Can I apply for SDI if employer cannot accommodate light duty after my back injury?
So I've been out for almost three weeks now after throwing out my back at a non-work event (slipped on my friend's patio steps, nothing workers' comp related). My doctor cleared me for light duty about ten days ago, meaning I can sit at a desk, can't lift anything over five pounds, can't stand for more than 20 minutes. I work in a bakery and there is literally nothing light duty there, we're on our feet for eight-hour shifts minimum and hauling 50-pound flour bags is just part of the day. My manager says they can't accommodate anything I need and basically told me to stay home until I'm fully released. So now I'm sitting here wondering, can I apply for SDI if employer cannot accommodate light duty? Like does it matter to EDD that my doctor technically cleared me for SOMETHING, even if that something doesn't exist at my actual job? I haven't filed yet because I wasn't sure if the light duty clearance would mess up my claim. My bills aren't going to wait for me to figure this out.
78 comments

Diego Castillo
Medical certification from my back surgeon came back matched in SDI Online after almost two weeks of it showing nothing. When I had the same situation, the certification question was whether I could do my regular or customary work, not whether I could do some other kind of work. I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get that confirmed because the phone line was eating my attempts every single morning. The agent pulled up my claim and said the certification showed I was unable to perform my regular work, which is what mattered for the DI side. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ
0 coins
Logan Stewart
What did you actually ask the agent once you got on the line, was it just about the certification wording or did they look at something specific on your file?
0 coins
Diego Castillo
Asked whether the certification my doc submitted matched what EDD needed to see for someone who had a light duty release but couldn't actually do light duty at their job. Agent confirmed the certification was received and that it reflected inability to perform regular or customary work, which was the right language.
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
been trying that disability number for eleven days straight. gets to a certain point then drops. eleven days.
0 coins
Sean Matthews
The standard EDD uses is whether you can do your regular or customary work, and that's spelled out on EDD's own site. Light duty somewhere else doesn't enter into it. If your job is physically demanding and your doctor's certification says you can't perform that work, the claim should stand on the certification as written. File the claim through SDI Online in myEDD. Give your doctor the receipt number so they can submit the medical certification. The 49-day window from when your disability started is the one to watch.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
AuthorSo the receipt number goes to my doctor's office and they look up the claim on their end?
0 coins
Sean Matthews
Exactly. Your doctor's office finds your claim in SDI Online using that number and submits the medical certification from their side. Without it EDD can't process anything, so get it to them quickly.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
does the doctor have to use specific wording when they fill it out or can they just say what they told you at the appointment? i'm kind of scared mine will just write whatever and it'll get denied
0 coins
Zadie Patel
Filing right away would be the first thing I would do in your position. The disability has to have lasted at least eight days before benefits start, and you are well past that. Keep in mind the first seven days of your claim are a non-payable waiting period regardless, so the sooner the claim is in, the sooner that waiting period is counted and behind you. Missing the 49-day window from your disability start date can disqualify you entirely.
0 coins
A Man D Mortal
Wait, so the seven days is not the time EDD takes to process? I thought they were making you wait while they reviewed it. This is different from processing time?
0 coins
Zadie Patel
They are completely separate things. The seven-day waiting period is built into the law, those days simply are not payable no matter how fast EDD processes your claim. Processing happens after both parts of the claim are submitted.
0 coins
Declan Ramirez
yeah i got confused by this too when i filed last year
0 coins
Emma Morales
The question your doctor answers on the certification is about your capacity to do your specific, regular work, not about some generic light duty category. Bakery work is physically demanding and well-documented as such. If your physician certifies that you cannot perform your regular and customary work because of this injury, the fact that your employer has nothing light duty to offer you is consistent with that, not in conflict with it. File and get the receipt number to your doctor's office today.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
AuthorThat is such a relief to read. I was genuinely scared the light duty clearance would just cancel everything out.
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
yeah doc certifies the job you have not some imaginary desk position you dont actually have
0 coins
Emma Morales
Exactly. The certification speaks to your actual job demands. EDD isn't looking at whether you could theoretically do different work somewhere.
0 coins
Lucas Parker
Waiting period question tripped me up on my own shoulder claim last spring. Used Claimyr to get an agent on the phone and asked whether my waiting period had been counted from the right start date. Agent looked it up and confirmed the first seven days of my claim were logged as the non-payable waiting period from the date I listed as my disability start date, and the first payable day was recorded as day eight. That cleared up why the payment I got was for the amount it was.
0 coins
Donna Cline
My question is whether the start date I put in matches what my doctor's office put, because I'm not sure they used the same date I did. Going to try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when I call?
0 coins
Lucas Parker
Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and the date you listed as your disability start date. Also know the date your doctor says the disability began, so you can compare if the agent reads you what's on the certification.
0 coins
Harper Collins
ugh the start date mismatch thing almost wrecked mine. doctor's office put the date of the appointment not the date i actually couldn't work anymore. had to have them resubmit. anyway.
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
From a paperwork standpoint, file the DE 2501 or submit through SDI Online as soon as possible. Your disability start date goes back to when you first couldn't perform your regular work, which sounds like three weeks ago now. That's the date that counts for your 49-day window, not the date you decide to file. Once you have your receipt number, get it to the doctor's office the same day if you can.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
AuthorThe disability start date would be the day I stopped being able to work, not the day my doctor saw me and cleared me for light duty, right?
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
The start date is the first day you were unable to perform your regular work due to the injury. If you stopped working three weeks ago because of the back injury, that's the date, not the appointment date.
0 coins
A Man D Mortal
okay so if the doctor's appointment was two days after I stopped working do I put the first day I couldn't work or the first day I saw the doctor? I always thought it had to be the day of the appointment
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
Your doctor certifies whether you can do the actual physical demands of your job. Bakery, lifting flour bags, eight hours on your feet: none of that is light duty. If your physician says you can't perform that work, the certification supports your claim. File now.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
This. The job description does the work for you in a case like this.
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
Came here wondering the same thing as the original poster and this thread answered it better than anything I found elsewhere.
0 coins
Logan Stewart
EDD's disability line is a full-time job just to get through. I've logged maybe 30 attempts over two weeks and gotten to a person exactly zero times. At some point the line just ends the call. No warning, just done. If you have a specific question for an agent about your certification or your claim, do not count on getting through by just dialing.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
does it help to call right when they open at 8? I've been trying around 10 and it's just a recording that eventually hangs up
0 coins
Logan Stewart
Eight in the morning was no different for me. The volume of people calling is what it is. The recording runs out of things to say and then drops you.
0 coins
Gianna Scott
The SDI Online message feature through myEDD actually got me a response in a few days when the phone wasn't working! Worth trying if it's not super urgent.
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
Base period came up as a question on my own desk-job injury claim. Phoned EDD through Claimyr after getting nowhere on the disability line and asked which quarter they were using to calculate my benefit amount. The agent pulled up the claim and read me which quarter of the base period had been used and what the wage figure in it was, so I could check it against my own records.
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
The base period quarter thing is exactly what I needed to sort out on my own claim. Used Claimyr too after the agent confirmed my receipt number had been matched to the right claim and I'd been listed as self-certifying incorrectly. Once the agent straightened that out I resubmitted the right form through SDI Online.
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
how long have you guys been trying that disability line before finding other ways through, asking because ive been at it for two weeks and starting to feel like its impossible
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
Two weeks was about where I was before I stopped just dialing.
0 coins
Sydney Torres
The Notice of Computation comes after EDD processes the claim. It shows your weekly benefit amount. It is not an approval, just the number they calculated. Worth reading carefully when it arrives.
0 coins
A Man D Mortal
So getting the Notice of Computation doesn't mean I'm approved? I thought that was the approval letter.
0 coins
Sydney Torres
Not an approval. Just the payment calculation. Approval comes through payments actually being issued, or a denial comes through a Notice of Determination.
0 coins
Zadie Patel
To add to that: if you receive a Notice of Determination and disagree with it, you have 30 days from the date on the notice to file an appeal using the Appeal Form that comes with it.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Jenkins
my coworker had almost exactly this situation last year, different job but same light duty problem, and she filed SDI and it went through fine. the key was her doctor wrote the certification around what her actual job required her to do, not some generic light duty standard. doctor knew the job, wrote accordingly, done.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
AuthorDid she have to explain her job to the doctor in detail or did they already know from treating her?
0 coins
Kaitlyn Jenkins
She brought in her job description from HR, like a printed copy, so the doc could reference the actual physical requirements. Made the certification more specific. Might be worth doing the same, lol.
0 coins
Emma Morales
Bringing documentation of your job's physical demands is a good practical move, especially for physically intensive work where the demands aren't obvious from a job title alone.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
im really nervous about one part of this, what happens if EDD decides the light duty clearance means i could have worked somewhere even if not at my own job? can they deny the claim on those grounds? i've been reading stuff online that's making me spiral
0 coins
Sean Matthews
EDD's standard is your regular or customary work, not theoretical work at some other job. The certification from your doctor is about whether you can perform the duties of your actual position. Light duty clearance that doesn't match your real job's demands doesn't override that.
0 coins
Dylan Fisher
Don't spiral on hypotheticals. File, get your doctor's certification in, and let EDD evaluate based on your actual job requirements.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
okay that helps a lot. i think i was reading forum stuff from other states that have different rules and getting confused
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
bakery work is brutal man, there is no light duty version of that job and anyone whos worked in one knows it. file the sdi, get your doc to certify around your actual job duties, done
0 coins
Ruby Knight
AuthorHa, yes. My manager literally laughed when I mentioned light duty. There is nowhere to put me.
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
exactly. that laugh is basically your evidence lol
0 coins
Donna Cline
Has anyone had EDD push back and ask for more documentation when there's a light duty release involved? Genuinely curious whether that adds a step.
0 coins
Sean Matthews
EDD can request additional information, but the main thing driving the claim is the medical certification. The certification language around regular and customary work is the key document. Additional requests are possible but not guaranteed.
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
Mine went through without any additional requests, but my doctor was very specific in the certification about why I couldn't perform my job duties. The more specific the certification, the less gap there is for questions.
0 coins
Donna Cline
Makes sense. I'll make sure my doctor's office knows to be specific about my actual job demands when they submit.
0 coins
Harper Collins
just want to flag for anyone reading this, the 49 days runs from when you became disabled not from when you filed. so if youve been out three weeks already the clock has been running. dont wait. anyway
0 coins
Ruby Knight
AuthorFiling tonight. I've been sitting on this too long already.
0 coins
Harper Collins
good, give the receipt number to your doctor right after
0 coins
Declan Ramirez
same thing happened to me, almost missed the window because i didn't know the 49 days started from the disability date
0 coins
Gianna Scott
The myEDD website makes the SDI Online filing pretty smooth once you're set up! The hardest part for me was remembering to get the receipt number to my doctor's office fast enough. Turned out they needed it within days to fit it into their submission schedule.
0 coins
A Man D Mortal
Is there a specific spot in SDI Online where the receipt number shows up after you file, or do they email it?
0 coins
Gianna Scott
It shows up right on the confirmation screen after you submit Part A. Screenshot it or write it down immediately because you'll need to give it to your doctor's office so they can find your claim and submit their part.
0 coins
Zadie Patel
Printing or saving that screen is a very good idea. The form receipt number is what your provider uses to locate your claim in SDI Online.
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
Payments go to a Money Network prepaid debit card unless you set up direct deposit in SDI Online. Worth choosing direct deposit before your first payment processes if you prefer that.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
AuthorIs there still a Bank of America card or is it all Money Network now?
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
It's Money Network now, the Bank of America card is from the old setup. EDD's current card is Money Network.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Jenkins
yeah i was confused about that too when i set mine up, glad i asked before expecting a certain card
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
the automated line 1-800-480-3287 at least gives you payment info without having to reach a person. not perfect but its something when youre waiting
0 coins
Ruby Knight
AuthorDoes that line work even when the claim is still pending or does it only have info once payments have started?
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
mostly useful once payments are issued. when things are still pending it doesn't have much to say. still easier than nothing
0 coins
Sydney Torres
SDI Online also shows payment information once it's there. Same limitation as the automated line during pending status.
0 coins
A Man D Mortal
So to make sure I have this straight for my own situation, once I file Part A and give the receipt number to my doctor, I just wait? There's nothing else I need to do until EDD contacts me or the Notice of Computation shows up?
0 coins
Zadie Patel
Once Part A is filed and the receipt number is with your doctor, the next step is theirs. After EDD receives a completed claim, they typically contact the claimant about status within 14 days. The Notice of Computation will come separately and shows the potential weekly amount.
0 coins
A Man D Mortal
Okay and if 14 days passes and I've heard nothing, is there a way to follow up without just calling and hoping to get through?
0 coins
Sean Matthews
In SDI Online through myEDD, you can send a message by going to your claim and choosing Request Claim Update. That gets your question to EDD without depending on the phone line.
0 coins
Lucas Parker
One thing I'd add for the original poster: make sure your doctor's office knows this is an SDI claim and that they need to submit through SDI Online with the receipt number, not just fax something or assume another system handles it. Some offices get confused about which submission path to use.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
AuthorMy doctor's office mentioned they'd done SDI certifications before so I think they know the system, but I'll confirm when I call them tomorrow.
0 coins
Lucas Parker
Good. Ask them specifically whether they're submitting online through SDI Online or mailing a paper form. They should use whichever they're set up for, but you want to know so you can follow up if nothing shows in your claim.
0 coins
Gianna Scott
My doctor's office was completely online about it and it still took about a week to show up on my end in SDI Online. The receipt number being right was the thing that made it match.
0 coins