Paid family leave denied because employer tops up pay — how to appeal?
So I finally filed for PFL to bond with my baby after my SDI pregnancy claim ended, and EDD sent me a denial. The reason on the notice said something about my employer supplementing my wages during leave, basically my company has a top-up policy where they pay the difference between PFL and my full salary. I had no idea that was even a thing to worry about. I didn't think it mattered who else was paying me as long as I was actually on leave and bonding with my baby. Has anyone had their Paid Family Leave denied because employer tops up pay and figured out how to appeal? The notice has an Appeal Form (DE 1000A) attached but I have no idea what to actually write on it. Do I need to gather pay stubs? A letter from HR? I'm completely lost and the 30-day window to appeal is ticking.
71 comments

Joshua Hellan
Pull the denial notice out and read the specific reason code on it before anything else. Appeals for PFL denials go to the same process as DI appeals: fill out that DE 1000A, write a detailed explanation of your situation, and mail it to the return address printed on the notice itself, not to EDD's general address. If you've misplaced the form, a detailed letter works too, but attach copies of anything that shows you were actually on bonding leave during those weeks.
0 coins
Olivia Kay
AuthorThank you, the return address part is helpful. I do have the DE 1000A. Should I include my employer's top-up policy in writing, like a letter from HR that explains how their supplement works?
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
A written explanation from HR describing the policy would be a reasonable thing to include. You want the administrative law judge to see the full picture of what you received and why.
0 coins
Olivia Kay
AuthorOkay I'll ask HR to put it in writing. I didn't even know an administrative law judge was the one who reviews these.
0 coins
Jibriel Kohn
DE 2525XX came back from my doctor's office later than I expected on my own disability claim, and I ended up talking to an EDD agent because of Claimyr (claimyr.com). The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the extension request had been received and what date it was logged. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Anyway, for your appeal, I'd write out a clear timeline on that DE 1000A, what weeks you were on leave, what PFL was supposed to cover, and what the employer supplement actually was.
0 coins
Edison Estevez
What did you have ready when the agent picked up, like claim number and that kind of thing?
0 coins
Jibriel Kohn
Had my Social Security number, the claim ID from SDI Online, and the specific date I expected the extension to show up. Agent found it right away.
0 coins
Emily Nguyen-Smith
Been hitting that line most mornings for two weeks and can't get past the busy signal. Good to know someone's getting through.
0 coins
James Johnson
The 30-day clock runs from the date printed on the denial notice, not the day you received it in the mail, so check that date carefully. EDD's appeals page confirms the deadline is 30 days from the issue date. If you're past that window, you can still appeal but you have to explain the reason for the delay and an administrative law judge decides whether to accept it.
0 coins
Olivia Kay
AuthorChecked the notice, I still have about 18 days. That's cutting it closer than I'd like. Filing the DE 1000A today.
0 coins
Sophia Rodriguez
The delay exception is worth knowing. I didn't realize you could still appeal late if you give a reason. Does that apply to DI denials too or just PFL?
0 coins
James Johnson
The same DE 1000A and the same 30-day rule apply to DI denial notices as well. And yes, a late appeal with a stated reason goes to the judge for a decision on whether to accept it.
0 coins
Mia Green
My coworker had something similar happen with PFL and she was really confused because she thought the top-up from the employer was just extra generosity, not something EDD would even look at. I honestly don't totally understand the rule here either. Is EDD saying you can't get PFL at all if your employer pays you during leave?
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
The denial notice explains EDD's reasoning in that specific case. What's written there is what matters for the appeal, and the administrative law judge weighs both sides. Without seeing the exact reason on the notice, I wouldn't want to guess at the rule.
0 coins
Mia Green
That makes sense, every notice probably says something a little different. I'll stop trying to figure it out from the outside.
0 coins
Emma Bianchi
Ask EDD directly through SDI Online if the notice language is confusing. The Request Claim Update option gets a written answer you can keep.
0 coins
Lucas Kowalski
EDD's phone line is a joke. Called at 8 on the dot four mornings running, got a recording telling me the line was full and to try again, then it hung up. If you need to actually speak to someone about what that denial code means before you write your appeal, you're going to be waiting a while.
0 coins
Olivia Kay
AuthorThis is my fear. I need someone to explain the denial reason to me in plain language before I fill out the appeal form.
0 coins
Olivia Martinez
The SDI Online message option is slower but it gives you something in writing, which is actually useful for an appeal. Might be worth trying that in parallel with attempting the phone.
0 coins
Lucas Kowalski
Yeah online message is fine if you've got time. I needed an answer same day, which is why the phone line thing drives me crazy.
0 coins
Lucas Kowalski
Claim start date on mine got recorded wrong in the system and I finally reached an agent through Claimyr to get it straightened out. Agent confirmed the date EDD had on file and said a correction notice would go out by mail. For your situation, I'd use the SDI Online message feature while you're waiting to get someone on the phone, so you've got a paper trail for the appeal.
0 coins
Charlie Yang
I want to ask EDD whether my claim's first payable day falls on the right week because the waiting period timing on mine looks off. Going to try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when I try it?
0 coins
Lucas Kowalski
Have your claim ID from SDI Online, the specific week in question, and your Social Security number. The agent can pull up exactly which weeks are showing as pending or paid.
0 coins
Grace Patel
I've been redialing since last Tuesday. Still haven't gotten a person.
0 coins
ApolloJackson
Wait, so does PFL even have a waiting period like SDI does? I thought both programs had that seven-day unpaid window at the start and that's why my first week wasn't paid. If the employer is covering that gap, is that why EDD denied it?
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
PFL actually has no waiting period at all. That seven-day unpaid window is only for Disability Insurance claims. If your first PFL week wasn't paid, the reason is something else on your specific claim.
0 coins
ApolloJackson
Oh wow, I had no idea PFL doesn't have the waiting period. I've been telling people the wrong thing. So what would cause a first week to not pay on a PFL claim?
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
Without seeing your notice, I can't say for certain. EDD sends a denial notice when a week isn't payable, and that notice tells you the reason and your right to appeal.
0 coins
ApolloJackson
I think I need to actually read my notice more carefully. I assumed the waiting period applied and just moved on.
0 coins
Isabella Russo
For the appeal letter itself, being organized about amounts and dates helps. I'd list each week, what PFL would have paid, and what the employer top-up added, so the judge can see the actual numbers from your Notice of Computation and your pay stubs side by side.
0 coins
Olivia Kay
AuthorThat's a good approach. I have my Notice of Computation and I can pull the pay stubs that cover the leave weeks.
0 coins
Isabella Russo
Exactly. If HR gives you a written description of their supplement policy, attach that too. Judges respond to documentation over explanations.
0 coins
Sophia Rodriguez
Does the Notice of Computation show up for PFL claims the same way it does for a DI claim? I've only had a DI claim and mine came pretty quickly after EDD processed the medical certification.
0 coins
Isabella Russo
PFL has its own computation notice, yes. It works similarly in that it shows your potential weekly and maximum benefit amount. Check your SDI Online account for the PFL claim documents.
0 coins
Rajiv Kumar
30 days goes so fast when you're home with a newborn! I had to do an appeal for a totally different EDD thing years ago and I barely got it in on time. File the DE 1000A today even if your letter isn't perfect yet, you can always send a more detailed letter to the return address afterward!
0 coins
Olivia Kay
AuthorFiling it today, yes. I'll send a supplemental letter with HR's documentation as soon as I have it.
0 coins
Rajiv Kumar
Great plan! Even a simple note with your claim number and 'I am appealing the denial dated X' gets you in under the deadline, the details can follow.
0 coins
Aria Washington
my company does the same top up thing and i never even thought to mention it when i filed, did you have to disclose it somewhere on the pfl form or did edd find out some other way
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
Employers report wage information to EDD, so it can surface during processing. Whether something needs to be disclosed upfront depends on the specific form instructions, which vary.
0 coins
Aria Washington
ugh so its just something they figure out on their end, good to know
0 coins
Liam O'Reilly
Notice of Computation on my DI claim had a base period quarter I didn't recognize, and I got through to an agent using Claimyr. The agent told me exactly which quarter of my wages they used and confirmed the weekly benefit amount showing on the notice was correct. For the person appealing the PFL denial, the same DE 1000A form is what you'd use, and the administrative law judge process is the same.
0 coins
Emma Bianchi
Payment method on mine also needed sorting. Used Claimyr for it and once the agent confirmed the direct deposit was on file, I went back to SDI Online and checked that the routing number matched what I'd entered. Took about five minutes total once I was on with someone.
0 coins
Chloe Delgado
been trying that line since monday. four mornings, same result every time.
0 coins
Emma Bianchi
Yeah the mornings don't always work either. No real pattern to when it picks up.
0 coins
Ava Harris
Something worth verifying before you mail the appeal: confirm the return address on the notice matches where you're sending it. Mailing to EDD's general address is a common mistake and can delay things significantly when there's already a deadline involved.
0 coins
Olivia Kay
AuthorDouble-checked, using the return address printed on the actual denial notice. Not the general EDD address.
0 coins
Ava Harris
Good. Send it in a way you can confirm it was received, like certified mail, so you have a delivery record if the timing is ever questioned.
0 coins
Olivia Martinez
Filing the appeal even without a complete explanation attached is better than missing the window. You can supplement it with more documents after, but the 30-day deadline itself can't be undone if you miss it.
0 coins
Olivia Kay
AuthorAlready printing the DE 1000A. HR said they can get me the top-up policy letter by end of week, so I'm sending the appeal now and the HR letter right behind it.
0 coins
Olivia Martinez
That's the right move. The judge will have both pieces before the hearing.
0 coins
Emily Nguyen-Smith
What the notice says is what you're appealing. Write to that specific reason, not a general argument about being on leave. Administrative law judges want to see you addressing what EDD actually said, not a broad case for why you deserved the benefit.
0 coins
Olivia Kay
AuthorThis is really useful framing. I need to quote the denial reason back and argue against that specific point, not just say I was on bonding leave.
0 coins
Emily Nguyen-Smith
Exactly right. Stick to what the notice said and show why that reasoning doesn't apply to your situation.
0 coins
Jacob Lee
Keep a copy of everything you send: the DE 1000A, the HR letter, the pay stubs. Appeals can take a while and you'll want to be able to reference what you submitted.
0 coins
Olivia Kay
AuthorCopies made. Dating everything too so I have a clear record of when I sent what.
0 coins
Jacob Lee
Good. If EDD mails you anything else about the appeal, open it right away. Sometimes there's a response deadline you won't want to miss.
0 coins
Charlie Yang
Is there any chance the employer top-up thing is a misunderstanding on EDD's part, like maybe the pay was categorized wrong? My wife's leave pay got confused with regular wages on a past claim and took forever to untangle.
0 coins
Isabella Russo
That kind of misclassification does happen. The appeal is exactly the right place to lay out what each payment was and where it came from.
0 coins
Charlie Yang
Makes sense. The appeal letter is basically your chance to explain what EDD might have read wrong in the wage data.
0 coins
Sophia Rodriguez
Have you tried the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online? For a PFL claim you should be able to send a message to EDD and ask them to explain the denial in plain language. It won't stop the 30-day clock but it might help you write a sharper appeal.
0 coins
Olivia Kay
AuthorSending a Request Claim Update right now alongside the appeal. Great idea to have their explanation in writing.
0 coins
Sophia Rodriguez
And whatever they write back, attach it to your supplemental letter. If EDD's own explanation supports your appeal, that's useful.
0 coins
Mia Green
Just want to say, bonding leave being denied is so stressful when you're already exhausted from a newborn. You're doing the right things by tackling it head-on.
0 coins
Olivia Kay
AuthorThank you, that actually means something right now. This whole process has been a lot on top of everything else.
0 coins
Mia Green
You've got this. And once you get through the appeal you'll know exactly how the system works for next time, not that anyone wants a next time with EDD.
0 coins
Edison Estevez
DE 1000A filed late once because I didn't realize the 30-day window was from the notice date. Judge accepted it because I explained I hadn't received the notice until days after the postmark. If you're ever in that situation, that reason is worth putting in writing.
0 coins
Olivia Kay
AuthorGood to know that late-receipt is a valid reason for the judge. I'm still inside the window but I'll remember that if anything else ever gets denied.
0 coins
James Johnson
That's consistent with what EDD's appeals information says. The key is explaining the reason in writing and letting the administrative law judge make the call.
0 coins
Chloe Delgado
update if you hear back? curious how pfl appeals usually go on these top-up situations
0 coins
Olivia Kay
AuthorWill do. Mailing the DE 1000A today and the HR letter as soon as I have it. I'll post back once I hear from EDD about the hearing.
0 coins
Grace Patel
Hope it works out.
0 coins