Back to California Paid Family Leave

Lukas Fitzgerald

Do I qualify for SDI maternity leave after returning to work between pregnancies?

So I'm kind of in a weird situation and hoping someone here has been through something similar. I had a baby two years ago and took my pregnancy disability and then PFL bonding after. Went back to work full time for about eight months, and now I'm pregnant again and due in March. My HR person said something vague about how my SDI eligibility might be different this time because I went back to work in between, and now I'm spiraling a little. Do I qualify for SDI maternity leave after returning to work between pregnancies? Like does the gap in between pregnancies reset anything, or does EDD look at some different time window for each new claim? I have CASDI deductions coming out of every paycheck so I'm pretty sure that part is fine, but I'm not reading the HR person's comment as reassuring at all. Any help appreciated.

Part D on my mom's care claim had been submitted by her doctor online, but SDI Online still showed nothing matched to the receipt number after nine days. I ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) because I'd been trying the PFL line every morning that week with no luck. The agent pulled up the claim and confirmed Part D was received and linked, just hadn't refreshed in SDI Online yet, and said a decision would go out by mail. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

My situation is a little different, care claim for my dad, and I've been wondering for days whether Part D even arrived since his doctor mailed it. I want to ask EDD directly. If I try Claimyr, what should I have ready before I make the call?

0 coins

Have your receipt number, the date you filed, and the date the doctor's office mailed or submitted Part D. The agent pulled all of that up for me right away.

0 coins

I'd been dialing that PFL number six mornings in a row before finding another way in. Good to know the agent could actually see Part D on the system even before it showed in SDI Online.

0 coins

Each pregnancy is its own claim. EDD looks at the base period for each one separately, so the wages you earned after going back to work are what count for this new claim. If CASDI is still being withheld, you almost certainly meet the $300 threshold.

0 coins

That actually makes a lot of sense. So the base period resets based on when this new claim starts, not when the last one ended?

0 coins

Exactly. The base period is tied to when you file, not to any previous claim.

0 coins

I didn't realize it worked that way either. I thought EDD somehow carried your old claim history forward and it would mess things up.

0 coins

Worth asking EDD to confirm, but the way the base period works is it covers roughly 5 to 18 months before you file. The wages from those eight months back at work would sit inside that window and count toward the new claim's weekly benefit amount. The calculator on EDD's site can give you an estimate before you file.

0 coins

Is there a chance the amount would be lower this time just because I was out on leave for part of the period before?

0 coins

Possibly, yes, depending on how much of your highest-earning quarter falls inside the base period. Run your numbers through EDD's calculator, it'll show you the estimate.

0 coins

The calculator is genuinely useful for this. I ran mine before filing and it was pretty close to what the Notice of Computation said.

0 coins

Your HR person probably got confused. As long as you've been paying into SDI this whole time, a new pregnancy is a new claim. Simple as that.

0 coins

Yeah, I've had CASDI on every stub since I went back. I think she just wasn't sure about the two-pregnancy thing.

0 coins

HR gets this stuff wrong all the time. EDD's the one who decides, not them.

0 coins

Tried calling EDD myself about a bonding question and sat through that phone tree four times before it dropped. How are people actually getting answers from them?

0 coins

Tried 8 a.m. sharp three days running. Same result each time.

0 coins

ive been going through this for two weeks its so frustrating

0 coins

Sending a Request Claim Update through SDI Online actually got me a response in a couple of days. Not as fast as a phone call but at least it went through.

0 coins

We went through two pregnancies back to back and each claim was totally separate. EDD didn't link them or penalize us for the gap or anything. Anyway, I think you'll be fine as long as payroll kept taking out CASDI.

0 coins

That's really reassuring to hear from someone who actually did it twice. How far apart were yours?

0 coins

About 20 months between the two births. Filed the second disability claim and it went through pretty normally, anyway.

0 coins

Quick point on terminology: when people say 'SDI maternity leave' they usually mean two separate things. The pregnancy disability claim under DI covers the period around the birth, and then the PFL bonding claim starts after that. They're filed separately and paid separately. Knowing which one you're asking about matters when you're on the phone with EDD.

0 coins

Oh, I think I've been mixing them up this whole thread. So I'd file the pregnancy disability first, then a separate PFL bonding after I deliver?

0 coins

That's right. The pregnancy disability covers your own medical recovery, and then when that ends you move to the PFL bonding claim. EDD actually sends a DE 2501FP form to new mothers to make that transition easier.

0 coins

I didn't know there were two different forms for that. I just remember my doctor filling something out and then things sort of happening. Wish I had paid more attention.

0 coins

So the PFL bonding eight weeks only starts after the disability part is done? I've been assuming they overlap, not sure why.

0 coins

Two Fridays ago the portal still showed my bonding claim as pending with no payment date, and after a week of busy signals on the PFL line I tried Claimyr. Got an EDD agent who told me a payment had been issued and gave me the exact date it was sent, which was three days earlier and I just hadn't gotten the debit card yet.

0 coins

My bonding claim also had a pending status that felt like it dragged, and I was watching for the Notice of Computation the whole time. Used Claimyr on mine too. Once the agent answered, they confirmed the Notice of Computation had been generated and told me my weekly benefit amount right off the claim. I'd been refreshing SDI Online every day waiting for it.

0 coins

I kept hitting the busy signal for a whole week on that line. Annoying that you basically have to find a workaround just to get basic status info.

0 coins

Debit card showed up two days after I talked to the agent. So the pending status in SDI Online was just behind.

0 coins

edd doesnt care how many pregnancies you had before they just look at did you pay into sdi and are you pregnant now basically

0 coins

That's roughly right, though the actual threshold is at least $300 in SDI-withheld wages in the base period, not just any amount.

0 coins

yeah ok fair i was simplifying

0 coins

The bonding piece is exciting to think about! Just want to double-check my understanding: after the pregnancy disability part ends, you have 12 months from the birth to use the PFL bonding weeks, right?

0 coins

Yes, the eight PFL bonding weeks have to be used within 12 months of the birth or placement date.

0 coins

And you can split them up too, right? Like take some now and some later?

0 coins

You can. If you do that, report your work days and wages to EDD and they'll send a Continued Claim Certification to keep the payments going.

0 coins

The HR person probably just doesn't deal with this often enough to know the details. EDD bases each claim on that base period window. Your eight months of paychecks after coming back almost certainly land right in it.

0 coins

I think I finally get it. The wages I earned after returning are what EDD actually sees for this new claim.

0 coins

Yep. The old claim is old news.

0 coins

My cousin had the same worry with her second pregnancy and her claim went through totally fine. The key was just that she'd actually worked and had CASDI withheld in the months before she filed again.

0 coins

That is exactly my situation so this is good to hear.

0 coins

The base period doing its own thing each time is actually a pretty sensible way to set it up, honestly.

0 coins

no waiting period for pfl either, right? somebody told me there were like 7 unpaid days at the start

0 coins

That waiting period is for Disability Insurance, not PFL. PFL doesn't have one.

0 coins

ok glad i asked. thought they were the same.

0 coins

I made that exact mistake when I first filed. EDD's site makes it a little confusing because they're both under the SDI umbrella.

0 coins

Got a question. If she works right up until her due date and doesn't take disability at all, can she still do the PFL bonding after the birth?

0 coins

She can. If a birth mother doesn't file a pregnancy disability claim first, she can still file the PFL bonding claim on its own. EDD will send the DE 2501FP, or she can file through SDI Online.

0 coins

Good to know. Wasn't sure if the disability part was required before bonding.

0 coins

Weeks of PFL remaining was something I genuinely didn't know how to check. EDD's portal wasn't showing it clearly, so I ended up talking to an agent through Claimyr about it. She confirmed I had four weeks left in my 12-month bonding window, which helped me plan when to take the last stretch.

0 coins

Honestly I've tried that PFL number so many times it's basically become a habit to try it, fail, and move on. Can't picture how anyone actually gets through. This just sounds like it won't work for me either.

0 coins

I didn't believe it would either. Tried the number myself every day for a week before that. The agent I spoke with was definitely EDD, she had everything on the claim right in front of her.

0 coins

Had a question about which weeks had been paid and what was coming next on my care claim. Tried talking to an EDD agent and they confirmed the two most recent weeks and told me when the following payment was scheduled to process. Actually got my answer.

0 coins

Alright, might give it a shot for the payment schedule question I've been sitting on.

0 coins

Worth clarifying one more thing: PFL doesn't protect your job. It pays you, but keeping your job during leave is a separate question under CFRA or FMLA. Those are for your employer and an HR person to explain.

0 coins

Wait, so EDD pays me but doesn't guarantee my job is there when I come back?

0 coins

Exactly. EDD pays the benefit. Job protection is CFRA or FMLA territory, and whether either covers your situation depends on your employer and those laws.

0 coins

EDD is pretty clear about this on their site: PFL provides benefit payments but not job protection. Worth a separate conversation with HR, different from the eligibility question.

0 coins

Checking your start date and whether you're inside the 41-day window to file is something you really can't guess at. I was nervous about whether I'd filed in time and ended up talking to an EDD agent. The agent pulled up my claim's start date and confirmed the receipt number was timestamped inside the 41-day window, so the filing was good.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I keep seeing it mentioned here.

0 coins

It's a service that waits on hold with EDD's line for you, so when a live agent picks up your phone rings. Saves you sitting there for however long.

0 coins

Oh. I actually need to ask about whether my wife's proof of relationship document was received for her bonding claim. That would be useful.

0 coins

Had no idea that was an option either. The phone situation with EDD has been the most stressful part of all of this.

0 coins

For the original question: each time you file, EDD calculates wages from the base period tied to that claim. Going back to work between pregnancies is actually what makes the new claim strong, because those wages are fresh and in the window.

0 coins

This thread has genuinely cleared so much up. I was worried the second pregnancy would somehow be treated differently.

0 coins

EDD sees two separate claims. The first is closed. The second gets evaluated on its own.

0 coins

Filed my second claim about a year after the first closed. No flags, no questions, nothing. It went through like a first-time claim.

0 coins

That's the most calming thing I've read in this thread.

0 coins

Okay I think I actually feel better now. As long as I've been paying CASDI, the new claim should be evaluated completely on its own merits.

0 coins

That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Had a small panic when I thought the 41-day clock started from my due date and not from when I actually started leave. I'd been misreading the instructions. I ended up talking to EDD through Claimyr and the agent told me the claim's start date on the system was the actual first day I stopped working, so I was well within the window.

0 coins

So the 41 days runs from when you stop working, not from when the baby arrives?

0 coins

For a pregnancy disability claim, the start date is when disability begins, not necessarily the birth. The agent confirmed the date that was recorded matched my last day at work. For the PFL bonding claim after, the 41 days runs from when bonding leave starts.

0 coins

This is something I would have gotten wrong too. Good to know to file once I actually start the leave, not on some date I guessed at.

0 coins

The form instructions say no earlier than the first day of family leave and no later than 41 days after. Filing it on the day you stop working and start leave is the safest move.

0 coins

Bottom line for you: eight months of CASDI deductions after returning to work puts you in solid shape for a new claim. File when your leave starts, not before.

0 coins

Filing date is the first day of leave. Got it. And I'll use SDI Online through myEDD.

0 coins

That's the one. Keep your receipt number from that confirmation screen.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure