Back to California Disability

Ivanna St. Pierre

SDI claim pending after workers comp appeal no response from EDD

So my situation is kind of a mess and I'm not sure where to start. I got hurt at work about four months ago and filed for workers' comp, but the whole thing got disputed and I ended up filing for SDI because I still couldn't work and the workers' comp wasn't paying out during the appeal process. My doctor submitted the medical certification and everything looked like it was in order. But my SDI claim has been sitting pending for weeks now and EDD hasn't sent anything, no notice, no payment, nothing. I've tried calling the disability line multiple times and I either get a busy signal or the automated system just ends the call. I don't even know if EDD is waiting on something from me or if there's a hold because of the workers' comp appeal. Has anyone dealt with both of these at the same time? Like does the workers' comp appeal automatically freeze your SDI?

Medical certification being matched up was what held my claim too, actually. Filed mine in SDI Online, handed my doctor the receipt number, and two weeks later the claim still said pending. Ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) because the phone line just played a recording and cut me off every morning I tried. Video on getting a live person at the disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent looked up my claim and told me the certification had come in under a slightly different receipt number so it wasn't matched to my claim yet. She told me to have my doctor's office resubmit with the exact number from my SDI Online confirmation screen. My doctor's office did it the same afternoon and the pending status cleared within a few days after that.

0 coins

Receipt number matching is what tripped me up too. My provider entered one digit wrong and the whole cert sat unattached for over a week. Used Claimyr the same way, agent pulled up my file and confirmed the certification was there but unmatched, so I went back to the office with the right number and they fixed it.

0 coins

the line hung up on me four mornings in a row. didnt even get to hold. glad something worked for you two

0 coins

So if EDD can't match the cert, do they send any kind of notice or does it just sit pending without you knowing? Because I've gotten zero mail from them.

0 coins

From what the agent told me, EDD contacts the claimant about the status usually within 14 days after the cert comes in. If you're past that and there's nothing, the cert may not have landed correctly or the workers' comp situation may be adding a layer.

0 coins

Workers' comp and SDI at the same time is not common. EDD itself says that. There are exceptions but nobody on a forum can tell you if your case is one of them. That's a question for EDD directly.

0 coins

That's actually really helpful to know there are exceptions. I wasn't sure if SDI would just automatically deny me because of the workers' comp.

0 coins

same thing happened to a guy on my crew. comp was disputed for months. he filed SDI and EDD sorted it out eventually but it did take longer than a normal claim

0 coins

Longer is the word. And you have to keep at it because EDD won't always chase you down.

0 coins

49 days after my disability started was the number that scared me when I first read about filing. Does the workers' comp dispute change that deadline at all? Like if someone is waiting on workers' comp to settle, does the 49-day window still apply for the SDI medical certification?

0 coins

The 49-day window applies from the disability start date regardless of what is happening with a workers' comp claim. If the certification isn't in by then, the claim can be disqualified. That's EDD's rule and there's no exception written there for a pending comp appeal.

0 coins

49 days feels really short when you're also dealing with attorneys and comp adjusters. So the doctor has to submit within 49 days even if comp hasn't resolved?

0 coins

Exactly right. The physician submits the medical certification within 49 days of when the disability began, and that clock doesn't pause for anything on the workers' comp side.

0 coins

not sure if this helps but I think you can file SDI first and then workers comp catches up later? I read that somewhere but I'm not 100% sure how it works

0 coins

Pending with no notice and no payment after weeks usually means EDD is waiting on something. Could be the cert, could be a question about the comp case. Only EDD knows which.

0 coins

and good luck finding that out when the line drops you every single time

0 coins

Yep. That's the whole problem.

0 coins

Has anyone actually gotten through to a real person at that number? I've tried 1-800-480-3287 at 8am and again mid-morning and it just ends the call.

0 coins

Waiting period was something I had to verify on my own claim. The first seven days of an SDI claim are unpaid regardless of anything else going on. Not processing time, not a hold, just seven days that EDD does not pay. I wasn't sure if the workers' comp period I'd already served would count toward that so I tried Claimyr to reach EDD, and the agent confirmed the waiting period ran from day one of my SDI claim start date specifically, not from when the injury happened. That cleared up a lot of confusion on my end.

0 coins

Every time I've called that disability line it either rings forever or just cuts off. How did you actually end up talking to someone? I tried for two weeks straight.

0 coins

The Claimyr route is what worked for me. The number and the hung-up calls were the same wall I was hitting before that.

0 coins

Agent told me my Notice of Computation showed the right quarter and amount after I finally got through. Having that confirmed was the piece I needed before I knew what to appeal.

0 coins

So the seven days is definitely not the same as processing time? My mom kept telling me it was just EDD processing slowly but it sounds like it's a separate rule.

0 coins

Completely separate. The waiting period is the first seven calendar days of every new claim. No payment for those days no matter how fast or slow the processing is. Processing is what happens after.

0 coins

I might be confusing things but isn't SDI only for non-work injuries? Like if it happened at work shouldn't it always be workers' comp and SDI wouldn't apply?

0 coins

Work injuries go to workers' comp, that part is right. But when comp is disputed or delayed and not paying, people sometimes file SDI. EDD says it's not common to receive both at the same time and there are exceptions. It's not an automatic denial.

0 coins

oh I didn't realize there were exceptions. I thought EDD would just kick it back automatically.

0 coins

EDD decides case by case. Nobody on here can promise you what they'll do with yours.

0 coins

My claim sat pending almost three weeks after I thought everything was in. Turned out my doctor's office thought they'd submitted through SDI Online but it hadn't actually gone through on their end. Worth double-checking with the provider's office that the submission confirmed, not just that they started it.

0 coins

My doctor's office swears it went through. But honestly I didn't think to ask them if they got a confirmation on their end. I'll ask that specifically.

0 coins

Ask them for the confirmation screen or whatever receipt they got on the provider side. That's how we figured out mine hadn't actually posted.

0 coins

yeah doctors offices drop the ball on this more than people think lol they said they sent mine too and they hadnt

0 coins

EDD has the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online if you log into myEDD. It won't fix everything but at least it's a way to flag the question without spending a morning on the phone. You pick the request type and type out what you're asking. I used it when my cert was delayed and got a response in SDI Online within about a week.

0 coins

I didn't even know that feature existed. I've been going straight to the phone every time. I'll try sending a message through there today.

0 coins

Definitely worth trying alongside the phone. Some people get answers faster one way, some the other, kind of depends on the week.

0 coins

request claim update saved me once too. had a pending question on my cert and they answered through the portal. anyway

0 coins

Ask EDD, EDD's online contact form, is another option when the phone line isn't working. It won't get you an instant answer but it creates a record that you asked, which matters if there's ever an appeal involved later.

0 coins

Does Ask EDD actually get a response? I've used EDD's contact forms before for unemployment stuff and it took forever.

0 coins

Response time varies. The value is the paper trail as much as the answer itself.

0 coins

Paper trail is real. Keep screenshots of every submission date.

0 coins

For what it's worth the Notice of Computation is what finally made things feel real on my claim! It shows your potential weekly amount but it's not an approval, just so you know if you get one. Approval shows up as actual payment or a denial notice.

0 coins

So getting a Notice of Computation doesn't mean you're approved? I thought that was like the confirmation that you're in the system.

0 coins

Nope, it just shows what your potential payment could be based on your wages! Actual approval is when the money moves or you get a formal determination notice.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation is the DE 429D. It tells you the potential weekly and maximum benefit amount based on the highest-paid quarter of your base period. It is not an eligibility decision.

0 coins

my sdi sat pending for almost a month once and i never found out exactly why, it just eventually processed. not saying thats helpful but sometimes it just takes longer than it should

0 coins

That's both reassuring and frustrating at the same time lol. How long did it take before you got your first payment?

0 coins

like five weeks total from when i filed. but i had the comp situation too so maybe thats why

0 coins

five weeks is rough when you've got no other income coming in

0 coins

Base period question was what I finally got answered on my own claim after weeks of that phone line doing nothing but hanging up on me. Tried it through Claimyr and the agent pulled up which quarter of my wages they were actually using, because I had switched from full-time to part-time about eight months before I filed and I wasn't sure which period would count. Turned out the highest-paid quarter they found was from before I cut my hours, so the weekly amount on my Notice of Computation was higher than I expected.

0 coins

what even is Claimyr, I've seen it mentioned a few times in here

0 coins

Service that sits on hold with EDD's disability line for you, so when a live agent picks up your phone rings instead of you burning through your morning trying to get through. That's pretty much it.

0 coins

oh that's actually useful. I've been trying to get someone at EDD to tell me whether the weeks I worked reduced hours count toward my base period and I can never get through. might try that for it.

0 coins

the line is genuinely useless some days. four attempts, four hangups. not exaggerating.

0 coins

Direct deposit versus the Money Network card is worth sorting out early. If you chose direct deposit through SDI Online your payments land in your bank account. If not, EDD sends the Money Network prepaid debit card. Not Bank of America anymore, that changed.

0 coins

Wait, it's not Bank of America? I thought EDD still used them. Where does the card actually come from now?

0 coins

Money Network now. If you're expecting a Bank of America card it won't come. Set up direct deposit in SDI Online if you haven't yet.

0 coins

Yes the Money Network card confused a lot of people when it switched! My neighbor almost threw hers out thinking it was junk mail.

0 coins

Workers' comp and SDI overlapping is not simple. EDD says it's not common to get both at the same time and there are exceptions. If you're already getting any workers' comp payment for the same period, that affects the SDI side. If comp is appealed and not paying anything yet, that's a different situation. EDD decides.

0 coins

So right now comp is paying nothing because it's under appeal. Does that mean SDI is more likely to approve the same period?

0 coins

EDD decides that, not the forum. The workers' comp appeal status is a fact EDD considers. Tell them exactly where the comp appeal stands when you reach them.

0 coins

What she said. Put it all in front of EDD and let them sort it. Don't try to guess what they'll do.

0 coins

49 days from the disability start date is the deadline for the medical certification to be in, as others have said. But the claimant's own part has its own window too: file no earlier than nine days after the disability starts and no later than 49 days in. If you've already filed, make sure the receipt number your doctor needs came from the SDI Online confirmation after you submitted.

0 coins

Nine days before filing was something I didn't know about. What happens if someone filed on day three? Does EDD reject it?

0 coins

EDD's rule says to wait nine days after the disability begins before filing. Filing before that window could cause issues. The form receipt number for the provider comes from the SDI Online confirmation screen after the claimant submits their part.

0 coins

I filed on day 11 and it went through fine. But I had no idea about the nine-day thing when I did it, just happened to wait that long.

0 coins

EDD's disability line is 1-800-480-3287. Eight to five Monday through Friday. State holidays they're closed. That's the only number. Tried it at 8:02 on a Tuesday once and still got dropped. Just putting it out there in case someone has a better time of day.

0 coins

8am is when everyone hits it at once. I've tried noon, I've tried 4:30. Mostly the same wall.

0 coins

Yeah I figured the trick doesn't really exist. Just keep trying.

0 coins

closed on state holidays too so if you dont know the holiday schedule you waste a whole morning dialing

0 coins

Appeal denial situation confused me for a while. If EDD sends a Notice of Determination saying the claim isn't payable, you have 30 days from the date on that notice to appeal. The form is the DE 1000A and it comes with the notice. If you lost the form you can write a detailed letter instead to the return address on the notice.

0 coins

I haven't gotten any denial notice at all yet, just nothing. So technically I'm still waiting to see what EDD decides?

0 coins

If there's no Notice of Determination yet, the claim is still pending or processing. The denial notice is what starts the 30-day appeal clock. No notice means you haven't been denied yet, which is different from being approved.

0 coins

Pending and denied are very different things. No news isn't bad news yet.

0 coins

Extension after the initial claim period is handled by the physician submitting the DE 2525XX, not by the claimant filing a new claim. If you end up needing more time off after the first approval window, the doctor takes care of their part and EDD sends that form with the final payment notice.

0 coins

Good to know about the extension process. I'm not there yet but honestly not sure how long this recovery is going to take.

0 coins

Understandable, it's a lot to manage at once. The main thing for now is getting the current pending situation sorted.

0 coins

DE 2525XX is the form name? I want to write that down just in case my own claim goes long.

0 coins

Partial week pay is something EDD controls the calculation on. If you go back to work part time at some point report it to EDD and let them figure the amount. Don't try to calculate it yourself and don't just stop certifying without telling them.

0 coins

I'm nowhere near going back yet but I'll remember that for when it comes up.

0 coins

Reporting part-time hours the right way matters a lot. Someone I know forgot to report a couple of shifts and ended up with an overpayment notice. Not fun.

0 coins

Overpayment notices are easier to avoid than to fix. Report as you go.

0 coins

Automatic payments are a thing after EDD gets rolling on your claim! But after five payments, ten weeks basically, EDD sends the DE 2593 questionnaire asking if you're still unable to work. Return it within 20 days or benefits can stop. Mark your calendar for that one.

0 coins

i missed that form once and my payments stopped mid-claim. had to scramble to get it sorted. dont miss the DE 2593

0 coins

Twenty days to return it, got it. I'll set a reminder the second I see any payment come through.

0 coins

Smart move! It catches people off guard when it shows up because things seem to be running on their own until then.

0 coins

Taxes on SDI benefits, since it comes up: California does not tax them. Whether they're taxable at the federal level depends on the situation and EDD's tax information page or a tax professional is the right place to get that answered for your specific case.

0 coins

California not taxing SDI is one of the few straightforward things about this whole process.

0 coins

Agreed. The federal side is where it gets complicated enough to need actual advice.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure