Medi-Cal denied over income limit but Covered says contact Medi-Cal — what do I do now?
So I applied a couple months ago and just got the denial letter in the mail. It says my income is over the limit for Medi-Cal. Fine, I figured I'd just go through Covered California then. But when I tried to set up a plan there, their rep told me I need to contact Medi-Cal directly because something about my case isn't resolved on their end. Now I'm stuck in the middle with no coverage and no idea who's actually supposed to handle this. Has anyone dealt with this loop before? I'm a single adult, early 30s, and I do gig work so my income bounces around month to month. I reported that on the application. The denial Notice of Action came last week and I honestly don't know if the income they used was even right. What am I supposed to do when both sides keep pointing at each other?
78 comments

KhalilStar
Got turned away by Covered California for the same kind of back-and-forth a while back. What I'd ask the county first is whether the income they used on your application was your monthly average or one specific month's earnings, because for gig work that can swing the whole decision. Under the rules for the kind of Medi-Cal most working-age adults qualify for, they look at expected annual income, not just one pay period. If a high month made your application look over the limit, it's worth calling the county and asking them to walk through how they calculated it, then deciding from there whether to appeal or reapply with a better income estimate.
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
Good point — if the number they used doesn't match what you actually expect to earn over the year, you can ask for a State Fair Hearing within 90 days of the date on the Notice of Action. You don't have to accept the denial.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorOkay so the NOA came last Thursday. That means I have 90 days from that date to request the hearing? I didn't realize the clock started from the letter, not from when I read it.
0 coins
Kaiya Rivera
The 90 days runs from the date printed on the Notice of Action itself, yes. Keep the envelope too in case there's ever a question about when it arrived.
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
The loop you're describing — Medi-Cal pointing to Covered California and Covered California pointing back — usually means there's a pending eligibility issue that neither side has fully closed out. Ask the county specifically whether there's still an open action on your case, because sometimes a denial doesn't fully clear until the county marks it resolved on their end, and Covered California's system sees it as unfinished. Once the county closes it properly, Covered California should be able to move forward with enrolling you.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorThat actually makes sense. So I should call the county first and ask if the case is fully closed on their end before I try Covered California again?
0 coins
Noah Irving
Calling the county is the right move. BenefitsCal might still show something pending even after a denial, which can hold up the Covered California side.
0 coins
Vanessa Chang
Had a similar thing happen when my income changed mid-year. The county hadn't updated the case status and Covered California kept saying they couldn't proceed. One call to the county sorted it.
0 coins
Madison King
Verification deadline on my case was something I had no idea was coming. When I applied, the county sent a request for proof of my income, but I didn't see the letter until it was almost past the deadline. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) — it held with the county's Medi-Cal line while I was at work and I ended up talking to a worker who told me exactly which document was still missing and that the due date was three days out. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at Medi-Cal: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g. I got the right pay stub uploaded to BenefitsCal that same afternoon and the case moved forward. If you're not sure what the county is waiting for on your end, that's the question to ask them directly.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorThree days is cutting it close. Glad you got through in time. I'm going to try reaching someone at the county because I want to know if they actually used the right income figure for my denial.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
Knowing the exact document and deadline made all the difference in that situation — without that call you might have just missed it without knowing.
0 coins
Ella Knight
The income figure question is exactly the kind of thing a county worker can pull up on your case. Worth asking them to confirm what number they used and where it came from.
0 coins
William Schwarz
Something Covered California people sometimes don't explain clearly is that when their system sees an unresolved Medi-Cal case, they literally cannot complete your enrollment until the county sends them a signal that the case is finished. It's not that anyone is being unhelpful — their systems are linked and one side can't move without the other. The question to put to the county is whether they've sent a final disposition on your application to Covered California's system, and if not, to do that now.
0 coins
Lauren Johnson
This is what happened to my cousin — exact same message from Covered California. The county had to resend the closed-case status before anything could move.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorSo even a denial has to be formally 'sent' over to Covered California? I assumed the denial would automatically do that.
0 coins
William Schwarz
Not always automatically — sometimes there's a lag, or something in the application flags it for a manual step. The county can usually see on the case whether the transfer to Covered California's system happened.
0 coins
Jade Santiago
For what it's worth with the gig income issue: when income changes month to month, what matters for MAGI Medi-Cal is what you reasonably expect to earn over the whole year. If the county used a high month's earnings and projected that out, your expected annual income might actually be lower than what the denial says. You can ask the county to reconsider based on a corrected income estimate, or you can request a State Fair Hearing and explain the fluctuation to the judge. Either path is open within 90 days of the NOA date.
0 coins
Caleb Stone
The hearing option is real — I requested one when my hours dropped and my income looked higher than it actually was. The judge is separate from the county, which helps.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorDoes requesting a hearing stop me from also trying to contact the county directly at the same time? Or do I have to pick one?
0 coins
Jade Santiago
You can do both — the rules say you can talk to the county eligibility worker while the hearing is pending. Sometimes the county fixes it before the hearing date and the hearing becomes unnecessary.
0 coins
Daniel Price
MAGI rules are what apply here and those rules have no property limit at all — only income is counted. I want to flag that because I've seen people panic thinking they have to prove what they own, but for a working-age adult applying on income, the county doesn't ask about savings or a car or anything like that. The issue in this case is purely whether the income number they used was right.
0 coins
Olivia Evans
Good clarification — I confused MAGI and Non-MAGI rules when I first applied and thought my car and savings account would count against me. They don't for most adults under 65.
0 coins
Sophia Bennett
Non-MAGI is a different set of rules that applies to people 65 and up, those with a disability, or long-term care situations. For a single adult in their 30s doing gig work, MAGI is what applies and it's income only.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorOkay that's a relief. I was worried they might be looking at something other than income. Sounds like the fight here is just over whether the income number was calculated correctly.
0 coins
Aiden Chen
The State Fair Hearing request is submitted through the county office, by phone at 1-800-743-8525, or online through the California Department of Social Services. You don't have to show up in person — it can be done by phone. And you don't need a lawyer. The judge is not a county employee, which matters if you feel like the county got the number wrong. Write down everything: the date the NOA came, what income figure it lists, and what your actual expected annual income is.
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
Agreed on writing everything down. I requested a hearing once and the notes I had on the income discrepancy were the most useful thing I brought.
0 coins
Lauren Johnson
The phone option for hearings made it a lot less stressful for me. Didn't have to take a day off work.
0 coins
Kaiya Rivera
Keep a copy of the NOA too. The hearing judge will want to know exactly what the county's stated reason for denial was.
0 coins
Zoey Bianchi
An address change I reported to the county a few weeks ago wasn't showing up in BenefitsCal and I wasn't sure if the case had picked it up. I had Claimyr wait on the county's line for me and when I got on with the worker, she confirmed the new address had been recorded on the case. It was a relief to know the change was actually there, because I didn't want any mail going to the old place, especially a Notice of Action about a pending case. If you've reported any changes and you're not sure they landed, that's worth verifying directly with the county.
0 coins
Noah Irving
Reported changes not showing up in BenefitsCal is nerve-wracking. Good that the worker could confirm it on the case directly.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorMine's a denial situation not a change report, but I've been worried about the same thing — whether anything I submitted actually registered. County confirmations seem like the only way to actually know.
0 coins
Vanessa Chang
Covered California told me to contact Medi-Cal once too, and what it turned out to mean was that my application had a flag on it that needed the county to clear manually. The Covered California rep couldn't tell me exactly what the flag was — they said I'd have to ask the county. So the loop you're in is real and the only way out of it is the county, not more calls to Covered California.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
Covered California reps don't have access to the county's case details — they can see that something is unresolved but can't tell you what it is.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorThat's exactly what happened on my call with them. The rep said she could see something wasn't finalized but couldn't tell me more. So I really do need to get to the county.
0 coins
KhalilStar
Once the county clears whatever is flagged, Covered California is usually able to move forward fairly quickly.
0 coins
Christopher Morgan
I want to add one thing on the Covered California side. If the county fixes the flag and you end up enrolling through Covered California instead, your old Medi-Cal denial doesn't affect your eligibility for a Covered California plan — those are separate determinations. Covered California's eligibility is based on whether your income is above the Medi-Cal threshold. So once the case is cleared, you just need to show your income is above the cutoff and you can get a plan there, potentially with premium assistance depending on where your income falls.
0 coins
Caleb Stone
Premium assistance through Covered California for income above the Medi-Cal range is real — the amount depends on your income and the plan you pick. Worth looking into once the case is cleared.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorGood to know the denial doesn't follow me over to Covered California. I was worried it would somehow disqualify me there too.
0 coins
Daniel Price
The two programs really are separate doors. Medi-Cal for income at or below the threshold, Covered California for income above it, and the county and Covered California are supposed to hand you off between them smoothly — when it works.
0 coins
Olivia Evans
Has anybody asked about retroactive coverage here? I know the question is about the denial, but if there were medical expenses in the three months before the application date and you end up qualifying after all, retroactive Medi-Cal can cover bills from that period. It's worth asking the county about that at the same time you're asking about the income issue, because there's a one-year window from the date of service to request it.
0 coins
Ella Knight
Good point — if the income dispute gets resolved and eligibility is established, you'd want to ask about those prior months at the same time rather than making a second call later.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorI do have one bill from about six weeks before I applied. Didn't know that could potentially be covered. I'll ask the county about that when I call.
0 coins
Jade Santiago
Ask specifically about retroactive Medi-Cal for that month — the county needs to know you're requesting it, it doesn't happen automatically.
0 coins
Sophia Bennett
County transfer on my case was a whole ordeal I didn't see coming. I'd moved from one California county to another and thought the case would just follow me, but it stalled. I let Claimyr sit on hold with the new county's Medi-Cal line and when the worker picked up, she confirmed the case hadn't yet moved over and gave me the name of the document I needed to give the new county to get the inter-county transfer going. I didn't realize I was supposed to report to either county within 10 days of moving. If you move while your case is open — even pending — report it right away.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
The 10-day window for reporting a move is easy to miss when you're in the middle of moving. Good that the worker could tell you exactly what was needed.
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
Inter-county transfers trip up a lot of people — they assume the county they applied in keeps the case forever. Reporting the new address to either county is what starts the move.
0 coins
Noah Irving
The income question you're raising — whether the county used the right figure — is basically the heart of a State Fair Hearing request for a case like this. What you'd be arguing is that the income they calculated doesn't match your actual expected annual income. Bring whatever documentation you have: pay records, app statements, bank deposits from the gig work, anything showing what you actually earned and what you expect to earn going forward. The judge will look at the county's calculation and yours side by side.
0 coins
Lauren Johnson
Gig income is genuinely harder to document, but showing a range of months is usually better than one or two pay statements.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorI do have records of my earnings for the past eight months through the app I use for gig work. Would screenshots of those count as documentation?
0 coins
Noah Irving
Ask the county what they'll accept — different counties may handle documentation differently, and for a hearing you'd want to confirm with the county office what format works.
0 coins
Christopher Morgan
Employer health coverage listed on my case was showing up even though that job had ended six months earlier. I let Claimyr hold with the county's Medi-Cal line and talked to a worker who pulled up my file and confirmed the old employer coverage was still listed as active on the case. She said I needed to report that it had ended, which I did right then with her on the line. If you have or had other health coverage — from a job, a spouse's job, Medicare — it has to be reported to the county and it can affect how they calculate your case.
0 coins
William Schwarz
Old employer coverage sitting on a case after it ended is surprisingly common. Glad you got that cleared.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorMine is straightforward — no employer coverage, no Medicare. Just the gig work and nothing else. But good to know that's something the county tracks.
0 coins
Aiden Chen
For gig workers specifically, the best way to present income at the county is to describe what you realistically expect to earn over the next 12 months, not just what your best month looked like. If your work is seasonal or project-based, explain that. The county is supposed to use expected annual income for MAGI cases, not a single month projected out. If the denial was based on one high month, that's exactly the kind of thing a State Fair Hearing judge would want to hear explained.
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
This is well put. Expected annual income is the right frame for a gig case. One spike month shouldn't determine the whole year's eligibility.
0 coins
Caleb Stone
Seasonal workers I know have had luck explaining the pattern — high earnings for a few months, low for the rest — and having the annual average come out under the threshold.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorMy highest month was about three times my lowest. If they used that month to project the full year, the annual number they got would be way off. That's what I need to explain at the hearing or to the county directly.
0 coins
Ella Knight
One procedural note: even while you wait to contact the county, you can go to https://benefitscal.com/Public/login and check if there's a message in your account about the denial or any outstanding documents. Sometimes there are notes there that explain more than the mailed notice does. It won't replace the call to the county but it might give you useful information before you get through.
0 coins
Vanessa Chang
BenefitsCal messages are easy to miss — there's no outside notification that one is waiting. Worth logging in just to check.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorChecked it right now. There's nothing beyond what the NOA said, but at least I know there's no other pending request sitting there that I'd missed.
0 coins
Kaiya Rivera
To put a finer point on the Covered California piece: once you get through to the county and they clear whatever is unresolved on your case, you have to actively go back to Covered California and complete the enrollment. It won't happen automatically just because the county fixed their end. Set a reminder to follow through on that once the county call is done.
0 coins
KhalilStar
Had to do exactly this — the county fixed the flag, then I had to call Covered California again and go through the enrollment steps. It doesn't happen on its own.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorGood to know I have to close the loop on both ends. I'll follow up with Covered California the same day I talk to the county.
0 coins
Daniel Price
Covered California's number is 1-800-300-1506 and their site is https://www.coveredca.com/ if you need to get back to them once the county issue is resolved.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
If you request a State Fair Hearing and the county fixes the income issue before the hearing date, you can withdraw the hearing request. So there's no downside to filing for the hearing now to protect your 90-day window, even if you think the county might fix it on its own. You can always cancel if it gets resolved.
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
Filing the hearing while also working it out with the county is a smart move — the hearing is a safety net if the county conversation doesn't go where it should.
0 coins
Olivia Evans
The hearing request itself doesn't cost anything and doesn't hurt your case. It just preserves your right to appeal.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorI didn't know you could withdraw it later. That changes things — I'll go ahead and file the hearing request now and then work the county call at the same time.
0 coins
Caleb Stone
There's a possibility worth considering: if the income dispute gets resolved in your favor and Medi-Cal approves you, coverage would start from the approval, but you can also ask about whether the month you applied counts for retroactive coverage purposes. The county handles retroactive Medi-Cal separately from the main case, so make it a point to ask when you call. Don't assume it comes with the approval automatically.
0 coins
Ella Knight
Retroactive Medi-Cal for prior months is a separate request, not an automatic part of an approval. Easy to miss if no one tells you to ask.
0 coins
William Schwarz
The window for asking retroactive coverage is within one year of the month of the service, so you have time, but it's better to ask at the same time as the income issue.
0 coins
Lauren Johnson
Came across a situation like this last year with a family member's case — Medi-Cal denial, Covered California pointing back at the county, the whole loop. What finally got it resolved was the county worker confirming on the call that the denial had been properly closed and asking them to resend the status to Covered California. Took one phone call to the county to get both sides unstuck. The county line here is (800) 540-6880 if you're in Tulare County.
0 coins
Noah Irving
Resending the closed-case status to Covered California is a step not everyone knows to ask for. Good that the worker knew to do that.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorI am in Tulare, so that number is exactly what I needed. Going to call first thing tomorrow morning and ask specifically about the status transfer to Covered California.
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
Wherever you land — Medi-Cal or a Covered California plan — make sure you don't let the 90-day hearing window expire while you're waiting for the county to fix things. The income question on the denial is worth protecting with a hearing request even if you ultimately end up on a Covered California plan instead. Keep your options open.
0 coins
KhalilStar
The hearing and the Covered California enrollment aren't mutually exclusive — you can pursue both and see which resolves first.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorFiling the hearing request tomorrow before I call the county. Want to have that protection in place first. Thanks everyone — this thread gave me a clear path forward.
0 coins
Aiden Chen
Requesting the hearing at 1-800-743-8525 takes about five minutes. Do it before that 90-day window gets any shorter.
0 coins