Back to California Disability

Brian Downey

Can I get SDI while workers compensation claim is pending in California?

So I hurt my back at work about three weeks ago and filed a workers comp claim through my employer right away. The thing is, workers comp is dragging its feet and hasn't approved anything yet. My HR department basically shrugged and said to figure it out myself. I can't work, bills are piling up, kids need stuff, and I have zero income coming in right now. Someone at urgent care mentioned I might be able to file for California EDD disability in the meantime but I honestly have no idea if that's even allowed when there's a workers comp situation going on. Has anyone dealt with this overlap? Like can I even file for SDI while my workers comp claim is sitting there unresolved, anyway.

Filing an SDI claim when workers comp hasn't paid out yet is something EDD does address, though the answer isn't a simple yes or no. EDD's own language on this is that it's not common to receive both at the same time, but that exceptions exist. What most people in your situation do is file the SDI claim and let EDD sort out the overlap. You have 49 days from when the disability began to get both your part and your doctor's medical certification submitted, so the clock matters here.

0 coins

So I actually can go ahead and file even with the workers comp thing open? I was worried EDD would just reject it outright.

0 coins

Filing doesn't hurt you. EDD reviews your situation and decides. Not filing because you're waiting on workers comp is usually the bigger mistake, since you can run out of time to file at all.

0 coins

Does the workers comp situation have to be fully denied first before SDI even looks at your claim, or can they run at the same time? Not sure how that works.

0 coins

Strained my shoulder on a job site last spring, same situation as yours. Workers comp adjuster went quiet for weeks. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get an EDD disability agent on the line about whether my extension, the DE 2525XX my doctor submitted, had come through. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the DE 2525XX was received and matched. Went back to work the week after that call anyway, but at least I knew where things stood.

0 coins

Claimyr worked well on my end too, different reason though. Needed to find out if EDD had set up my payments to go to direct deposit or the Money Network card since I'd changed it partway through my claim. The agent confirmed it had switched to direct deposit before the next payment went out.

0 coins

What did you ask when you got the agent, like did you have to explain the whole workers comp piece or just your claim number?

0 coins

For my call it was pretty straightforward, I had my claim ID and the week in question ready. Agent found it in maybe two minutes and told me the payment method had updated. No deep explanation needed on my end.

0 coins

How long had your extension been sitting there before you phoned?

0 coins

The part worth pinning down here is that SDI and workers comp serve different legal purposes, which is why EDD doesn't automatically deny an SDI claim just because workers comp is open. EDD's own site says it's not common but doesn't say it's prohibited. If workers comp eventually pays you for the same period, there can be an offset situation, but that's EDD's determination to make, not yours to guess at before filing.

0 coins

Offset meaning I might have to pay some back if workers comp comes through later?

0 coins

That's the concern, yes. What you owe back and when depends on what EDD decides after they see both. The safe move is to report everything accurately on your claim and let them calculate it.

0 coins

EDD rarely explains these things clearly until after you owe money, so document everything from day one.

0 coins

Wait so when you file the SDI claim, do you have to disclose the workers comp claim on the form? Like is there a specific box for that? I'm asking because I had a minor work injury too and I'm terrified of doing something wrong on the form and losing everything.

0 coins

Yes, the DE 2501 asks about other benefits or claims you have pending. Answer honestly. EDD uses that information to figure out how the two programs interact on your specific case.

0 coins

Okay and if my doctor already submitted the medical certification for the workers comp side, does that also count for SDI or does she have to do a whole separate one?

0 coins

Separate certification for SDI. The DE 2501 Part B goes through SDI Online with your receipt number. Workers comp uses its own forms through a different process. Your provider needs to do both.

0 coins

Three weeks of trying that EDD disability line and every single time it's either a recording that hangs up or a busy signal before I even get to a menu option. I've called at opening, mid-morning, right after lunch. Nothing. It's not like I have a soft question either, I need to know if my wages from gig work even show up in my base period correctly before I commit to filing.

0 coins

the line does that for weeks and then one day you get through and it feels like luck

0 coins

Not counting on luck when my rent's on the line, honestly.

0 coins

Filing online through SDI Online might actually answer the base period question faster than the phone. When you start the claim it shows you the quarter they're looking at. At least you'd know before you submit.

0 coins

Claim start date got flagged on mine and I couldn't get anyone to explain what that meant on the phone after trying for days. Claimyr got me to an agent who looked it up and said the start date in the system was showing one day after what I'd put on my form, which was the difference between being in and out of the waiting period window. Got it corrected before the first payment was issued.

0 coins

That Claimyr thing sounds like a marketing pitch to me, ngl. How does anyone actually end up talking to EDD through some third-party thing.

0 coins

Thought the same thing before I tried it. Had a Notice of Determination sitting on a claim I was pretty sure had a documentation error. The agent confirmed the notice had been issued and told me I had until the date on it to appeal with the DE 1000A. That was exactly what I needed to know.

0 coins

Okay so if the agent was an actual EDD person that makes it different than I thought. Might look into it for my own situation.

0 coins

Start date correction sounds like it could have cost you real money. Glad that got sorted before it became a bigger problem.

0 coins

December 4th is when my own injury happened, also work-related, also with workers comp in limbo. Filed SDI the following week. The Notice of Computation came about two weeks after my doctor's office submitted the medical certification. It showed my potential weekly amount based on my highest-paid quarter. Workers comp still hasn't resolved and EDD hasn't denied me. Not saying that's what happens for everyone, but it moved.

0 coins

This is actually really good to hear. Did you have to do anything specific when you filed to flag the workers comp situation, or did you just answer the form questions as they came?

0 coins

Just answered the questions on the form honestly. There's a section that asks about work-related injuries and other pending claims. I filled it in accurately and EDD did the rest.

0 coins

Two weeks for the Notice of Computation is about what I've seen too. Some people stress that it means approval but it really just shows the potential amount, not a guarantee you'll get paid.

0 coins

Workers comp disputing a claim while the injured worker has no income is about as common as it gets. EDD disability exists partly for situations like yours. File and let the two systems argue it out.

0 coins

That's a pretty direct way to put it and honestly makes me feel better about just going ahead and filing.

0 coins

Agreed. Waiting to see how workers comp resolves before filing SDI is how people miss the 49-day window and end up with nothing from either side.

0 coins

my coworker had almost the exact same thing happen, workers comp just sat there for like two months and she filed sdi and got paid while waiting, so it can work out

0 coins

Whether it works out depends on the specifics of each claim. Not a guarantee just because one person got through.

0 coins

yeah fair point, just saying it wasnt automatically blocked or anything

0 coins

Notice of Computation on my claim had an amount that looked off compared to what I expected from my wages. Phoned EDD using Claimyr and the agent walked me through which quarter they pulled from my base period. Turned out they were using the right quarter, I'd just miscounted which months fell in it. That cleared up pretty fast.

0 coins

When you got the agent, did they explain how the base period quarters are counted or just tell you which one they used?

0 coins

Just told me which quarter, didn't go into the formula. But that was enough for me to check my own pay records and see they had it right.

0 coins

been dialing that line myself for going on two weeks now, mornings mostly. never got past the recording.

0 coins

If workers comp eventually pays for some of the same weeks that SDI already paid, does that mean EDD sends a bill? Like how does that even get communicated, do they just mail you something or does it show up in SDI Online first?

0 coins

EDD mails a notice. That notice will explain what they determined and give you 30 days from the date on it to appeal using the DE 1000A if you disagree with the amount. Don't ignore anything that arrives by mail during an open claim.

0 coins

Okay so I need to actually open every piece of mail from EDD, not just the payment stuff. Got it.

0 coins

Anything from EDD during an active claim should be read the day it arrives. Deadlines on those notices move fast.

0 coins

Had a client at the salon going through almost this same thing, back injury at work, workers comp stalled, she filed SDI and it helped cover her while everything was pending. She said the hardest part was getting the medical certification from her doctor's office to actually submit through SDI Online in time.

0 coins

Is there a way to confirm the doctor submitted it? Like does SDI Online tell you when it's been received?

0 coins

You can check the claim status in SDI Online. If the certification is in, the status updates. If it's still showing pending with no update after a week or so, it's worth contacting the office to confirm they used your receipt number.

0 coins

Receipt number is the key piece. The doctor's office needs it to find your claim in the system. If they search without it things can get misrouted.

0 coins

The 49-day deadline trips people up in this situation because they're waiting to see if workers comp comes through before committing to filing SDI. By the time workers comp drags on long enough to realize it's not coming soon, the SDI window has closed. File SDI now and sort out the overlap later.

0 coins

Filing tonight. The 49-day thing made up my mind. Workers comp can do whatever it does on its own timeline.

0 coins

Have your receipt number ready to give the doctor's office the same day if you can. Faster they submit the medical certification, faster EDD has everything they need.

0 coins

The waiting period question comes up a lot in these work injury threads! Just to be clear for anyone reading, the seven-day waiting period at the start of an SDI claim is not just processing time, it's literally seven days you won't get paid no matter what. Day eight is when benefits can actually start.

0 coins

So those seven days are just gone regardless of how fast EDD processes the claim? That feels harsh.

0 coins

Exactly, it's baked into every new claim. Not EDD being slow, just how the program works.

0 coins

Knowing that going in helps with budgeting at least. I didn't know and it threw me off.

0 coins

Question on the medical certification part for a work injury claim. My doctor said she mostly does workers comp paperwork and wasn't sure about the SDI form. Is there a different process or does she just submit the same certification?

0 coins

SDI certification is separate. Your doctor completes Part B of the DE 2501 through SDI Online using your receipt number. Workers comp uses a totally different form through a different system. She may not have done the SDI side before but it's available online.

0 coins

Got it, I'll bring her the receipt number and ask her to look it up in SDI Online. Hopefully that makes it easy enough.

0 coins

Doctors who work mostly in the workers comp world sometimes assume one filing covers everything. It doesn't. Make sure your provider knows you need the SDI medical certification submitted separately through SDI Online with your receipt number. It's a quick ask once they know.

0 coins

my doctor hadnt done sdi before either and once i explained the receipt number thing she figured it out pretty quick

0 coins

Usually doesn't take long once they know what to look for in the system. The confusion is mostly just not knowing SDI and workers comp are entirely different pipelines.

0 coins

Patients in this situation do better when they file SDI without waiting. Workers comp timelines are unpredictable and the SDI clock doesn't pause for them.

0 coins

Filed. Doctor has my receipt number. Now just waiting to see what happens.

0 coins

Good. Check SDI Online in a week or so to confirm the certification came through.

0 coins

For anyone confused about unemployment versus SDI in this situation: if you still can't work due to the injury, unemployment isn't the right fit. Unemployment requires you to be able to work and looking for work every week you claim it. SDI is for the weeks you can't work at all.

0 coins

I was actually about to ask about that. So I shouldn't file for unemployment while I'm still out with the injury?

0 coins

Not while you're unable to work. SDI covers those weeks. When your doctor clears you and you're able to work again, that's when unemployment could come into play if you need it.

0 coins

Filing unemployment while still unable to work and on SDI would be a problem. You can't claim both for the same days.

0 coins

the overlap thing confused me too at first. i thought workers comp meant i couldnt touch any other program. turns out you just have to be honest on the forms and let edd figure it out.

0 coins

EDD figuring it out usually comes in the form of a notice later that you then have to deal with on a deadline. Stay on top of your mail.

0 coins

yeah thats the part i learned the hard way. opened a letter two weeks after it came and barely made the appeal window.

0 coins

Physical therapist told my buddy she could certify his SDI claim. Someone should let him know that's not how it works before he wastes weeks waiting on something that won't be accepted by EDD.

0 coins

Physical therapists aren't on EDD's list of who can certify a DI claim. The list includes physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, dentists, psychologists, licensed midwives, and authorized officers at US government facilities. Your buddy needs to get the certification from one of those providers, not from his PT.

0 coins

Figured as much. He's going to be annoyed. His GP is the one who needs to do it.

0 coins

This comes up more than people expect. PTs are great for treatment but they can't start the SDI clock.

0 coins

Does EDD actually need to know what the injury was, like a diagnosis name? I'm nervous about how much medical detail they want on the form.

0 coins

Your doctor handles the medical detail on the certification. You describe your situation in general terms on your part of the form. You don't need to include a clinical diagnosis yourself.

0 coins

That's a relief. I was picturing having to write out all kinds of medical stuff on my end.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure