Back to California Paid Family Leave

MidnightRider

Can I get PFL while collecting unemployment benefits?

So I got laid off in October and I've been on unemployment since then. My wife just had our second kid last week and I want to take some bonding time, which is great timing in one way because I'm not working anyway. But now I'm reading stuff online that's making me worried. Can I get PFL while collecting unemployment benefits at the same time? Like would I just file a PFL bonding claim on top of the unemployment, or does one cancel the other out? I really need to know before I do something wrong here because we could use both payments if that's possible, or at least I need to know which one to pick. Anyone dealt with this before?

Filing date on my own care claim got complicated and I had to figure out exactly when my 41-day window closed. I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) because the phone line ate my morning three days running. The agent pulled up the claim and told me the leave start date on file, which let me count the 41 days exactly. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Claimyr sounds like it might just be an ad dressed up as advice. I try to be fair but every time I see a service like this recommended in a forum I wonder who's behind the post.

0 coins

Felt that way at first too, honestly. Then I tried it after two weeks of getting nowhere on the PFL line. The agent I reached was EDD's own, confirmed my DE 2580GF for intermittent days had been received and which weeks were still open. After that I figured it was worth mentioning wherever the topic comes up.

0 coins

Fair enough. I may give it a try then, if the line keeps doing what it's been doing.

0 coins

Back to my actual question though, does anyone know the PFL and unemployment overlap thing? That's really what I need sorted.

0 coins

PFL and unemployment don't pay at the same time. EDD won't issue both for the same days, so you'd have to choose. Most people in your spot stop the unemployment claim and file the PFL bonding claim for the weeks they want to bond.

0 coins

So I'd actually have to pause unemployment, not just add PFL on top of it. Got it. Does pausing it mess anything up for later?

0 coins

You'd want to ask EDD about reopening unemployment when bonding ends. PFL has its own claim and timeline. They're separate systems.

0 coins

This happened to a customer of mine. She said stopping unemployment and starting PFL was straightforward, she just filed the bonding claim and EDD sorted out the overlap dates. But she did say she asked EDD to make sure she didn't accidentally get paid twice for the same week.

0 coins

Yep. One at a time. EDD's pretty clear that you don't collect both for the same day.

0 coins

Does EDD catch that automatically, or could someone accidentally get both and then owe it back? I'd be terrified of an overpayment notice.

0 coins

Overpayments happen. Report everything accurately and you'll be fine.

0 coins

Overpayment notices are no joke. Report your situation right and don't double dip, it's not worth the headache.

0 coins

I called EDD about almost this exact thing last spring and the hold time was absolutely brutal. Tried three mornings before I gave up. Eventually sent a Request Claim Update through SDI Online and got an answer that way, took a few days but it worked.

0 coins

The SDI Online message thing, is that under the claim ID or somewhere else in the account?

0 coins

In myEDD you open SDI Online, pick the claim, then find Request Claim Update. Pick the type closest to your question and write it out.

0 coins

That route took about four days when I tried it, but it did eventually answer my question. Way better than redialing for hours lol.

0 coins

Payment method was the thing tripping up my bonding claim. The direct deposit I'd set up wasn't showing as confirmed, and I couldn't tell if I'd even be paid by the time the two-week mark hit. I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr. The agent told me the payment method on file, confirmed it matched what I'd entered in SDI Online, and said the first payment had already been issued to that account.

0 coins

When you got on with the agent, did they need anything from you to pull up the account, or just your ID?

0 coins

They asked for my Social Security number and claim ID. Had both right there, took maybe a minute to verify before they were looking at the claim.

0 coins

been trying that line since tuesday. three disconnects. good to know that option is out there.

0 coins

Wait, I'm confused about something. If you're not working because of unemployment, can you even file PFL? I thought PFL was for people who had to leave their job to bond. If you already left, does that still count? Sorry if that's a dumb question.

0 coins

The eligibility rule is that you have to be employed or actively looking for work when the leave starts, plus at least 300 dollars in base period wages with SDI withheld. Someone collecting unemployment is typically considered actively looking for work, which is why this situation can arise. But EDD decides, so it's worth confirming with them directly.

0 coins

Oh that makes more sense. So the wages with SDI withheld, that would be from my previous job, not from right now when I'm not earning anything?

0 coins

Yes, the base period looks back at wages you already earned, usually five to eighteen months before the claim starts. What's on your Notice of Computation will tell you the actual quarter they used.

0 coins

Thank you, that actually clears it up. I'll check the calculator on EDD's site to get an estimate of what the weekly amount might look like.

0 coins

The short answer is no, you can't get both. Pick one for any given week.

0 coins

Yeah that's what I'm starting to understand. The question is whether PFL pays more than unemployment or not, since I'd be giving up unemployment to take it.

0 coins

Pull up the benefits calculator on EDD's site and run the numbers. What your Notice of Computation says is the real answer.

0 coins

Good call. The weekly amounts depend on your wages and income, so there's no one-size number anyone here can give you.

0 coins

So you just had a baby and you're on unemployment, first of all congrats on the new baby. Second, the bonding claim is filed in SDI Online through myEDD. You say you want to start bonding, give the start date, and upload a proof of relationship document like the birth certificate. That's the main thing dads and partners need that a birth mom doesn't.

0 coins

The birth certificate, do we have that yet? He was born last week so we have the paperwork from the hospital but I don't know if the official one is issued yet.

0 coins

A lot of people use the hospital paperwork initially and then upload the official certificate when it arrives. The Declaration of Paternity form from the hospital is another option EDD accepts. Worth checking exactly what SDI Online asks for when you get to that screen.

0 coins

My husband used the Declaration of Paternity and it went through fine.

0 coins

Don't sit on the filing. You've got 41 days from when the bonding starts and that clock is running. File as soon as you decide you're doing PFL instead of unemployment.

0 coins

Bonding started the day he was born, right? So the clock is already ticking from last week?

0 coins

That'd be my read. File the claim from your leave start date and don't delay.

0 coins

The 41 days is from the first day of the family leave, yes. You choose when that is, but the sooner the better given where you are.

0 coins

you cant do both at the same time, its one or the other per day. most people just switch to pfl for the bonding weeks and go back to certifying for unemployment after

0 coins

Wait, can you actually go back to unemployment after PFL ends? I assumed once you filed PFL your unemployment claim just closed.

0 coins

yeah from what i understand you reopen the unemployment claim, its not gone. but definitely check with edd on that one

0 coins

Reopening unemployment after a leave period is something to confirm with EDD directly. The process for reopening varies and they would know the status of your specific claim.

0 coins

Receipt number on my bonding claim kept confusing me because I didn't realize I needed it to track things in SDI Online. I used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent and she told me the receipt number tied to my claim was already in the system and confirmed the proof of relationship had been received. Saved me a lot of back and forth wondering if anything was lost.

0 coins

My bonding claim has been showing pending for eleven days and I want to know whether the birth certificate upload actually registered. I'm going to try Claimyr for that. What do I have ready when I get on with the agent?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number and the claim ID from SDI Online. The receipt number helps too if you saved it from the confirmation page when you first filed.

0 coins

This is useful, I saved my receipt number on my phone right after I filed last year's claim. Habit now.

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period, which is one nice thing about it. Disability has that seven-day unpaid stretch at the start, PFL skips that entirely. So day one of bonding is a payable day if everything's approved!

0 coins

That's worth knowing. I thought PFL worked the same as the disability claim and had that waiting period too. Good to have it corrected.

0 coins

Completely different. No unpaid waiting period on PFL at all.

0 coins

I definitely assumed there was a waiting period. That changes the math a little on which is better for those first weeks.

0 coins

My coworker switched from unemployment to PFL when her foster placement came through and said it was pretty smooth. Filed in SDI Online, submitted the foster care agency letter as her proof of relationship, and the claim moved fairly fast.

0 coins

Foster placement uses a different document than a birth certificate, interesting. Good to know there are a few options.

0 coins

Yeah EDD has like four different documents they accept depending on how the kid came into the family. The list is in SDI Online when you go through the filing steps.

0 coins

The thing that annoys me is EDD gives you 41 days but their phone line eats half your day if you have questions before you file. I had maybe three days of that in a row trying to figure out the unemployment interaction before I gave up and messaged through SDI Online.

0 coins

Three days of that is brutal. At some point you just have to make your best decision and file.

0 coins

Pretty much. The SDI Online message came back with a clear answer eventually. EDD's written answers are actually useful, the wait is just annoying.

0 coins

Is the eight weeks of PFL separate from whatever I might have already used? Like if someone took five weeks of PFL last year after their first kid, do they still have eight full weeks for the new baby?

0 coins

The eight weeks is per 12-month period, covering bonding, care and military assist together. If five weeks were used in the last 12 months, only three are left in that window.

0 coins

Oh wow, so the two kids' bonding would share the pool if they were within 12 months of each other? That's actually a big deal.

0 coins

If the kids are more than 12 months apart, the first window closed and the new claim starts a fresh 12-month period. Kids that close together would be a tighter situation.

0 coins

Two kids in 12 months, our household has had two dogs get pregnant in 12 months but not us. This is for my second, first was three years ago so I think I'm fine.

0 coins

For anyone weighing unemployment against PFL, the weekly benefit amounts are calculated differently. PFL is based on your wages in the base period with SDI withheld. Unemployment is based on earnings too but through a separate calculation. The benefits calculator on EDD's site can give you an estimate for the PFL side, and your unemployment award letter shows what that side pays.

0 coins

Practical advice. Run the numbers before you decide.

0 coins

Yeah I've got my unemployment weekly amount already. I need to run the PFL estimate to compare. Thanks for laying that out clearly.

0 coins

PFL paid me more than unemployment did. Depends on your wages though.

0 coins

Good to hear it can go that way. I'll check the calculator.

0 coins

Worth a few minutes to find out before you commit.

0 coins

the fact that you cant stack both is frustrating when youre already laid off. but its the rule so at least you know going in

0 coins

Not ideal but at least EDD is clear about it. Better to know now than get an overpayment letter later.

0 coins

yeah overpayment is not a hole you want to dig yourself into

0 coins

Filing the bonding claim through myEDD is pretty straightforward once you're in SDI Online. The form walks you through it. The piece people miss is uploading the proof of relationship, which for dads is usually the birth certificate or the Declaration of Paternity.

0 coins

Got the Declaration of Paternity from the hospital already so I think I'm set on that front. Appreciate the reminder.

0 coins

Keep a copy somewhere. EDD might ask for it in a different form later and having it handy is easier.

0 coins

Before switching from unemployment, it may help to note the exact date you want bonding to start. That date anchors the 41-day window and also tells EDD which days should be on the PFL claim versus the unemployment claim, so the two don't accidentally overlap.

0 coins

So the bonding start date is something I actually designate when I file, not just the birth date automatically?

0 coins

You pick the date in the claim, yes. Many people use the birth date, but it's a date you enter when filing.

0 coins

Don't overthink it. Use the birth date, that's what most people do.

0 coins

For anyone worried about the 41 days: file even if you don't have everything perfect yet. Getting the claim in preserves your window and you can follow up with documents after.

0 coins

What happens if the proof of relationship doesn't get there in time? Does EDD deny the whole claim or just delay it?

0 coins

EDD needs the document to process things, but the claim itself stays open while they wait. Filing late is the bigger risk since that's what cuts off days you could have been paid.

0 coins

Filing tonight then. I've been going back and forth but that's the move.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure