Back to California Disability

Taylor Chen

Why is SDI payout lower than calculated benefit amount from employer

So my HR department gave me an estimate of what my SDI would be before I went out on leave and the number they gave me was noticeably higher than what actually showed up on my Notice of Computation. Not talking about a small rounding difference, we're talking a gap of like $80 a week. HR said they used EDD's calculator but now I'm getting a different figure on the actual notice. I've been out since mid-October after a back procedure and the payments I've been getting match the lower number on the notice, not what HR said. Does EDD use a different formula than what employers plug into that calculator? Or did HR just enter something wrong? Anyone dealt with this gap before?

October start date is actually important here. The base period EDD uses looks back to wages from roughly 5 to 18 months before your claim started, so the highest-earning quarter in that window is what drives your weekly amount. If HR pulled your most recent pay instead of that specific lookback quarter, they'd come up with a higher number than EDD does.

0 coins

That could be it. I got a raise in January so my recent pay is higher than what I was making in that lookback window. HR probably used current salary.

0 coins

Wait so EDD doesn't just look at what you were making right before you got hurt? That seems like it would always come out lower than people expect.

0 coins

Pretty much, yes. The base period is set when you file, not adjusted for recent raises. The Notice of Computation shows which quarter they used, so check yours against your pay history from that period.

0 coins

Notice of Computation on my claim last spring had a weekly amount that also confused me. Ended up reaching EDD about it through Claimyr (claimyr.com) and an agent pulled up my claim and confirmed which quarter they'd pulled and what the high-quarter wages were. The gap between what I expected and what the notice said made sense once I saw the actual quarter. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

The quarter detail you mentioned is exactly what tripped me up on my own claim. I'd already used Claimyr by then to ask about the waiting period, and the agent walked me through which days actually counted as the non-payable seven and which day the first payable one was. Cleared up why my first deposit was smaller than I expected.

0 coins

How long were you on hold before anyone picked up? I've called that line four mornings in a row and it just runs me around to a recording.

0 coins

The line never connected for me on my own, tried it Tuesday and Thursday two weeks straight. Through Claimyr I ended up talking to someone that same afternoon.

0 coins

Alright, might be worth trying. That recording has gotten real old.

0 coins

Another thing that catches people off guard: the benefit percentage isn't flat. EDD pays somewhere between 70 and 90 percent of your high-quarter wages depending on where your income falls. Lower earners get closer to 90 percent, higher earners get closer to 70. If HR assumed a flat 90 percent for everyone, that alone would explain part of the gap.

0 coins

HR actually told me they used 90 percent. So that's probably part of it right there.

0 coins

My HR did the exact same thing, assumed the top percentage and then I was surprised when the notice came in lower. It's annoying that they don't warn people.

0 coins

The calculator on EDD's site gives a more accurate estimate than a flat-percentage guess. Worth running your own numbers there before your next claim just to have a realistic baseline.

0 coins

HR estimates for SDI are basically guesses dressed up as math. I've never seen one come in accurate. EDD's Notice of Computation is the only number that actually matters.

0 coins

Harsh but not wrong.

0 coins

Yeah I'm starting to see that. The notice is what it is, HR estimate was just wishful thinking apparently.

0 coins

Worth double-checking whether any of your wages in that base period were from a time before you were subject to SDI deductions, like if you switched employers or had a gap in covered employment. Wages without that CASDI deduction on the paystub don't count toward your SDI benefit calculation.

0 coins

I've been with the same employer the whole time and always had the CASDI line on my stubs, so that one probably isn't the issue for me. But good to know.

0 coins

Wait, so if someone did a few months of freelance with no SDI deductions, those months just get zeroed out in the calculation? That would really hurt the benefit amount.

0 coins

Correct. Only wages with SDI contributions count. The requirement is at least $300 in SDI-covered wages in the base period to be eligible at all, and the benefit is figured from those wages only.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation also isn't an approval, just so you know. It shows the potential amount if you're found eligible. Some people think it means the claim is done processing when it isn't yet.

0 coins

Nobody told me that either. I thought getting the notice meant I was good to go. So what actually confirms eligibility?

0 coins

Payments showing up, basically. Or if it's denied, EDD sends a Notice of Determination instead. The computation notice just locks in the dollar figure.

0 coins

Okay that makes me feel slightly better, mine is still pending and I was worried because I had the notice but no payment yet.

0 coins

EDD uses the quarter, HR uses your current pay. They're almost never the same number. The notice wins.

0 coins

Pretty much the summary of this whole thread.

0 coins

yeah exactly this, took me forever to figure out why my check was lower

0 coins

Weeks paid on my claim had a discrepancy I couldn't reconcile from SDI Online alone. Called EDD through Claimyr and the agent went through each week that had been issued and which ones were still pending. Turned out one week in my claim period had been skipped because the medical certification came in with a date gap, and I hadn't noticed.

0 coins

Skipped week because of a date gap sounds exactly like something that would happen on my claim. I've tried that disability line probably a dozen times, never gotten past the automated part.

0 coins

My own record on that line before was about the same. The agent I reached confirmed the certification was the issue and said EDD would mail a notice about it.

0 coins

My provider closed a date gap on mine and the week paid out within two weeks after! Make sure the certification covers every day you're claiming.

0 coins

Fine, I'll give it a shot this week. I've got a week that looks like it was just skipped and I want to know why.

0 coins

Also just a heads up, if your employer has their own short-term disability or leave plan, those numbers can get mixed in and suddenly nobody knows which estimate came from where. HR sometimes conflates the two.

0 coins

We do have a company STD policy on top of SDI. That might be part of the confusion, honestly I didn't think to separate the two when HR gave me the number.

0 coins

Yeah that'll do it lol. EDD pays its amount based on your SDI-covered wages, your employer's plan is separate. Ask HR to show you which estimate was just the EDD piece.

0 coins

My claim is still pending and I'm honestly terrified the payout is going to be way less than I planned for. I went out at the start of November after shoulder surgery and HR's number had me thinking I'd be okay and now reading this thread I'm not so sure.

0 coins

Run the EDD calculator yourself, it's on EDD's site, before you assume the worst. Put in your actual wages from about 5 to 18 months ago and it'll give you a closer estimate than what HR usually provides.

0 coins

I didn't know there was a calculator on EDD's site I could run myself. Going to do that tonight.

0 coins

Do it! Knowing the actual number early helps you figure out your budget while you're out.

0 coins

The base period quarters are fixed by when you file, not when you stop working. People sometimes try to time their filing to include a higher-earning quarter and it can change the outcome. Not suggesting you should have waited, just explaining why the quarter matters so much.

0 coins

That's actually a useful thing to know going forward. Can you pick which quarter EDD uses, or is it just automatic?

0 coins

Automatic. EDD determines the highest-paid quarter within the base period window. You don't choose it, but knowing your earnings history helps you understand what they'll land on.

0 coins

I had no idea timing the filing could matter like that. Would have been helpful to know before my procedure.

0 coins

DE 2525XX came back from my doctor and EDD hadn't logged it yet when I checked SDI Online. Got on a call through Claimyr and the agent confirmed the extension form wasn't showing on my claim yet and said to wait for a notice by mail.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly?

0 coins

Service that gets you on the line with an EDD agent without you sitting there redialing all morning. Stays on hold for you, your phone rings when someone picks up at EDD.

0 coins

Okay. I've got a question about my own Notice of Computation that I keep putting off because I can't get through. Might actually try that.

0 coins

the waiting period thing catches a lot of people too. first seven days of the claim dont pay anything, so the first payment covers day 8 forward. if you calculated from day 1 the total looks lower than it should.

0 coins

I knew about the waiting period but honestly didn't account for it when I was doing my own rough math. That does explain some of the difference in total amount.

0 coins

Is the waiting period one calendar week or seven business days? I never got a clear answer on that.

0 coins

seven calendar days. starts on the first day of disability, and day 8 is when it gets payable.

0 coins

my employer estimate was off by like $60 a week, turns out they used my gross not my sdi-covered wages which arent always the same thing

0 coins

Good catch. Some wage types aren't subject to SDI deductions so they don't get counted. If HR just grabbed total gross pay the number will almost always come out high.

0 coins

Is there a way to know which wages counted without calling EDD? Like can I see it in SDI Online anywhere?

0 coins

The Notice of Computation shows the high-quarter amount EDD used. Cross-referencing that against your paystubs from that quarter will tell you if anything got excluded.

0 coins

I told my client about this exact thing last week, she was shocked her SDI payment was so much lower than what her company told her to expect. She's out for the same kind of recovery you're describing and was counting on the higher number for rent.

0 coins

That's the stressful part. I arranged my bills expecting the HR estimate and now I'm short every two weeks.

0 coins

If the gap is significant and you think EDD got the base period wrong, you can appeal the Notice of Computation within 30 days of the date on it. Worth looking at the date on yours.

0 coins

30 days goes fast so check that date right away.

0 coins

Patients at my hospital often assume their leave pay will match their regular check. It rarely does. The SDI benefit is a wage replacement, not full pay, and the base period calculation often surprises people. Reviewing the Notice of Computation closely when it arrives is the best thing to do.

0 coins

That's actually reassuring to hear from someone in healthcare. I keep thinking something went wrong but maybe it's just how it's supposed to work.

0 coins

Usually it's the formula, not an error. If the Notice of Computation amount seems truly off after checking your old paystubs, there's an appeal process.

0 coins

49 days from your disability start date is the deadline for the medical certification to be in. If the certification came in late or covered different dates than your claim, EDD might calculate from a later start date, which shifts the base period and can drop the weekly amount.

0 coins

My surgeon's office submitted it pretty quickly so I don't think timing was the issue, but I hadn't even thought to check that it matched my actual start date.

0 coins

Worth confirming the certification's start date matches what you put in your claim. A one or two week mismatch in start dates can shift which quarter EDD pulls from.

0 coins

I had the same situation with my wrist injury claim! HR gave me an estimate based on what I'd been earning the past few months and EDD came back with a different base period quarter entirely! Once I understood the lookback window it made sense but it took me a while to figure out why the numbers didn't match!

0 coins

The lookback window is the part most people don't realize is even a thing until the notice shows up with a number they weren't expecting.

0 coins

Exactly! The EDD calculator on their site was what finally helped me understand what they'd actually count!

0 coins

Bottom line is never trust HR on what SDI pays. Run your own numbers or wait for the notice. Learned that the hard way two years ago.

0 coins

Lesson learned on my end too. I'll know better next time.

0 coins

HR means well. They just don't know EDD's formula.

0 coins

Fair. Not their job to know it exactly I guess.

0 coins

Don't forget you can also check the payment info line at 1-800-480-3287 if SDI Online isn't showing you enough detail on what's been issued and what's still pending.

0 coins

Good to have that number. SDI Online shows my payments but doesn't explain why the total is what it is, so calling might help.

0 coins

Yeah SDI Online shows you the amounts but the agent can actually explain the specific weeks and what was applied to each one.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure