Back to California Disability

Yara Campbell

SDI overpayment paid family leave paid instead of disability pregnancy — what do I do now?

So I'm about 10 weeks into my maternity leave situation and I just got a notice saying I have an overpayment on my account. When I look at what happened, it seems like EDD paid me under Paid Family Leave instead of Disability Insurance for the weeks before I gave birth, which I'm pretty sure is backwards? I was out starting about 4 weeks before my due date because my doctor put restrictions on me, so that should have been a DI claim, not PFL. I'm not even totally sure how this happened because I thought I filed the disability claim correctly through SDI Online. Now they're saying I owe money back and I don't even understand what I did wrong or if this was their error. Has anyone dealt with an overpayment where the wrong program paid out during pregnancy? Do I appeal the notice or is there a different process? I'm already stressed enough with a newborn and I don't know where to start.

Your doctor's restrictions before delivery are exactly what DI covers for pregnancy. PFL is the bonding claim that follows after the birth, so the two programs should not overlap and they definitely should not swap places. The notice you received should be a DE 2517 with an Appeal Form DE 1000A attached. You have 30 days from the date printed on that notice to file the appeal, so read the date carefully and do not wait on this.

0 coins

Filing the appeal form today then. The date on my notice is from last week so I still have time, just barely found this thread.

0 coins

Good. Keep copies of everything you send.

0 coins

The appeal goes to the return address printed right on that notice, not to EDD's general mailing address. Worth double-checking before you drop it in the mail.

0 coins

DE 429D came in showing a weekly amount that looked off, so I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to sort it out. The agent pulled up my base period and confirmed which quarter they used to calculate the benefit. Video on getting a live person on EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. She clarified that the Notice of Computation isn't the same as an approval, just what your potential weekly amount would be, so the amount on mine was correct for my wages.

0 coins

Sounds like marketing to me. How would some service get you through to EDD when nobody can get through on their own?

0 coins

Tried the number myself across four mornings before that. Each time the line disconnected before I hit any menu option. Claimyr just held the line in my place until a live person at EDD picked up, then my phone rang. The agent was EDD, not some third party.

0 coins

Okay, tried it myself after my DE 2501 situation went sideways. Agent confirmed my claim start date and which weeks were still pending on their end. Still not sure why a service needs to do what a phone line should do, but it worked.

0 coins

My disability claim had the same Notice of Computation confusion, thought it meant I was approved. Good to know it's just the potential amount.

0 coins

Didn't even realize there was a difference between the notice and an actual approval. Have to look at mine again.

0 coins

EDD mixing up DI and PFL on a pregnancy claim is more common than people think. You filed for disability, your doctor certified, and somehow bonding benefits went out instead. That's their error, not yours, and you have every right to say so in the appeal.

0 coins

That actually makes me feel a little better. I was worried they'd say I did something wrong when filing.

0 coins

Put in the appeal and send your doctor's certification paperwork with it. Show what you filed for.

0 coins

Worth noting that in the appeal letter you can explain the timeline, your work restrictions starting before the due date, your doctor's certification, all of that becomes the record the judge looks at.

0 coins

Wait, I'm confused about something. If PFL has no waiting period and DI does, could EDD have accidentally started PFL early to avoid dealing with the DI waiting period? I'm probably wrong but that's the only reason I could think of why they'd pay the wrong one first.

0 coins

The waiting period on a DI claim is the first seven days, which aren't payable. It's not processing time, it's just a non-payable window built into every new DI claim. EDD wouldn't swap programs because of it. What likely happened is a filing or matching issue between your two claims, not anything about the waiting period.

0 coins

Okay that clears it up for me, I had the waiting period completely mixed up with some kind of delay.

0 coins

The seven-day thing trips a lot of people up. It just means day eight is when the first payable day starts.

0 coins

this happened to a guy i work with not exactly the same but edd paid the wrong claim type and he just appealed with his doctors paperwork and it got sorted out took a while tho

0 coins

How long did it take for his appeal to come back?

0 coins

like 6 or 8 weeks i think but he said once he showed them the doctors cert it was pretty clear cut

0 coins

Overpayment notice on a program mix-up is frustrating but it's the right path. Appeal it. Bring the medical certification your doctor filed, the dates your restrictions started, and the original claim you submitted. That's your whole case.

0 coins

For the appeal record, I'd organize it chronologically: restriction start date, claim filing date, medical certification submission date, then the dates the PFL payments went out. Makes it easy for the judge to see exactly where the gap is.

0 coins

Pulling all my paperwork tonight to build that timeline. This is really helpful.

0 coins

Screenshots from SDI Online showing what you filed and when are worth saving too.

0 coins

Honestly edd doing this during a pregnancy leave is wild lol. You file disability because your doctor said you can't work, and they pay bonding instead? The whole point of the two programs is they're supposed to run back to back, not get swapped.

0 coins

Right, the typical order is DI for pregnancy and recovery, then PFL for bonding after. If those got reversed or overlapped it's a pretty clear administrative error.

0 coins

File the appeal and spell it out for them in plain language. DI first, PFL second. That's how it's supposed to work.

0 coins

Which weeks were paid under PFL versus DI was the question I needed answered on my own claim, and after three weeks of getting disconnected I talked to an EDD agent through Claimyr about it. The agent went through my payment history week by week and told me exactly which ones had posted under each program.

0 coins

Honestly this sounds like a sponsored post or something. Feels too neat.

0 coins

thought the same thing before i tried it on my own claim. agent told me my payment for a specific week had already issued, i just hadn't seen it hit the card yet. that was real EDD info, not someone guessing.

0 coins

Alright, fair enough. If I can't get through by Friday I'll give it a shot.

0 coins

Knowing exactly which weeks were coded under which program would actually help my appeal a lot. I need to figure out what their records show.

0 coins

The overpayment notice itself is worth reading closely because sometimes it breaks down which specific weeks and amounts they're calling overpaid. That detail tells you exactly which payments went to the wrong program and by how much.

0 coins

Cross-reference whatever weeks they list with your bank or card records. If the amounts match the PFL payment schedule rather than a DI schedule, that's your documentation right there.

0 coins

Mine does list specific weeks, six of them. All fall in the four weeks before my due date and the two weeks right after, which is exactly when I should have been on DI not PFL.

0 coins

Those are the weeks your doctor's certification should cover for DI. Bring that document and the specific weeks the notice names, and your appeal tells the story on its own.

0 coins

Your doctor's certification is the key document here. If it shows dates before your delivery when you had restrictions or were unable to work, that's the evidence that DI should have paid, not PFL. Keep that with your appeal.

0 coins

My OB's office submitted it through SDI Online, so I need to get a copy from them to include with my appeal paperwork.

0 coins

Ask the office to give you a printed copy or a summary showing the certification dates. That's the piece that ties your restrictions to the specific weeks in the overpayment notice.

0 coins

My cousin went through something kind of similar where her claims got mixed up and she ended up with an overpayment notice too. She was really scared about it but once she sent in the appeal with everything from her doctor it got resolved. Try not to spiral too much, you have a solid case from what you're describing.

0 coins

Appreciate this, really. I've been in my head about it all week.

0 coins

New baby plus an overpayment notice is genuinely a lot to deal with at once.

0 coins

DE 2525XX was what came up on my own pregnancy claim when I needed more recovery time, and I used Claimyr to reach EDD and ask whether the extension had been submitted by my midwife. The agent confirmed it had come in and told me EDD would send the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification, the DE 2500E, with my final regular payment.

0 coins

Did the agent say whether you needed to do anything on your end after the midwife submitted it, or did it just move forward on its own?

0 coins

She said the extension goes through once the provider's side is submitted and EDD processes it. She told me to watch for the DE 2500E in my mail and that would confirm things.

0 coins

been trying that disability line for going on two weeks now. every morning same thing, rings a few times and cuts off.

0 coins

For the original poster's situation, the extension piece isn't really the issue, it's the program mix-up that generated the overpayment. The appeal is the right move.

0 coins

Don't sit on the appeal thinking you have plenty of time. 30 days goes fast with a newborn. File it this week, include your doctor's certification, write a plain explanation of what should have been DI and what dates, and mail it with proof of delivery.

0 coins

Mailing it tomorrow. Got the DE 1000A from the notice and writing the explanation tonight.

0 coins

Certified mail with return receipt. That way you have proof it got there.

0 coins

Is there any risk they'd deny the DI claim retroactively after you appeal? Like could you end up losing the PFL payments they made AND not getting DI for those weeks?

0 coins

An appeal on an overpayment notice is specifically about whether you owe that money back, not a new determination on your DI claim. What you're challenging is whether EDD has the right to call those payments overpayments given that the wrong program paid. That's different from starting over.

0 coins

The underlying question is whether DI should have been the payer for those weeks. If the appeal establishes that, the overpayment finding should go away because the right benefit was just paid under the wrong label.

0 coins

Okay that makes more sense. I was imagining a worst case where everything unraveled.

0 coins

EDD's disability line is genuinely brutal. Spent most of two mornings last month trying to reach someone about my own claim and got nowhere. I feel for anyone trying to sort out something complicated like a program mix-up over the phone.

0 coins

ive given up calling and just use ask edd now. takes longer but at least it goes somewhere

0 coins

Ask EDD and Request Claim Update in SDI Online are both slower but they create a written record, which isn't the worst thing for an appeal situation.

0 coins

For the actual appeal letter, lead with the date your restrictions started, your due date, and the medical certification your provider submitted. Then state plainly that DI covers the period of disability before and after delivery when your provider certified you couldn't work, and that PFL is for bonding after recovery. The mix-up becomes obvious when the timeline is laid out.

0 coins

Writing it out in a timeline format like this makes it a lot clearer. Thank you.

0 coins

Keeping the letter factual and date-driven is the right call. The less editorializing the better when it goes to an administrative law judge.

0 coins

Short and clear tends to work better than long explanations in these letters from what I've seen.

0 coins

For the waiting period on the DI claim, make sure your appeal doesn't accidentally argue you should have been paid for the first seven days. Those seven days are never payable on a DI claim, so your appeal should be focused on the weeks after that.

0 coins

Good catch. My restrictions started about 4 weeks before delivery so there are plenty of payable weeks after the waiting period to argue about.

0 coins

Correct. Day eight is the first payable day, so with four weeks of restrictions you'd still have roughly three weeks of DI before delivery to make the case around.

0 coins

The overpayment notice is not EDD saying you committed fraud, it's just their system flagging that money went out that may need to be corrected. The appeal is exactly the tool built for this. Use it.

0 coins

Needed to hear that actually. The word overpayment made me feel like I was accused of something.

0 coins

Program errors happen more than EDD would probably like to admit. You doing the right thing by appealing it.

0 coins

Once your appeal is filed, check SDI Online for any status update on the claim. Sometimes after an appeal is received the pending action on the account changes and you can see that it was logged.

0 coins

Will do. Logging into myEDD to check the claim status while I wait on the appeal outcome makes sense.

0 coins

Request Claim Update in SDI Online is also worth using to send a follow-up message if you don't hear anything after a few weeks post-appeal.

0 coins

late to this but just want to say the PFL versus DI confusion on pregnancy claims is real. i got told by someone at my job that bonding and disability were the same thing. they are not.

0 coins

Different programs, different rules, different clocks. DI covers your own medical recovery, PFL covers bonding with the baby after that. They're supposed to run one after the other, not on top of each other or in the wrong order.

0 coins

HR at a lot of jobs lumps them together when they explain leave, which does not help lol.

0 coins

Update from me: appeal is mailed, certified. Included the DE 1000A, a letter explaining the timeline, and a copy of my doctor's certification from the OB's office. The certification clearly shows the restriction start date was four weeks before delivery, which is exactly the period the overpayment notice covers. Now I wait. Really grateful for everyone here, this thread helped me understand what I was actually dealing with.

0 coins

You put together a solid appeal packet. The certification dates are exactly what ties it together.

0 coins

Certified mail was the right call. Keep that receipt somewhere you can find it.

0 coins

Fingers crossed the timeline speaks for itself. Sounds like it should.

0 coins

Let the documentation do the work. You've submitted everything they need to see it clearly.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure