California EDD PFL for disability self employed workers — does CASDI on your paystub still count?
So I've been freelancing full-time for about three years now — graphic design, mostly contract work through a few agencies. I still get W-2s from two of them because they classify me as a leased employee and they do withhold CASDI from my checks. My dad has been dealing with a pretty serious health situation these past few months and I'm going to need to step back from work to take him to appointments and be there for him. Someone told me I might not qualify for PFL because I'm "self-employed" but technically I have those two W-2 employers taking out CASDI. I filed a PFL care claim on SDI Online last week and uploaded everything I could through the portal. My dad's doctor said she'd submit Part D online using my receipt number, which I gave the office. I'm just really uncertain about whether the CASDI withheld from those W-2 wages is enough to meet EDD's threshold. Can freelancers with partial W-2 income actually qualify for PFL? And does it matter that I also have 1099 income on top of those W-2s?
77 comments

Hugo Kass
The 1099 income question trips a lot of people up. CASDI only gets withheld from W-2 wages, so only those wages count toward the $300 minimum EDD needs to see in your base period. The 1099 earnings don't factor in at all because no SDI was withheld on them. If your two W-2 employers withheld at least $300 total in CASDI from wages paid during the base period — roughly 5 to 18 months before your claim started — you should clear the threshold. The actual amount on your Notice of Computation will be what matters, since EDD calculates your weekly benefit from the highest quarter of W-2 wages in that window.
0 coins
Simon White
AuthorThat is really helpful to know. Both agencies paid me fairly consistently last year and the year before, so I'm pretty confident the CASDI withheld adds up well above $300. I just kept second-guessing myself because a friend who does purely 1099 gig work told me she couldn't get PFL at all, and I lumped myself in with her situation without thinking it through.
0 coins
Nasira Ibanez
Purely 1099 with no CASDI withheld is a totally different situation from having W-2 employers in the mix. Your friend is right for her case, but yours sounds like it should be fine based on those W-2 wages.
0 coins
Khalil Urso
The base period thing confused me too when I filed a care claim for my mom last spring. The 41-day deadline caught me completely off guard — I didn't realize the clock starts from the first day you stopped working, not from when you file. I ended up filing on day 38 and barely made it. Worth knowing that up front so you don't cut it close.
0 coins
Simon White
AuthorI filed about 10 days into my leave so I should be okay on the deadline front. But I had no idea about the 41 days either until I started reading the SDI Online help pages. EDD really buries that information.
0 coins
Myles Regis
Lost two weeks of benefits on a care claim years ago because I thought I had more time. 41 days from the first day of leave, and after that EDD can deny benefits for the days that passed before you filed. File as early as you're allowed, which is on that first day of leave itself.
0 coins
Simon White
AuthorWait, you can file on the very first day? I thought you had to wait a bit. Good to know for future claims.
0 coins
Brian Downey
Debit card vs. direct deposit was the part of my own care claim I nearly got wrong. I'd selected direct deposit in SDI Online and then the first payment never showed up in my bank account. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to EDD's Paid Family Leave line and an agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the bank routing number on file didn't match — somehow an old account number had pre-filled. She told me I could update it in SDI Online under payment preferences and resubmit, which I did that afternoon. First payment landed two days after that. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM
0 coins
Simon White
AuthorPayment method is something I hadn't even looked at closely. I'll double check my direct deposit info in SDI Online today — really don't want to track down a lost payment on top of everything else with my dad's situation.
0 coins
Jacinda Yu
The old-account pre-fill thing happened to someone in my office too. Direct deposit in SDI Online does pull from whatever you last entered, and if you've had a care or disability claim before with a different bank account it can carry over that old info. Worth verifying before the first payment date.
0 coins
Brian Downey
Exactly, and there's no notification in SDI Online that the routing check failed — it just looks like the payment is processing. Getting an agent to look at the actual account info on file was the only way I figured out what was wrong.
0 coins
Landon Flounder
Freelance W-2 situation is basically the same as any salaried employee's for PFL purposes. EDD doesn't care how you describe your work arrangement — if CASDI came out of the check, those wages are in play. The only thing that ever made a difference in my experience was making sure the Part D actually got to EDD. For a care claim, that doctor's certification is the piece that can hold everything up.
0 coins
Simon White
AuthorMy dad's doctor said she'd submit Part D in SDI Online using my receipt number. I gave the office the number on a printed sheet so there'd be no confusion about which digits to enter. Hoping that keeps things moving.
0 coins
Callum Savage
Giving the receipt number in writing is smart. When I had a care claim for my husband last year the office initially said they'd fax it, and I had to go back and explain that SDI Online submission or mail are the two routes — uploading it myself or having the office email it are not options. The doctor's office sometimes assumes their own systems work for EDD too.
0 coins
Landon Flounder
Fax and upload mix-ups are really common with doctor's offices. The key thing the person above said is right — Part D either goes in SDI Online by the provider or it's mailed. If you try to upload it through the claimant side it can delay the whole claim. The 41-day clock is ticking for Part D the same as it is for the initial filing.
0 coins
Ally Tailer
What actually happens if Part D doesn't arrive in time? Like does EDD just deny the whole claim or do they give you a warning first?
0 coins
Hugo Kass
EDD mails a notice — the Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination (DE 2514) — if they can't process the claim because something is missing. That notice comes with an Appeal Form (DE 1000A). You'd appeal within 30 days of that notice if you disagree with what it says. But the safer play is making sure Part D is in well before 41 days, because once you miss that window you're looking at losing benefits for those days.
0 coins
Ally Tailer
Okay so there's not really a grace period — you just get a denial and then you fight it. That's brutal. I'm about to file a care claim for my grandpa and I'm going to hand-deliver the Part D instructions to his cardiologist's office myself.
0 coins
Myles Regis
Hand-delivering the receipt number and instructions to the doctor's office is exactly the right move. The staff turnover at a lot of medical offices means the person who took your call two weeks ago isn't necessarily the one processing the form today.
0 coins
Aliyah Debovski
The base period wage question is worth looking at closely before you assume you're fine. EDD's benefit calculator on their site lets you put in quarterly wages and it'll estimate the weekly benefit amount. Plug in just your W-2 wages — not the 1099 income — and see what range you're in. The actual number will be on your Notice of Computation once EDD processes the claim, but the calculator gives you a ballpark so the notice isn't a surprise.
0 coins
Simon White
AuthorI ran the calculator last night using just the W-2 numbers from my two agencies. The estimate came back higher than I expected honestly, which made me feel a lot better about the financial side. I'd been mentally budgeting on the low end.
0 coins
Aliyah Debovski
Good — and the Notice of Computation isn't an approval, just so you know. It shows the potential weekly benefit amount but EDD still has to decide eligibility. So don't read the notice as a green light on the whole claim, just as confirmation of what your benefit would be if everything checks out.
0 coins
Nasira Ibanez
That distinction messed with my head when I got my own notice. I thought the NoC arriving meant I was approved and started telling my employer I'd be out. EDD still had to confirm everything and I was technically in pending status for a few more days after the notice showed up.
0 coins
Miranda Singer
PFL has no waiting period like SDI disability does. I made that mistake on a bonding claim two years ago — I thought the first week wouldn't be paid because I remembered the SDI waiting period from when I was out with an injury. PFL starts paying from day one of your leave.
0 coins
Simon White
AuthorI had actually wondered about that because I'd heard the seven-day thing somewhere. Good to know PFL doesn't have the same waiting period.
0 coins
Cass Green
To be clear for anyone reading: Disability Insurance has that waiting period, but PFL does not. Two different programs, and the rules don't cross over. I've seen people delay filing PFL because they assumed they'd lose the first week anyway — costs them nothing to file right away and they're leaving money on the table.
0 coins
Ally Tailer
The DI vs PFL confusion is so real. My sister assumed her PFL bonding claim would work the same as the pregnancy disability she'd just finished and almost missed the fact that she had to file a separate bonding claim at all.
0 coins
Finley Garrett
Receipt number on my care claim for my father-in-law got lost between tabs the day I filed and I panicked a bit. I ended up using Claimyr to reach an EDD agent and she pulled up the claim by my SSN, confirmed the receipt number, and read it back to me so I could write it down. Gave the number to his pulmonologist's office that same afternoon.
0 coins
Simon White
AuthorI was really careful about copying mine into a notes file and also writing it on paper before I closed the browser. But it's good to know there's a way to recover it if it gets lost. His pulmonologist's office probably appreciated having it quickly.
0 coins
Madison Tipne
Filing in SDI Online through myEDD also emails a confirmation with the receipt number, at least it did on mine. Worth checking spam if you can't find it.
0 coins
Finley Garrett
The email confirmation is a good point — mine had gone to spam, which is half of why I panicked in the first place. Ended up not needing the confirmation email once the agent gave me the number directly.
0 coins
Jacinda Yu
Something that caught me off guard on a care claim was the Part C part. My wife is the claimant and I'm the sick family member, and when she filed she didn't realize I had to fill out and mail Part C myself as the care recipient. The doctor's office was ready with Part D, but Part C sat on our kitchen table for five days because we didn't understand it was a separate mailed form.
0 coins
Simon White
AuthorI had to explain this to my dad actually. He kept thinking the doctor was handling everything and I had to show him Part C was his statement to fill out and mail. He's been a bit scattered with everything going on so I'm going to sit with him and fill it out together this weekend.
0 coins
Landon Flounder
Sitting with the care recipient to fill out Part C together is probably the most reliable way to make sure it gets done and mailed. A lot of care claims get delayed not because of the doctor but because the recipient didn't know Part C was their job.
0 coins
Jacinda Yu
Exactly — and don't upload it through SDI Online thinking that counts as submitting it. Part C gets mailed on the paper form, same as Part D if the doctor chooses mail over the SDI Online submission route. Uploading either one through the claimant portal can delay the claim.
0 coins
Holly Lascelles
Has anyone dealt with EDD asking for additional proof that the person you're caring for is actually a qualifying family member? I'm about to file a care claim for my grandfather and wasn't sure if grandchildren are covered.
0 coins
Hugo Kass
Grandchildren caring for grandparents — and grandparents caring for grandchildren — are both listed as qualifying relationships for PFL care claims. So a grandchild filing a care claim for a grandparent should be covered.
0 coins
Holly Lascelles
That's a relief. I was reading conflicting things in different places and wasn't sure if the grandparent relationship was included. My grandfather's situation has been getting more serious and I want to make sure I'm filing the right claim.
0 coins
Myles Regis
Siblings, parents-in-law, and grandparents are all in the list. The list is fairly broad. If you ever have a doubt about a relationship that isn't one of those, asking EDD directly is the safest move before you count on that claim.
0 coins
Cass Green
The eight weeks thing is a combined limit across bonding, care, and military assist claims within any 12-month period — not eight weeks per type of claim. So if someone bonded with a new baby for five weeks earlier in the same 12-month stretch and is now filing a care claim, they'd only have three weeks of PFL benefits left.
0 coins
Ally Tailer
I did not know it was a shared pool. I just had a baby six months ago and took five weeks bonding, and my mom has also been unwell. So theoretically I'd only have three PFL weeks left right now for a care claim.
0 coins
Cass Green
Exactly. And the 12-month window runs from the first claim's start date, not a calendar year. So keep track of when that first claim started to know when new weeks open back up.
0 coins
Simon White
AuthorThat's really important. I haven't used any PFL in the past year so I should have the full eight weeks available. But I'll keep that in mind because my dad's situation may be ongoing.
0 coins
Madison Tipne
The intermittent claim option saved me when I was caring for my mom. She had good weeks and bad weeks, and I didn't want to burn all eight weeks at once. On the DE 2501F paper form there's a question about whether you'll work during leave — you answer yes and note the days and hours you're working. EDD then sends a Continued Claim Certification and you report your work and wages as you go.
0 coins
Simon White
AuthorI may need to do something like that too depending on how my dad's treatment schedule lands. Some weeks I might be able to take on a few design projects and other weeks I'll need to be fully focused on him. I didn't know intermittent leave was an option until this thread.
0 coins
Madison Tipne
Filing the DE 2501F on paper gives you that yes/no question about working during leave. If you file the SDI Online claim and then decide to work part time later, you'd contact EDD to work out the reporting. The key thing is you have to report any wages — even if they haven't been paid yet — when EDD sends the Continued Claim Certification. Not reporting can lead to an overpayment.
0 coins
Khalil Urso
The overpayment risk from not reporting is real and annoying to deal with after the fact. I had a week where a client paid me for work from a prior month and I didn't connect that it counted as wages for that period. Had to sort it out with EDD and it held up my next payment.
0 coins
Callum Savage
Appeals are a thing too if EDD denies any part of the claim. The notice EDD mails — the DE 2514 — comes with an Appeal Form (DE 1000A), and you have 30 days from the notice date to file it. 30 days goes fast when you're managing a family health situation on top of everything else.
0 coins
Holly Lascelles
30 days from the notice date, not from when you receive it, right? Because mail can sit a few days before you open it.
0 coins
Callum Savage
EDD goes by the date on the notice, so opening your mail quickly during a claim period really does matter. If you're uncertain about anything on a denial, appeal and explain your situation — it's better to appeal and lose than to miss the window.
0 coins
Cass Green
Filing the appeal online is an option too so you don't have to track down a mailbox while you're running around with a sick family member. The DE 1000A is the form but the online route is faster if the deadline is close.
0 coins
Myles Regis
For the 1099 income question from the original post — worth repeating that those earnings genuinely don't count at all toward PFL eligibility or the benefit amount calculation. EDD only sees what's reported to them through SDI-withheld wages. A purely 1099 self-employed person with no W-2 income would have to look at the voluntary SDI election option to get any coverage, which is a whole separate enrollment process.
0 coins
Simon White
AuthorVoluntary SDI election for the 1099 side of my income is something I'd never heard of. I won't worry about it for this claim since I have the W-2 wages, but I'll look into it at some point. My 1099 income has been growing and it would be nice to have some coverage tied to it.
0 coins
Myles Regis
Voluntary plan enrollment is handled differently and has its own requirements, so it's worth reading about on EDD's site separately from a standard PFL claim. Not relevant to your current care claim but useful background for the future.
0 coins
Nasira Ibanez
Worth knowing about if your work situation shifts and the W-2 agencies drop you to a lower classification. The gap in coverage can sneak up on you.
0 coins
Miranda Singer
The Notice of Computation on my care claim for my mom showed a weekly benefit amount that didn't match what I'd estimated using EDD's calculator. I'd used the wrong quarters — I was putting in the most recent four quarters instead of the highest single quarter from the base period window. I used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent and she confirmed the quarters EDD had used to calculate my benefit amount and explained which wages had hit in which quarter. Ended up making sense once I had the right quarters in front of me.
0 coins
Simon White
AuthorThe base period math is confusing when you have income spread across multiple employers. I'll double check my estimates using just the highest quarter once my Notice of Computation arrives rather than assuming my running average.
0 coins
Aliyah Debovski
Highest quarter of wages in the base period is what EDD uses for the weekly benefit amount, not the average. The EDD calculator on their site walks you through it if you put in each quarter separately — it'll show you which one it's pulling from.
0 coins
Miranda Singer
The agent also confirmed my claim was still in pending status at that point — this was about nine days after I filed — which at least told me nothing had gone sideways. She said the NoC isn't an approval, just the wage calculation, which matched what people here have said.
0 coins
Malia Ponder
Does the PFL weekly benefit amount change if you have multiple W-2 employers? Like does EDD add up wages from both when figuring out the highest quarter?
0 coins
Hugo Kass
EDD combines wages from all employers who withheld SDI when calculating the base period. So if you had two W-2 employers during the base period, both sets of wages count together toward the highest quarter. It's the total SDI-covered wages in that quarter that determines the benefit amount.
0 coins
Malia Ponder
That's actually really good news for my situation. I work part time for two different companies and was worried EDD would only look at one of them.
0 coins
Khalil Urso
Combined wages across employers is standard — EDD aggregates everything that had CASDI withheld. The confirmation of which employers and which quarters they used is on the Notice of Computation when it arrives.
0 coins
Kyle Wallace
Eleven days into my care claim for my dad and the second payment still hadn't posted. Payment history in SDI Online showed the first one but nothing after. I ended up using Claimyr to get an EDD agent on the line, and she went through the payment schedule on my claim and confirmed which weeks had been paid and what the date was for the next payment. Turned out there was a gap because I had a week flagged for Continued Claim Certification that I hadn't sent back yet — I hadn't even seen it arrive. Mailed it the next day.
0 coins
Simon White
AuthorThe Continued Claim Certification piece is something I need to stay on top of. If I'm taking this intermittently and reporting wages, those forms are going to be coming regularly. I'll make sure I'm watching for them in the mail.
0 coins
Kyle Wallace
The form comes in the mail and if you don't return it, benefits stop. No automatic reminder — you just have to check. I'd been waiting on a payment that was actually waiting on me.
0 coins
Madison Tipne
Setting a physical reminder to check the mail every few days during a claim period sounds obvious but I've seen people miss the Continued Claim Certification twice in a row. EDD doesn't send a warning before stopping the payments.
0 coins
Ryder Ross
Quick thing on the tax side — California doesn't tax PFL benefits, but I remember reading something about federal taxes. Can anyone clarify?
0 coins
Hugo Kass
California doesn't tax PFL, that part is clear. For the federal question, EDD mails a 1099-G in January covering the year the benefits were paid, and whether PFL is taxable at the federal level is something to check on EDD's tax information page or with a tax professional. I'd be cautious about anyone stating it as a firm rule either way — it's worth verifying for your own situation.
0 coins
Ryder Ross
Fair enough, I'll check the EDD tax info page and talk to my accountant. I just didn't want to be surprised come filing season.
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
My employer told me I'd have to use up all my accrued vacation before PFL kicks in. Is that actually how it works?
0 coins
Cass Green
An employer can require you to use vacation or sick time alongside PFL, but the combined amount of your regular wages and PFL can't push your total income above your normal take-home pay. How exactly your employer layers its own paid time off with PFL is their own policy decision. For the job protection piece — whether your employer has to hold your position while you're on leave — that's a CFRA or FMLA question, not something EDD controls. PFL pays the benefit but doesn't protect the job on its own.
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
So EDD doesn't set the rules on the vacation part — that's just my employer's policy as long as it stays within the wage cap. Got it. And I need to ask HR separately about whether CFRA applies to my situation for the job protection side.
0 coins
Landon Flounder
HR is the right place for the CFRA question. EDD handles PFL only — the job protection layer is entirely separate and depends on your employer's size and your situation. EDD's site won't answer that one for you.
0 coins
Malia Ponder
Coming back to the original question about self-employed and W-2 income — I'm in almost the exact same boat. Two agencies, one treated as W-2 and one is 1099. The W-2 agency has been consistent so I'm not worried about the threshold, but I did want to confirm one thing: if the W-2 agency reduces my hours during leave, do I still report those weeks as "working" even if it was just a few hours for a project I finished before the leave started?
0 coins
Hugo Kass
Any wages you receive or earn — even from work you did before your leave started — have to be reported on the Continued Claim Certification for the week you receive them. It's the week the money becomes available to you that matters for reporting, not necessarily when you did the work. If you're unsure how a specific payment should be counted, ask EDD directly.
0 coins
Simon White
AuthorI have this exact same concern with projects I invoiced before stepping back. I'm going to call EDD before that first Continued Claim Certification arrives so I know exactly what to report and there's no overpayment issue later.
0 coins