Back to California Paid Family Leave

Hugo Kass

Can you transition from SDI to PFL after resigning from job?

So I've been on disability (SDI) for about six weeks now for a back injury I got at work. The thing is, I also have a newborn at home, my son was born right before I got hurt, so I've been kind of doing both at once except I can only get one at a time obviously. Here's where it gets complicated: I'm thinking about resigning from my job because the relationship with my employer has gotten really bad, they want me back as soon as I'm cleared and I just don't want to go back there. My question is can you transition from SDI to PFL after resigning from job, like once my disability period ends can I still file a bonding claim for my son? I've seen some things online that say you have to be employed but I'm not totally sure if that means employed when you file or employed when you paid into it. My son will still be under 12 months when my disability ends so the bonding window should still be open I think. Really nervous about this.

Payment method on my bonding claim was showing wrong after I transitioned from my disability claim, it still had the old debit card address and I needed to update it before the first PFL payment went out. Spent three mornings in a row hitting that EDD line and getting the same recorded message telling me volume was too high. Ended up trying Claimyr (claimyr.com) and finally got to talk to an actual EDD agent. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed my direct deposit info hadn't carried over from the DI claim, so I updated it right then on the call. Way less stressful than whatever I was doing before.

0 coins

Three mornings and you got through on the fourth try with some service? I've been dialing that 877 number for a week straight. Either it tells me call volume is too high or it just disconnects. Hard to believe anything gets you a real person on that line.

0 coins

I know how that sounds. The agent I spoke with was EDD, pulled my claim right up. I wasn't expecting it to work either after everything I'd tried.

0 coins

After my denial notice came I tried Claimyr too and got through. The agent told me a DE 2514 had been issued on my claim and I needed to appeal within 30 days using the form that came with it. Got that filed in time. Really glad I didn't keep banging my head against the phone line.

0 coins

Alright, I'll give it a shot. Nothing else has worked so I've got nothing to lose at this point.

0 coins

The eligibility rule that tripped me up when I first looked into this was about being employed or actively looking for work. When I read it carefully it says you need to be employed or actively looking for work at the time the family leave begins, not necessarily at the time you file. So if you resign and then start your PFL bonding leave, the question is whether you're actively seeking work. If you're not going back to any job, that part matters.

0 coins

Hugo Kass

Author

So if I resign before my disability ends and I'm not looking for work because I'm home with the baby, that could be a problem for the PFL claim?

0 coins

That's the question EDD would be looking at, yes. The safest answer is to contact EDD directly about your specific situation before you resign.

0 coins

I didn't realize it depended on whether you're looking for work. I thought PFL was just for anyone who paid into SDI. This whole thing is more complicated than I thought.

0 coins

You paid into SDI while you worked, that part's already done. The question is your status when the leave starts. Worth a call to EDD before you make any move on the job.

0 coins

Yep. Don't resign until you know where you stand. That's the kind of thing you can't undo.

0 coins

Hugo Kass

Author

Yeah I keep going back and forth on the timing. I really don't want to mess up the PFL by moving too fast on the job situation.

0 coins

The EDD site spells it out as being employed or actively looking for work when the family leave starts. That language is on the PFL eligibility page. It doesn't say you have to be employed at a specific employer, just that you meet that status. The separate requirement is at least $300 in wages with CASDI withheld during your base period, which you clearly have if you've been on a disability claim.

0 coins

Does 'actively looking for work' have a formal definition EDD uses, or is it kind of loose? Wondering how they'd actually verify that.

0 coins

EDD doesn't publish a detailed definition on the PFL pages. That's another reason to contact them directly rather than guess.

0 coins

Hugo Kass

Author

Okay this is helpful. So theoretically if I resigned and was job hunting, the actively-looking part might still be satisfied? I just don't know if I'll actually be looking while home with the baby.

0 coins

My cousin went through something kind of similar, she left her job while on maternity leave and still got her PFL bonding weeks paid out. But her situation might have been different because she didn't resign until after the PFL was already running. Timing seems like it really matters here.

0 coins

The start date of the leave versus the date of resignation is probably the key variable. If PFL was already in progress before she resigned, that's a different situation than resigning first.

0 coins

Yeah exactly, she'd already been getting paid for a few weeks before she put in her notice. So the leave was already established I guess.

0 coins

Hugo Kass

Author

That's a really important distinction. I haven't filed for PFL yet because I'm still on the disability claim. So mine would be a fresh start, not a continuation.

0 coins

Resigning mid-disability claim is its own complication before you even get to PFL. EDD needs to know your work status changed.

0 coins

How does EDD find out you resigned if you don't tell them?

0 coins

You're supposed to report it. And employers can respond to EDD inquiries. Easier to just be upfront.

0 coins

Hugo Kass

Author

I hadn't thought about how the resignation would interact with the disability claim itself. So I might need to report that to EDD even before I think about transitioning to PFL.

0 coins

Filing date on my PFL bonding claim got confusing because I lost the receipt number from when I initially filed in SDI Online and wasn't sure if EDD had matched my documents. Ended up getting hold of an EDD agent through Claimyr and she confirmed the receipt number, found that my birth certificate had been received and matched to the claim, and told me which week the claim had started from. Whole thing was about two minutes once I had her on the line.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? Haven't heard of it.

0 coins

It waits on the EDD phone line in your place, then your phone rings when a live agent picks up. That's basically the whole thing.

0 coins

Huh. I need to ask about my claim's start date and whether the 41-day window is still open. Might try that.

0 coins

if you already paid into casdi while you worked you should be fine for pfl i think, they dont care if youre employed now they care that you were employed before and paid in

0 coins

That's partly right but the employment status at the time leave starts does matter for PFL eligibility. It's not only about having paid in. The EDD eligibility page is clear that you need to be employed or actively seeking work when the family leave begins.

0 coins

oh i didnt know that part, figured once you paid in you were good

0 coins

The base period wages with CASDI withheld is one requirement, the status at the time leave starts is a separate one. Both have to be met.

0 coins

We went through the transition from my wife's disability claim to her PFL bonding claim after our second was born. EDD mailed her a form specifically for new mothers, the DE 2501FP, and she just filled that out and sent it in. No extra documents needed. Her situation was different from yours because she stayed at her job, but the form process was pretty smooth anyway.

0 coins

So there's actually a different form for a birth mom going from disability to PFL? I didn't know that. I've just been looking at the regular bonding claim stuff.

0 coins

Yeah they mail it to you automatically. She didn't have to go find it herself. It's called the DE 2501FP. No birth certificate or anything extra required with that one.

0 coins

Hugo Kass

Author

My situation is a little different since I'm the dad filing a bonding claim, not the birth mom. So I would go through SDI Online and upload the birth certificate or other proof of relationship, right?

0 coins

For a father filing a bonding claim directly, yes, you go through SDI Online under myEDD and you need a proof of relationship document. A birth certificate works, or a Declaration of Paternity if that's what you have.

0 coins

Hugo Kass

Author

Got it. And the 12 months from birth is the window I have to use all eight weeks?

0 coins

Correct. All eight bonding weeks have to be used within 12 months of your son's birth.

0 coins

Just want to confirm, the eight weeks is total, not eight weeks per parent, right?

0 coins

Each parent files their own separate PFL claim and each gets up to eight weeks, but the eight weeks is the limit per person across all PFL types in a 12-month period. So if you used some weeks for a care claim in the same year, those would count against your eight.

0 coins

Makes sense. Good to know both parents can claim it.

0 coins

Wait so both the mom and the dad can each get eight weeks for bonding? I thought it was eight weeks total shared between them. That's actually better than I thought.

0 coins

PFL doesn't protect your job. Just so you know. EDD pays you but your employer has zero obligation to hold your position from PFL alone. That's CFRA's job.

0 coins

Probably a moot point here since he's planning to resign anyway.

0 coins

True. Just figured someone should say it since people assume PFL covers everything.

0 coins

Hugo Kass

Author

Yeah I know PFL doesn't cover the job. At this point I'm kind of relieved to know that piece isn't my concern since I'm leaving regardless.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came through on my PFL claim and I didn't understand why the weekly amount looked different from what I expected based on my wages. Couldn't figure out if something was wrong or if I was just doing the math wrong. Used Claimyr to get an agent and she walked me through the base period they used, which was 5 to 18 months before my claim start date, highest quarter. The number on the DE 429DF ended up being correct, I was just looking at the wrong quarter.

0 coins

The agent confirmed the base period they used? That's exactly what I needed to know when my computation came. Mine looked off too and I finally got through on my own claim and the agent told me the Part D from my mom's doctor had been received and was matched, which was why the care claim finally moved forward! So glad to have that confirmed!

0 coins

When did your mom's doctor submit the Part D, and how long between submission and EDD confirming it was matched?

0 coins

She submitted it online using my receipt number, and it was matched within about a week. The agent confirmed the date it was received on EDD's end which was really helpful!

0 coins

To answer the original question more directly, EDD's own eligibility language says you need to be employed or actively looking for work when the family leave begins. Resigning before you start PFL puts you in a gray area unless you're genuinely job hunting. I'd call EDD and ask about your specific situation before you give notice.

0 coins

Hugo Kass

Author

Calling EDD is easier said than done, I've tried twice this week already.

0 coins

I hear you. Mornings seemed marginally better for me before I found another way in. But yeah the line is brutal.

0 coins

One thing worth noting on the timing: you have to file within 41 days of the day your bonding leave starts, not 41 days from when your disability ends. So if there's a gap between the two where you're not on any claim, that clock is still running.

0 coins

Hugo Kass

Author

So I shouldn't let time pass between when my disability ends and when I start the PFL bonding leave, or I risk losing days off the front?

0 coins

Exactly. The 41-day window from leave start is the hard deadline. Beyond that you can lose benefits for those earlier days.

0 coins

And the 12-month window from your son's birth date is a separate deadline, so you've got both to track.

0 coins

no waiting period for pfl either, unlike disability. people mix that up all the time.

0 coins

wait disability has a waiting period?

0 coins

seven days unpaid at the start. pfl doesnt have that.

0 coins

Yeah that caught us off guard on our first claim. PFL starting the first day was a nice change.

0 coins

Filing in SDI Online is pretty straightforward once you're in myEDD. For the bonding claim as a dad you'll go through Apply for Benefits, then the PFL bonding option. Upload the birth certificate right when you file so it's already there.

0 coins

Hugo Kass

Author

And if I don't have the official birth certificate yet? Our son's was delayed from the county. Can I use a Declaration of Paternity instead?

0 coins

Yes, the CS-909 Declaration of Paternity works as a proof of relationship too. You're not stuck waiting for the birth certificate.

0 coins

Hugo Kass

Author

That's a huge relief, I've been stressing about that. We have the CS-909 so I can move forward with that.

0 coins

The benefits calculator on EDD's site can give you an estimate of your weekly amount before the Notice of Computation comes. Worth running your numbers so you're not caught off guard.

0 coins

Where exactly is that calculator? On edd.ca.gov?

0 coins

Yeah it's on edd.ca.gov, just search benefits calculator. It's under the PFL section.

0 coins

Resigned mid-claim or not, EDD is going to look at your base period wages, that's already locked in. The employment status piece is what you need to clear up before you file for PFL.

0 coins

That's the bottom line. Base period is in the past. Status when leave starts is what's in question.

0 coins

Hugo Kass

Author

Okay so to summarize what I've learned here: my base period wages are already established and the CASDI contributions I made should be enough to clear that threshold. The thing I need to sort out is whether resigning before starting PFL bonding leave could affect my eligibility based on the employed-or-actively-looking requirement. I'm going to try to reach EDD directly before I do anything on the job.

0 coins

If you can't get through on the phone, the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online can be used to send EDD a message. It's under your claim ID once you're logged in through myEDD.

0 coins

Hugo Kass

Author

I haven't tried that yet. Would a question about whether resigning would affect my eligibility be appropriate to send that way, or is it too complicated for a written message?

0 coins

It's worth trying. Lay out your situation clearly, ask the specific question, and reference your claim. They may respond with enough to go on.

0 coins

Ask EDD, the online contact form on edd.ca.gov, is another option if the SDI Online message route doesn't get you a quick answer.

0 coins

Payments are every two weeks once the claim is running, and each day pays out as one seventh of your weekly amount. So if you end up taking some intermittent days while you figure out the job stuff, those smaller payments can still add up!

0 coins

Just make sure any days you work are reported to EDD. Wages during PFL have to be reported and not reporting them can create an overpayment situation.

0 coins

Hugo Kass

Author

Good reminder. If I did end up working any days during the bonding period I would absolutely report them. I don't want to deal with an overpayment on top of everything else.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure