Denied SDI because employer university of is SDI exempt — what to do
So I got a denial notice from EDD and I'm honestly kind of panicking. I've been out for about six weeks after a procedure and I filed my SDI claim through SDI Online like I was supposed to, got my doctor to submit the medical certification, waited... and then got a Notice of Determination saying I was denied. The reason EDD gave was something about my employer being exempt from SDI participation, and I work at a university. I had no idea universities could be exempt from SDI. I've been paying into something on my paystub this whole time — or at least I thought I was? Now I'm looking at my old pay stubs and I'm not sure if what I see is actually the CASDI deduction or something else entirely. Has anyone dealt with this? The denial notice mentions I have 30 days to appeal and there's an appeal form included. I don't know if I should appeal, look into whether my employer actually has some kind of voluntary plan instead, or just give up. Six weeks with no income is already really hard and I feel like I'm running out of options.
83 comments

Henry Delgado
Seven days after my procedure I finally got to talk to someone at EDD about the waiting period on my own claim, after weeks of that line just cutting me off. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through — the service waits on that line so your phone rings when a live EDD person picks up. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent confirmed my waiting period started the day I listed as my disability start date, not when EDD got my paperwork, which I had completely wrong. For your situation with the university exemption, the denial notice itself is your starting point — that 30-day appeal window is real and it closes fast.
0 coins
Olivia Kay
What exactly is Claimyr? Never heard of it.
0 coins
Henry Delgado
The service stays on hold with EDD's disability line while you do other things, then your phone rings once an actual EDD person is on the line. What's your claim situation?
0 coins
Olivia Kay
Rotator cuff repair, been out eight weeks. Need to ask about the waiting period same as you did — gonna look into this because that line hung up on me three mornings straight.
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
Before deciding whether to appeal, the most important thing to check is your paystub — specifically whether the deduction reads CASDI. If you've had that deduction taken out, your employer was participating in SDI and EDD may have the wrong information about the exemption. If the deduction is different, your employer may have a Voluntary Plan instead of state SDI, which is a separate arrangement and EDD wouldn't pay that claim directly.
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
AuthorI pulled up three old paystubs and honestly I can't tell. One line just says 'State DI' and another says something that might be CASDI. Is 'State DI' the same thing?
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
State' DI on a paystub is typically the same CASDI deduction, yes. The key is that something was withheld. Bring those paystubs when you appeal or contact EDD —'they reevidence.
0 coins
Jibriel Kohn
Wait, so if the university had a Voluntary Plan this whole time, does that mean EDD can't help at all? Like is the appeal even worth it then?
0 coins
Edison Estevez
A Voluntary Plan is actually approved by EDD and has to provide at least the same benefits as state SDI. So if the employer has one, the claim goes to whoever administers that plan, not to EDD directly. The denial might actually be EDD correctly redirecting, not a final no.
0 coins
Emily Nguyen-Smith
Check HR. First thing. Find out if the school has a Voluntary Plan and who runs it. That's the fastest answer you'll get.
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
AuthorI emailed HR the day I got the denial and they haven't responded yet. It's been four days.
0 coins
Emily Nguyen-Smith
Go in person if you can. Email takes forever.
0 coins
James Johnson
HR at big institutions can be so slow. I had to physically show up at my employer's office to get a straight answer about my leave paperwork too — same thing, emails just sat there.
0 coins
Sophia Rodriguez
The denial doesn't necessarily mean the whole claim is dead. EDD issues a Notice of Determination with an Appeal Form (DE 1000A) when a claim isn't payable, and you have 30 days from the date on that notice to appeal. If your paystubs show CASDI deductions were taken, that's worth appealing with those stubs as documentation.
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
AuthorThe notice is dated about nine days ago so I still have time. The DE 1000A is included, I have it. Should I write a separate letter explaining the paystub situation or just fill in the form?
0 coins
Sophia Rodriguez
A detailed explanation attached to the DE 1000A is your best move. The form itself just has limited space. Write out the timeline, attach copies of the paystubs showing the deductions, and mail it to the return address on the notice.
0 coins
Mia Green
The more specific the better when you write that explanation. EDD needs to see the actual deduction, not just your word that it happened.
0 coins
Emma Bianchi
Appealed one of these years ago. University exempt situation, different reason, but same denial code essentially. Attached four months of paystubs. Won on appeal.
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
AuthorThat's really encouraging. Did you have to go to a hearing or did they resolve it on paper?
0 coins
Emma Bianchi
Resolved on paper. Never had to show up anywhere.
0 coins
Lucas Kowalski
That's not always how it goes though. Some appeals do go to a hearing. Depends on the case.
0 coins
Emma Bianchi
True. Mine didn't, but yeah — not guaranteed.
0 coins
Olivia Martinez
My wife went through something kind of similar — her employer was a nonprofit and there was confusion about SDI participation. She just submitted her paystubs showing the deduction and EDD reversed it. Took a few weeks but anyway just saying it can work out.
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
AuthorA few weeks feels long when I'm already six weeks in with nothing, but I'll take it over a full denial. Thanks for sharing that.
0 coins
Olivia Martinez
Totally understand — the waiting is the worst part. Hope it moves fast for you.
0 coins
Charlie Yang
my old job was at a school district and they had their own plan not edd so i had to go through the district for disability payments, took forever to figure out that wasnt an edd thing at all
0 coins
Charlie Yang
if your uni has their own plan HR really is the only way in, the edd line wont know the details of the schools plan
0 coins
Edison Estevez
That tracks — EDD can confirm whether a Voluntary Plan exists for a given employer, but the claims process for those plans is handled by whoever the employer set up to administer it, not by EDD.
0 coins
Sophia Rodriguez
Calling EDD to verify what's actually on file for my employer ended up being the clearest thing I did on my own claim. The base period quarter question had been driving me crazy — my income varied a lot and I didn't know which quarter EDD was looking at. Used Claimyr to reach an agent and she pulled up my claim and told me exactly which quarter they used in the base period calculation.
0 coins
Grace Patel
Claimyr worked well for me too when I needed to sort out a payment date question. The agent I spoke with found the exact date my payment had been issued and that it went to my payment method on file — helped me figure out why I hadn't seen it yet. Really glad I tried it.
0 coins
ApolloJackson
Did the agent say anything about whether the payment date they found matched what SDI Online was showing, or was that info only available by phone?
0 coins
Grace Patel
SDI Online showed it was issued but not the specific date. The agent gave me the actual date it went out, which SDI Online doesn't display that precisely.
0 coins
Isabella Russo
Have you tried the Request Claim Update feature in SDI Online? You open your claim in myEDD, pick Request Claim Update, choose the type, and write in your question. It's not instant but sometimes faster than waiting for mail!
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
AuthorI didn't know that existed. I'll try it today and ask about the exemption determination. Even if it takes a few days that's something.
0 coins
Isabella Russo
Yes, definitely use it! And keep a copy of everything you send, just in case.
0 coins
Rajiv Kumar
Those paystubs matter a lot here. If CASDI was deducted, the employer was paying into SDI on your behalf and the exemption denial may be incorrect. Take the paystubs, the denial notice, and your appeal form and get that DE 1000A mailed before the 30 days is up.
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
AuthorThe 30-day clock is what's keeping me focused right now. I'm going to get the appeal in this week regardless and then sort out the HR question separately.
0 coins
Rajiv Kumar
Good call. Appeal first, HR conversation second. Those two tracks can run at the same time.
0 coins
Henry Delgado
The 30-day deadline on a denial notice — I've seen people miss it and then have to explain the delay to an administrative law judge, which adds even more time. Don't let that date slip.
0 coins
Jibriel Kohn
If someone does miss the 30 days, is the appeal automatically rejected or can they still explain why it was late?
0 coins
Henry Delgado
EDD says a late appeal needs reasons for the delay, and an administrative law judge reviews whether to allow it. So it's not automatic — but it's harder and not guaranteed.
0 coins
Edison Estevez
The rule is in EDD's appeals information: late appeal needs an explanation of the delay, and the ALJ decides. It's definitely easier to file on time.
0 coins
James Johnson
Can I ask something that might be dumb — if the university IS legitimately exempt from SDI, does that mean the worker just gets nothing? Or is there always some other plan they have to offer?
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
Not a dumb question at all. A truly exempt employer isn't required to have a Voluntary Plan, so in theory a worker at a fully exempt employer might have no SDI-equivalent coverage. That's why checking paystubs is so critical — if CASDI was deducted, the exemption claim is likely wrong.
0 coins
James Johnson
That's really sobering. So the paystub really could be the whole case.
0 coins
Edison Estevez
Essentially yes. If the deduction was taken, EDD has the wrong picture and an appeal with documentation should correct it. If no deduction was ever taken, the path forward is different — that's when HR becomes the first stop to find out what coverage actually exists.
0 coins
Aria Washington
been trying to figure out my own exempt employer situation for two weeks, same kind of denial. this thread is the most useful thing i've found
0 coins
Mia Green
Paystubs and the DE 1000A — those are the two things. Send that appeal before anything else.
0 coins
Aria Washington
yeah i pulled my stubs and the deduction is there. mailing the appeal tomorrow.
0 coins
ApolloJackson
For the record on the numbers side: the Notice of Computation (DE 429D) is what shows your potential weekly benefit amount. If you got one of those before the denial, that's not an approval — it just shows what EDD calculated. The denial came separately as the DE 2517.
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
AuthorI got the DE 429D first and I actually thought that meant I was approved. The DE 2517 came about a week later and that's when everything fell apart.
0 coins
ApolloJackson
The DE 429D only shows the potential amount — EDD is very clear it's not eligibility confirmation. A lot of people read it as an approval because it has numbers on it.
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
That's a really common misreading. The notice says 'potential' benefits for a reason. The determination on eligibility comes separately and that's the DE 2517.
0 coins
Liam O'Reilly
Payment method stuff came up for me mid-claim — I'd set up direct deposit in SDI Online but then wasn't sure if it was actually active or if the Money Network card was going to get the payment instead. Claimyr got me to a live EDD agent and she confirmed direct deposit was on file and active for my claim.
0 coins
Isabella Russo
Wait, hold on — how does Claimyr work, really? I see it on so many forums but it kind of sounds like one of those things someone made up to get clicks.
0 coins
Chloe Delgado
Tried it on my own claim when I couldn't get through for days. The agent I spoke with told me which weeks had been paid and which were still pending. That was EDD's own person — not a third party.
0 coins
Isabella Russo
Okay, hearing that it was actually an EDD agent makes it more real to me. I might give it a try to ask about my own pending weeks.
0 coins
Olivia Kay
If HR confirms a Voluntary Plan, ask them for the plan documents. Those documents should spell out what the claims process is, who the plan administrator is, and how to file. That's your next claim after the EDD appeal.
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
AuthorI'll ask specifically for the plan documents if HR confirms one exists. I didn't know I could ask for those directly.
0 coins
Olivia Kay
You can. They're required to give them to employees.
0 coins
Lucas Kowalski
The university saying 'we're exempt' and EDD agreeing are two different things. EDD has to have an actual record of the exemption. Worth asking EDD directly whether the exemption for your specific employer is actually on file with them.
0 coins
Sophia Rodriguez
That's a solid point. EDD can confirm whether a Voluntary Plan or exemption is registered for a given employer. If it's not, the denial may have been issued in error without EDD even checking their own records.
0 coins
Emily Nguyen-Smith
That would be a rough error. But yeah, ask EDD directly, don't take HR's word or the denial's word as the final answer.
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
Medical certification came through on my own claim but then EDD said they hadn't matched it to my file. Claimyr got me to an agent who looked at my claim and confirmed the certification had come in but was still showing unmatched — she said to give it a couple of business days. Everything resolved on its own after that.
0 coins
James Johnson
Did the agent say anything about why it went unmatched in the first place, or just that it was there?
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
She said only that the certification was received and not yet matched to the claim, nothing about why. I didn't push further since she said to wait.
0 coins
Aria Washington
been trying to get through to that line for about two weeks now. three attempts this week alone and nothing.
0 coins
Mia Green
To loop back to where this started — if appeal, paystubs, and HR are all pointing in different directions at once, don't freeze up. File the DE 1000A before the 30 days closes. That's the one deadline you can't undo, and everything else can keep moving while the appeal is pending.
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
AuthorFiling the appeal this week. HR finally responded and said they're 'looking into' whether a Voluntary Plan exists, which is not exactly a ringing confirmation either way. So I'm not waiting on them.
0 coins
Mia Green
Filing without waiting on HR is exactly right. The appeal protects you while the other stuff gets sorted.
0 coins
Jibriel Kohn
Just want to double check — mailing the DE 1000A to the return address on the denial notice, right? Not to some general EDD address?
0 coins
Edison Estevez
Correct. The form goes to the address printed on the denial notice itself. EDD is specific about that — claim forms and appeal documents go to where the notice says, not to a general EDD address.
0 coins
Chloe Delgado
HR told me once that our university 'doesn't participate in state disability.' Turned out we did have CASDI withheld — HR just didn't know what department handled it. Check payroll separately from HR.
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
AuthorPayroll separately — that's a good call. HR and payroll are different offices here and I went straight to HR. I'll contact payroll directly about the deduction.
0 coins
Chloe Delgado
Payroll will know exactly what was withheld and can pull the deduction history faster than HR usually can.
0 coins
Charlie Yang
if your paystubs show casdi was taken out you should be fine on appeal, they cant deny you if you paid in
0 coins
Edison Estevez
The deduction being present is strong evidence for the appeal, but EDD still makes the eligibility determination — it doesn't automatically reverse. The appeal is what gives EDD the chance to correct the record with that documentation.
0 coins
Charlie Yang
fair enough, but like realistically if the deduction is there that gets fixed right
0 coins
Edison Estevez
In most cases yes, the documentation resolves it. But the appeal is still the step that gets it in front of the right people.
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
Quick update: payroll confirmed CASDI was deducted every pay period for the last two years. HR finally wrote back and admitted they may have submitted incorrect information to EDD when the claim was filed. I'm mailing the DE 1000A today with four pay stubs attached and a written explanation. Really glad I didn't just accept the denial.
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
That's exactly the outcome those paystubs were going to show. Good documentation, timely appeal — that's the right path.
0 coins
Emma Bianchi
HR gave EDD wrong information. Classic. Appeals office will sort it.
0 coins
Mia Green
Paystub trail and a written explanation — you've got everything you need in that envelope.
0 coins