Back to California Paid Family Leave

Christian Burns

Can employer sick pay cause PFL bonding claim to be denied?

So I finally filed my PFL bonding claim through SDI Online last week, and now I'm spiraling a little because I just found out my employer is going to keep paying me through their sick leave bank for the first two weeks of my leave. I didn't ask for it, HR just automatically applied it. Does this mean my PFL bonding claim is going to get denied? I'm a first-timer with all of this and I have no idea if the sick pay from work and the PFL benefits can even run at the same time, or if one cancels out the other. The baby is here and the last thing I want is to lose the PFL money because of something HR did without telling me. Anyone been through this?

Weeks left in my 12 months was actually what I needed confirmed before I could plan anything. My first bonding claim wrapped up in the spring and I wasn't sure how much PFL time I still had for a care situation coming up. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to reach someone on the PFL line and ended up talking to an EDD agent within that same call. She pulled up my claim and told me I had three weeks remaining in the 12-month window. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. That number mattered because I knew exactly what I was working with before the care situation started.

0 coins

The DE 2500E was something I hadn't even noticed until an agent pointed it out on my own claim. Claimyr got me to someone at EDD after I'd been trying the line myself for two straight mornings, and the agent read off when my first payment was issued and walked me through what the notification meant. After that I actually understood what to watch for in SDI Online.

0 coins

two mornings trying the line and you got through that fast? i call at eight on the dot and either the system hangs up or i sit there for an hour with nothing.

0 coins

Tried at 8 too, same wall every time. That's honestly why I stopped trying on my own.

0 coins

41 days surprised me when I first filed, and I think the sick pay question here deserves a careful answer. PFL and employer sick pay can run at the same time, but your wages from that sick pay combined with the PFL benefit can't add up to more than your normal weekly wages. If they would, EDD adjusts the PFL amount, it doesn't deny the claim outright. So the claim shouldn't be denied just because HR applied sick leave automatically.

0 coins

Wait, so it reduces the PFL amount rather than canceling it? That's actually a relief. I thought the whole claim would just get rejected.

0 coins

Exactly right. The claim stays open. It's the payment amount for those overlapping days that gets adjusted if needed.

0 coins

This is the part that trips people up most, the difference between a denial and a reduced payment. Two completely different outcomes.

0 coins

HR applying sick time without asking you doesn't mean PFL goes away. Report those wages to EDD when you certify. That's on you to do, not HR.

0 coins

Report them through SDI Online? Or is there a form I mail in?

0 coins

SDI Online handles it when you get your continued claim certification. Fill in what you earned.

0 coins

Don't skip that step. Unreported wages is how people end up with an overpayment notice later.

0 coins

My cousin went through almost this exact thing after her baby came and she was panicking for nothing, the PFL came through fine. She just had to show her wages for those two weeks and EDD figured out the rest. Took a little longer to get the first payment but it was not denied.

0 coins

Okay that's reassuring to hear from an actual person who went through it.

0 coins

Did her first payment come after the two sick weeks were done, or did EDD pay something during them too? Not sure how the timing works.

0 coins

EDD paid for the days after the sick pay ran out first, as far as she could tell. For the overlapping days the amount was smaller, not zero.

0 coins

edd doesnt deny a bonding claim just cause you got sick pay from work, they just adjust what they owe you for those days

0 coins

Mostly true. The key detail is that your total pay plus PFL can't top your normal wages for those days.

0 coins

yeah thats what i meant, they dont just cut you off they just do the math

0 coins

The rule as I read it on EDD's site is that sick leave, vacation or other paid time off can be used at the same time as PFL, but the combined amount of your wages, excluding overtime, plus the PFL benefit can't exceed your normal weekly wages. That's the ceiling. It doesn't trigger a denial, it sets an adjusted payment for the days involved.

0 coins

Is that written somewhere I can point HR to if they ask? They seem confused about this too.

0 coins

The Paid Family Leave Benefits and Payments FAQs on EDD's site have this. The DE 2530 guide covers it as well, that's the PFL brochure EDD publishes.

0 coins

Good to have an actual source on that. HR departments are surprisingly often confused about PFL rules.

0 coins

My HR did the same thing with my sick bank, didn't ask, just applied it. First payment still landed, was just a bit lower for those two weeks. Report the wages, done.

0 coins

How long did the first payment take for you?

0 coins

About two weeks from when EDD got everything. Anyway.

0 coins

My claim's start date was something the EDD agent sorted out for me. I had filed fourteen days after the baby came and wasn't sure if I'd blown the 41-day window somehow. I called EDD using Claimyr and the agent confirmed my start date was recorded correctly and that I was well inside the 41 days. Couldn't have gotten that answer by staring at SDI Online.

0 coins

Honestly I'm a little skeptical that any service gets you a live person at EDD. I've tried that line probably a dozen times across different days and it either cuts me off or I wait and wait and get nothing. What actually happened when you called?

0 coins

Line rang, Claimyr held it, I got a person. The agent was an EDD employee who had my claim open in front of her. That's it.

0 coins

Used it myself for a different thing. When I had someone reporting intermittent days I needed to confirm whether EDD had gotten the DE 2580GF back. The agent checked and said the form was received and the days were marked. That was three days after I'd mailed it.

0 coins

Sick pay from your employer doesn't void the PFL claim. Just disclose the wages when you certify and let EDD do the math on what's owed for those days.

0 coins

Where exactly in SDI Online do I report those wages? I want to make sure I'm putting it in the right place.

0 coins

When EDD sends your continued claim certification, there's a question about work and wages. Answer it there, that's the place.

0 coins

PFL is so confusing the first time around! Employer paid leave running alongside it threw me off too when I had my first. It ended up fine, just took me a bit to understand how the payments were calculated.

0 coins

Makes me feel less alone that this confused other people too.

0 coins

Absolutely! And once your Notice of Computation arrives you'll see the weekly benefit amount EDD has on file. That helps a ton for planning.

0 coins

Sick pay doesn't cancel PFL. EDD pays the difference up to your normal wage. Seen this play out the same way on multiple claims.

0 coins

Is this different if the sick pay fully replaces your salary?

0 coins

If sick pay already covers your full normal wage, PFL would pay nothing on top of that for those days. No denial, just zero benefit owed on those specific days.

0 coins

That's the right read. The combined total simply can't go above normal wages, so if sick pay fills the gap completely, PFL has nothing left to add.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is an absolute joke. I've redialed that 1-877-238-4373 number maybe forty times across different mornings for my own bonding claim questions and the recorded message just ends the call or I get a 90-minute wait and nothing. How is anyone supposed to get answers.

0 coins

That line is brutal. Same experience here before I tried something different.

0 coins

What did you do, just give up and wait for mail?

0 coins

No, I found another way to get through. The EDD agent I reached confirmed everything I needed about my claim right on that call.

0 coins

Wait, I'm confused. Someone mentioned CFRA earlier in another thread and I thought CFRA was the same as PFL. Are they the same thing?

0 coins

They're two different things. PFL is the benefit payment from EDD, up to eight weeks of partial wage replacement. CFRA is job-protected leave under California law. PFL doesn't protect your job on its own, that's what CFRA does if you qualify.

0 coins

Oh wow I did not know that. So I need both to have the job AND the payment?

0 coins

Whether CFRA covers you depends on your employer and your situation. EDD handles the PFL payment side only. For the job protection piece you'd want to talk to your HR or look into CFRA separately.

0 coins

Nobody told me PFL has no waiting period either. I kept holding off on spending anything because I was bracing for seven unpaid days like disability has. Somebody at my yoga class swore PFL had the same waiting period.

0 coins

There's no waiting period on PFL. The waiting period is a disability insurance thing, not PFL. Benefits are payable from the first day of leave, as long as EDD confirms eligibility.

0 coins

Genuinely could have used that correction three weeks ago.

0 coins

yeah the waiting period thing messes people up all the time, its only on disability not on bonding

0 coins

Payment method was something I hadn't set up before my first check. Phoned EDD using Claimyr and the agent confirmed my claim was set for the debit card since I'd filed on paper. Wanted direct deposit instead, so the agent told me I'd have needed to file through SDI Online to get that option. Good to know before the next one.

0 coins

What is Claimyr? I keep seeing it mentioned in this thread and I have no idea what it is.

0 coins

It waits on EDD's line in your place and your phone rings once a live EDD agent picks up. Anyway, pretty simple setup.

0 coins

Oh interesting. I've been trying to get someone on the line about whether my proof of relationship was received because SDI Online just says pending. That might be worth trying.

0 coins

Benefits calendar threw me off at first. EDD pays each eligible day at one seventh of the weekly benefit amount, so if you're only collecting for part of a week because sick pay covered the rest, you get the per-day rate for the days they owe you.

0 coins

So on a week where my sick pay covered three days and EDD covered four, I'd get four times the daily rate for that week?

0 coins

Roughly, yes, subject to the total wage ceiling. For exact numbers your Notice of Computation is the place to look.

0 coins

just file and report the sick days. edd does the math. been there, its fine.

0 coins

Thank you, honestly this thread has been so helpful.

0 coins

Proof of relationship is something to double-check while waiting. If you filed in SDI Online for bonding and uploaded a birth certificate, it should show received. Worth confirming before the payment delay question pops up.

0 coins

Mine shows received. I uploaded the birth certificate the same night I filed so I was at least careful about that part.

0 coins

Then you're in good shape there. Main thing left is reporting those sick pay wages when the certification comes.

0 coins

My receipt number was actually the thing that saved me headaches early on. Wrote it down the second I saw the confirmation screen. I tried the EDD line twice and got nowhere, so I ended up using Claimyr to reach an agent. She verified the receipt number was linked to my bonding claim and that nothing had been flagged as missing. Knowing the number was matched correctly meant I wasn't starting from zero every time I had a follow-up question.

0 coins

Used Claimyr once myself. What the agent told me about my DE 2514 was the most useful two minutes of that whole week. Denial notice had come in the mail and I needed to know if the appeal window was still open. Agent confirmed the 30-day window and told me the date my notice was mailed.

0 coins

what did you do after that call, did you file the appeal?

0 coins

Mailed the DE 1000A the same afternoon. Filed well inside the 30 days once I knew the mailing date.

0 coins

Eight weeks total, not eight per claim type. Saw someone above imply bonding and care claims each have their own eight weeks. That's not how it works. It's eight weeks across bonding, care and military assist together inside any 12-month window.

0 coins

That's a really important correction. Used two for bonding and then had a family care situation and lost track of how many I had left.

0 coins

The 12-month window runs from the first day of the first claim, not the calendar year, so it's worth checking your start date when planning.

0 coins

My mom's doctor was late getting Part D in for a care claim I filed for her earlier this year and I was panicking the whole time. The 41-day window is for the leave start date and EDD needs Part D within that window. Got there in time but barely.

0 coins

That sounds stressful. I'm glad it worked out for you.

0 coins

It did, but I was refreshing SDI Online every day until the status updated.

0 coins

Is Part D something that also applies to bonding claims? I keep reading about it and don't know if it matters for me.

0 coins

Part D is only for care claims. It's the physician's certification that the person you're caring for has a serious health condition. Bonding claims don't have a Part D at all. The proof of relationship document, like the birth certificate, is what a bonding claim needs instead.

0 coins

That clears it up completely. I've been reading care claim instructions and confusing myself.

0 coins

yeah totally different forms depending on what kind of claim you got

0 coins

Updating in case anyone finds this later. My continued claim certification came in and I reported the sick pay wages on it. EDD sent a Notice of Computation and my weekly benefit amount was adjusted for those two weeks, exactly like people here described. The claim wasn't denied. Payments are coming in. Report the wages, let EDD calculate the rest, and don't panic the way I did.

0 coins

Glad you posted the update. The adjusted-not-denied distinction is exactly what trips people up.

0 coins

Great outcome! First time through is always the most confusing part.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure