Does Medi-Cal pay secondary if provider is out of network for primary insurance
Trying to figure this out before my appointment next week. I have Medi-Cal and I also have insurance through my husband's job. The specialist my doctor referred me to is out of network for his work plan. The in-network options were all booking out four months and I can't wait that long. So I called the specialist's office and they said they take Medi-Cal, but I'm not sure how it actually works when the primary won't cover a visit at all because the provider is out of network. Does Medi-Cal step in and pay like it normally would, or does it not pay anything because the primary technically could have covered it if I'd gone in-network? I don't want to show up and get hit with a surprise bill. Has anyone dealt with this?
77 comments

KhalilStar
Share of cost notice I got last year had me confused about this exact issue — I had two coverages listed and couldn't figure out what I owed versus what each plan was responsible for. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to my county's Medi-Cal line because I'd been trying all morning and kept hitting a busy signal. Claimyr waited on hold for me and I ended up talking to a county worker who pulled up my case and read me the share of cost amount printed on my Notice of Action. She confirmed that the other health coverage was listed on my case and explained that I needed to report it to DHCS at 1-800-541-5555 so they could coordinate it properly. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at Medi-Cal: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorThanks, good to know. Did the worker say anything about whether out-of-network visits with the primary were handled differently? That's the part I'm stuck on.
0 coins
KhalilStar
She didn't get into that level of detail on my call — it was really just about what was on my notice and getting the other coverage reported. For the specific out-of-network question I'd probably ask your health plan or the provider's billing office since they deal with the coordination side.
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
Reporting the other coverage to DHCS is a real step people skip. The 1-800-541-5555 number is on DHCS's Other Health Coverage page and that's specifically where you send it, not just to the county.
0 coins
Kaiya Rivera
Your husband's work plan being listed as primary is the key thing here. When you have both, the private insurance gets billed first and Medi-Cal is supposed to cover what's left over. But the out-of-network part is what makes it complicated — if his plan pays nothing because the provider is out of network, Medi-Cal generally steps in as secondary for covered services. The thing is, whether the visit is a covered service under your Medi-Cal managed care plan matters too. I'd call your Medi-Cal health plan's member services before you go, tell them exactly who the specialist is and that your primary won't cover it, and ask what they'll pay. That way you're not guessing.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorOkay so Medi-Cal doesn't automatically refuse to pay just because I went out of network for the primary — it still looks at what I actually owe after? That's kind of a relief. I'll call the plan.
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
Calling the plan first is the right move. The managed care plan is different from the county office — the county handles whether you're eligible, but the plan is who decides what gets covered and what they'll pay on a specific visit.
0 coins
Noah Irving
Exactly — and the specialist's billing office should also know how to handle dual coverage. They deal with Medi-Cal coordination all the time if they're a Medi-Cal provider. Ask them to run it by their billing team before you go in.
0 coins
Vanessa Chang
Wait I thought if the other insurance doesn't pay, Medi-Cal just acts like it's the only coverage and pays what it normally would? Like if the primary pays $0 it's the same as not having it at all?
0 coins
Kaiya Rivera
Not quite — it's a bit more nuanced than that. Even when the primary pays nothing on a specific claim, the coordination rules still apply and Medi-Cal calculates its share based on what it would have paid as the only coverage. Your plan or the county can tell you what that works out to for a particular visit, but it doesn't automatically become full primary Medi-Cal just because the other plan didn't pay.
0 coins
Vanessa Chang
Okay that makes more sense. I was mixing it up in my head. So it's not like having no insurance at all, it's still secondary math even when the primary pays zero.
0 coins
Madison King
Exactly right. And that's why telling the provider upfront that you have both is so important — they need to bill them in the right order or the whole thing gets messy.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
My husband's job plan was listed on my Medi-Cal case without me even doing anything, because DHCS gets data from somewhere and adds it. When I went to a provider they tried to bill the work plan first and it got denied for out-of-network, then Medi-Cal paid its portion. It went through fine in the end but I had to follow up twice with the billing office because they almost sent it to collections before the Medi-Cal payment posted. So the process can work, it just takes patience and you need to watch the billing closely.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorThe collections thing is exactly what I'm scared of. How long did it take for the Medi-Cal payment to post after the primary denied it?
0 coins
Julian Paolo
Honestly it was about six weeks from the denial to when Medi-Cal paid. The billing office said they had to get the denial explanation from the work plan first before they could send it to Medi-Cal. Keep copies of everything.
0 coins
Ella Knight
Six weeks is a long time to be waiting and watching. Glad it worked out though — the billing order really does matter when you have two coverages.
0 coins
William Schwarz
I went through something similar when I had employer coverage and Medi-Cal at the same time. The provider was out of network for my employer plan and I was nervous. What actually happened was the provider's billing team submitted to both, the work plan denied it for out-of-network, and then Medi-Cal paid as secondary. I didn't end up with a balance for that visit. But I want to be clear — my managed care plan was different from yours and the service I got was something they covered. If Medi-Cal doesn't cover the specific type of visit through your plan, that changes things.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorGood point about the service type. I didn't even think about whether my Medi-Cal plan covers this specialist's specialty. I'll check that too when I call.
0 coins
Lauren Johnson
The specialty matters a lot. Some things need prior authorization from your Medi-Cal plan even as secondary. Your plan's member services can tell you whether the specific type of visit needs approval first.
0 coins
William Schwarz
Prior auth is a real thing to check. I had one claim go smoothly and a different one the same month get held up because the plan wanted authorization I didn't know about. Ask specifically whether this type of appointment needs it.
0 coins
Jade Santiago
Application date on my case got questioned a few months back — the county said they hadn't received something I was sure I'd submitted, and BenefitsCal just showed pending with no detail. I tried the county line for days. Eventually I let Claimyr hold for me while I was at work, and when I ended up speaking with a county worker she read me the date my application was logged and told me which document was still outstanding. That cleared everything up and I got my Notice of Action within two weeks after sending the missing proof in.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorBenefitsCal just saying pending with nothing else is so frustrating. Good that you were able to find out what was actually missing.
0 coins
Caleb Stone
Pending with no explanation is the worst. At least when it tells you something is missing you know what to do. 'Pending' with nothing is just a wall.
0 coins
Daniel Price
The other health coverage really does have to be reported — both to DHCS and to your doctor or the specialist's office. If the provider doesn't know you have two coverages they might only bill one or bill in the wrong order. Tell the specialist's front desk when you book that you have employer insurance as primary and Medi-Cal as secondary. That way their billing team sets it up right from the start.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorMakes sense to tell them upfront. I'll do that when I confirm the appointment. Should I also bring something in writing showing both coverages?
0 coins
Daniel Price
Bringing your BIC for Medi-Cal and the insurance card from your husband's plan is enough. The billing office will want both card numbers anyway to file correctly. Having them both in hand saves a phone tag cycle.
0 coins
Olivia Evans
Always bring the physical cards if you can. I've had offices say they don't have my Medi-Cal on file even when I reported it, and having the BIC right there meant they could add it on the spot.
0 coins
Sophia Bennett
I want to flag one thing nobody's said yet — if your Medi-Cal is through a managed care plan you need to check whether the specialist is in that plan's network too, not just whether they take Medi-Cal in general. Taking Medi-Cal and being in a specific managed care plan's network are two different things. A provider can take Fee-for-Service Medi-Cal but not be contracted with your particular plan.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorOh I didn't realize there was a difference. The specialist's office just said they take Medi-Cal. How do I find out if they're specifically in my plan's network?
0 coins
Sophia Bennett
Your plan's member services number is on the back of your BIC. Call them and give the specialist's name — they can tell you in a few minutes whether that provider is in network for your plan and whether the visit type needs anything on their end.
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
This distinction trips a lot of people up. 'We take Medi-Cal' usually means Fee-for-Service, which is a fallback when you don't have a plan assigned yet. Once you're in a managed care plan, you need to verify with the plan itself.
0 coins
Noah Irving
Had a situation where my primary insurance paid out-of-network benefits — not the full amount, but something — and then Medi-Cal calculated what it owed based on what was left after that partial payment. So even partial primary payments matter. It's not just a yes-or-no for the primary; whatever they pay affects how Medi-Cal calculates its share. The billing office at the provider handles this but it's worth understanding before you go.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorSo if the primary pays even a small out-of-network amount, Medi-Cal's share adjusts based on that? Not just on a full denial situation?
0 coins
Noah Irving
Right, the remaining balance after whatever the primary paid is what Medi-Cal works from as secondary. The provider's billing team runs this calculation — it's not something you have to figure out yourself, but it explains why the amount can vary.
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
This is why the billing office at the provider really does need to know about both coverages upfront. They can't calculate secondary correctly if they don't have both on file from the start.
0 coins
Aiden Chen
BEEN DEALING WITH THIS FOR THREE YEARS. I have both and every single time it's a different answer from someone different. One clerk says Medi-Cal won't pay at all if you chose to go out of network. Another says it pays the leftover. The provider's billing says one thing, then sends a bill anyway. I finally got it sorted on a specific claim but it took FOUR months. The system is not set up for people with both coverages. Keep every piece of paper.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorFour months is exhausting. I'm going to keep everything — the referral, the denial, everything — just in case.
0 coins
Aiden Chen
Seriously, every piece. Date it when you get it. If someone tells you something on the phone, write down the date and what they said. You will need it.
0 coins
Madison King
The inconsistent information from different people is real. The actual rule is that Medi-Cal is secondary to other coverage, but how it gets applied on a specific claim depends on what the primary paid and what the service is — and not everyone you talk to knows all the pieces.
0 coins
Zoey Bianchi
My sister told me Medi-Cal just refuses to pay anything if you go out of network with the primary, like it's a penalty for not following the primary's rules. Is that actually true? Because reading this thread it sounds like that's wrong.
0 coins
Kaiya Rivera
That's not how it works. Medi-Cal as secondary pays what it would based on its own coverage rules after the primary processes the claim — including when the primary processes it as an out-of-network denial. It's not a penalty for going out of network with the other plan. The question is whether the service is covered under your Medi-Cal plan.
0 coins
Zoey Bianchi
Good to know, I'll pass that along. We were both confused about this.
0 coins
Sophia Bennett
It's a really common misunderstanding. The 'you chose out of network so Medi-Cal won't pay' idea gets passed around but it's not the rule. The right question is whether the service is covered under Medi-Cal, not whether the primary's network was used.
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
Reporting other health coverage within 10 days of getting it is a rule — changes like getting employer coverage through a spouse are supposed to go to the county within that window. If that hasn't happened yet, doing it now through BenefitsCal or by calling the county is the move. DHCS also has an Other Health Coverage page and the number 1-800-541-5555 specifically for this. Having it on record properly is what makes the coordination work smoothly.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorI reported it when I first got the coverage added — it was a few months ago when open enrollment happened at his job. So it should be on the case already. But I'll double-check in BenefitsCal to make sure.
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
Good — if it's already reported the county should have it. Worth confirming the case shows it. If you're ever unsure whether a reported change made it onto the case the county line can confirm.
0 coins
Ella Knight
Checking BenefitsCal after reporting a change is a good habit. The case showing it on file is what the provider's billing team is working from when they coordinate.
0 coins
Christopher Morgan
Renewal form came due on mine right when I was switching from one job to another and I lost track of the envelope. Wasn't sure if the county had gotten the form I eventually submitted or if the due date had already passed. I had Claimyr hold the line for me one morning — I'd tried twice the week before and hung up after long waits — and when I got through to the county worker she looked up my case and told me the date the form had been received and what the due date had been. It was in on time, which I hadn't been sure about, so I was relieved.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorLost-in-the-shuffle renewals are stressful. Good that yours made it in on time.
0 coins
Lauren Johnson
The renewal due date is visible in BenefitsCal too, for anyone who wants to check without calling — but if you need to confirm the county actually received a form you submitted, the county worker is the one who can tell you that, not the site itself.
0 coins
Madison King
Fee-for-Service Medi-Cal is worth understanding here as a backup concept. If you're between managed care plan assignments, or if the provider genuinely only takes Fee-for-Service, that changes how the claim gets processed. But most people on Medi-Cal are in a managed care plan. Ask the specialist's billing office specifically which type of Medi-Cal they're contracted with — that one question clears up a lot.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorI'll add that to my list of questions for their billing office. 'Which type of Medi-Cal are you contracted with' — good phrasing.
0 coins
Madison King
Exactly. Some billing staff will just say yes to 'do you take Medi-Cal' without distinguishing. Asking which type pins it down.
0 coins
Vanessa Chang
I learned this the hard way when a provider said they took Medi-Cal and then the claim got rejected because they weren't in my plan's network. The managed care piece is the one people don't know to ask about.
0 coins
Caleb Stone
BIC I was waiting on after a plan switch never showed up and I had an appointment coming. I let Claimyr hold with the county while I handled some stuff at home, and when I got on with the county worker she confirmed a new BIC had been sent and gave me the month it went out. The provider was able to look me up by name in the meantime, but it was good to know the card was actually in the mail.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorGood to know the county can confirm whether a BIC was actually sent. I'll keep that in mind if mine ever goes missing.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
Providers can often look you up without the physical card during the gap. Having the county confirm it was sent is reassuring for cases like that.
0 coins
Lauren Johnson
The county is the right place to go for a missing BIC — not the health plan and not DHCS's main line. The county mails it and they're the ones who can tell you whether one went out.
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
The managed care plan's Ombudsman is a resource people don't know about. If you have a problem with how your Medi-Cal plan handles a claim — like if they deny the visit or refuse to coordinate properly — you can call the Medi-Cal Managed Care Office of the Ombudsman at 1-888-452-8609. That's the number for when you've already tried working it out with the plan and hit a wall. Hopefully you won't need it, but it's there.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorI hadn't heard of the Ombudsman. I'll save that number. Hopefully the billing all goes smoothly but it's good to have a next step if it doesn't.
0 coins
William Schwarz
The Ombudsman helped me when a denial went nowhere through the plan itself. They don't make coverage decisions but they help you navigate the appeals process and can get answers the plan's regular member services line won't give you.
0 coins
Ella Knight
Saving that number too. Didn't know there was a specific office for managed care plan issues separate from the county.
0 coins
Olivia Evans
Prior authorization from your Medi-Cal plan is worth asking about specifically for the specialist visit. Some specialties require it even when the visit would otherwise be covered. The plan's member services on the back of your BIC is where to ask — give them the type of specialist, what you're being seen for in general terms, and ask if any authorization is needed before you go. Getting that answer before the appointment is much easier than dealing with a denial after.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorPrior auth before versus denial after is a much better situation. I'll call the plan this week before I confirm the appointment date.
0 coins
Olivia Evans
Good call. Some plans have different requirements for the same specialty depending on what you're being seen for, so the more detail you can give them when you ask, the clearer the answer will be.
0 coins
Ella Knight
To summarize what this thread has covered in case it helps anyone who finds it later: Medi-Cal does act as secondary when you have other health coverage, it pays its portion after the primary processes the claim, and an out-of-network denial from the primary doesn't automatically mean Medi-Cal refuses to pay. What matters is whether the service is covered under your Medi-Cal plan, whether the provider is in your managed care plan's network, and whether prior authorization is needed. Report both coverages to the county and tell the provider upfront about both.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorReally appreciate everyone's input here. I feel a lot better going into this appointment knowing what questions to ask and what to watch for on the billing side.
0 coins
Kaiya Rivera
Good luck with the appointment. The key steps are calling your Medi-Cal plan before you go, telling the specialist's billing office about both coverages when you arrive, and keeping documentation of the primary's response — whatever it ends up being — in case you need to follow up.
0 coins
Aiden Chen
Documentation is everything with dual coverage situations. Even when it all goes smoothly, having the paper trail means you can answer any question that comes up in the billing process.
0 coins
Zoey Bianchi
Does any of this change if the person is on Medicare instead of a job-based plan? My mom has both Medicare and Medi-Cal and I'm trying to figure out if the same coordination rules apply for her.
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
Medicare and Medi-Cal together is a different setup from job insurance and Medi-Cal. For Medicare members, most care goes through Medicare and Medi-Cal can help with what Medicare doesn't cover, like premiums. The coordination rules are specific to that combination — your mom's county can walk through what applies on her case specifically.
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
For Medicare plus Medi-Cal the county checks both when she applies or renews. The specifics of what Medi-Cal covers as secondary under Medicare depend on her particular situation and what Medicare covered on a given claim — the county or her Medi-Cal plan is the right place to ask rather than trying to work it out from general information.
0 coins
Zoey Bianchi
Got it, I'll have her ask her county office. I wasn't sure if the same thread applied but it sounds like it's similar in concept but different in the details.
0 coins
Daniel Price
Keep in mind that if something goes wrong with the billing after your visit — the primary denies it, Medi-Cal doesn't pay what you expected, or the provider sends you a bill — you have options before you pay anything. For a plan coverage issue, you can appeal to the plan within 60 days of the date on the plan's Notice of Action. After that, a State Fair Hearing is available. The Ombudsman number mentioned earlier is also a good first call if you're not sure where to start.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
AuthorSixty days from the date on the notice for the plan appeal — writing that down. I want to know the deadlines ahead of time so I don't miss them if something goes sideways.
0 coins
Noah Irving
The 60-day window for the plan appeal and then 120 days after the plan's decision to request a State Fair Hearing. Missing those windows makes it much harder to contest a denial, so noting the dates on any notice you get is worth doing immediately.
0 coins
Vanessa Chang
Honestly I didn't know there was a hearing option for plan denials specifically. I thought State Fair Hearings were only for eligibility stuff. Good to know it applies to coverage denials through the plan too.
0 coins