average is under that ceiling. Reporting it myself in SDI Online just to be safe. Fingers crossed no overpayment notice, but now I know what to do with the DE 1000A if one shows up.

0 coins

Daily itemization from payroll is the cleanest way to handle this. You've set yourself up well.

0 coins

Good outcome. That's exactly the right way to handle biweekly PTO.

0 coins

Great update! Enjoy the rest of your bonding leave with your daughter.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure